Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Lucy's Luncheonette

    5.0 (7 reviews)
    Closed Closed
    Updated 2 months ago

    Lucy's Luncheonette Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Lucy's Luncheonette

    Recommended Reviews - Lucy's Luncheonette

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Cherokee R.

    Cherokee R.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Susan V.
    181
    238
    295

    5 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Cherokee R.

    Cherokee R.

    Thank you Susan!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jeff D.
    1
    49
    13

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Cherokee R.

    Cherokee R.

    Thank you Matt!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    A great new addition to Middletown. Owners are friendly, breads and other baked goods are out of this world world.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Lucy's Luncheonette

    You might also consider

    Mazzotta's  Bakery

    Mazzotta's Bakery

    4.6(32 reviews)
    4.7 mi
    $

    Last weekend was the third time that Mazzotta's cupcakes were the centerpiece of our family…read morebirthday celebration! As always Maria's cupcakes were delicious , moist and flavorful. They were also beautiful! The ones frosted with vanilla buttercream looked like beautiful white roses, and the strawberry cupcakes were topped with yummy whipped cream frosting and a strawberry. Mazzotta's is awesome!

    I stopped by this bakery looking for end-of-school gifts for teachers and principals, and it ended…read moreup being a huge success. I picked up an assortment of Danish pastries to share, and they were a hit. Everyone loved them, which made gift-giving easy and stress-free. It's always nice finding something that feels thoughtful and is appreciated by so many people. Of course, I couldn't leave without picking up a few treats for myself. I brought home the chocolate hazelnut and coconut ice cream flavors, and both were absolutely delicious. The chocolate hazelnut was rich and creamy, while the coconut had a refreshing flavor that was perfect for a warm day. I also purchased two breakfast pastries. One was a raspberry-flavored pastry that I really enjoyed. The other was supposed to be filled with vanilla, but the filling tasted different than I expected. It wasn't my favorite item, but with so many options available, that's bound to happen sometimes. The selection was impressive, everything looked fresh, and there was something for every sweet tooth. Whether you're stopping in for dessert, breakfast pastries, ice cream, or gifts for a special occasion, this is definitely a place worth visiting. I'll definitely be back to try more flavors and discover a few new favorites.

    Photos
    Mazzotta's  Bakery
    Mazzotta's  Bakery
    Mazzotta's  Bakery

    See all

    Mozzicato -De Pasquale's Bakery & Pastry Shop - Bottom: What they told me I'd get advertised on Facebook  Too: sad reality for the same price

    Mozzicato -De Pasquale's Bakery & Pastry Shop

    2.6(71 reviews)
    3.4 mi

    A Sweet Little Stop for Italian Gelato!…read more I stopped by Mozzicato DePasquale Bakery & Pastry Shop because I was craving some ice cream, and I'm so glad I did! I had a hard time choosing, so naturally... I tried three flavors. I started with the coconut, which had little flakes of coconut on top. The coconut flavor was fresh and not overly sweet, and the texture was really creamy. Next was the torrone, and this one surprised me. The pieces of torrone throughout gave it a nice texture, but the flavor wasn't overpowering. It still tasted fresh and balanced, which I really enjoyed. Then there was the mint chocolate chip. The chocolate chips were small enough to blend nicely into every bite instead of taking over the ice cream. The mint and chocolate had a really nice balance; refreshing without being too strong. Honestly, all three flavors tasted incredibly fresh, and you could tell there was attention to the quality of the ingredients. I also appreciated that the staff was friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. The bakery itself has that classic Italian pastry-shop feel, making it the kind of place where you can stop in for something sweet and somehow leave wanting to try five more things. My favorite? I'm having a hard time choosing because each flavor had something different going for it. The torrone was probably the most unique, while the mint chocolate chip was the perfect classic. If you're in the mood for something sweet, I definitely recommend stopping in and trying a few flavors. I'll be back to see what else I can get myself into!

    This is the worst and overrated bakery in the area. They're all about the appearance rather than…read moremore interested in the quality and taste of their bakery goods flavors and bread texture are completely off pastries our second rated pastries in the coolers tasted like refrigeration, hold, and stay on need to change their management for higher quality control overrated overpriced stay away

    Photos
    Mozzicato -De Pasquale's Bakery & Pastry Shop - Their varieties of cookies and other things they sell

    Their varieties of cookies and other things they sell

    Mozzicato -De Pasquale's Bakery & Pastry Shop
    Mozzicato -De Pasquale's Bakery & Pastry Shop

    See all

    Neil’s Donuts

    Neil’s Donuts

    4.3(141 reviews)
    2.0 mi
    $

    I haven't lived in Connecticut for over 10 years at this point, but one thing I very much miss is…read moreNeil's Donuts. I used to frequent the Wallingford location many years ago, so when I found out they opened a location in Middletown, I just had to go. My wife and I stopped here yesterday morning (a Wednesday) and got in and out super quickly. I kept it simple and ordered a glaze donut as well as a chocolate sprinkles donut and boy oh boy, I think Neil's has one of the best chocolate sprinkles donuts I've ever had. The top of the donut was completely covered and the dough on both donuts were so soft and delicious. Overall, Neil's Donuts is a dang gem and one of the best things Connecticut has to offer and such a great place. It looks like a cozy little donut shop, the staff have always been super friendly whenever I was here, and the food here it top notch and dang good. If you want a donut, this is the place you are gonna need to come check out.

    Usually love this place.... However, I went this morning in…read morea rush on the way to work. I put in an Uber Eats order and stated multiple times "no cheese" as I'm allergic. When given my item, the receipt even said no cheese and somebody signed off on it How about when I went to eat my sandwich there was cheese and I hadn't throw it out (i always check first just incase) because some of it had melted to the bagel This is not right as this could have been harmful for my health. I'm putting this night as complaint but a warning people since this restaurant does not often check the safety of their customers

    Photos
    Neil’s Donuts - Menu, and que for when the shop gets busy

    Menu, and que for when the shop gets busy

    Neil’s Donuts - Egg & Cheese on bagel

    Egg & Cheese on bagel

    Neil’s Donuts - The array of donut choices. They even have maple bacon donut.

    See all

    The array of donut choices. They even have maple bacon donut.

    Tony's Flour Shop - Vertical chess

    Tony's Flour Shop

    4.8(51 reviews)
    6.0 mi

    I've heard so much about Tony's Flour Shop, I am so happy I recently got to check them out my self…read more I am almost never in Cromwell, but on this occasion I was meeting a friend and Tony's was the perfect midpoint for us. This place is so adorable on the inside, it is small and pretty intimate, but the decor is precious! There are so many toadstools (the oversized red mushrooms with polka dots) and rainbows everywhere. Tony's specialty's are all his mom's recipes. There was a delightful selection of an assortment of sweets. Of course you can get your coffees and teas too. Each month they change their drink specials. I got a slice of their Salted Caramel Pecan Blondie and a May Specialty Latte called Fay Valentine. The Blondie was rich with caramel on the outside but decadently sweet, yet crunchy. This is an indulgence for sure! The Fay Valentine is a Banana and Peanut Butter Latte, absolutely delicious! I kept slurping long after it was gone! Please go check out the restroom at Tony's, even if nature isn't calling you to go. I have never before encountered a more magical restroom. If I tell you there's Alice herself hanging upside down from the ceiling, maybe that's enough reason to go. I had a wonderful time with my friend at Tony's Flour Shop, the staff is super helpful and friendly. I cannot wait to return.

    Whooooah! I have never wanted to brag about a breakfast sandwich in my life, but Tony's Flour Shop…read morewould be the one! I ordered three things - decaf coffee, the egg, bacon and cheese breakfast sandwich on homemade Italian bread, and a salted croissant. The breakfast sandwich was beautiful - buttered and gently toasted on the outside, soft and squishy on the inside, the bacon was perfectly crisp, and the egg wasn't runny, as I had requested. I have NEVER IN MY LIFE had bread like this; it elevated the entire thing That Salted Croissant tho! I was carb-loading double-fisted style, and it was an amazing way to end my work trip. Thank you for the Studio Ghibli stickers! I knew this place was legit when there was a bowl with giveaway stickers And the service was friendly, prompt, and helpful I will definitely be back and would STRONGLY recommend Tony's Flour Shop!

    Photos
    Tony's Flour Shop - Cute inside

    Cute inside

    Tony's Flour Shop - White hot chocolate with a spiced cookie

    White hot chocolate with a spiced cookie

    Tony's Flour Shop - Pepperoni and cheese stuffed bread Pretty yummy

    See all

    Pepperoni and cheese stuffed bread Pretty yummy

    A Little Imagination Cakes

    A Little Imagination Cakes

    4.0(39 reviews)
    4.3 mi
    $$$

    Hyper realistic cakes are not plentiful in Connecticut (nor does Hope from A Little Imagination…read moreCakes brand herself as such), but take a look at the shoe in the cake she made for my wife's birthday and tell me that doesn't look real! If you need a special cake for a special occasion, you need to reach out to Hope and she will work with you. Shoot her an email, and you are replied with an automated list asking for the date of the event, serving size, inspiration of images, flavor choices, and phone number. She initially requested a phone call to follow up, but we just replied back and forth and we got this thing finalized. Not only was this cake beautiful, but it was delicious - I picked a simple red velvet with vanilla buttercream, and it was done to perfection. A special cake my my special girl on her special day. Thank you, Hope!

    We picked up birthday boys' cake today, and immediately after seeing it, I had an…read moreohmygodjusttakemymoney moment. I kept my cool though, because I'm the adult (even though I also watch the show this cake was based on) and got to see my son's magical reaction to seeing the most amazing birthday cake he's ever seen in his life. Cake weathered the ride home like a seasoned passenger while dad and I fielded questions about why we can't eat his birthday cake before his party tomorrow. The process of requesting a cake and specifying certain parts and asking for input on others was painless and smooth. Will update with how the magnificence tastes tomorrow. Edit: Bomb cake. Very eatable and worth the calories.

    Photos
    A Little Imagination Cakes - The purple pillow's fondant cracked and slid off, but the top white pillow lasted.

    The purple pillow's fondant cracked and slid off, but the top white pillow lasted.

    A Little Imagination Cakes - Baby Shower! August 29, 2015

    Baby Shower! August 29, 2015

    A Little Imagination Cakes - My amazing wedding cake(s)/cupcakes

    See all

    My amazing wedding cake(s)/cupcakes

    Lucy's Luncheonette - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...