So glad we have this cute cozy cafe in Sayre. A bonus that it's open until 6. It's great for the community. Although, I do wish we had a cafe that's open even later. read more

Mad Hatters Cafe & Co-Op - A happy cozy space with lots of seating. The seats are kinda comfortable. - Cafes Near Me - Athens, Pennsylvania

My companion and I tried Mad Hatters today for lunch. The staff was friendly and helpful. I ordered the Mediterranean Tuna Salad and she ordered the Mushroom Grilled Cheese. My salad was light and delicious! Her sandwich was filled with lots of mushrooms and gooey cheese. We were both pleased with our meal and will definitely return! read more

Mad Hatters Cafe & Co-Op - Mediterranean Tuna Salad - Cafes Near Me - Athens, Pennsylvania

Food is great. Atmosphere is great. The issue is that she doesn't seem to be open very often. I'm not joking when I say I've gone out of my way 6x to eat here (during regular posted open hours) and she's been open exactly once. Final straw was yesterday when I got my 85 year old mother-in-law loaded in the car, we arrived and, surprise! Closed AGAIN. read more

This place is a hidden gem! The owner could not have been nicer, the coffee, egg wrap (you can add all sorts of great stuff for the same low price) and smoothies were delish and fresh. The cafe itself is really cute with a small, well curated gift section, a cooler with some to-go items and a bunch of small tables. I was informed they have cooking classes for adults and kids but I don't actually live in the area to take advantage. read more

It's been a few since I've stopped in!! However, the last couple times were great. I love the feel of the place for sure. Very welcoming and Terry always is up to chatting with you. My coffee was spot on and I loved the gluten free bagel when she had them that day. The Ramen was next up. It was during thanksgiving and it was the special that night. Absolutely delicious!! Keep doing amazing things. I'll be in again soon!!! read more

Awesome Coffee shop!! I drove by it for a couple years before stopping and now it's my regular jam. I love the cappuccino here and the brownies are so good you won't care if it makes you fat or not. Dunkin' Donuts doesn't hold a candle to this local treasure. read more

They have been catering meals at my work. Unbelievably affordable for the quality and quantity we get. I love this place!

What a lovely place. It's something that the valley is missing, a proper coffeehouse. (Dunkin Donuts doesn't count). I really enjoyed the atmosphere. The bathroom is particularly interesting. It's very unique and well decorated with an Alice in Wonderland theme. The food was great. I would suggest the home made baked goods. read more

Been following this amazing place in social media and today for my first time they did disappoint. Great healthy food choices. I had a pesto chicken panini that was fantastic. Also has a cute area to shop found some nice goodies for gifts and a zero waste utensil on the go set. Everyone should stop by and try this place the owner was amazing and so friendly. read more

See all

In this area you can easily find pizza, fast food or Italian options. What you can't find, is a restaurant serving fresh, locally sourced, healthy food. Until, now. Let me add: delicious. I've only heard great things about Mad Hatters Cafe. It's cute, fun, and has a creative and constantly changing menu. They even have vegan options which is so incredibly rare for this location in Pennsylvania. We stopped in for dinner last night around 5:45pm. They were all set up for a 'paint and wine' class, so there was limited seating for non class participants. I ordered the Cran Apple Chicken Salad with Feta and my father had the Taco Salad and Potato Soup. The salads are large! Neither of us could finish them. It's so fresh they literally chopped the lettuce to order. Love it!! read more

Mad Hatters Cafe & Co-Op - Cran Apple Chicken Salad!! - Cafes Near Me - Athens, Pennsylvania

So, I'll be honest, I havent come by since they moved to the new location. They could have only improved with the move though. I can rarely pay others for anything these days so dont take my lack of patronage to mean anything against them. It's also unfortunate that both Mad Hatters and their now neighbor 911 Earth have to be buried in the south....Athens and not Sayre or Waverly. Yes, if I drove to Wegman's and had a really nice panini press at home I could certainly make the same food. I also could do the same cooking I get at the Railhouse or whatever diners around here (The Grille and Bri Marie offer higher complexity). I also dont want to do it myself. These folks at Mad Hatters procure better food stock and you can feel good about what you are consuming while enjoying their company, and comfortable ambiance. I hope they still have what I call the "crush your nuts" peanut butter machine (or whatever nuts/legumes you put in there). read more

Awesome!! Amazing coffee Great place to meet up with friends for Breakfast. Food is always fresh and made the way you like it. And the chicken quesadilla on Fiesta Friday are truly the best and my favorite read more

The new venue is beautiful, with soaring tin ceilings and refinished old oak floors. There is now a little more seating and the kitchen/prep area is separate from the cash register, so it can be kept neater. The food and offerings are still the great organic ones as before. Here's to much success at the new location at Pine & Main!! read more

A pleasant little gem for the valley. It's very homey and welcoming. The menu changes frequently but always has tasty yet organic options as well as an array of yummy drink options. I'm a sucker for their chai lattes. I get one every time. The owner is super friendly and accommodating. My friend is lactose free and the owner was very attentive to that which my friend appreciated. Overall it's a cute little oasis that you should toatally check out! read more

I came to the Mad Hatter today with my husband for lunch, we walked in and were greeted warmly by the owner and the other girl at the counter. Their menu was written on the chalkboard behind the counter, there were a few parts of it that were difficult to read but it had all the info there, hubby got a BLT on sour dough and I got the grown up grilled cheese on 5 grain bread, yum-o! 3 types of cheese and super delicious. The cool part was you got apple slices and carrots with your sandwich, however had we known that beforehand I wouldn't have gotten carrots but hubby and I traded so it worked out. While we waited about 10 minutes for our food I browsed the co-op area were there was a selection of local artisans wares for sale. Very neat! Such things as homemade soaps, local honey, scarves and music and lots more. Terry, the owner, was very proud of her restaurant, she was very excited to show us her gluten free bakery items made by a local, licensed 17 year old baker, she let us know the gluten free breads are made fresh and she has a new freezer coming to accomodate more stuff. Nothing is processed and you can see there is a lot of love put into the cafe. We will be returning! read more

Had lunch here today. My vegetarian sandwich was so delicious! And everyone at The mad Hatter is always so friendly. This is really the best place around for vegetarian, vegan, and fresh local produce. And did I mention the adorable frosted sugar cookies? Only a $1.25 :-) read more

Mad Hatters Cafe & Co-Op - Posted hours as of 9/2/15 - Cafes Near Me - Athens, Pennsylvania

The woman working there was SO NICE she had such a friendly and warm personality. The food is also sooooo goood!!! I love the build your own breakfast sandwich option. Super yummy and I love the side of fruit they add. The food is actually pretty cheap too, for 3 people it was $14. read more

Wonderful cozy atmosphere with delicious food, desserts, and coffees. What mor could anyone ask for? A must try! read more

See all

This place has awesome food, pleasant and courteous service and a warm, inviting atmosphere. I particularly like the build your own breakfast and their soups that knock the chill off. read more

I ate lunch yesterday at Mad Hatters, and loved my meal! I had the Rice Bowl with Peanut sauce... I'm not if that's the exact name, but it was fabulous! The chef and owner is great. The menu selection is exceptional For the neighborhood! My carnivore lunch buddies had the Chicken,bacon, ranch wrap and both thought it was delicious. Kudos for being right next door to my favorite health food store, 911 Earth. The two together will entice me to come from Ithaca regularly. Thank you for a great lunch! read more

An interesting little place and an aesthetically pleasing atmosphere. I ordered an ice coffee and was pleasantly surprised with how good it was and my boyfriend ordered their strawberry frozen lemonade. All around a good place to go for your caffeine/lemonade fix and will go again when I'm in the area for lunch :) read more

I have been visiting this little whimsical nook of the valley for a few years now and though the food is always delicious and homemade, organic, and fresh, the owner's attitude and welcoming personality are what make this place so great. She is the heart of why you should support small business, as she supports other small businesses right in her own place. If you want to go somewhere the staff will know you by name, this is the place. I recommend the breakfast wraps: cheap, so good and toasty, and she lets you load them up with whatever you like! Taco bowls were great too. Avocado egg salad is wonderful too. And don't forget the coffee! read more

This Valley, where I have lived as one of my residences for thirty one years, is short of places to run into friends and have great ad hoc conversations that isn't a bar. I stopped in to Mad Hatter after my time at the gym across the street, Inspire Fit, and ordered the soup of the day, that proved to be a delicious and savory chicken vegetable. One of the best things about the Mad Hatter is that I can trust their food; they are not going to poison me out of ignorance. As I finished the soup, they were pullling morning glory muffins out of the oven and so--having recently lost 35 pounds--I had one, guilt-free. Delicious with a cup of coffee! read more

Wonderful Chai Latte with steeped tea and fresh steam milk of your choice! No sugar!! Delicious Rolls and sandwich.

I've never ordered something I didn't love here! Along with the owners amazing customer service and always over the top attitude, I always recommend this little shop. read more

Great food! I love the healthy choices! The owner is very friendly too. I love the environment. Very relaxed and welcoming.

I wouldn't recommend this place. It's not very cleanly inside, the baked goods are mediocre at best and the coffee is terrible. Almost anywhere else you can get better coffee and/or baked, which is disappointing. I like supporting local small businesses over corporate chains/franchises, but I'd go to Dunkin' Donuts any day over this place. read more

Had to spend much of the day a a local hospital. Used yelp to find a restaurant for dinner. Do to positive reviews we tried this place. Very unusual, but good. I had the Buffalo chicken sandwich and tortilla soup. If you like spicy Buffalo wings you will love this sandwich. Soup was very thick, very tasty. The rest of my family got burritos . You can choose anything you want on them. Everyone loved their meals. Steamed Coco assume!! Try it. Don't pay attention to the outside of building. GO IN !! read more

Friendly, tasty. It is next to the Citizen's Bank on Main Street, not where the GPS says it is. She steeped the tea, made all the food from scratch. Special orders is what she is used to. And a gluten free backrest case from a local baker. read more

Mad Hatters Cafe & Co-Op - Veggie scrambled eggs with melon. All fresh veggies. - Cafes Near Me - Athens, Pennsylvania

I love this place. Their coffee is always delicious and they know what the word "vegan" means. They always offer a traditional item and a vegan item. Their menu isn't big but it is varied throughout the week with homemade items prepared in their open kitchen right in front of you. They also offer some co-op and local grocery items in the back of the cafe. read more

Nice clean and friendly but they advertise themselves as being gluten-free vegetarian vegan and organic. But when I got my omelette It had all sorts of stuff in it that I didn't order I would not advise it for anybody with food sensitivities. I couldn't eat what I ordered because it wasn't what I ordered. horrible experience. Complete waste of time and money. I only gave one star because the grid won't allow anything less read more

Very friendly staff! Food is exactly what my body wants and needs! Excellent artichoke and red pepper salad and basil chicken sandwich. Very fresh food from local farms. I had a salted Carmel cappuccino all syrups are made in house. I wish more restaurants put this kind of care into the food they serve. read more

Great breakfast! Home made favorites and a friendly "what can I get yah!". Friendly staff does it all, can tell the locals like this place. Bring your appetite this place has big portions at a very reasonable price. read more

Fun, friendly, casual, local, focus on healthy eating. I am part of a group that meets every Wednesday for vegan dinner here from 5 - 7 pm. Join us. Menu changes each Wednesday. Always delicious vegan dessert dreamt up by Janelle. Organic local yogurt, eggs, greens and beef jerky. Lots more! You will have to find out for yourself. read more

Took my father in law for lunch, and we were so pleasantly surprised!! Such a great alternative to the "same ole' thing". Very fresh, healthy, and most importantly, DELICIOUS!!! I highly recommend, and sincerely doubt that you'll be disappointed read more

Was happy to see she uses local produce and homemade sausage from local pork. Had a breakfast wrap that was absolutely amazing.

Stopped by at the place as I was driving thru. The staff was extremely nice. However, I thought the food was bland and overpriced for what I got. I walked away feeling I overpaid given how satisfied I was with the food. read more

A good lunch spot if you are not a meat eater and prefer to have a light lunch. Ingredients are fresh. Prices a bit high for a sandwich or salad, but the quality justifies the price. Not a great place for meat eating kids. Seating is bohemian. read more

I love this place! There are so many "fast food" places in town. It is so nice to have a place with good and healthy food. I love going in for lunch. It's such a nice change!! read more

Nice lunch here. Very comfortable place with clever theme and excellent food. Just a short drive down the road from the Guthrie medical complex in Sayre. Veggie, vegan, gluten free, selections too. read more