I needed an emergency, same-day birthday cake for my son. Maria didn't hesitate when I called - and made a beautiful cake that served 20+ teenagers, She then delivered it with candles, plates, forks, napkins, and a knife. The day was saved and the cake was amazing! read more

My husband got me a cake for my birthday. It was just like our wedding cake and she did a spectacular job! I don't usually like bakery cakes because they don't use butter for the icing but this cake was absolutely DELICIOUS! Thank you so much for such a wonderful cake! read more

Got a cake from here for my wife's birthday. From the first phone call with this fine establishment everything went very smoothly and the cake was very good. Honestly this is the best cake we've had in a long time. All the people who shared the cake with us at my wife's office said it was delicious. Can't wait to get another one!!! read more

Mazzotta's Bakery - Bungalow Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

She made the best red velvet cake I've ever had! Honestly! The service was great too, she'll be my new baker to go to! I was tired of the same people at these big places disappointing me and I was happy to find a family owned business. I'm happy to see she lives up to the hype in these reviews. read more

Amazing quality, service, and ambiance. My dad said it was the best cheesecake he's had in a long time.

My mom ordered this cake for my boyfriend's birthday. We were trying something new and thought he would like it. One of the best cakes we've had. The decorating was beautiful. The pistachio mousse wasn't too sweet and was nice and light. The cake as moist and had a great texture with the pecan bits. Will definitely order cakes from here moving forward. I'd recommend this to anyone who likes desserts with nuts. A great small business! read more

Mazzotta's Bakery - Pistachio cake with pistachio mousse - Bakeries Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

I ordered a carrot cake for my daughter's birthday, she is studying at Wesleyan University. Maria was very helpful and also thought of everything she would need to enjoy the cake with her friends. My daughter and her friends loved the cake and said it was delicious. Thank you Maria! read more

Ordered a red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting for a company function and it was incredible!! Everyone commented on how delicious it was, how moist and home-made it tasted - well worth the calories. The decoration was also on theme with our company colors and she added our logo on edible paper, which was a nice surprise. I highly recommend this bakery. read more

Not a bad place to go. The food is tasty. I would recommend trying it if you're in the neighborhood

I found Mazzotta's on Yelp and called 3 days before my Mom's 65th birthday in hopes for a spectacular cake. Not only did Maria call me back immediately after I left a message, she took the time to work with me and understand the vision I had for the cake because it was for someone so special. Despite the last minute call, she made the cake with so much love and attention, I was blown away. After one bite, my husband and I decided we were going to ask Maria to bake us a cake for our anniversary. Fast forward a couple more days, and I have placed an order for cupcakes for my upcoming baby shower!! Maria at Mazzotta's is phenomenal! The cakes are DELICIOUS, the menu is extensive (not only cakes, but other amazing selections!!) and she offers delivery!! I highly recommend Mazzotta's Italian bakery and will be ordering from her until the end of time. read more

See all

Never ever did I expect the knowledge and understanding I got from Mazzottas. We needed a large order of Dairy Free, Gluten Free cupcakes for a wedding for those who could not eat the Traditional Wedding Cake! When I first reached out to her every question I asked get a "of course we do" answer. Boy were they delicious and I felt bad putting a sign on the Tray saying Dairy Free, Gluten free as so many were scared to try them. It was their loss but for those who needed this they were so surprised!! Absolutely fantastic!! Thank you so very much!!! read more

The building is gorgeous and the food is all so nicely displayed. While we did have a bit of a wait, the staff was fast and so friendly! The pastry chef personally came out to talk to us about what was safe for my son who has a milk allergy. That made my day! We got a variety of pastrys and they were all fresh and delicious! So excited to have this place close by. We will be back!! read more

Mazzotta's Bakery - Awesome variety of pasties, they were all absolutely delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

This place has all your Italian bakery needs. It has pizza from the slice or pie and fesserts ranging from gelato to canolis. The prices weren't bad either. I had a slice of the canolli pie and that was superb. The only reason I don't have 5 stsrs is the service is slow and the people working were gloomy. I will definitely be coming back for more dessert. read more

Worst Napoleon I have ever had. Soggy and near frozen in the middle Clearly not made recently Just another bulk bakery with goods brought in from another site read more

Maria is the best. I ordered a birthday cake for my son and she made it for me same day just so I'd have it on time. The Strawberry and cream is so delicious and fresh, It's perfect. My Wife's family had been getting cakes from the Mazzota's since she was a little girl and now we've kept the tradition going with our kids. Best Bakery in the State read more

Accidentally reviewed the wrong place so 5 stars for now. Owner touched base and was gracious I'm guessing I will love this place.

I ordered a birthday cake: it was so good half the guests had finished their second slice within ten minutes. They muttered about best cake they'd ever eaten: it was without doubt the best I'VE ever eaten. Plus, I'd ordered it only the day before, and it was ready exactly when promised. Efficient, delicious, and Maria was a pleasure to deal with. read more

Best cake ever. I've decided I'm not baking them anymore. She made a special order cake and it was incredible!

Maria made nine dozen beautiful, delicious cupcakes for my mom's 95th birthday! They were a hit with all the residents and staff at the senior living facility where my mom lives. My mom loves fresh strawberries so Maria put them into the cake and frosting, and topped each cupcake with a berry! read more

We ordered a birthday cake and it looked great and tasted even better! Our guests loved it and kept asking where I got it from. Service and communication was great as well. Definitely recommend this place for events! read more

Shout out to Mazzotta's Bakery for delivering a beautiful custom cupcake creation to my son in college for his 19th birthday. This out of town mom was grateful that they were easy to work with, responsive, flexible, had great ideas, made delicious cakes, delivered on time. Talented bakers, terrific business! read more

Amazingly talented and wonderful business woman. She treated us with such kindness and respect from the moment we walked in the door. She is excellent and the cakes are DELICIOUS!! read more

I had ordered a cake a week in advance for a special reunion of my unit in the army. This cake was supposed to be the great desert finish. The cake was to have our combat patch (edible) in the middle. The cake was to be picked up on 6 August 2022. Not only did I have to wait 15-20 minutes for it to be ready, but the special middle was paper. I was told no one took care of the middle piece and freeze it it was simply not done. I was told I could take pictures with this middle, and take off and smooth the whipped cream frosting over any imperfections it made. It was basically a take it or leave attitude. The cake itself was not great. I paid 100 dollars for a cake ordered in plenty of time (at least a week), that wasn't what I ordered and rudely told basically you get what you get. I will never ever order from this place again. I will make sure I tell everyone who will listen that this place is way overpriced and if this is their helps attitude and baking skills it sucks. If you treat combat veterans who recently retired this way, I feel real bad for all the honest hardworking people you serve. You should close your business read more

I would have given the bakery five stars but the service was EXTREMLY slow. I walked in at 10 am and there were 8 people ahead of me and I only saw one sales clerk. I walked out and returned at around 1:30. I took a number as the large sign indicated I should do and waited in line again with only four customers ahead of me. They had two women now and one was training a young girl. One sales lady was talking about her grandson, on and on...Holy moly, talk about slow and they weren't even using the numbered tickets. Others customers were coming and going in front questioning what number they were on now. There were approximately 15 customers in the bakery when I got waited on. NOTHING was priced or labeled?? Hopefully, they will things will get better because the pastry was delicious! I would only stop in again if I didn't see any cars out front. read more

Every time I'm in town I have to pick up some delicious cannolis and more than it's always somebody's birthday!! She can make any cake for you in any design!!! Maria is the best!!!! read more

Best in all of ct - Florida people do not know what a true Italian bakery is - staff is awesome

I highly recommend them. For the students at Wesleyan, they will deliver huge, warm cookies to wherever they are on campus. The staff is delightful. read more

Recently had a 9" strawberry cream cake from Mazzotta's and it was delicious! Not too heavy, not too sweet, wonderfully layered with good strawberries and covered in whipped cream, everyone loved it. Highly recommended! read more

Used Mazzotta's to cater my son's rehearsal dinner for his wedding this past weekend and could not have been happier. The food was excellent and the peach/fresh strawberry cake was delicious. Would highly recommend them for any any events, we will definitely be using them for any of our future events. read more

As a special treat for my 70th birthday, my daughter arranged for a completely no-sugar-added cake from Mazotta's. It was not only delicious, it was beautiful also. Amy said it was a pleasure to work with Mazotta's to have made exactly what I would want. Thank you! read more