The one thing I can say about Maggie McFly's Middlebury location is that despite the enormousness of their menu, the quality of the food is consistently good! I got the Ruben with a gluten-free cheese bun. OMG! It was out of this world! I've never had a cheese bun before, and they made a believer out of me. It was soft and fresh. The Reuben was made with Angus beef and it was juicy and cheesy with the zip of sauerkraut! My sweet potato fries were hot and crispy and went well with my Sauvignon Blanc. To quote Arnie.. I'll be back! read more

Maggie McFly's - Angus Ruben on a cheese bun with sweet potato fries - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

I am a frequent patron of Maggie Mcflys and at numerous locations throughout CT. This particular visit was of my typical experiences at Maggie's with good service, good atmosphere and great food. However, when it came time to pay the bill at the end of the evening my waitress Natalie came to the table to get the check and my credit card to pay the bill. After a bit of waiting, she came back and when I opened the check presenter only the receipt was in there, not my Credit card that I paid with. I asked my waitress where my card went to which she could not give me an answer other them "maybe it fell out, let me check". She returned later saying that she could not find it. She then told me to "just cancel it and get a new one". I was completely upset at the lack of regard for my situation not to mention I cannot understand how my card just disappeared from the register to the table. This credit card is also one of the heavy metal cards not the plastic cards, so I know from experience that if it drops to the floor, it is quite loud. I feel that she did not take the time to thoroughly look for the card, nor take any type of responsibility for its disappearance. Needless to say, the whole experience was something to be desired and put a bad taste in my mouth. I'm concerned with how this happens when it's the waitress job to take the payment and return it to the table, where did it get misplaced in the process. I do not think that I would personally return to this location after this encounter. **update** I have spoken to a manager on the phone the day after the incident. She was very rude on the phone. I had let her know about the situation from last night where a server ran my card to pay my bill then returned with receipts for payment but no card. She rudely cut me off and said "yea yea, we have it come get it whenever at the bar area". She made it seem as if I were the one who misplaced my card. That is unacceptable. She did not even apologize or offer any resolution to the situation. I will most definitely not be returning to this location. I am very disappointed in how this situation was handled. read more

Maggie McFly's - Bang-Bang Shrimp & Chicken - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

See all

This place was amazing! Let me start by saying I have gluten and dairy allergies- I'm used to leaving restaurants starving, disappointed, and or sick. None of that was the case here!! I was so excited to eat chicken tenders and amazing bbq sauce, French fries, and even had leftovers. Their menu is also HUGE so I had tons of options! My family does not have allergies, and they all were so excited and happy with their meals too. Since we live in NH we'll be making a trip back at some point! read more

Maggie McFly's - Gluten free chicken tenders - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

A cockroach ran across our table. Didn't offer to move us after we told them the first time. Had to wave them in the kitchen once we realized our new table guest hung around for us to grab a photo. Didn't give us a discount or anything after knowing we didn't eat our food afterwards. read more

Maggie McFly's - Cockroach - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

The other night, my husband and I went to Maggie McFly's for dinner. The service was all very nice. We thought the hostess & servers were fantastic. The food was good. Was it fantastic? I mean it was standard food. ‍ The not-so-great: 1. The parking lot was very dark and I felt unsafe. 2. The restaurant was DIRTY. Like seriously dirty. 3. The menu was stupid long. One reason I never go to Cheesecake Factory (among several) is the menu is TOOOO LONG. Why can't restaurants pick something and do that really well? 4. I ordered a cocktail. I'm not even sure there was vodka in it? 5. Fries were just warm. It's pretty unlikely I'll come back. read more

See all

Food is usually good but in my Caesar salad i asked for chicken and instead of regular chicken it was BBQ. Additionally, there was a large shard of GLASS in my salad. The manager took it off our bill and gave us a small gift card but the gift card wasn't even enough to cover a main course and a drink. Pretty pathetic overall, not going back. Clearly they don't care all that much about the cleanliness of their kitchen and the safety of the customers. read more

If I was basing my rating on food alone, I would give it a 5. The food was great. I've never had a Cuban before but after having the one here, I want to know what an authentic Cuban tastes like because it was very delicious. The Eggplant fries were good but I've had better at other places. I would order them again if I went back though. But since I'm basing it off of food and service, I have to say, the food was great. The bartender was ok. He wasn't awful or amazing, he was just there. Politely taking my order and cashing me out. It was pretty slow when I arrived so I get it but he never introduced himself so I have no idea what his name was. Not 100% necessary when the food is great but it's just the icing on the cake to have that info. I still enjoyed my experience read more

See all

We enjoyed our dinner. Waitresses was very nice, fun atmosphere. I would return if I pass the again. Like the menu, options for everyone. read more

See all

This place was packed on a Saturday evening as we had to wait. It was a large place with an upstairs dining area as well as a spacious bar space. The service was good while the menu was one of the larger ones I have seen. I also liked they had their suppliers of certain items on their menu too. There was only one general issue. One of the people at my table ordered a pizza, but the waiter politely told us they do not serve pizza in the winter because it would be too smoky and no windows can be open. It did not make sense that pizza was on the menu if it cannot be served. I did not see any signs or mentions on the menu about this policy regarding the pizza. It was disappointing. I tried the panko fried avocado with a side of sriracha aioli ($6.99). I have never seen fried avocado before and I was tempted to try. It was solid especially with the aioli as a complement. For my entrée, I had the jambalaya ($17.99). It came with shrimp, chicken, sausage, onions, tomatoes, peppers, and basmati rice in a spicy Cajun sauce. This was a well put together dish. There was plenty of everything. The sauce really made the dish. Will I go back? Probably. read more

Maggie McFly's - Panko Fried Avocado - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

See all

Word to the wise, NEVER order takeout. We've only tried twice, and both times it was a horrible experience. The first time it took the driver almost 2 hours to get the food. First they told him they never received the order. We called and complained and all of a sudden it had magically just come through. Then it took more than an hour for them to give it to the driver. By time we got it, it was cold. We had originally vowed never to do takeout there again. But that was a couple years ago, so we thought we would take a leap of faith that they had improved. But here we are again, 2 hours post order and no food. Again they told the driver they never received an order. This is the only restaurant we have issues with. They're food is decent, but not good enough to take a gamble on getting dinner from them again. read more

Love the bar bites menu even tho the tex-mex egg rolls were greasy once. I sent them back and got the buffalo chicken sliders with fries. Yum! Only $8! read more

Maggie McFly's - great deals at the bar! Why isn't this promoted more?!? - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

We love the ambiance of this restaurant, it's very fun. Too bad they don't keep up on the maintenance of some of the items (the train no longer runs), and got rid of the game units that was enjoyed by all the kids! The food is usually very good, one time I received a strange "chicken soup" with pieces of grilled chicken in it- makes you wonder if they used leftovers to make the soup! Another time the risotto was extremely salty and runny. Kid portions are huge- but since they serve a variety of ages, I guess it is understandable. The service is always pleasant and attentive. Great place! read more

Maggie McFly's - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

See all

Their food is amazing. I had not been here before but I ordered their food for delivery. The delivery was amazing. It arrived early, everything was included and everything tasted great. I will definitely be ordering from here again. read more

See all

This is the first time I have ever written a bad review for any restaurant in my life. The bartender had ZERO personality. It took her 20 minutes to take our drink order (there were 8 people at the bar) It took another 10 minutes to take our food order. No SMILE, no PERSONALITY!! Ordered water and 10 minutes later got water. Barely ate my dinner and asked for it to be wrapped. Felt it necessary (for the 1st time in my adult life) to write a review on my receipt where we only left a 15% tip....only to find out she threw out my leftovers. She offered 1 1/2 hours later to replace my leftovers. Really Maggies!? Why would you allow her to be your head bartender/server??? So disappointed!! We are never coming back! read more

Just had a business meeting at Maggie McFlys in Middlebury. This is the original Maggie's location. I've been here before but its been a few years. I love the ambience of this place. We went on Valentines Day and after we arrived it REALLY filled up. The sell point of Maggie's is not just the quality of their food but the SIZE of their menu. Ladies and Gentlemen, their menu is huge. Largest menu that I've seen at any restaurant. They redid the look of their menu too! Very sleek and professional looking. These arent your laminated menus at a mom and pops. The menu has to be like 20 pages. This time I got Chicken Piccata. It was a creamy based Piccata and it was EXCELLENT. The chicken was cooked well through too. They also have a decent beer draft list. Several different IPAs. I went with Sea Hag for this night. Service was great and I was so full I didnt have room for dessert. I will definetly be back again. Hopefully sooner than this last span. read more

See all

Being accused of not leaving a tip (I left 20% cash) because the waiter misplaced it in her own apron pocket then the waiter come to your table to argue with you about it is insane. I agree with leaving tips for good service which the service was good but to do that to customers is so rude, disrespectful and wrong. 1st I left the tip, 2nd I left it in cash for your benefit, 3rd so if someone doesn't leave a tip you think the next step is to accost them at their table when they are getting ready to leave in front of everyone there? Tipping is not law and you're just wrong. read more

Service was TRASH! Let's start with the tables across from us. Patrons politely asked for the bill for their drinks after waiting an hour. After 20 more minutes they put their cash on the table and left... another 5 minutes goes by and they bring the bill to the wrong table. ‍ Next table gets served but with no utensils. So they take them from another table because if they ask it may be another half hour. Third table gets served someone else's food. The correct table has to yell across the patio to get their order. This happened to an additional table. For us, 30 minutes for apps another 40 for entree. They have come to or passed by our table several times NEVER CLEARING THE TABLE. Too bad. The food was decent but the service is a reason to NEVER RETURN. read more

Maggie McFly's - They've come to our table twice now and haven't cleared the apps. - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

I went to Maggie Mcfly's for the first time on Saturday and I'm going say the food is really good. The nachos came loaded with chicken, veggies, and a nice amount of cheese. The fish sandwhich comes with 2 fillets, lettuce, and tomato. The fish was nice and flakey, and the coleslaw added flavor to it. I would try to make the portions smaller though because the fish was to big. I had to take apart the sandwich to eat it. The restaurant was clean, and had two floors so they had plenty of seating. Service was good they asked for our drink right away and food came out in a decent amount of time. The one bad thing to say about the place is the prices are too expensive I probably won't eat here often. Other than that everything else was really good. read more

We stopped by at Maggie's for lunch and I was not disappointed! The food was great and it came out just on time. We first had the dim sum as an appetizer and I shared the Maggies Famous Shellfish Pot which was amazing! The drinks were okay. Customer service was also great. read more

See all

Absolutely disgusting all the way around my daughter and I ordered the Wagyu Burger and the Burger came out like it was in the microwave. The Bread was stale it was just the most disgusting piece of meat I ever has once I took the stale bread off I couldn't even break the Meat with a fork. It was ordered medium. The appetiser was the spinach dip which came with stale chips and the garlic bread was hamburger buns cut into strips. I was upstairs and made my way downstairs to which it was the side of the kitchen I walked down the steps to an overfilled garbage can of a rotten smell of food.It looked an absolute mess and smelled. The Manager at the bottom of the steps listened to my problem about the horrible food with a cocky smirk as if he's used to it. I believe the Department of health should pay a visit to this trashy Business. Middlebury Ct Location. read more

Not impressed with how down hill this restaurant has gone. I have celiac, and told them my dinner was for a gluten allergy (easier to understand). I got my dish with gluten free pasta (supposedly). It tasted firm and I thought it was cooked well. I got very sick. It was either regular pasta or gluten free pasta cooked in the same water. I got shrimp and scallops, and for 30.00 I got bay scallops. They were clearly frozen. Also, they were was little alcohol in our drinks (if any). Service was very slow, and they clearly forgot one of our drinks. If you have allergies do not go here. One of our plates was dirty as well. read more

This place has consistent decent food for decent prices. Lately I'm really enjoying their buffalo cauliflower, my husband orders their burgers, all the time. read more

Maggie McFly's food is absolutely amazing. They have the best Nachos of all time and extremely good ribs, pastas, burgers and so much more. They have a 24 page long menu and every single thing on it is great. This is one of my favorite restaurants. The service is also great with friendly and nice waiters and waitresses. The ambiance is also really really cool and has a plane hanging from the ceiling over the bar. A really cool and funky place with amazing food that I love to go to. I would extremely recommend. read more

I go to this location regularly because it's close by so I can say the food is good each time! The staff is always great and friendly. Happy hour at the bar has a good selection and of course the decor is super cute with palm trees, flying airplane, and a toy train track lol! read more

Maggie McFly's - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

If I could leave 0 stars for this review I would. I just walked out of the middlebury location with my wife after waiting 20 mins for a table because the hostess gave our table to two people who just walked in. When we asked about why she just gave them our table she said they had a reservation. I guess she didn't realize that we heard the two customers ask for a table for two and didn't mention they had reservations. No accountability what so ever or offer to remedy the situation just told us to wait until another table opens so we left and will never be back!!! read more

With two starving girls while driving back from AAU basketball, we figured the original Maggie's was a safe (if uninspired) bet. Man we're we wrong. I'll preface the rest of this by saying that I grew up in Naugatuck, and I've been periodically stopping into this particular restaurant for 25 plus years. Our server, Whitney, tried to play the cool server card by not writing anything down. She promptly forgot my drink order. When I told her what it was, she disappeared for ten plus minutes, and returned without it again. Also of note: my daughter's Sprite was not Sprite but seltzer and needed to be returned. 35 minutes after being seated, I got my drink and we ordered food. 35 minutes after that, the food arrived. The food itself was solidly mediocre, which is exactly what I've come to expect from Maggie's. The net / net: If you don't value your time and are satisfied with the same level of quality that can be had by grabbing a bag of salad and some crappy chicken nuggets from the grocery store, this is the place for you. However, if you are a sane human, stay away from this steadily declining franchise. read more

I have good and bad on this one. Love the atmosphere but disappointed with small amount of lobster on lobster roll. Very disappointing didn't even cover hot dog bun. But the best part of this place is an outstanding employee who went out of the way to do everything possible to make sure we had a great experience. This employee is outstanding. Make sure when you go ask for Jake. read more

Worst experience ever. Called in advance for dinner for 8. All parties arrived separately, gave the name for the table and they seated us at two separate tables, not even on the same floor. What's the point of giving the name for a reservation if they don't even seat you together? Took almost an hour of everyone sitting there before we realized the rest of the party should have been there at this point. My 80 year old GRANDPARENTS were left alone upstairs for almost an hour before we were able to contact them since they don't look at their phones all the time. Onto the service: they did not give us enough napkin rolls with the utensils inside. We had to ask twice for extra utensils which NEVER ARRIVED! My friend's food arrived cold, along with the entire table next to us who also complained about their food being cold. One side arrived with a long HAIR in the bowl. They forgot to bring a side for one of the meals as well. We had mentioned this to the server Samantha. She said she would bring out the side and new chicken for my friend's salad. We did not see our server again until well after everyone finished eating. At this point we reminded her of the food missing. She said she would ask her manager to comp the food and asked if we wanted dessert. At this point, the entire party had been there for nearly 3 hours. Only two people ordered dessert. After another 20-25 minutes we had to go looking for our server to ask where our one bowl of ice cream and one milkshake was. This was also a birthday dinner and the server ignored this, and a party guest had to mention quite obviously "we have a birthday girl here" before they brought a complimentary bowl of ice cream. The server then says, "one check?" when I had specifically called in advance and asked for separate checks for each couple. One party guest went to speak to the manager who never showed her face to apologize for the terrible service, seating the party guests on different floors, cold food, hair in food, etc. The manager got defensive and argumentative before finally ending up taking about $40 off the bill for the food that never arrived. In total, our party was there for over 3 hours. We go to Maggie's for birthdays and celebrations multiple times a year. Tonights dinner at the Middlebury location is by far the worst experience we have ever had and we will not be returning. Time to find a new place to celebrate! read more

Took my dad here for his 86th birthday. He was very tickled when he ordered his dessert & they reversed the candles to 68 instead of 86. whether it was onpurpose or not he got a big kick out of it. Had kind of a strange server. She seemed nonplussed over everything. We ate outside-When I complained about the swarm of bugs around our table she shrugged her shoulder & said "it's outside!" i suggested to her that it might be the trash barrels on the other side of the fence we were sitting up against. yep. They were wonderful about bringing out Birthday dessert. read more

See all

What a lovely time we had today over a leisurely lunch! We both had the Thai Chicken salad! Nice choice for a very hot and humid day! Caroline was our server and could not be sweeter and more kind; with prompt and courteous service. Chicken was well seasoned; and certainly plentiful! The restaurant itself was plenty cool given the temperature outside! We were able to sit and visit catching up! read more

It has been several years since I've been to this Maggie McFly's location, perhaps 10. Certainly before I starting Yelping. I recall the food & service being OK, nothing really special, I guess that's a big reason why I haven't been back in such a long time. Well, not much as changed, it seems. My wife ordered a Maggie's BLT (came with soup, she had the NE clam chowder), and I went a BBQ Pulled Pork Burger (w/ sweet potatoes fries). LONG wait for the food, the place was moderately busy the afternoon we were there. Our server Alex was a nice guy, funny. Food finally arrived, my wife was a bit underwhelmed with her sandwich, but she liked the soup. I thought my burger was OK, not bad, but I've had better. read more

See all

This used to be my go-to place that I used to love! I would go at least twice a week between dinner, lunch, or drinks with friends. The food is still decent however the wait times and lack of attention from staff is very disappointing. I gave excuses of her covid that ...well, was covid. I gave excuses in the spring 2021 that everyone was short-staffed due to stimulus packages and people staying home. But now?... It's been 40 minutes and we're still waiting to pick up our meals for take out. It'll be quite a few years before I'm back again. read more

Love love their seafood casserole and margarita flights . Food always fresh and service is great .

The ramen was unexpected and amazing! This is a worthy pit stop for the traveler dissolutioned by Waterbury proper... this is a true oasis! Thank you! The menu was so large, it was hard to choose, but this ramen surprised and impressed. Everything else I saw served looked amazing as well... read more

Maggie McFly's - Beef Ramen Bowl - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

Huge gluten free food selection! They bring out the food with the allergy sticks. Very good food! read more

See all

Stopped in here late night Sunday. Impressive hours. Interesting booths, not a lot of privacy unless you head upstairs. We were seated in front of (our sides facing) the TV, which meant that everyone in the room was looking our way which just felt strange. I'm sure to most this wouldn't matter but it was something we noticed immediately. Ordered coconut shrimp app... so so glad I did. Huge shrimp!!! Very good quality. Dinner was Lemon Chicken (Picatta), and my partner had a buffalo chicken sandwich on a gluten free roll. He was very pleased with the quality. Overall very pleased, cool menu with locally sourced ingredients. ***Oh, as an FYI- no pizza served here in the Winter (per our waiter). This would have been good to know before we took time to look over the menu. We were informed of this after the fact and quickly had to choose other items (which turned out fine) but was strange. read more

See all

The menu is huge and quite frankly overwhelming. Service was slow for weekday lunch - one waitress - Buffalo Chicken Salad was okay - kinda pricey without being anything great. read more

This review is not for the service at all. Both my boyfriend and I went inside the middlebury location to order "takeout" . We went inside and ordered and waited for our food, which mind you came out in a very timely fashion. The restaurant was pretty dead for a Saturday so I actually figured the food would be done quickly. What I didn't figure was when I got home with my order that I would see 3 chicken tenders in my order. 3!!! I paid 12.99 for 3 chicken tenders and a half pound of French fries. I am so disgusted at this restaurant. Covid or not there should be no reason why my order only came with 3 chicken tenders. Absolutely ridiculous. Never again am I coming to this establishment. This is not the first time I've been disappointed by them but it will be the last. I could of went to McDonalds for half the price .. So disappointing I wish I could give no stars read more

Maggie McFly's - Back East Porter Battered Fried Chicken Strips.. 3!!!! - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

This place is always hit or miss for me. Wanting a good beer and fresh pasta, I came in last night for a late evening dinner. Amy the bartender was attentive. The taste of the food was good as well, but it seems there is always something missing in the attention to detail here at Maggie's. First off, a "Little Cranky" IPA which is a 4.5% alcohol volume was served in an 8 ounce glass! Are you kidding me? For the price charged? Budweiser draft has more alcohol than this beer and is served in a pint glass. Second, there is no fresh cracked pepper in the establishment and last but not least, no parmesan cheese for my pasta! :( It's just the little things that add up to us not wanting to return. read more

Maggie McFly's - Super tiny Little Cranky.... 8oz glass for a 4.5% beer is unheard of in the craft beer industry. Those are only usually for 7% or highers. - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

Great place, my wife and I have been her several times, today picked up an order to go that was hot and ready when I arrived! Thanks read more

Maggie McFly's - Hot Spinach and Artichoke Dip... (all garlic bread with no veggies) - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut