4/5 Stars Lump & Luscious Lobstah Roll! My mama got a hot roll & I got a chilled roll. I got the cold Lobstah roll with mayo, celery, lemon and I added a side of butter... duh! Talk about melt in your mouth! Perfect for a filling / cooling evening Sunday meal after the beach. DELISH!! Only reason I didn't rate this wonderful establishment 5 stars is because my roll could have used a lil more celery and lemon & the fries could have been seasoned. But if you're looking for a generate plain lobster roll, you would love it here! It's hard to earn a 5 star from me but this was damn near close! read more

Lobstah On A Roll - Colonial Style Lobstah Roll - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Quaint old house . Wanted to love it- didn't was good , not great .lobster rolls- ok came with fries cream of lobster bisque very good . Lobster rolls $48 good service! read more

See all

Walk in and the decor feel is similar to being in Cape Cod in the spring. Unfortunately that's where things go a bit wobbly afterwards, with the exception of the very bubbly and pleasant young woman behind the counter. Started with a cup of Clam Chowdah and unfortunately they needed to run it thru the microwave again to heat it up a bit more than it was served. But before that, they needed to add some clams, the overall flavor and consistency was on point, it just lack clam meat. I went with the Crab cakes, which were very tasty. Unfortunately, they lacked in some type of binder to hold the ingredients together. There was plenty of crab in them, just fell apart. My companion, (a true Bostonian) had the Lobstah Roll. Said it was very well prepared and tasted fresh. But not for the price. One and done. read more

See all

We stopped by this place on a very quick visit of St. Augustine. It sounded good but unfortunately it didn't deliver. We ordered a lobster roll and a bowl of chowder. First she gave us a cup of chowder, then after inquiring multiple times that they might be wrong, they finally gave us the bowl of chowder. The chowder was bordering on cold. "Luke cold" is how I would describe it, very disappointing. The lobster roll was ok, but nothing to write home about. Try somewhere else. read more

Lobster roll was good. Service was good. Theres a few seats indoors that can accomodate up to 6 people. read more

Lobstah On A Roll - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

The lobster itself is probably a 4 but we had a problem with access the steps were to much for my wife to maneuver so we sat outside. We had the 6oz Maine hot butter lobster roll and the lobster tacos. It was ok but was lacking in comparison to other lobster rolls we have had. I wasn't able to get pictures due to a dead battery. read more

I came in here for lunch and ordered the Boston lobster roll, 7 shrimp basket, and key lime pie. The cashier and the employ were very friendly and helpful. The restaurant is in a older historic looking building. There is limited seating inside. The lobster roll was delicious, the fried shrimp where large, and the key lime pie taste more like cheese cake. It is a little on the pricey side but you are getting quality seafood. If you're not a seafood person, they also have burgers. They also have beer and wine for purchase in the fridge. Overall, definitely a good place for lunch. read more

See all

Very Yummy! It was super good! Definitely would come back every now and again! Pricey...but it's good, fresh lobster so no complaints!! The people there were super sweet as well and gave us plenty of time and answered our questions as it was our first time! read more

Lobstah On A Roll - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

The lobstah grilled cheese, lobstah roll, and fish sandwich were all good. Only complaint was the side salad that was a bunch of iceberg lettuce instead of a salad. Cute place if you want a quick meal in a laid back space with either dine in or take out. The lady at the counter was also nice and upbeat. read more

The service was great and the place is charming, walk up and order kind of place. The food is not worth the price.

Found this amazing restaurant via the InKind app. The menu is amazing and I had a hard time choosing so asked for recommendations. The Lobstah Grilled cheese is off the charts delicious! Wish I lived in the area so I could be a regular customer! Amazing service, great ambiance and delicious food. 10/10 Recommend! read more

Lobstah On A Roll - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Great quality and fresh! The onion rings were so good! They have a parking lot and the lady who took our order was so helpful!

After reading the reviews I wasn't expecting much, but I was pleasantly surprised. Food was good, staff was friendly and efficient.

Very small place. You have to pay to park even in a parking lot. I got the lobster roll $40 (so not worth it). They warm it up in water not butter, but hey at least it's not in the microwave. I think, that was what I was told. Lobster was cold and rubbery and very small. It was put on a sweet roll which I was told it's the same as the New England split top which is totally untrue, I'm from New England. the fries tasted like they were frozen. My husband had them Masshole, which was a steak and cheese almost $19. No way worth it because it was smaller than an $8 sub from Subway and probably the same amount of meat. Well, the cookies were good read more

See all

Food was very, very good. 5/5 Ambiance was clever and amusing even. 5/5 Great location. 5/5 Seating was limited but we got a table. 4/5 4 stars because 4.5 is not an option and because it was very expensive. We dropped 60 bucks and we both had water and we ordered the chowder to split and a lobster roll to split. $$$ read more

See all

What a super little place. Small but food was good. The lobster was tasty but a splurge for me. It was priced similar to other places. The lady who waited on me was super friendly and nice. She even gave me a taste of her delicious clam chowder for free. In a nice cup with crackers. It was delicious. Next time I go to St Augustine I will order the clam chowder ! read more

Lobstah On A Roll - 6" lobster role with butter - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Yes! This! I am originally from Southeastern Mass, an hour South of Boston. This, I had to try this place! Ad soon as you walk in, the place is filled with New England decor! The employees were welcoming and enjoyed hearing my Massachusetts accent. They assured me that this was legit and I was ready for it! I loved the items on the menu and, of course, I was going to try the Lobstah Roll! However, as soon as I saw that a steak and cheese sub was on the menu, I went for it!! Here in Florida, I have found that it's hard to find a great steak and cheese sub made with shaved steak. This was wonderful! It reminded me of the subs I made enjoyed up there. Made with actual shaved steak, onions, peppers, cheese, mayo! I can't explain it! You MUST try it! read more

See all

Stopped in for a quick lunch bite and man this place does not disappoint. Outstanding lobster roll with clarified butter. The shrimp tacos were fresh and flavorful, even though I opted for their mango salsa to be on the side. Service was fast and the food is brought to you once it's freshly made. The inside is very sea and ocean themed, cozy and inviting. read more

See all

This place was around the corner from my B&B. It a large stand alone house with a parking lot next door and across the street from Cafe Alcazar so you could come here for some kick ass New England style seafood or eat inside some dead rich folks former swimming pool. I choose here and decided to get an order of the clam chowder that was incredibly thick and delicious. With a name like The Wicked Famous Fish sandwich how could I not give this a try? It comes stacked with fried cod pieces - perhaps it's a filet, maybe two, but they break it apart to give it some height. Probably helps with it getting mushy since it isn't smashed under a bread blanket. I enjoyed my lunch.. shuffled on back to my B&B and took a nice little food coma nap on this unusually hot winter day. read more

Lobstah On A Roll - Wicked Famous Fish Sandwich - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

After visiting the Lightner Museum we walked down the street and saw this restaurant. It was delicious!! The special today was the fish sandwich. My husband and i each had the fish sandwiches with coleslaw and hush puppies as our sides. It was a great choice!! read more

Been craving a lobster roll for a while now and they didn't disappoint! I got the New Englander with a side of tots, and the wife got Lobster Mac. The food was amazing, service was great and staff was super friendly. read more

Lobstah On A Roll - New Englander - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I came here because my friend brought me. She had been here all the time when it was the bantam chef however, this new place kept their famous fish sandwich, thankfully. It's Alaskan cod. It is massive and super delicious. The cashier said that the owner is really from Boston. It has been recently renovated I'm guessing because every finish looks brand new. The staff was super sweet. We went on a Tuesday at 7:30 in the place was a ghost town but to our advantage or fish sandwich came out literally in about six. Minutes. They're fresh what is fried perfectly. The french fries were a bit over salted for my friend but for me, they were fine they do serve a thick fry. It was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside perfectly done. For the amount of sandwich you got it was very reasonably priced . This place is on Granada towards the back entrance of the Lightner Museum. You can get parking in the city lots all around the restaurant. I love how they had their menu posted outside. They have a couple of picnic tables outside, and the weather is always so great so it's a perfect option. Definitely will be back. Great food great service and super cute place to eat read more

Lobstah On A Roll - Decorated - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

We have eaten here before but always got the lobster. Today we tried the fish sandwiches and an order of hush puppies. Fish sandwich was so huge that I brought half of it home. It was light and didn't have a greasy aftertaste. Solid 5 on the sandwich but hush puppies were just ok. They looked better than they tasted. Service was good, friendly, and fast. We ate inside where there are a few tables. You order at the counter. So it is a fast casual restaurant. read more

Lobstah On A Roll - Wicked Famous Fish Sandwich - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Fantastic spot with delicious lobster rolls. Worth the trip. Great folks who have a high attention to detail. Service was fantastic.

Outstanding hidden gem--well worth the effort to find! I had the hot lobster roll and onion rings, and both were absolutely fantastic. The lobster roll is hands-down the best thing I've eaten since moving to Florida. Packed with tender, flavorful lobster--no fillers, no skimping. It's generous, indulgent, and yes, a bit pricey, but worth every penny. The onion rings were spot on--crispy, golden, and perfectly seasoned with a light, flavorful batter. Great texture and not greasy at all. The ambiance is relaxed and inviting, with cool New England-style decor that makes you feel like you're on the coast in Maine. Prices reflect the quality--$26 for the small hot roll and $8 for the onion rings--but the freshness and flavor justify it. This place nails it. I'll definitely be back. A must-try for seafood lovers. . read more

A must try if ever nearby this location... fresh and delicious... We needed these in our lives... glad we stopped Looked just like the photos advertised read more

It has been a minute since I've written a review on Yelp; and I dread writing this review, because my wife and I had such high hopes for our visit to Lobstah On A Roll, in Saint Augustine. First off, again, let me state that I am in no way a food expert.........I'm rather pedestrian actually. But I do love food! Having lived for 14-years in New Hampshire, my wife, children and I made literally hundreds of trip into Boston where we would enjoy Lobster Rolls, when we could afford to do so. They aren't cheap. Anyway, while I admit to not being an expert, I will say that our visit to Lobstah on a Roll, was disappointing. The people and the service were fine.......the ambiance is okay....nothing to brag about, but not a huge distractor. The issue is that the lobster roll was terrible. The roll overall was simply bland and offered very little in the way of taste. The overall portion was okay, but when paying over $30 for a roll, you'd expect a bit more than the portion provided. You have options for your roll: Mayo, Naked, or Hot butter....we both went with the Mayo; not a good choice, and one bite into the roll and we knew we make a mistake. I'd suggest trying the 'hot butter' if you go there. The bun: NOT a New England Lobster Roll bun.......very heavy and 'bready' (hope that makes sense). Highly imbalanced with the amount of lobster. The bun can make or break a good lobster roll........this one broke it; shattered it. I get that this isn't flattering; however, it is an honest review on the lobster roll we had. The people, service and ambiance are fine. Lobster Roll - not fine. Oh, I also had the clam chowder..........it was better than the lobster roll. read more

This place was perfect for our family. We finished the trolly tour and came to have some lobster rolls. Kid friendly and nice staff!

We found this hidden gem on our recent trip to st Augustine! We actually had booked an air bnb above the restaurant without knowing it! Of course once we discovered we were above this restaurant, we had to try it out! I feel like not enough people know about this place! Incredible and fresh seafood items! And what they are known for--LOBSTAH on a roll! I did get one to go and tried it and it was amazing! While eating there, i got the lobster tacos (YUM!!) and fried oysters! Both delicious! The staff was very friendly and they were excited for it to be my first time! I will definitely be putting this on the agenda every time i go back to St Augustine! read more

See all

Came here for the lobster rolls and we were not disappointed! We made the drive up from Daytona Beach and arrived just after they opened. We each got a small size lobster roll - one cold with mayo and one hot with butter. They were so, so delicious! The rolls are soft and warm, the meat portion is generous, and they were both very flavorful. My husband also ordered a cup of the lobster bisque which was good. Creamy with a ton of little flecks of lobster throughout. The one downside was the side dishes. The onion rings were good but nothing to write home about. The hushpuppies were unfortunately very bland. Lacking in both onion and salt. Guess I should have known better than to order a Southern staple from a Boston-founded restaurant. Cute New England theming throughout the restaurant and quick service. Paid public parking right next door and a short walk to the main strip on St George. read more

Lobstah On A Roll - Regular Lobstah Roll hot with butter 5 Piece Hush Puppies - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

I've only had lobster rolls here, but I drive out from Jacksonville for them as we no longer have any options locally. It's so delicious and I love it! I always get hot with butter, but they also offer cold with mayo. read more

Lobstah On A Roll - 6 oz lobster roll and small fries - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Having visited Portland, Maine years ago I was excited to experience a New England style lobster roll again and this sounded like the perfect place to do so. Cozy more than small, there are also a few outside tables. You order at the counter and they bring over the food when ready. The service was pleasant and friendly. The menu contains many other choices that all sound delicious, but we ordered the lobster rolls (one small, one large, both "cold") and the lobster bisque soup. The bisque was outstanding, full of flavor with just the right touch of cream and--I am pretty sure--sherry. Absolutely yummy. The lobster rolls were smothered in large chunks of sweet lobster meat which is a nice portion for the price. The lobster meat itself was superb. But...the "cold" is supposed to have some mayo and there really was so little as to be none, and there were no additional flavors, spices, whatever. No tarragon. No celery. No scallions. Just lobster meat. Even the roll was dry. It was good, yet disappointing. They also serve lobster rolls hot with butter if that's your thing. I will probably go back to try something else on the menu and definitely another cup of bisque, but will look elsewhere for a more flavorful lobster roll. read more

See all

Lobster roll was good and exactly what you would expect. It's expensive, but so is everything else.

The food here is amazing and giantly portioned which I absolutely love. When you walk in the service and ambiance are just amazing. You get greeted with a warm welcome and an amazing warm smile. read more

Omg day made. Now look..sometimes you get what you pay for so sometimes it's gonna cost a little more. Having said that, a New Englander lobster roll is $36, HOWEVER..it was the best damn lobster roll on earth and it made my life!!! We actually got 1 and shared it because we both got a cup of clam chowder which by the way will also blow your socks off!!! A New Englander Lobstah roll advertises 6 ounces of lobster meat. You can get it 2 ways, hot with a side of melted butter or cold with mayonnaise. Ummm hot with melted butter please and thank you. The roll was perfect lightly toasty as well. Please do yourselves a favor and stop by here and have your day blown. The people are wonderful there as well! read more

Lobstah On A Roll - This is only my 1/2 of the sandwich!!! - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Lobstah On a Roll, St Augustine, FL 1 This is a cute concept and that's where it ends! I was looking forward to trying the lobster roll once my daughter showed me the restaurant. We get to the restaurant where it sits in historic St. Augustine so you have to pay for parking, which should be fine since all of historic St. Augustine is that way. My biggest problem with this place is the PRICE! After paying for parking they are asking $34 for a large lobster roll and $23 something for the small. Now I don't know if they jacked the prices up due to it being Labor Day weekend or they are always that ridiculously expensive! The other things on the menu was also pricey being $15-$16 piece. If this wasn't ridiculous enough EVERYTHING was a la carte. Needless to say only one person in the family of 3 could try the lobster roll. On a side note we asked for it to go and they brought it to us not in to go boxes. We had to send it back so they could put it in to go boxes. Needless to say it was $70 for 3 people. And when we got home with our to go, we realized they FORGOT the one reason we went there, the over priced lobster roll! read more

Lobstah On A Roll - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

We decided to head to St. Augustine for a walk around and wanted to get a lighter lunch but something delicious- that's when my husband spotted LOAR when we we're parking. He had heard good reviews and decided to give it a try. I got a cold roll with mayo and husband got a warm roll with butter - we both got the Bostonian which have 4 ounces of meat. They were nicely filled up with lobster and were a much better value than their 6 ounce version in my opinion. The atmosphere was cute and there's a clear view into the kitchen, which I prefer. We ended up splitting a soup and my husband went back for a hotdog (so much for the light lunch). Everything was great. The chowder was creamy but could stand a bit more clam for the price. Seating was limited but they had tables inside and outside. read more

See all

$45 for literally 5 small pieces of lobsters on a small piece of bread. Don't waste your money here.

This is a very small place with about 20 indoor seating, two on the porch, and two picnic tables outside. We came right after the lunch crowd, and it was packed. I am assuming the orders took longer than normal, but it was worth the wait. I ordered the Bostonian while my wife had a fish sandwich and clam chowder. The Bostonian was packed with lobster meat from the claws. The first bite packed my mouth and all the flavor. The extra warm butter was not needed at all. The clam chowder was very fulfilling and large chucks of potatoes. My wife fish sandwich looked like a skyscraper. How much fish can you pack between two buns? This place knows how to do it. The two ladies cooking/prepping did an outstanding job while the front counter lady assisted everywhere else. This place looked like a hot spot for lunch if you were near Granada Street. read more

Lobstah On A Roll - Bostonian-warm with butter - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Had lobster shell in my roll! Geez! Nothing is worse than taking a bite from your lobster roll and crunching down on lobster shell. When I advised the employees they could care less. Done with them! I'm going to DJ's clam shack from now on! read more