Ever since we moved to Evergreen, this has been the go to pizza spot in town. CLASSIC NY style pizza, good flavor, excellent crust, and overall just damn good. I'm originally from Chicago but I had my fair share of ny style and this hits the spot. Service is always good to me, either in person or online. Overall the place is in a strip mall but Renee is always the sweetest person! Oh and the baked ziti is dope too. read more

Locals Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

Nice and friendly staff to sooth the weary traveler. Good tunes playing. Peaceful atmosphere. Got a pepperoni slice, 6 bone-in BBQ wings and a bottled water. Parm and crushed red peppers enhanced the foldable slice. Delicious. Crust was good. Cheese was good. Sauce was good. A grand slice. Clean restroom.s. Goodly wings with the blue cheese dressing. I enjoyed my experience. I shall return. Try them. You'll be glad you did. read more

See all

We have been 2x and won't go anywhere else in Evergreen for pizza. We have a pizza oven at home and have stopped using it because this pizza is so fantastic! I'm baffled by any of the negative reviews - they do not match our experience in the slightest. read more

Just awesome NY style pizza that you fold and eat. I typically buy pizza by the slice. Their lunch special is terrific. Love love love the people that work there. read more

Had a Perfect pizza tonight. Easy order on phone. It was ready on time . Service gal was polite and showed me what I was getting . 100% nailed it. read more

Amazing pizza. Best pizza I have had in Colorado since we moved here 5 years ago. Super friendly people and nice space. Definitely going to be coming back again. read more

I don't live in Colorado but happened to be driving thru on a road trip. I wasn't expecting much. Instead I found a super friendly pizza shop, very solid food, and an overall great experience. The service was fast, the restaurant was clean and the beer was ice cold! These days spots like Domino's or Poppa Johns get all the press yet their pizza isn't what it used to be. Locals is different. Very fresh. I asked them to make our pizza with super thin crust and they accommodated. Thank you! read more

We dine at Locals once or twice a week and decided to have them cater a small gathering of friends at our house. Baked ziti, antipasto salad and garlic bread followed by cannoli for dessert. Incredibly great and everyone was impressed with the meal. If you want some Italian food that tastes like your Sicilian mother made it, then go to Evergreen Local Pizza, it's so much more than that! read more

Very little pizza sauce and very little cheese. basically, overcooked cardboard with burn bubbles. Do not recommend. Will not make that mistake again. read more

Great New York pizza. You won't get any better in Colorado. Fast service. Friendly staff.

The owner and staff are wonderful very friendly personable. The pizzas are so good the best pizza I've had in a very long time. Definitely on the pricey side. Was told that it's not your typical pizza when you order per item which makes it pricey. The ambience is your typical pizza place. They have a cute little patio out back. read more

Came into town for a visit from Arizona . Family member took me here , what a damn good surprise it was . I'm somebody who enjoys a nice New York thin crust with that cornmeal finish THIS WAS IT . I ate about 4 pieces and it was just too damn good . Everybody was really nice and their xl pizza feeds plenty( massive slices ) !! If I'm ever in town again I will be here ASAP. ( if I could get these pizzas vaccum sealed and shipped I WOULD ! They also had a couple games for the kids which was nice ! read more

Locals Pizza - Just a massive piece of pepperoni as big as my head . - Pizza Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

See all

We ordered a large pizza and the crust was perfect crust around.. the pizza was great the service was great! We are coming back!

It was fine, not great. Got a cheese pizza and their sauce is a little too sweet for me. Relatively fast service though.

This place had some bad reviews. I stopped in because I live close by. Had lunch special. $9.99 slice salad and drink. It was good and large. I'll be back. read more

An 18 in was huge! We really like and will be back. Look for deals on DoorDash for pickup read more

Locals Pizza - 18 in pepperoni, sausage, and spinach - Pizza Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

See all

We love the NY style pizza. The mozzarella sticks were also amazing. Everyone was really friendly and the service was great.

I am a self established pizza connoisseur and their pizza is fantastic. They are always so welcoming and have a great outdoor patio in the back. 10/10. read more

Service was fine but generally just a disappointing experience overall. "Locals" is the former Anthony's Pizza in the shopping center near Safeway; the old sign from Anthony's is out back on the deck, stacked against the wall with other crap. Unfortunately Locals Pizza certainly won't be the pizza for these locals. Evergreen does generally struggle for reliably good pizza, so "Locals" isn't uniquely bad. It's just well down the lower tier of otherwise mediocre pizza to be found around town. The pizza standard for the area is pretty low, and somehow Locals seems to come in under that bar. Pizza crust was "meh," on the dry and starchy side, and the toppings were haphazardly tossed about the pie. It looks like someone spent all of 30 seconds assembling it. And there are no beers on tap to help wash it down. No soap or paper towels in the restroom, just clutter. We ate on the patio which was indeed open, but the door from the restaurant to the patio was mostly blocked by an enormous stack of to-go boxes. Going in and out we had to navigate a bit of a hurdle. The other door to the patio was screwed shut, so it seems that the best storage plan for the bundle of unassembled boxes was to park it right in front of the exit to the deck. On the positive side of the column, no one from our party got sick. If that's the standard, they pass. But a bake-at-home pizza from elsewhere would have been better overall. Sorry to be down on a local spot trying to make it, but Locals has a very long way to go to be worth trying again. I suspect these are "management issues" that should be fairly easily resolved if only there's a will. No attentive manager would keep a restaurant in such negligent condition. read more

The Pizza was amazing, I had a regular pie and my wife had a white pie. Reminds me of a traditional pizza restaurant. The service is always great. read more

Exceptional Service; Good Product; variety of TV Options for in Store dining. . A Great local Business.

Best NY style pizza I ever had! Love! Reasonable prices too along with great service.

Fantastic people, great pizza, awesome desserts. This is our new spot. We will make the drive from Arvada any day for this! Thanks you! read more

I hope when this place goes out of business soon that someone who knows what they're doing takes over. Never known a veggie pizza to come with jalapeños on it and after picking it up "right out of the oven". Was cold and taste like it was 45min old. Looks like they lost all their employees due to not paying them so don't imaging that the owners can do it all on their own for long. read more

Locals Pizza - Cold "veggie" pizza with unwanted jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

Average at best. Definitely can't compare to Guido's in Genesee. Neither food nor ambience makes the cut. Guido's wins!

Great pizza! Perfect crust. Renee is awesome. We will be back-next time in Evergreen.

visited and a teen was being berated by a manager. manager then started talking to my partner about guns. even as a gun guy my partner was puzzled, he was just trying to order us food. pizza was fine but the vibes were off. we won't be visiting again. read more

Genuinely the worst pizza I've had in my entire life. It was completely raw. I've had better pizza in middle school cafeterias.

Two 12" pizzas were over $50. We ordered extra cheese, but both were overcooked with very spare toppings and a large crust margin around the outside. Pizzas tasted old. Why, oh why, can't Evergreen do better. Go to Campfire for pizza, or maybe Naples. read more

This place was great! Pizzas, salads and fried pickles were all delicious and the staff were very friendly and accommodating!

Not kidding when I say that Locals might be the best pizza I've tried in all of Colorado. I think they may have a low rating due to childish folks upset over a difference in political opinion or the like; but let's ignore all that and get back to the pizza. I'm not sure if anyone remembers the iconic "Famous" pizza joint off broadway, that got replaced by a subpar chain-gentrified donut shop? That used to be the best pizza in all of Denver, and many critics agreed so. But after they closed, Denver and surrounding areas really hit a metaphorical dark winter for good pizza. Then boom, 2022/2023... Locals Pizza (with the outside sign simply reading "PIZZA" nonchalantly and curiously... in Evergreen, Colorado of all places! This place takes me back to the likes of the best pizza I've had out in NYC. Please, if you like pizza like me, take a chance and try this spot! Best of the best! read more

Wow. Legit NY style pizza. Had the two slice and drink lunch special for $8.25. Huge slices, awesome crust, nice workers. I travel for a living and really appreciate excellent crust and fresh toppings on a pizza like I find in NYC and Philly. So glad to see a go-to slice pizza place in Evergreen. Excellent. read more

I love this restaurant, and I am so happy Evergreen has authentic NY style pizza. The sauce, cheese, and crust are PERFECT. Besides the food being delicious, the staff is helpful, cheerful, and professional. Whenever I go to pick up our Friday night pie, Ginger is there with a smile. She is a bright young girl there whom the whole neighborhood adores! You can't go wrong at Locals - the food just like home on the East Coast, and the people like family. read more

I found the best NY pizza outside NY at Local's Pizza in Evergreen Colorado!! I eat it at least once a month. The taste of each flavor of pizza I've eaten there is so tasty! You will enjoy and not be disappointed! read more

This place is amazing and the pizza is the best!!! Don't believe the negative reviews as they must be from a disgruntled ex-employee or some other issue. The staff, the food, and the place are all great. read more

I lived in New York City in the 60s and 70s. This place really took me back! This is the most authentic NY style pizza I've had in many, many years. And the staff was welcoming, courteous, and thorough. It's about 30 miles from my house, but I will definitely be going back. read more

Went in to order a pizza and he gave me a previously cooked pizza that he accidentally cooked earlier in the day, threw on my preferred toppings, and sold it as "fast service under 3 minutes!" Needless to say it was not fresh and a waste of $25 for a pizza. read more

Advertises slices, but does not sell them. Not sure how it's possible to be out of slices at a pizza shop.

I went in to order takeout and they turned me away. They were making pizza behind the counter but the young man at the cash register said it would be a while before they could accept an order. read more

Picked up a take out pizza. Asked for parm and red peppers. They won't give them for take out. Have never had that happen at a pizza joint. Was very greasy as well. read more