OMG, The best pizza on the mountain. And they make the best Tito's dirty martini! We keep going back. Luckily it's real close to our cabin. But even if it wasn't so close we would keep going back. read more

Great little spot! Delicious pizza, like seriously delicious. Service was great too. Highly recommend if you want a delicious, no frills experience. read more

This was recommended by a friend, so my husband and I tried it out. The food was really good. I got the naked garden pizza. The crust was amazing and the toppings were so good! It was family friendly and had a bar vibe. It was fun, the food was good and the service was friendly. We will definitely come back. read more

Excellent food, Excellent service great atmosphere, have a bar NO COMPLAINTS FROM ME!!!

We saw the good reviews and this place did. It disappoint. Everything was piping hot when it got to the table. Pizza crust is amazing. The burger was great and the kids raves about the French fries. Super friendly staff read more

We are renting an RV at Juniper Ridge and asked around for a good restaurant and Sandi's was recommended. Let me tell you this was one fantastic place along with Haley the most gracious and wonderful server, the food was outstanding, We had the Friday fish specials and they were delicious, We will be here for 3 months and I can see us coming back to Sandi's many, many more times, read more

Wow! We are so glad we went here! We were visiting up from the Valley, and wanted to eat at a local place. While it's a short drive out of Show Low, it is more than worth it! We tried the 'Sweet Heat' burger! Not only was this thing huge, it tasted just as good! Jalapeño bacon, onion rings, pepper Jack cheese, and bbq sauce! Awesome combination! We loved the atmosphere here! Everyone working here worked super hard, and took super good care of us. Jason came out and talked to us and made sure all was ok! We appreciated the personal touch. The customers are also super friendly! We hear the pizza is great! We will be back! read more

All I can say is, wow!! 2 nights in a row... Simple menu, but consistent. Good flavor, and ample portions... Thank you for a place for us locals... read more

Great food and drinks. Very laid back locals hangout. Will be back again and again !Blanca Specialty PizzasBlanca Specialty Pizzas

I've recently moved to the area one of my favorite foods are wings and they have some if not they best wings on the mountain! Great job!

I giving Sandi's 5 stars because the pizza was as good as it gets. The dough was good but not as pictured on this site. We had their name sake combo and a pepperoni pie. Sandi's is out of town (Show Low) and close to White Mountain Lake, which I did not expect when we headed for the restaurant. It is a small clean unique place with lots of locals dining there and picking up to go orders. There are no draft beers but plenty of canned and bottled beers. Also soda's come in the can with a glass of ice. If you want to go for a drive and have some pretty good pizza, this is the place. read more

Just ordered carry out for 6. The burgers were a real hit, everyone loved theirs! Yummy mushroom burger. One gal was astounded her burger was a actually rare, as she ordered it! Blanca pizza is always a hit, as well as box car Charlie's sandwitch. Everyone's food was HOT, one of my pet peeves, especially for fries. Gonna be doing this a lot more often! read more

Hidden secret!!! We have parents/grandparents living in the area and looked for a place to eat. This popped up, but we didn't know if it really existed. It did, and was great!!! Nice selection of beer and great pizza / meals. Our whole group was happy and the price was much better than driving to Show Low. Server did a great job making sure our every wish was granted and even treated us to a nice piece of cake for dessert. YUM!!! read more

Sandi's has become our new favorite restaurant! The pizza and calzones are delicious, and the wings are the best on the mountain - hands down! We haven't tried anything that we have not absolutely loved! A hidden gem in White Mountain Lakes! Highly recommended. read more

I have been here a few times. The pizza is barely edible for me. The staff is very friendly, attractive bartenders with spunky personalities. Thats about where it ends. I feel bad for giving this establishment such low review, I just cant eat their pizzas or anything else except their beefy sandwich. So in summary the low review is for the food, not the ambiance or the staff. Im sure it's a great hangout for the locals after work. There's really not any other option unless you drive into town (Show Low) read more

we stumbled upon this little gem. quaint little pizza house with a nice menu. The pizza was very much homemade which was great. Crust was gooey and crunchy on the edges. The staff made us feel at home and we're very attentive. Textbook hole in the wall pizza place..don't judge by the outside..go on in and be pleasantly surprised by the taste and service! read more

M J’s Hideaway - Pizza Near Me - Show Low, Arizona

Found this little gem of a restaurant after reading Facebook posts. So glad we did! First visit was about 2 months ago and we've already gone back 3 more times. The food is delicious and as we understand it both the flour (for the dough) and the sauce are imported from Italy. We've met owner Sandi, chef Jason and server Tobie and have enjoyed visiting with all three. It's nice to have this restaurant in our small community and to see it consistently busy. Give it a try! read more

See all

What a surprise to find this place. The pizza was great! We are on vacation from Phoenix and would place this on the top. The home made pesto was very flavorful. The pizza was made to order including thin or thick crust. The thin crust crisp and the thick was perfect. Everything was fresh and homemade. When we arrived they were unexpectedly slammed. Had to call in extra help. We still had excellent service and food in a timely manner. Loved it!! read more

We bought a place in White Mountain Lake in March 2020 and every time we eat at Sandi's, the staff and Sandi are wonderful. The food is delicious! No item on the menu has disappointed. read more

Red house is my go to place after a long drive to the mountains from Phoenix. Holly is always welcoming and ready with a cold beer. Pizza takes a while to be served but worth the wait, the Red House pizza crust is really good. read more

We had a great lunch here today. The pizza was delicious, and the fish fry was nicely battered cod fillets with good fries and cole slaw. It is a little bit of a drive, but the area is fun to see, and well worth it for the food and service. read more

Originally planned to go to a well known pizza spot, but when we arrived, sooo many were not wearing masks, so left. Googled pizza spot and Sandi's Hideaway came up and they had amazing reviews! Definitely had good pizza, good music & were very hospitable. AND they were wearing their masks!! Highly recommend this spot!! read more

We love leaving great reviews for places, but unfortunately, the truth of it is that our experience at Sandi's was not good. We had a 40 minute drive from Pinetop to get to Sandi's and were really looking forward to it, since the reviews indicated that the pizza was great. We called 18 times from 6:26pm to 6:54 pm on our drive over on a Friday night, but it seemed the phone was kept off the hook, because there was a constant busy signal. It never rang. We wanted to order our pizza ahead and pick it up when we got there. It was busy when we arrived, but not busy enough to keep the phone off the hook. It never rang while we were there, so it seems strange. Anyway, we ordered a pizza to go w/Ricotta and Pepperoni. We were told it would be about 25 mins. It was ready at about that time, but it only had Ricotta on it and no pepperoni! The lady at the counter who took our order admitted that she typed it in wrong and the cook toasted some pepperonis and set it on top of our already cooked pizza. The pizza was just ok. We thought it would have mozzarella cheese and we were just adding ricotta and pepperoni, but I guess if you don't specify mozzarella as well, it will only come with sauce. The whole experience was disappointing and not worth the drive. Hopefully customer service improves. We were given a card for a free pizza next time. We will give the card to our friends who live here as we were just visiting from out of town. Hopefully they enjoy the drive and the free pizza. read more

Long, long waits. for either soggy pizza, burnt fish, canned sauce. Last 8 times. Don't know if someone else bought this or they lost their cook? or what? Highly not recommended unless you are starving and too loaded to go to town. SUCKS read more

I love this places pizza! The only reason it has 4 stars instead of 5 is because they messed up our order. We ordered two pizzas and they only made one. We then had to wait 20 minutes for the other pizza and the first one became cold. read more

Tried this place for the first time, they have the best customer service out of any restaurant on the mountain. It feels like your at home there, and the owners are very personable and friendly. And the pizza is great! We will definitely be coming here many more times! read more

What a wonderful welcoming restaurant and the food was amazing. This place has been remodeled & is so cute. Highly recommended!!

Disappointing to say the least. 6 of us were there the other night. When we arrived there were 6 other diners seated. After 45 minutes 2 of us got their dinner. Which was good although the fish have shrunk to fish nuggets. When I complained to the owner she offered to bring us more. 2 more fish dinners arrived with raw fish. The last 2 of our party were served shortly after that, at over an hour since we arrived. There were 3 people working. read more

Boy can that girl make a pizza . My wife and I had dinner there and we were pleasantly surprised , we had pizza and onion rings , very tasty , great cocktails also , I left happy , and the little woman had a buzz.. It,s so nice to have a place so close to us , no need to drive all the way to Show Low or Taylor. read more