Horrendous service - this is an older pizza place and I wanted to like it. I've never been and for the first time went today for some football pizza pies for the house. An older white haired guy with an accent took my order and when it was ready simply put the boxes in the counter and pointed to me. Call me old school but a smile and a thanks certainly still goes a long way... I asked if those were my pies. He nodded without a word and walked away after putting a credit card slip and pen on the counter. I get it that he's a popular place and seems to have the monopoly in the area. I however am not from the area and won't return as this was a "gotta try it" decision. Message for ownership -- Appreciate your customers and maybe you will have more consistent business. As for the pizza, it was simply an unremarkable "meh", and didn't blow me away. With all the Italian and pizza spots in Jersey there are so many better experiences and better tasting also out there. I will not be returning. read more

M & S Pizza - Not an out of his world nearly 5 star place. If you have nowhere else to go, they have pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

Wow....BEST. PIZZA. EVER. I highly recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza if you like a bit of spice. Also the stuffed meat pizza is amazing read more

M & S Pizza - Buffalo pizza and stuffed meat pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

Very old school looking Pizzeria. Looks like the building is straight out of the late 70's / early 80's. This is mostly a take out place I find. Food wise is great. Pizza has a good amount of cheese and toppings. The Sicilian Pizza is the best here. The hot sandwiches worth a try. Chicken Parmesan sandwich is my favorite here. read more

M & S Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

I love the pizza here. This is my favorite place to pick up a pie. The texture of the dough, the cheese and the sauce are all perfect. The staff are all the same people who have been there for many years and I assume it is a family owned business. These guys know how to make pizza. Far to often you go to a pizza place and everything is pre-made or the guy making the pies has only been at it a few weeks. Not at M&S. You can tell Pizza is their life. I have been going here for many years and they have consistently been the best. I remember coming here as a kid with my dad and sitting at the tables drinking the grape juice. They always had cups from other restaurants that I had never heard of (Must buy them as surplus). The memories that come back each time I walk in the door makes this #1 automatically for pizza in my book. read more

Great food and good price. Considering everything in New Jersey is expensive as hell.

Really good basic pizza. Consistent and well priced. The eggplant pie is a favorite, always enjoyable.

Good solid pizza, slices could be bigger, cant go wrong looking for a quick bite to eat read more

M & S Pizza - Plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

M&S I is pretty much only pizza we order. Always delicious with just right amount of sauce & cheese with tasty crust. Chicken Parmigiana platter can't be beat! Excellent staff! read more

Pretty much on par with your average NJ pizza place. Definitely some higher quality spots in South Jersey. However, I think this is a great representation of your old school pizza shop. Worth stopping by for a quick slice. read more

I ordered a large pepperoni pie. They were quite generous with the pepperoni. That being said, the crust was floppy, not crispy at all. The sauce was over-salty, and there was far too much cheese. They did not cut the pie well either. They did not cut through the crust at all, and I need my slicer just to take slices out of the box. The crust was so floppy, that the cheese and pepperoni fell off of the front of the slice. This is so different from the rest of the reviews here that I cannot help but wonder if maybe they were just off tonight read more

I'm in town from Alabama for work and my girlfriend, who is from New Jersey originally, told me I had to try local pizza and subs. She swore up and down That anything I could get here would be worlds above what I can get in Alabama. So I went to M&S and I got a couple slices of pepperoni pizza and a peppers and sausage sub. I was utterly amazed at how good the bread for the sub was, the pizza crust was crunchy and chewy at the same time, and was better than any pizza I've ever eaten before in my life and so was the sub. read more

M & S Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

See all

Cheesesteak meat is the lowest grade you can possibly buy. I'm insulted you served me this pigs feed for 10$. It was chewy like bubblegum. How vile. Shame on you. read more

Great pizza. The crust holds itself up when folded. Good sauce to cheese ratio... I wish there was a little more sauce though since it is very tasty. The crust itself was both crunchy and chewy. Staff was prompt and friendly. Keep up the good work. read more

Great little quaint pizza place right on the highway. Good parking in a lot next to the building, and an atmosphere that makes it known this is a pizzaria. I love walking in straight to the counter because it feels like I am back in high school with the environment and decor. Pizza is amazing as well as the garlic knots. read more

Good tasting pizza! Perfect balance between cheese, sauce and dough. Old school feel pizzeria is hard to find these days in Jersey. The guys behind the counter even look the part! Furniture is all wooden and old school. I also get the strombolis as well. Not the best, but above average for a pizzeria. If you really want good strobolis, head down by Rutgers, on Easton Ave and go to Stuff Yer Face =) Another thing worth noting that M&S has are their unique drinks. I like the grape flavor the most. read more

Let me be very clear in sighting my credibility on food on matters. I have lived and worked in Bergen County for a few years and have many drunken nights in NYC. Living back in Rockaway I can clearly and absolutely without a doubt say this is my favorite pizzeria. A few deciding factors let me point to this simple conclusions. First) For as long as I can remember, it's been the same three guys in there everytime I walk in. Weekend, weekday, day or night. The old man with white hair, the heavy set gentlemen and the other fellow wearing glasses. Second) For as long as I can remember, they have NEVER delivered. A pizza place in this day and age that doesn't deliver and still be in the business? What does that tell you about this place? That people are willing to drive and pick up their food because it is just that good. I have had chicken parm subs (phenomenal), meatball parm subs, plain pies, buffalo pies, margherita pie (probably the greatest one there) as well as pepperoni pie and I would gladly drive here and pick any of these up than order elsewhere. Overall, I've been ordering from here for years and will continue to do so. Stay true to your extra saucey, perfectly cheese covered, crisp bottom dough yet fluffy crust for all time M & S. If you do order make sure it is M&S and not M&S II !!! read more

Love this place, the food is great the service is phenomenal!! Everyone who works here is warm and friendly and they do wonders to make sure you leave feeling good. read more

I oreded lg meatball and onion as picture someone upload it. Pizza is above average but the best I ever had. Ill go back again unless I find better one near by. One thing downfall was, the owner isn't really frendly guy. Maybe he were tired of holiday season but no greeting no thank you. Just grumpy guy. Hope he fix his attitude towards the customer in the future. read more

I'm not a fan of pizza unless it's buffalo chicken or deep dish...but this pizza is fabulous! The crust is the perfect amount of fluffy and crunchy. The cheese and sauce is always flavorful and fresh. This is our go to pizza place and it has been consistently great for years. read more

My favorite pizzeria ever since I was a child I introduce my girlfriend she's from Pennsylvania she said she love the pizza and the combination sub meatball parm and chicken parm so far. read more

M&S is RESTAURANT quality food in a pizzeria. They have amazing pizza. I love the thin and my family loves the sicilian. Their subs are fresh and tasty -- hot or cold. When you order a cheese steak the peppers are actually fresh peppers cut by hand (not from a can). Wings great. They do have a dining area -- but you don't go for the ambiance. The attention they aren't giving to their decor is focused on their food which is a good thing. read more

Everyone in the reviews seems to love the pizza so I think I probably just got a bad pie. The thing was a total sauce fest. Ingredients tasted fresh. Just edible regular (saucy) pizza read more

This place is a classic for me. Good Pizza, Easy Location, great prices. Also you can't beat their Sunday deal for a pie

This place is a great old time pizza place. The pizza is great! If I lived here full time I would be one of their regulars. read more

I love trying highly rated pizza places on yelp. This place was a waste of calories and time. I'm shocked this place was rated anywhere above 2 stars. Number one it was a very dirty eating area. We arrived maybe 5 minutes after opening and we had to wipe down our own table as every single table was full of crumbs, grease soda spills. Probably there from the night before. I enjoy a hole in the wall feel, but this was gross. The pizza was not good at all. Way too cheesey . Garbage cheese, sauce was watery. Crust flopped right down and couldn't support a helium balloon let alone the mountain of water and melted cheese it had on it. The dough it self tasted very floury. Honestly the worst pizza I've had in Jersey. Mall pizza is better. read more

Yup believe the hype! It's all about great pizza. Spoke to the guys and they are in no way connected to the M&S II up the block. Sauce was tangy and the pizza tasted great. read more

One of our favorite pizza places. Straight forward, high quality pizza. Their Sicilian pie is also very good, as is their antipasto salad. We also like their sub sandwiches. We have been going here as long as I remember and have never been disappointed. read more

I have been coming here since I was a kid with my parents. Very friendly guys who seem like they never forget a face. This is a classic pizzeria. I have always had a good experience here. The pizza is delicious whether you are eating in or bringing it home (sometimes take out doesn't taste the same as if you're eating in but that doesn't happen here). Hands down the BEST Sicilian and Plain slice in the area read more

This place is incredible. Everything is great. Sausage is off the chart giid. Just hag a small Calpine with Sausage abd pepperoni that was to due fie. Ate the whole thing! This place is great,!! read more

In northern Jersey visiting family. I always try to get a slice before I leave. I was in Dover while visiting someone and found this place on Yelp. It did not disappoint! The crust is really good! Also got a chicken parm and it was piping hot and delicious too. Sat in store to eat and even though it was an off time, 2:30 on a Sunday, the place was bustling. read more

Without a doubt the BEST pizza on the planet. It's the SAUCE (full of flavor and put on the pie nice and saucy..no skimping or ladeling it on in a thin circle) - Its the CHEESE ( you CAN taste the difference in the flavor that comes out in their cheese others are waxy and tasteless - when you comapre M&S cheese to all others you notice immediately the difference in the taste and flavor of their cheese quality) - It's the CRUST ( Flavor so good you want to eat every bite). This is the place I will be telling my grandkids someday "now, back in the day we had a place called M&S...and they don't make pizza like that anymore". You go in and get a grape drink and it come out in a cup with some other businesses name on it. They don't care.. They dont waste their money on advertising of printing up their own cups.. They buy them from going out of business auctions or something... Because their product is the only advertising they need. NOW THAT really says something! Everyone from the area knows that there are 2 different M&S pizzas in the area on the same street (RT46) and within 1/4 mile of each other. This review is for M&S I NOT M&S II which sucks and is directly across from Shoprite in the old Burger King. I've always wondered WHY there are 2 pizza shops in the same town so close with nearly the same name. Was it a family feud situation where one family member left the business and said "I'll fix your a*s ..I'm moving down the street to open my OWN pizza place with the same name"... .????.. LOL! Whatever the case, M&S is amazing and so Delicious... My husband is on his way home right now with a pie..yum! read more

Love this place! Good pizza & sandwiches! Great people! I'm originally from Brooklyn New York and this place reminds me of what good pizza taste like! When it comes to pizza there is none better!!! read more

Delicious old fashion pizza. The restaurant doesn't look like much, and maybe it needs a fresh coat of paint, but the pizza is the best in town! read more

best regular non-specialty everyday oldschool Pizza joint in Morris County for sure. Great crowd. great sauce, great dough. the sicilian is very good and you have to wash it down with a grape soda or iced tea from the old fashion fountain soda machine. very good egg plant parm and cold cut sandwiches. read more

You want to start an argument? Then write the words "best" and "Pizza" in your next Yelp review. So I will refrain and restrain - let's just say, I love M&S Pizza. I eat there at least 3 times a month and almost every time my wife or I look at each other and say, "This is GOOD pizza..." We get it by the slice and we also take home whole pies - in either case, the results are always the same - This is GOOD pizza. Their home made sauce really makes it for me and the fresh dough and fresh mozzarella are icing on the cake. This is New Jersey pizza the way NJ pizza needs to be. The "ambiance" such as it is, is a throw back to the pizza places of my youth. SImple, almost Spartan seating. Clean and functional - that's all - nothing more or less. Good prices, friendly staff and ample parking. Case closed - go and enjoy a good slice. You'll love it. read more

MAKE SURE YOU ARE AT THE ORIGINAL M&S!! There is a Portuguese owned M&S ll nearby that makes the greasiest nasty pizza that I ever had. The original M&S is a no frills take out pizza place that has been in business for more than 40 years. The pizza is to die for. There has to be 8oz of sauce and nearly 1lb of cheese on each pie. Nobody and I mean nobody makes a Sicilian pizza like these guys!!! Must tries include the ham calzone its extraordinary. Additionally, these guys were toasting their Italian Combo sub before there was a Quiznos or Subway in NJ. If you are a sub fan, please try the Italian combo sub. You will have experienced sub heaven. I drive past 5 pizza places to get to M&S l and I bet you will too. read more

I am not sure where to begin.... sicilian pizza is the best I've ever had, the subs are enormous and VERY GOOD (not huge and flavorless). Meatballs.... excellent. I stop in whenever I pass the place. I also love the crushed ice and odd cups they use! read more

Disgusting pizza . I don't like the service or pizza at all! It tastes fake and Its to oily

Best Pizza in the area hands down nothing compares to it, I just don't like it, I LOVE IT!

Very good pizza from a unassuming '60s era storefront. The simple setting --- complete with orange- and grape-drink fountains --- will send you back in time. Efficient service, very reasonable prices. Top pizza pick for the area. read more