Been going here since I was a kid. Never had any problems, and in my opinion they taste way better…read morethan any place in town.

We got sick shortly after arriving home from dinner after eating a little bit of our mediocre…read morepizza. The pizza had extra oil poured on the crust, very greasy. Being the only diners there should have clued us in.

We picked up take out from Stars and Stripes and I have to say I was very pleased with what I…read morefound. The food was really really good especially the pie. We ordered just a basic pepperoni pizza, a supreme calzone and greek salad. The pizza was my favorite. I will definitely be back and ordering it again. The greek salad was very large and a good value for the money. I will likely order this again as well. The calzone wasn't bad but Ive had better not sure if I will order this again especially since there is so much better things on the menu and other items to explore.

Stars & Stripes has amazing gyros (at a bargain price that comes with a side of chips) and…read moreincredible small pizzas (their Hawaiian one is exceptional). Also they have very reasonable rates for their 2L bottles of soda (I think under $3 which is cheaper than a smaller bottle at a vending machine). I will definitely try their wings next time! Service is also very prompt and even though the interior is not designed for eating, it is still relatively spacious. Certainly recommended for a place to order pizza, wings, gyros, salads and 2L beverages!

Another weekend on Route 66! This time our stop was in Arcadia, OK at the Pizza Shack. In my…read morenever ending quest to find great pizza I stumbled across this place totally by accident. They have been opened for just about a year and they are right next to the Chicken Shack which is owned by the same people. Another great place to try. Although they only serve one size pizza and it's a thin crust my thoughts were that this wasn't a pizza for me. However, my wife loves the thin crust so I made an exception and thought I had to try it. We arrived later in the afternoon and we were the first dine-in customers. I noticed several others come in for to go orders. Now I'm not familiar with the Iowa Stone Pizza but I was about to be schooled! For simplicity sake one size, one style is not a bad concept. We opted for the Canadian Bacon & Pineapple and for many that's blasphemous but it reality it's a very good combo. My wife felt the meats would be too heavy on her stomach as she was getting over a short illness. Overall the pizza was better than I have expected since I'm not the thin crust kind of guy. It held up nicely with the toppings and cheese. If we make our way back again I'll have to remember not so much cheese. I'm not as big a cheese fan as my wife, typically she'll order extra cheese - she didn't on this one! We started out with the Savannah Sticks - Cheesy Bread - tasty, but I'm not a cheesy bread fan. The staff was quite enjoyable and they provided us with all the details we could ask for! They were quite engaging and that made the dining experience great. Unique rustic indoor dining decor, we sat at a picnic table and had a great conversation with our friends! Obviously there was more pizza than we could eat so a take home bag was in store for us! Their Saturday hours made it easy for us to choose a time to go. Weekdays they open at 4 but Saturday's they open at 11. This is just another stop in my weekend adventures and another restaurant in Route 66.

They have great pizza (10" ones also available) as well as breadsticks, and the interior…read moreenvironment is awesome with a lot of historical decorations and things on the wall. Also the store is connected to the Chicken Shack which is adjacent. They are also able to make smaller pies for you, so excellent service. Visit both this place and the chicken shack if you are ever on historic Route 66!

Really like the owner. He was friendly and talkative…read more The pizza was pretty good. The price was reasonable.

I'm undecided about this place so I'm going to go back and try other items on the menu. I was not…read morereally impressed with the pizza it was a pre-made pizza dough ready to bake once toppings were put on, just wasn't for me. Ditto for the Calzone. Unfortunately I forgot to snap a pic. I do want to try their wings & subs so a return trip is in my future.

Wow! It's hard to believe that I have not visited here since 2015! Not for lack of not wanting to…read morebut rather my job took me away from this area. I never really dined in but always had orders called in for pickup. For whatever reason my wife wanted pizza but not our normal stops. Papa Angelo's was her choice. I had forgotten they have two sets of hours first from 1100 - 2:00 then again from 5:00 - 9:00. We arrived before 5 so we waited until they opened. My wife really didn't care what type of pizza so I ordered a 20" pizza 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 Italian sausage. Also ordered 2 side salads. The salads were well prepared! My only thing to put this over the top would be to serve in cold bowls. I opted for the house dressing which was delicious. The pizza was good like I remembered. I would prefer a little more sauce on my pizza but I think by default they have a set amount they put on. I would definitely get more sauce on my pizza on my next visit. It's not my favorite crust but it works! There is plenty of seating with a large area for groups. Adina who is part of the family came to visit with us at our table and we gained a lot of information about the restaurant and her family. What a wonderful woman to meet! Also on Friday's they have live music and they set up just prior to us leaving! We listened to a few songs prior to leading. I promise it won't be 10 years beside going back again!

I love this place. They have a great lunch special where you can just get some slices and not a…read morewhole pizza which is great when I'm on my own. Also love the amount of TVs are great when you want to watch some sports.

We visit often and look for new food ventures when here. First night would be pizza and chilling…read more Looked at many, found this and saw some nostalgic looking crust on the thin pizza. Read reviews but they all over the place. We experienced nothing but some older men taking orders and cooking - very friendly. Told them came in from Dallas and they seemed surprised. Pizza met our expectations. Will be back.

Meh. A little after 1pm on a Monday and we were the only ones there. The lady working was kind of…read morerude to my husband. He had walked in, said "we've never been here, is the pizza good?" To which the lady said "it should be". I walked over to the buffet. It was typical salad bar and a few pizzas that didn't look bad. Didn't look great. We decided we weren't really excited to eat there so we left. We went to a pizza place down the street and they were excited to see us walk through their doors.

My son, who is undoubtedly a pizza connoisseur, said this was the best pizza he's ever had…read more Granted, he is a seven-year-old kid who only eats cheese pizza. However, the rest of the family was impressed as well. I got the philbrook classic and could actually taste the garlic and tomatoes. Pictured is the golden driller, which I am told was very good, too! Will definitely be back.

Great pizza! We really love the sauce and crust. Veteran owned small business. Give it a try.read more

This place is a keeper! It was our first time there and the pizza and service were fantastic. We…read morereally appreciate an entrepreneurial spirit and this place has it and does pizza better than most that have a lot more name recognition. Some of those places can sometimes live off of their reputation and can scale so large that they lose what made them great. Oak City takes nothing for granted regarding the pizza, cold beer (at a great price) or their service. The staff were very friendly and the owner was really engaging. Since it was our first time there, she came out to our table to ask us how everything was and talked about how they got their start and a bit about their passion for making really great pizza. We have had excellent Neapolitan style pizza at some of the best places in the state and the metro, namely -- Andolini's in Tulsa on Cherry Street and the Wedge in midtown OKC, and neither of them have anything on Oak city. To start, the crust is tender and bubbly around the edges and has a great flavor. It looks exactly like the pictures on their web site and It's made from a 5 year old sour dough starter and is absolutely a perfect artisan style crust. The sauce has a mild, but distinctive tomato flavor that won't overpower the crust or the toppings. There is also no need to order extra cheese because the normal amount is plenty. We will definitely be back soon, and next time, we'll try the Detroit style pizza too -- along with the original. Do yourself a favor and try this place out soon. And by the way -- this is a legitimate review -- no 9ne asked me to write it, I just appreciate their product and effort.

First, I'll say this pizza is amazing. Having lived in Europe for several years, the margherita…read morepizza really hits and tastes similar to some of the best pizzas I've had in Italy. However, the team needs to work on ensuring that quality is 100% every time an order goes out. A few months ago, I came on a very busy night and the margherita pizza wasn't as crispy as it usually is. We also ordered the pesto pizza, and the balsamic glaze was forgotten. This week I went back and ordered the bone-in wings along with the margherita pizza. The pizza was excellent and ranks among some of the best in OKC. The wings started off tasting good, but I quickly realized they were not fully cooked -- they were ice-cold near the bone. I'm hoping they were pre-cooked and just not reheated properly. The staff did refund my money for the wings, which I appreciated. However, it would have been a nice gesture for a manager to stop by and apologize. Overall, this just highlights that the team needs to focus more on consistency and quality control. That said, this experience won't stop me from coming back, because the pizza truly is very good.