Stopped in for a quick lunch. Mario's had been here forever, but they are renovating the plaza so it's worth a visit to check out their new neighbors. I shared a slice of sausage pizza w/ hubby. It had a little kick and perfect amount of cheese. I tried the pepperoni, pesto and hot honey slice. It was a little flowery but pretty good! Hubby had the buffalo chicken slice. He never had one before. It looked good but he wasn't a fan. I think he's more of a traditionalist. I had a bite and say, yum! You can sit on the side for self-service or there is a great restaurant section w/ service and awesome specials. BYO and make it a date night. There's conveniently a liquor store next door. They always place nice music too! Stop in and enjoy. read more

See all

Stopped at this spot for lunch and ordered the fish wrap with other things for my clients. The order was called in and I picked up. When I arrived I parked in their lot. I walked in and paid at the counter. The place was big for eat in or take out. When I dug in the wrap was very good and filling just wish they put a little more tartar sauce for the wrap. All in all a decent experience. read more

Late-Night Gold in Jersey We rolled in late--way past what you'd expect most places to be serving anything worthwhile--but this little Jersey joint was still slinging slices like it was the middle of the day. And not just any slices... these were killer. Thin, crispy crust with that perfect fold, just enough grease to know it's the real deal, and toppings that tasted fresh, not like they came from a can five hours ago. What really made the night, though, was the owner. Totally unprompted, he came out to chat with us. Not in a rush, not doing the whole "how's everything?" drive-by. He pulled up, told us a bit about the shop, the dough, the sauce--stuff he actually cared about. You could tell this place is his baby, and it shows in every bite. Oh, and the ranch? Homemade. Not that packet stuff. Creamy, herby, a little garlicky--it made dipping the crust basically mandatory. It's rare to find that combo of good food, good people, and a spot that feels like home even if you've never been before. Jersey does it right. We'll be back when we fly out of Jersey, for sure. read more

Had a good Meal at this spot tonight. I had the food delivered so no comments about service or ambiance. I had the lasagna, chef salad, meatballs, and garlic knots. Everything was pretty good. Lasagna was cooked well, although the sauce was a little sweeter than I would prefer. Worth it to try if you get to go food. read more

Pizza hits the spot, excellent pasta dishes and great chicken dishes too. Fair prices for good food. My go to spot in the area for a traditional style large pie. read more

I will never turn down a good slice of pizza. Naturally, I was very excited to try this new spot when I was over a buddy's house. I'm from Hudson County born and raised, so good pizza is available rather easily here, and it is relatively abundant if you know where to look. I can't speak to the inside of the restaurant or the decor, as we had delivery. However, this place was prompt and had the food ready on time. Given where we were, we were pleasantly surprised by the food! Stromboli was excellent. It was cooked perfectly and very flavorful. As for the pizza, toppings were abundant and generous. Olive, pepperoni, sausage, Buffalo chicken, and plain cheese pizzas were all quite good. Cheese blend is also very nice and sauce was well-seasoned and flavorful. If you ask me, it was a bit of a departure from true New York pizza given that the crust was very crisp, making the pizza difficult to fold. However, that isn't a deal breaker, just a preference. Needless to say, would be happy to enjoy pizza from here again! read more

First time visit that came as a recommendation from the local wine shop. They were quick to tell me this was a place to go and must admit it's pretty good pizza! Nice people, and the knots were nicely done too! Solid four stars. read more

We have gotten delivery past 2 nights. Last night we got a pizza and spaghetti both was good. Tonight we got calamari and scallops both were yummy and we got lobster bisque its really good and got a cold sub for tomorrow. Delivery was on time and all the food was hot. Highly recommend this place. read more

The best Italian pizza restaurant near Randolph. I was try Grandma Pizza range from here it was fresh and hot...mmmmm what a taste. you must try from there. Good place for family dinning with your kids. That friendly staff really good. read more

Definitely mid pizza. Not the best I ever had nor was it the worst. Not super flavorful or something I absolutely must have again but just is okay. read more

If I could give this place negative stars I would. Ordered from this place and their app said 30 minutes. 2 hours later the food arrived cold. When I called about the order they iced multiple times about delivery times. First it was 45 minutes. Then an hour. Then 1.5 hours. When I finally complained they yelled at me for complaining. If you like food delivered in multiple hours and cold, I would highly recommend this place. Do not order from this place. Absolutely horrible. read more

I was starving and found this place while looking for a quick bite. The pizza was amazing. Probably the best pizza I've had in a very long time. The ambience was amazing. Had a casual section as well as a very upscale section and the service was quick and easy I was in and out. Enjoyed my food and left amazing place. Feel free to try here if you're in the area. read more

Mario's Famous Pizza is a very solid place for -yup- You guessed it, Pizza!! They also make some of the best Italian Comfort Food around. You literally can't go wrong with anything on the menu here, It's All very good and very consistent. For now they're a take out or curbside kinda place plus if You're hunkered down locally they have a fast and reliable delivery service so keep that in mind too. Hey did You know that Americans eat approximately 100 acres of pizza per day. That's a rate of 350 slices per second. Don't know about You, but I'm good for about half an acre a month ;) Not really sure why I never reviewed this spot up until now. Guess I gotsta step up My Yelp game . . [yeah right] Anyway, I'm here now and that's all that matters. Come And Get Your Munch On!! read more

Mario's Famous Pizza - "Plain Jane" - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Me and my family just came here, my aunt got a tuna pita. She said that it didn't taste that good, but something she could bare with. The pizza tasted good. The tables were nice and set and not dirty. Not to mention but the ceiling was a little dirty. The one thing that did confuse me was that there was no silverware when we got here. We ordered our food at 11:50 about, it came at 12:15 so it took 25 minutes. My grandma got a chicken cutlet, she got a small which was 7 inches and the large was 14 inches. She said it was very big. I got BBQ wings and usually when I go somewhere they're spicy, but here it wasn't spicy at all. I also saw a fly near my food. I wouldn't recommend this place if you want something nice and fancy. read more

So I asked the hotel clerk where to get authentic New York style pizza here. Shouldn't have been a problem but alas, it Was not to be. I ordered a small pepperoni and green olive pizza. Here's the good: lots of pepperoni and large olives on the pizza. They definitely did not skip. Now for the note so great: it wasn't what I would consider NY style. The bottom crust was too crisp and the toppings on top weren't crisp enough. The cheese didn't have that great gooey texture and the cornicione (edge crust) was not big enough. While I could fold a piece in half, it just didn't have that flexibility that true New York pizza has. Now don't think that the pizza wasn't good - it was alright. It just didn't scratch the itch that this southern boy had for NY style while traveling up north. (One extra ding against this place was the condition of the restroom I used while waiting. Barely lit and someone had defiled it if you know what I mean. ) read more

Got wings and a chicken parmigiana sandwich. Something has changed. Out of 10 wings 9 were drumsticks and they were dry and overcooked. Chicken parmigiana was terrible as well. Not worth the price. read more

It had been quite a few years since I was last at Mario's and was pleasantly surprised by it. The entire shopping center is getting a facelift with KMart being knocked down and new fronts on all the stores. I don't remember too much about how Mario's was, but looks very nice now. There is a big seating area in the front which is more of a formal restaurant, with still plenty of seating in back if you're just having a slice. I had a slice of white with broccoli and a small Gatorade. The pizza was very good and the price was just under $4....can't beat that! This pizzeria also delivers so that may be a future option as well! read more

I've been a patron of Mario's Famous Pizza since I was sixteen years old, and their quality, courtesy, and professionalism have continually won me over and will continue to earn my patronage. The atmosphere is quiet, cozy, and you have a great view out towards route ten westbound, which can help you coordinate or plan for traffic while you're eating. The food is delicious and the quality has been consistently great, and the menu is expansive yet focused, providing for a unique dining experience or the comfort of familiar favorites. They're equally comfortable building unique flavors off of the menu, and frequently they try new things like cauliflower crust, and now have their own ice cream brand! Do your taste buds a favor and try them out today! read more

Trust me on this, I have craved their Buffalo Chicken Pizza for over 15 Years!!! I could never find one that stood up to it or matched it's flavor. Recently I returned home and it was the first thing on my list of things I needed to eat. It is has remained consistently exactly what I dreamed about daily. This is a "last meal" pizza. read more

This place used to be one of our favorite places to order in, but has really really gone downhill. The food has always been average Italian/pizza but as one of the only local places that delivers we ordered a lot. Unfortunately, tonight was the last straw. Not only did they take almost 2 hours to deliver, they were extremely rude and dismissive on the phone. They claimed they had gotten the order late, but Grubhub confirmed exactly when they had gotten it with their sign off in accepting. So in summary, rude and untruthful. I will say that their actual delivery guys are awesome. Our favorites here were the sandwiches - really good size for the money (and flavor of course). The pastrami and egg is a standout. We get the regular cheese pizza for the kids - serviceable, but average. Good for kids, not really for adults. Anyway, goodbye to Mario's for us. read more

Great local spot. Ordered her for the first time after my sons party venue recommended them and has been our Friday night pizza since. Was surprised at how big and nice it was when we went to pick up the order in person one night (we usually opt for delivery). Solid menu with many options. read more

The food is very good however my sister and I noticed they changed the aluminum pan size of half tray size. It doesnt look the same as usual when we order before. I actually measure the depth of the pan is 2". The standard size of Half Size Deep Foil Pan - Depth = 2 9/16 Inches, Top Length = 12 3/4 Inches, Top Width = 10 3/8 Inches, Capacity = 120 oz. read more

We like the in restaurant dining area. Roomy and great atmosphere. Prices are reasonable. Zucchini sticks were amazing. Look a at the size of that cheesesteak Stromboli!!! BEST chicken parm sandwich I've ever eaten!!! read more

See all

Delivery was great and we love the veggie pizza the most but everything was great! Professional and friendly too!

This place is a gem. Pizza is always on point as ordered. I just had seafood fra devlo. Seafood perfection and generous. Sauce is wonderful taste. Pasta is always al dente. Also, great meatballs & lasagna. read more

Tonight we went to one of our favorite Italian restaurants in Morris County, When you're looking for a GREAT meal with HUGE portions-Mario's is your destination. We found this little place about five years ago and we have NEVER-EVER had a bad meal, bad service or a single complaint. I've also never finished a meal there because the portions are seriously huge. There's been times I've gotten dinner and another two lunches out of the leftovers. Now the place isn't fancy - one side is the pizzeria with 12-14 tables on the restaurant side, but you won't be disappointed. I've never had their pizza, but my 9-year old son rates it as a 4-star slice. Tonight I went with the shrimp Parm, my wife had the chicken parm, my kids had vodka sauce with chicken and linguini with garlic and oil. absolutely delicious. If you love garlic-they aren't afraid to use it - garlic bread, scampi, garlic and oil are all well doused with nice pieces of chopped (not minced) garlic. My personal favorite isn't on the menu, but they'll make it if you ask...if you like seafood and spicy in one meal order the seafood combo fra diablo-and ask them to make it extra spicy. So the next time you're in the mood for great Italian-and a lot of it-grab a bottle of red wine or a few beers (it's BYOB), drive out to Mario's and have one of the best pasta meals you're going to get. read more

This place has GREAT pizza! I ordered some shrimp pizza and Buffalo wings via DoorDash. It's a little strange because you can't track the driver or when it'll come. But it's not a big deal. I got the small pizza which in my opinion was pretty big. I've never had shrimp on a pizza but man I was pleasantly surprised. If you're looking for some yummy local food I recommend this place :) read more

Mario's Famous Pizza - Buffalo wings - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Ordered Veal Frances's with linguine and they gave me the veal and lemon butter sauce in one container and the pasta in a separate container with red sauce on it. Why would I want a red sauce on the pasta when I got lemon butter sauce? When I called to see if they would fix it I was told that it was MY fault that the mistake was made and that's how they always make the food... you always make the food with two different sauces? That isn't correct. We order here before and have never had the pasta separately or with a different sauce. Youre telling me it was an "accident" that they put the linguine in with the dinner previously? Youre telling me that the menu saying the entree comes with pasta is a mistake too? You're supposed to magically know to ask for your pasta without red sauce? BS! Didn't even offer to make plain pasta for us to come get. Customer service is extremely lacking. read more

Mario's Famous Pizza is that family style comforting food. It reminds me of the Italian dishes we used to eat in Newark, NJ where the tastes are delectable and the sauces are made with love! When I eat Mario's food it brings me back to my childhood days. Keep doing what you are doing Mario! We love you! Angelina R. & Family read more

It is between M&S and Mario's who has the best pizza in the Randolph/Dover area... prove me wrong. Fair prices and great specialty pies make this place my favorite. There is a reason this place has lasted while almost all the other stores around it have come and gone including Blockbuster, K-mart, and Pathmark. I highly recommend the buffalo chicken pizza. read more

Mario's Famous Pizza - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Food is worth going there for. But we've just ordered from here for the last time. We just paid an extra $7 in fees, plus we tipped because they charge a delivery fee and convenience fee to use a credit card. We scheduled a 5:30 delivery hours earlier, but food arrived at 6:05. The delivery fee does not go to the driver... in the end, we are paying for the driver's hourly rate and tipping on top of their profit from general business. No Thanks. read more

I've been ordering from Mario's for eons, and typically it's delivery all the way with my schedule! The pizza is good, although if you're looking for that deep down authentic Nona-just-made-it Italian cuisine Mario's may not your place, I'll level with you. They pre-make their noodles (not uncommon and not a crime) so you'll never have an opportunity to experience anything al dente (at least for delivery). Their sauce...not bad but it has definitely gone through phases throughout the years, much akin to the rate of social media lingo trends. If you are looking for a basic pizza pie or a generous helping of baked ziti, or even a very generous hot or cold sub sandwich, Mario's does a pretty stand up job. Also, nobody can beat their BBQ chicken wings! The sauce is outstanding and the wings are plump and tender!! The half sub portion is big and the whole will last you for a couple meals if you play your cards right. Their meatballs are also not too shabby. I enjoy the chicken cutlet sandwich, the Margherita pizza, and the fact that they serve Anthony and Sons Bakery dinner rolls with their delivery orders. I do miss the bread that used to accompany the delivery orders but I found that I often didn't finish all of it and it ended up getting tossed so in terms of food waste, the pre-wrapped individual rolls are probably much kinder. The tuna salad has a funky taste and has for quite some time so I no longer dig the tuna salads. Delivery is usually very prompt and they have very nice delivery drivers. The dining room is cute and it's BYOB if you're in the mood and have the time to kick back and chow down on carbs while sipping your vino. To cap it off, Mario's is good if you're hungry and your palate mood is not particularly discriminatory. I wish they could really impress me but I'm here to speak truth folks. That said, Mario's will always be a cozy little pizzeria down the road when my stomach calls for a quick bite. read more

See all

Wait to tip until you see the pizza. This was cold and disappointing. They wanted it back to show the owner, because I guess the owner thinks his customers are liars. The only remedy offered was an exchange for another one. Doesn't quite work for kids that need to go to sleep. I would have rather had a refund. Worst pizza of my life. Ever. read more

Mario's Famous Pizza - Cold and destroyed pizza. - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

I grew up in NY and have to say, this is the closest thing to NY pizza I've ever had in NJ! The flavors are amazing. The pizza I order is always consistently good. read more

Sooo good ! We love the pizza here, and my little one can't get enough of the extra garlicky garlic knots. Experience with customer service was great: the staff was friendly, helpful and the guys behind the counter interacted with everyone who came the door as if they were old fiends (they may have been, for all I know, since this seems like a popular local spot.) Will definitely return! read more

See all

Huge improvement since they now let outside services handle the deliveries. Food is and has always been delicious!

Ordered a chicken parm pizza delivery today and it was the best I've ever had. It looked like an ad in a magazine. There must have been the equivalent of 8 chicken parm dinners worth of full thin cut breaded chicken breasts on this thing and a ton of cheese. I didn't order extra anything. If this is a standard order I couldn't imagine ordering extra anything lol. Awesome experience! -Jay read more

Mario's Famous Pizza - Wow! - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Chicken parm was very tough to chew and even though it was cut very thin. Tasted just like veal! Don't recommend getting it if your looking for a thick juicy piece of chicken. And when I called to complain the manager came on the phone and said well thats how we cut our chicken sorry. I said it was definitely veal like not chicken and he said I can send another one but the chicken is cut that thin always no exceptions. Needless to say I won't be dining there ever again. read more

Food is decent, I would say on par with what one would expect from your decent every day pizzeria. What is sub-par (and for me personally unacceptable) is their business model. They charge a convenience fee and don't tell the customer if a credit card is used. read more

Ordered online and pizza came on time as requested. And their pizza is one of the best around. A bit pricy if you ask me. First time ordering I usually go inside. I received a flier at home and it had a coupon for free wings. I mentioned that in my order online and even called to verify in which the girl on the phone said yes we know about the wings. Delivery guy comes no wings! An hour later I get them, soggy. I still gave a great tip, not their problem who ever is running things isn't organized. But I won't order from them again. Will go more local next time. read more