When visiting my boyfriend's mother and stepdad with him this month, we wanted to have a pizza night as his nephew was staying for the summer in Eustis. They recommended this local spot, and I was excited to be able to support a locally ran restaurant. I would have loved to have dined in, but we picked up to take home to enjoy after placing an online order. What We Ordered: - Deluxe: my boyfriend said this was delicious albeit a bit greasy, which I shared the same sentiment with the pizza I ate. - Pepperoni + Mushroom: I shared this with his nephew as he wanted pepperoni and I wanted mushroom. It had a great crust, and you can tell they make the dough. Though a bit greasy, it was a very good pizza. Heck, I even had a third slice versus my usual two as it was that satisfying. One of the better I've had in 2026, and left me wanting pizza again when I got home. The staff was friendly when my boyfriend's mother popped in and mentioned they have a great dining area if we chose to dine in when we visit next as I remarked I'd love to try the pasta here as I'm more of a pasta girlie versus pizza. I'd definitely suggest to support this great local Italian place if in the area. read more

See all

First of all this establishment is 5 STAR restaurant! The restaurant was completely full when we arrived so please read the low rated reviews with a grain of salt. This restaurant is one of the best Italian restaurants that I have been to. We were greeted by a very cordial person who gave us a selection of seating and promptly found a table that we desired. Upon arrival she made us feel like family. Shortly after we were seated Jenna, our friendly server, greeted us. She was a fantastic server from the time we sat down in our booth until the time we departed. The family atmosphere in this restaurant made me feel that I was eating at Grandma's house! The menu offered a spectacular variety of Italian specialties that would satisfy most individuals. I selected the Shrimp Alfredo, with the side of garlic knots, and could not believe how much it exceeded my expectations! The sauce was very creamy and tasty while the shrimp tasted like they just came out of the water. The shrimp were firm and also very tasty. The garlic knots were outstanding. I would highly recommend this restaurant for you next Italian style meal! It is worth the trip because I guarantee(I do not normally add this to my reviews) that you not be disappointed! By the way the prices were reasonable for the amount and quality of food that you receive. Thank you for the wonderful experience and I will return the next time I am in the area! read more

Our server was very knowledgeable and friendly. The restaurant was clean and comfortable. I had the linguini with clam sauce and my husband had spaghetti and meatballs. The portions were huge and both were very tasty. The garlic knots were fresh and hot and the side salads were generous and fresh. read more

Luigi's Italian Restaurant - Spaghetti with Meatballs - Italian Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

Great meal here. We both got the assortment of a little bit of everything main course. Yummy. Huge. Garlic knots were awesome. We'll be back. read more

Luigi's Italian Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Our dinner was great !!! Great service and even better food! Little busy but got our food quickly!

Four of us went to lunch and it was in the first week they were open. They were very busy but we got a table immediately and a very pleasant smiling waitstaff was there to take our order. Everyone at the table thoroughly enjoyed every part of the meal. Speed and quality and quantity were all there and we walked away stuffed with smiles on our face. read more

Disappointing Service Overshadowed Excellent Food My wife and I visited Luigi's Italian Restaurant in Eustis, FL on January 9, 2026, expecting a great experience based on the many positive reviews. Unfortunately, while the food itself was excellent, the service and management response left a very poor impression. I ordered the veal marsala, and while it was well prepared, the portion was extremely small -- the veal medallion was roughly the size of a small playing card. When I politely mentioned this to our server, her demeanor changed immediately. She acknowledged the comment but essentially disengaged from our table afterward. I asked to speak with a manager, who explained that portions are determined by weight. After some discussion, he asked what resolution I was looking for, and I suggested that an additional piece of veal would be appropriate. He abruptly said that was not possible. A few minutes later, he returned and offered a 10% discount on the meals, which amounted to about $5 total. Frankly, I would have preferred a reasonable portion over a small discount. To add to the experience, I paid with an American Express card, and the server was unfamiliar with the data entry process and entered the CCV incorrectly. When she returned to the table, she loudly announced that my card had been declined. It was not declined -- I showed her how to enter the correct CCV, and the charge went through without issue. The food was genuinely very good, but between the abrupt change in service, the lack of a reasonable solution from management, and the embarrassing handling of the payment, we will not be returning. Quality food alone does not make up for poor customer service read more

No ambiance whatsoever. Served raw onion and green pepper on top of a slice of pizza. RAW! Never have I seen that in 72 years! This is the third time I've been disappointed by this place. Won't return. They wouldn't know Italian cooking if it slapped them in the face with a glove! read more

Luigi's Italian Restaurant - Raw onions and green peppers on a slice! - Italian Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Fantastic take out pizza- large supreme- great crust, cheese and layers of very delicious ingredients!!! Pricing is fair and service is on point. Will dine in on our next visit. read more

My hubby and I come here often. Food is always good and on point. The servings are large so I always take home leftovers. The service is usually fast unless it's a busy time of day then it can be a tad bit slow. read more

I called due to the pizza is charcoal burnt on the bottom, the lady said we asked for extra crispy and that's how extra crispy is and to next time not ask for extra crispy if you don't want charcoal, never in my life have I seen any pizza place burn the pizza and use the customer asked for extra crispy in order to not feel they need to right their wrong, I typically love this place but this just changed my opinion. read more

Luigi's Italian Restaurant - Is that extra crispy or just plain burnt? - Italian Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Omg!!!!So,like so many things here this is another hidden gem. Casual family friendly dining/pizzeria. Everything from the staff to the food is amazing!!!! Be warned,it can get busy and loud. It's worth it though! read more

No soup, it was spilled all over the meal. Pasta was in the wrong meal. Ordered before without issues, this was a mess read more

Luigi's Italian Restaurant - My soup was left spilled over . The wrong pasta was given. Worst order from them - Italian Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Food was very good but I ordered meat sauce and got meatless sauce. This is the second time this happened and I hadn't been back for 3 - 4 months. Today makes me not want to go back again and haven't decided if a return is worth it. Waitress told me they make a big batch of sauce and breakup one meatball and the meat is few and far to be seen. read more

Great affordable Italian food. I'm partial to their chicken Parmesan but the Stromboli is tasty as are their subs and pizza. Eat in or take out. read more

We have been here twice now, and we LOVE the food! Sometimes you think of Italian taste the same, but then you taste the REAL real. Get in there for the giant meatball and some to-die-for garlic knots. Super friendly staff and great location make it a no brainer. read more

Place is hit or miss. Been a few times and sometimes the pizza is good next time not so much. Last time I went I noticed they charged me .79 cents for raw onions on a meatball sub. I understand onions cost money but .79 cents for a slice of onion on a sub is ridiculous. read more

This was such delicious pizza! We were working late and just wanted to pick up something quick. So good. Everyone was super friendly on the phone as well as at the restaurant. Don't pass this place by just because it is very unassuming and in a strip mall. read more

Great service at lunch. The white pizza was piping hot and delicious. The eggplant parm was good, and a generous portion for a lunch special. The breadsticks were very hot, but a little bland (more salt/garlic, please). We will definitely return to try more things on the menu. read more

Got two extra large pizzas to go and picked them up! Great pizza, on time and my house guests loved them! Tangy sauce and cheesy! Yum.

We got the white pizza and garlic knots with marinara sauce. So yummy!! We've eaten here a few times already since moving to the area.

The food was very good. I forgot to ask for my pasta al dente, so it a slightly overcooked. The one thing I didn't like was the fact that they brought my soup out and as I started to eat it, my dinner plate arrived. I am not sure if the waitress caused that or the kitchen just does that routinely. The waitress was did a good job. I didn't have an empty glass until I was ready to leave. read more

Great food and big portions. Better be ready for a fest. You will leave with a food buzz. Enjoyed it!!

This is a family owned, operated, authentic Italian Restaurant. It feels like home, even if you're not Italian, you feel like you could be while eating here. EVERY THING is cooked fresh. This place is also formerly known as Gigis that was in Sorrento. Besides the food, Luigi, Samantha & Brenda are the staples of this place that make you want to come back. I have tried almost everything on the menus & everything was perfect. Even the to go orders are just as amazing when you get home. The staff are all caring, funny & loving! #LizzieSaidWhat Make this place your every week Italian fix! read more

We tried Luigi's a couple of weeks ago, and we were NOT disappointed! I have to say that this is the best pizza that I've had in this area. Their pasta dishes are amazing, their house salad and garlic knots are great too! I'm already planning to order again this upcoming weekend. They have amazing curbside service as well, with very friendly employees. read more

Luigi's Italian Restaurant - White pizza with added spinach. - Italian Near Me - Eustis, Florida

The food was fresh and delicious. Rhe customer service was awesome. You freaky feel at home coming here. I can't wait to go back and try something new. We had calamari, 2 different subs, garlic knots and 2 types of pasta. Sausage with marinara and chicken alfredo. Everyone tried a little of each and we were all very happy with our meals! read more

Love this place , found it by accident . Wait staff is hilarious , eclectic and super sweet ! Salad was fresh green and crisp , getting hard to find . Had the Angel hair with 3 huge meatballs . I could only eat 1/3 of it , took the rest home and ate two more times on it . I'm here now for my second visit , everything is the same so far ........... give it a try ! read more

Employees talked crap and made fun of other friendly customers in front of me that came in for service. Seemed pretty classless. Then, they messed up my $80 take out order, despite me repeating the instructions. When I called in to get it corrected, the manager talked down and got an attitude as if it was my fault they messed up the order. They refused to change it out at first even. I informed them they won't be receiving my family's business again. Bad service. read more

Worst service EVER!! There was 8 of us for a birthday. Everyone got their food but my mom's friends food was not correct. So they said they'd correct it. The server kept coming back and saying it would only be a few more minutes. Well, we were all pretty much done eating by the time she finally got her food so she asked for a to go box. She then received the bill and her meal was not comped or at least 50% taken off. She asked the server about it and she said she'd talk to the manager. She then came back and said 15% was as good as they could do or they would just comp the meal. My mom's friend politely asked them to just comp the meal. The server then took her food away. I've never in my life seen that. She wasn't looking for a free meal. Just at least 50% off. My best friend is a manager at a restaurant and I spoke with her about it. She said there was no way she'd ever allow that and there would be repercussions for the server if they took the food away. I think everything was handled poorly. My mom's friend didn't even get to eat dinner. We will most certainly never return. read more