I'd heard about this place, so last night gave it a shot. Menu offers much more than pizza. Good selection of appetizers and pasta dishes. One I'm going to have to try sometime. The Lasagna Sandwich. The concept and presentation of that dish intrigued me. Decor is what you would expect at the beach, corner of room displaying usual merch like t-shirts, cups, mugs, etc. place was much larger than I anticipated. Server was friendly and fast. Ordered a beer, server suggested bottle since it was happy hour, and bottles were cheaper than draft. I made up the difference in his tip for suggesting that. Pizza was very good. It was very simular to pizza place in Homewood that recently closed. IYKYK Ordered the 10 inch Big Dave, made two meals out of it. Not scrimping on the topping for sure. Definitely on my list next time I want pizza down here. read more

We ate there tonight. Let me start with saying we had excellent service. That was the good. I swear we drove by all week and their sign said $4 beers all day. When we got there and sat down we saw on the menue that drafts were $7 and bottles were $6. The waiter apologized and said today was the first day of "summer prices" Grrr. We ordered a 3-cheese pan pizza. The cheese and sauce were good, not great. The crust was brown on the edges and bottom but almost raw in the middle where the crust meets the sauce. I have not experienced that any other time with a pan pizza. I am not sure what was going on but we will not be going back anytime soon. Being retired I can't afford expensive beer and undercooked pizza. That is just my opinion from one night on my first visit. read more

We were seated immediately and looked at the menu.. but I knew what I wanted.. Antipasto salad! It's the best around. Of course I had Lillian's Supreme pizza, thin crust, got to watch my carbs.. Thanks Amber, you're the best... and thanks for the "heavy hand" .... We will be back soon.. read more

Huge menu selection of pizza and pastas. Some specialty pizzas highlight the gulf including one with shrimp. Garlic cheese bread appetizer was delicious. Food came out quickly and was hot. Pizzas are loaded with cheese and toppings. Gluten free pizza available. read more

See all

Reviewed so many pizza recommendations while on the road and this one had the most. If this is the best OB has to offer, then pizza is not worth getting while here. Ordered two takeout pizzas while driving into town. Estimated time was 25-35 min. Got a text at about 20 that they were done so they sat for another 10 before we got there. Better to have them done early than later. Pizza really didn't have much flavor. Crust was good and crispy. Sad to say I was very disappointed. read more

James and Anthony were super awesome and helped us when we broke the toilet. Very nice lads.

Overall for Take Out Experience: 5 Stars Ambiance: can't really rate the inside as much because we order as "to go". However, when you walk in and go to the left side, it is an open concept was a lot of tables to choose from. The right side of the entrance is dedicated for pickup or takeout. Located across the beach with plenty of parking in Lost Keys - Perdido, this pizza joint is situated in a large building. You can't miss the sign and if you do, get your eyes checked! Server: can't really rate the dining experience w a server but I have to give the establishment a 5 star rating just for a 15% military discount cuz most places have a 10% or Zero discount. However, the guys at the cashier / front counter were pleasant and friendly. We chatted for a minute as i was waiting for the pizzas and they were pretty laid back and friendly. Also, appreciative of my military service. Food: 4.5 Stars We ordered three different pizzas and a salad Salad: 4.5 Stars. Chef Salad. Would have received a higher rating but the ham and turkey slices were left as whole instead of sliced, shredded or diced. However the salad was pretty good with halves eggs, bountiful amount of greens, large homemade croutons which weren't supper crunchy, dry or hard. Had the right amount of salty / herb seasoning on the croutons and the salad was served with homemade ranch dressing. All dressings are made in-house. Note: they have several pizza sizes from 10"-18". 12" Hot Hawaiian Pizza- Pan crust (thick): Grilled chicken, bacon bits, pineapple, and jalapeños with barbecue sauce at the base. The sauce wasn't overwhelming so you can taste the other ingredients. The jalapeños kicks it up a notch so we asked the jalapeno to be on half of the pizza. It tasted wonderful and pan crusty was bouncy and slightly chewy. It was a good base for all the ingredients. 14" Florentine: 4 Stars - Veggie Pizza (we opted to add Pepperoni as a protein), and Pan Crust. Parmesan with white wine reduction, layered with spinach, mushrooms, basil, oregano and topped with Parmesan cheese. This was a lovely and flavorful pizza. The fresh vegetables kept it light and refreshing. Add jalapeños to step up the spice level! 18" Thin Crust Pepperoni 4.5 Stars - you can't go wrong with a classic. The thin crust was crunchy and charred to perfection. The tomato sauce was pretty decent. The star of the show were the pepperonis. It has a nice charred and the juicy caps of the pepperonis kept enough of the meaty liquid. The fresh shredded mozzarella cheese was even trout and had a slightly nutty flavor to it. We will definitely be back on the next beach trip and will try out their other menu items and the lunch pizza buffet which runs on Monday-Friday. read more

See all

Just got into town to start vacation and wanted somewhere to relax for a bit. The beer is cold and the food is good. Our group had the Greek Salad, Caesar Salad, Club sandwich and the Perdido Pass pizza. Everything was delicious. Our server was fantastic and very nice. read more

See all

Lillian's does everything well, great pizza, great pasta and great salad-we go every year and are always super happy with the food, atmosphere and friendly staff read more

This is our favorite place to eat pizza. We ate there last night We always have Big Dave's meat lovers pizza. They need to even out the ingredients on the pizza. I take pictures each time we eat there. Sometimes better than others. They need to be consistent when making their pizza. read more

Lillian's Pizza - Dave pizza all meat pizza. So good enough for 2 meals we took home half of the pizza. We will have the other half tomorrow. - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

Lillian's remains my favorite, go-to pizza joint in the area with a range of plates from wings and salad to the typical pizza restaurant dishes like Pizza (obviously), lasagna (best around), and less expected like Daiquiris and Quesadillas. The service has been top notch for years but lately there has been a lot of staff turnover causing a lot of nights with them being short on staff. In these peak summer months it's causing long waits and slower than normal service. I hope that the trend doesn't continue because it's still a great place where my group of friends regularly hang out, but it's frustrating to continue to experience this. Whether you eat inside or out, it's a great establishment and sunsets on the covered deck are unobstructed. The winter is absolutely beautiful out back, but be warned that during the summer it can get pretty hot, even with the fans running. With all that, I still recommend Lillian's if you're vacationing here, just passing through, or are a permanent resident! read more

See all

Great service, high quality pizza delivered quickly. Highly recommend the salads. Fresh ingredients including crisp lettuce and tasty cherry tomatoes. Highly recommend Lillian's. read more

I've been eating at Lillian's since I was a kid in 1997. It is still some of the best pizza and stuffed cheese bread you'll find. Even after moving and switching ownership it is practically as good as when they had the old ovens at their first location. Still a big treat when coming back home from out west. Cost has always been worth it. My only gripe is the $7.99 key lime pie. It's good, but the quantity just isn't there. read more

Lillian's Pizza - Keylime pie to go - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

This place was on the strip and not too far from our place. Saw it passing by and stopped. We ordered the pizza and wings. This was an order to go place on the side we were in. There appears to be a diner on the other side. We took our order back with us. The cheese was really good and so was the wings. Guess we were hungry as we forgot to take pictures of the food. Took a few pictures inside to share. read more

See all

We really like the pan pizza. It was the highlight. I would skip the garlic cheese bread. There isn't much flavor. Service was okay- not bad, but not great. The pizza is worth it though. read more

We grabbed pizza from here with no expectations. While our kid loved the bbq chicken on hand tossed crust, I thought it was pretty underwhelming. The stuffed pizza we ordered was delicious though. Even the next day. I wouldn't waste my money on one of their salads as the Cesar salad left A LOT to be desired for the price. Overall, we'd return because service was extremely quick and the food was decent enough. read more

This local pizza joint has been here for years! It used to always be a skip for me anytime I found myself in this area. However, upon returning after some time. I was pleasantly surprised. Our server was hospitable to our group of 20 and accommodated everyone well. A full bar is available, ICEEs, and various frozen drinks. I had a Miami Vice and it was perfection, just the right consistency. For a meal, I opted for a small house salad (dressing of your choice) and Lillian's Supreme pizza with thin crust. The salad wasn't anything special; only romaine lettuce, shredded carrots, a few tomatoes, and croutons but the ranch dressing was tasty. The pizza was the star. I really enjoyed the thin crust because the pan while it did look good. It appeared to be very bready and filling. All the meaty and fresh toppings with the thin crunchy crust was delicious. read more

See all

We tried 3 different specialty pizzas, and were not disappointed whatsoever! Two of our pizzas we ordered with pan crust and one with thin. Both were excellent and very tasty! We tried the Big Dave's, Perdido Pass, and the Scampi. The 16" pizza was a great value, 12 good sized pieces for 24.99! Our waitress was very friendly and attentive to the needs of the table. My only complaint which would take away one star would be that we were not aware that dipping sauces were $1.50 each. Our family of 6 ordered quite a few sauces and when we got the bill at the end were just a little surprised and if aware would have just shared a couple of sauces instead. It may have been listed on the menu but I didn't take time to look! Also, bring some cash if you would like to save some money on the final bill, as using a card charges an additional percentage! Otherwise, everything was perfect and I would definitely recommend to anybody staying through the area! read more

I hadn't been to Lillian's pizza in over 15 years, not because it wasn't delicious the first time, just haven't been back in the area until now. I wanted a grilled chicken salad, they don't have grilled chicken salads on the menu but you can add grilled chicken to any of their salads. I ordered a chef salad which was $13.99, added grilled chicken, which was $3.99 and I used a debit card to pay, which was a charge of .77¢ for a total of $20.16 My salad was ready quickly, my salad came with the normal chef salad toppings, the ham and turkey is rolled up long way, so I did need to pull it out and chop it up to be able to mix it with my dressing. I wasn't a fan of the chicken, it tasted more like the chicken you get in a premade store chicken salad, (in my opinion) the rest of the salad was good and tasted like it was made with fresh ingredients. I wouldn't say I'd buy this salad again but I'd definitely eat here again based on my salads taste, portion and appearance. For reference, I couldn't finish my salad, but my husband said he'd still be hungry if it was for him. I didn't like getting charged a extra fee for paying with a card, had I known, I'd have just used cash. But a lesson learned for next time, because me and my husband will definitely be checking out some of their other menu items in the future. read more

Lillian's Pizza - Chef salad added grilled chicken with ranch on the side. - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

Nothing fancy! We had food delivered to campground were we are staying. Garlic knots were good w marina. Green salad has 2 tomatoes and 4 croutons. Chicken ranch pizza had no flavor. Delivery driver was super nice. read more

See all

We ordered through Uber Eats on a rainy day. Big Dave's and garlic knots were awesome! Truly worth a try,

Club sandwich had no mayo no cheese no ham was too dry to eat. Will never order from them again. 19.00 for this horrible sub.

I had a thin crust supreme pizza. It was delicious. My husband had a calzone which he enjoyed. The staff were friendly. Prices are a bit high though. read more

Worse canzone I ever had. Bread was almost burned and tough, filled with wrong ingredients. read more

This pizza spot was near our Airbnb so we decided to grab food from here. I ordered the veggie pizza and wings. The pizza was good but the wings were my favorite out of the two. One side of this pizzeria is the restaurant and there is another side for to go orders. Staff was friendly and patient as this was our first time at the establishment. Order was completed fairly quick and we were provided with paper plates as well as the condiments. This restaurant is right across the street from the beach. read more

Well, we have driven by Lillian's for as long as it has been here. But when we're in our hometown of Pensacola or out here on the Key we're not ever thinking pizza. We're 100% thinking seafood. Mullet. Shrimp. Grouper. Oysters, etc., etc., etc. But the always packed parking lot here cannot be ignored. It's obviously hugely popular. Our synapses apparently short circuited this evening and we said, "Let's try Lillian's and see what that's all about". I started with a Bombay Sapphire Martini that was very nicely poured. We ordered the Lillian's Supreme with green olive add on. Thin crust. The crust is not particularly flavorful but it is quite thin and crispy! A+ on the thin and crispy. And the pizza...sauce, cheese and ingredients was quite enjoyable. Would definitely do again if we ever do pizza again on the Key. read more

See all

I sure hope this was a delivery issue and not how their pizzas normally come (picture for reference)... super disappointing. Visiting family and have heard great things. Can't say that was our experience... maybe order for pick up? read more

Lillian's Pizza - Ordered the supreme... - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

My boyfriend and I were visiting from Kentucky and saw this as we were checking out the area. All the reviews were good and they DID NOT disappoint. The thin crust pizza was Amazing and the employees that helped me order were fantastic! No wonder this place has such high praise!!! Definitely try this if you're in the area and want high quality pizza!! read more

We ordered 3 pizzas and spaghetti. The pizza dough had no flavor and the pizza was undercooked. All in all it was very disappointing and we will not go back. read more

We came in for a nice casual dinner. Had Kelly, Kelly, Kelly! as our waitress, and she was great! Verry attentive yet, not too much! Food was good as usual. Highly recommend this place after a day on the beach! read more

Lillian's Pizza - Meatball sandwich with side of potato salad. Soooo good! - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

My wife and I were really wanting some pizza so we decided to give Lillian's pizza a try. We were told it was owned by the same people who have jellyfish so we were excited to see how it was. My wife and I decided to sit at the bar and ordered cocktails to start. They currently have a Cinnamon flavor cocktails for special on Saturdays. My wife tried their cinnamon whiskey sour. She truly enjoyed it. I was not as adventurous and had a standard Manhattan. We ordered a small Caesar salad, small order of meatballs, and a bacon ranch chicken pizza on a thin crust. The Caesar salad came out as expected, and was delicious. Next, we were surprised by our pizza rather than the order of meatballs. That's OK. The pizza was surprisingly delicious! The taste combination was genuinely good! Our meatballs came out shortly after that. The meatballs are about the size of a baseball, four of them! The presentation was superb as was the aroma! We were going to pack all four take away , but they just smelled way too good so I broke down and had one. Absolutely delicious! We hope to be able to make it back here before we leave the area at the end of the month. Keep up the great work! read more

See all

Came in on Sunday and met a party that was already in place. The table they were sitting at was too small to accommodate us and I was told the manager was working to get us a bigger table. We sat there waiting for close to an hour. We never once had anyone from the wait staff approach us. When we were leaving we were basically told by the manager the first members of the party didn't wait to be seated so I guess that means we don't get served. We're local and always roll with a large part there. Never again. I'll eat Little Caesar's before I ever go back to that place. read more

Outdoor seating was nice. We ordered the thin crust Lillian's pizza. Very good! Also had potato skins that were big and very cheesy. read more

Lillian's Pizza - Lillian's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

Party of 3, we entered to a few tables already seated but otherwise didn't appear busy. We were seated quickly but service was very slow. After a few minutes the waitress Mandy took our drink order. Brought drinks about 10 minutes later, asked if we were ready for appetizers. We said yes and she told us she would be right back. 20 minutes later she came back and we ordered an appetizer plus our meals. App was garlic bread. It arrived another 20 minutes later. This was the last time we saw Mandy at our table, although she was still visibly working. 40 minutes later our 2 10 inch pizzas and 1 order of chicken parm arrived. (We are an hour and 20 minutes in to our visit at this point.) We finished eating and waited patiently for the check, another 20 minutes. The host finally approached us and asked if we were all set. She brought us the check, we paid and left. The food was good but it wasn't "wait for 2 hours" good. read more

Lillian's Pizza - Stuffed pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

Worst and greasiest pizza ever! Arrived at 12 o'clock. Eight from the buffet. It was just a big pile of grease on a plate. Obviously it had been sitting there since they opened. I'm just sorry that I had to give them even one star. The service was fine. The toilet had not been cleaned in the restroom. Overall, just a terrible experience! read more

I would liken the pizza crust to what you would expect at a Chuck e Cheese. Not worth the money.

Do I even need to leave a review 5 stars we tried the hamburger pizza one of the best pizzas I've ever had the server was very nice and about one pizza filled up our whole family of 6 read more

Lillian's is a long time favorite spot in Perdido Key with yummy pizza, pasta and crisp, fresh salads. Today I got two of my favorites: their Caesar salad and cheesy garlic bread. Lunch total with tea and half leftover for later: $20 Both salad and app was generous and delicious. Attentive service with a smile and laid back family atmosphere with back porch seating (fans) for cool days or busier times make this a great family choice. They had a lunch buffet today plus have a separate take out side for call ahead orders too! Full bar for those inclined with featured wines and cocktails, and a delivery car in the lot leaves little else needed! Cheers! read more

See all

Called in our order and it was ready when we arrived. Decent pizza and they offer a senior discount for all us old guys. Easy peasy dinner for our first night of our vacation. Super convenient location to our condo. read more

If you're in the area definitely check out Lillian's. It's one of the cheesiest pizzas I've had. Preferred the thin crust too. The cheesy garlic bread was also delicious. read more