It's good, but I'm surprised the reviews are so high. It tastes like Domino's....but they also have Indian options like chicken tikka. (Sorry, this is California pizza? lol) I placed an online order. I arrived at the estimated arrival time, but I had to wait 15 minutes because they were so busy on a Friday evening. The guy at the register had to stop to answer the phone every few minutes so everything was way too slow. The staff was really nice though. If you want to try Magoo's, go during off-peak times. The restaurant is kind of dingy; it has about six tables. The majority of the customers were ordering to-go. Magoo's is in a strip mall where two businesses have been shot at in the last week. I wouldn't go there after the sun goes down because of safety concerns. read more

Friendly service, quick order turnaround, and some amazing pizza in an unassuming parlor. Ordered the Chicken Tikka pizza with garlic sauce: the veggies were fresh, the cheese had great pull, the crust was soft and flavorful, and the best yet: that SAUCE! I will definitely be back just for the garlic sauce. Seems that most people do carry out, but we ate inside and were given plates and napkins, but it is a no frills environment. I loved that the staff remembered my name and checked in on how we heard of the restaurant and seemed authentically happy to have us try it! Nothing but good things to say!! read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Chicken Tikka Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The combination of Indian ingredients on pizza is genius. We tried the Chicken Tikka Pizza. The crust is Chicago style with a ton of topping. The sauce was creamy, tangy and hot. There was a lot of cheese. Bits of chicken, tomato and other vegetables permeated the sauce. We loved the pizza and a small size is plenty for two people to share. The clerk was friendly and engaging. He checked on us to see if we liked the pizza or needed anything. The pizza didn't take long to come out. The dining room is somewhat stark and dated. Most people order carry out. There are about a dozen tables. The beverage selection is limited to prepackaged sodas and juices. There is plenty of parking in the strip mall. Well worth a visit. read more

See all

This pizza lived up to the hype! Everyone told me this is the best pizza in Indianapolis and I loved it! We tried the chicken tikka and kebab pizza which are not your traditional pizza flavors. The kebab was a little spicy (so good in the ranch), but the chicken tikka stole the show! Don't forget sides of ranch because they have great ranch. I got carry out but there are plenty of tables to dine in. read more

See all

Dean Johnson, my grandfather, owned a TV store and subsequently many VHS tapes. It was in his living room that Mister Magoo gave me heart attack after heart attack, being the most negligible blind man to walk this earth. This California Pizza kitchen is anything but. Magoo's curated this Chicken Tikka pizza without blunder or stumble. It's a speciality pizza that doesn't ruffle conventional feathers, like the abominations that Cheeseburger pizza might. Inside this strip-mall's den of doughy discs lies a dining area that is comically long. Way too few tables fit way too big of a space. Neon "halal pizza"signs aren't one you see often, nor the reason I came, but it's definitely a draw that competitors cannot match. Cheers on cornering the market yo! Albeit not a spot I'd drag folks to, this slice of Indy is one worth an occasional rotation for those in the area. Here's to personal pizzas on sunny days. read more

See all

Chicken and veggie pizza was - decent pizza. Nice and saucy. I wish we had more toppings.

Subahanallah! The best pizza in town by far for the past 17+ years! Always ready fast! barakallahu feek! read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Small Meat lovers, small chicken Tikka, and mini beef pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

10/10 pizza and the people in the store are great guys the chicken tikka pizza is the best pizza I ever had read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

It was my first time going to Magoo's and I'll definitely be back. The Tikka pizza is delicious. The service was so warm and friendly to everyone who walked in. read more

We ordered to go Pizza from Magoo's California pizza for a weekend get together. I knocked a star off cause the pizza itself had a lot of oil dripping and while I love greasy, cheesy pizza I didn't expect oil stained fingers while chewing a pizza. Overall the size, portion and taste were ok but I couldn't figure the intent behind so much oiliness. It possibly could have been one of those days so I will try Magoos again before I decide for sure this isn't my type of pizza. read more

See all

Magoo's had been one of my go-to pizza joints for about 5 years now. My orders are always correct and fresh, you can tell the difference by the quality of their products. The building is always clean and the staff is friendly. 10/10 recommend read more

One of the city's hidden gems! This place has some of the best pizza around. Our go-to is the garlic cheese pizza read more

Food is great no matter what you get. Delivery has been hit or miss. Unfortunately have gotten the wrong order but idk if that's the fault of the restaurant. Wrong orders still gotten eaten and they were delicious. ‍ read more

Was home sick and newer to the westside's pizza joints so decided I'd give Magoo's a try. Worth it. I love wings so I had to try theirs. I always order them plain to truly gauge if the wing is truly good or not as you can mask a lot with sauce. They're baked, a little dry, but not bad by any means. Good sized and plenty of meat on each but nothing special. For the price I probably wouldn't get them again and venture towards one of their other many apps instead. That's the one star off as I've definitely had better wings at other pizza places. As for the pizza, I went with the gluten free, comes in 8 slices, Hawaiian so that's with pineapple, chicken, and bacon. This was really good with plenty of each topping on each slice. I reheated the other half in the air fryer the next day and it reheated perfectly. Big fan and will be getting Magoo's again to try the other combinations they have. read more

last Sunday was my first time trying Magoo's California Pizza & I must say they are a hidden gem! If you are ever on west side of Indy and craving pizza don't hesitate to stop by ! They get everything out in a timely manner and atmosphere is great ! Don't forget to tell them Tyrone sent you read more

Pizza is always amazing. Been coming here since a kid the service is top tier and every time I come back home i'll always stop and grab a large chicken tikka. Keep up the great work guys. read more

Not sure where this place gets the hype from. I ordered this as a branch out from our usual Greeks thinking we were getting another local quality pizza. Wrong. This pizza was closed to cold dominos than to anything enjoyable. Sauce is bland, crust is soft, toppings are few and far between. Garlic cheese bread is good but not good enough to go here again. read more

First time here at this strip mall pizza place and it was amazing! Came in and there was nobody in the building except for the workers. It was a very basic, unassuming interior with some tables and not much else on the walls. We almost walked away because the place seemed dead. We decided to stay and opted for the medium size pizza for 2 people. They let us split the pizza in half to try 2 different flavors--chicken tikka and beef kabob. As we waited, the crowd inside grew and grew. People were coming in and out for take out and more people were ordered for dine in. By the time our pizza came, the place was packed with such a diverse mix of people--very representative of the neighborhood. The pizza itself was fantastic. Both the chicken tikka and the beef kabob were delicious. The beef was our favorite and each bite of beef was packed with flavor. Even the crust was perfectly crispy and tasty. Easily my favorite pizza place in the city! read more

See all

Passing through town on a road trip, we stopped to grab a bite at a local spot. This place hit the spot! Delicious pizza, good service, and friendly staff. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Veggie thin crust mini pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The place is basically a take out but there is a seating arrangement if you want to enjoy hot food. The chicken tikka pizza with white sauce is hands down the best! Ask to make it spicy by adding jalapeños. The mere smell of the pizza is so appetizing that you can't resist!! Try it sometime. The service is great-as I was picking my order, someone got the sauce wrong and they gladly made another one for them. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Chicken Tikka Pizza with white creamy sauce - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My husband and I have a goal to try all the pizza joints in the city. It's a really tough goal, but someone has to do it! (LOL). We therefore drove thirty minutes out of our way on a dreary Sunday night to Magoo's, a place that we'd heard friends rave about. I ordered ahead on their website and selected a mini chicken tikka pizza with the white garlic sauce base, a large cheese pizza, and a side of their seasoned fries. If you're coming here, you have to try the chicken tikka pizza, as that's what they're known for. It's so unique and delicious. It comes with chicken, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, chicken tikka, and a white garlic sauce base. It was seasoned deliciously and we both enjoyed it. The cheese pizza also had an amazing flavor that we both loved. The friess were some of the best we've had, as they're coated in a flavorful seasoning that's not spicy; just amazing. A few more pros: + They make handmade ranch sauce to dip your pizza into + They offer gluten-free, dairy-free, and halal pizzas + They deliver within a certain range + Their staff was really kind + The online ordering system was super easy + You can order toppings on half the pizza and not the other half We'll be back for sure! read more

See all

I feel like these halal California pizza spots are the best kept secret in town! This Magoo's location is no exception. It's open late, their pizza is a bargain and it's very good! I phoned in my order late on a Saturday night (~9p) and was quoted half hour wait time. I arrived and there were several people inside waiting for their orders. The cashier was quite friendly and efficient despite being busy, and overall the place was clean and bright. There were several tables and chairs inside, but the chairs were all turned upside down on the tables. I'm assuming due to the late hour they don't encourage eating in? That's speculation on my part, though. My order was ready for pickup in the time specified. $16.34 for a medium veggie pizza...good deal! The crust is more of a hand tossed style, not too thick or thin. You have the option of white garlic sauce or traditional red sauce, as well. They don't skimp on toppings, either! I'll be back for more halal California style pizza again soon. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Vegetarian Pizza with red sauce - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I came to this location about 5 years ago, and I literally just went again yesterday and it was just as good as the first time. We got the chicken tikka pizza, a half chapli kabab, along with the half meat supreme pizza. I remember I loved the magzone, which is a calzon, and so I ordered one with Italian sausage. Since we were driving up from Texas to Michigan, and I wanted to make sure we got food on the way and had my order written a few hours before even reaching here. I know I got a bit greedy by ordering so much, but I have been waiting to come to this place for so long. It did not disappoint! We were able to use the restrooms which were clean, pray, and get our meal. They gave me I crushed red pepper on the side, plates and napkins, and I bought way too much ranch but I don't regret it because I was amazing. I have literally nothing to complain about, and that does not happen often, so thank you so much to this establishment for being the ideal pit stop! I am waiting to drive back down to Texas so that we can stop by here again. I cannot wait! read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

BEST PIZZA BY FAR!! all fresh ingredients I would highly recommend for who ever that makes it to Indianapolis!!

I personally do not eat pork for solidarity and overall health period with that being sad it is really cool being able to order from a restaurant that you don't have to worry about they're being pork on your pizza because they don't sell pork. Everything for the most part is beef and it is very good. I would say the only thing I don't like about the pizzas are the red sauce. It's too sweet for me personally so when I order again, I will be ordering the tikka masala pizza or one of the specialties without the red sauce. Other than that absolutely no complaints. Other than the fact, I would not recommend ordering it through GrubHub because I think the restaurant argues with GrubHub when they forget something. I had ordered some cheesy bread that I was really excited to try and I didn't get it and I tried to get a refund through GrubHub that didn't work which it usually does and then I called the restaurant told him what happened and they were happy to give me a refund, but I never got the refund because it was a third-party refund. Anyway, I hadn't had any issues until the last time I went and I still really wanted my cheesy bread but maybe some other time. read more

I love the meat lover pizza. No pork with white sauce is really good. They do not skimp on the meat either like some of the others. Pizza is always ready when stated it will be. The food is good but I have never eaten inside. read more

This was so good!! Somos un grupo hispano y nos trataron súper bien. Highly recommend the pizza here. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - On the way back home to Michigan stopped off for pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Legitimately good pizza. Good toppings and a generous amount of cheese puts this pizza over the top. It's out of bounds!

Hot, halal, fresh, and delicious. Got the thin crust half Chalpi Kebob and half supreme. Muhammad took my order and he is awesome! Highly recommend! read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Large half supreme half Chappli Kabab Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Unique pizzas (with Asian flavors). We plan to stop by again on our drive through Indianapolis.

No wonder this place has such great reviews, and it has great reviews on EVERY platform. Customer service is excellent & the chicken tikka pizza is the BEST pizza I've had in years. I was doubtful because I'd never had a pizza that didn't have tomato sauce as the base but I went with the recommended sauce and it was delicious. So savory, baked to perfection (not soggy or burnt) and the Medium is enough for 3 people. It's just a gorgeous pizza to even look at, let alone to eat. They've found a customer for life out of me, and I'll be sending everyone I know their way. I'm excited to try the other menu items too, if they care this much about a pizza I'd bet dollars to donuts that the rest of their menu is just as good. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Chicken Tikka Pizza It's just gorgeous isn't it? It's absolutely delicious. (This is the Medium) - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The pizza was great. It had a nice crispy crust and plenty of toppings. The price is very reasonable and it both looked and tasted delicious. We did eat our pizza in the restaurant but it appears that most of the business is take out. There was a steady stream of customers and Dashers taking pizzas out. read more

As I went grocery shopping at my favorite 38th streeet Patel 's I was told to try Magoo's pizza my family got a chance to try it today we ordered a large half chicken tikka and half veggie pizza . The gentleman helping us was very nice and willing to cut pizza in two halves and box in separate boxes because my mom Doesn't eat meat portion, price and waiting time was not bad and you did have an option to dine in . We liked both pizzas the white garlic sauce was unique with chicken but wished chicken tikka was more spicy and veggies had good flavor crust was nice . I would suggest to try it again with a variety of menu items available read more

See all

Amazing service! Delicious food prepared to perfection. True gem. Minority owned and operated. Mohammed greeted me with a smile, asked how we heard about them (we looked up places with good reviews). We are in town for the weekend for the race. I was concerned by poor reviews I saw on some other popular pizza chains, and I like to support local. This turned out to be a wise decision. We were immediately drawn to both the kebab pizza and chicken tika masala when looking at the menu online. We decided on the kebab. We ordered online, and I wasn't initially aware of an option to get half and half for two different specialty pizzas. Mohammed suggested that option for ordering next time. He opened the pizza box to show me and confirm accuracy of order. Everything was perfect! Pizza was ready within the estimated time window and hot. So glad we decided to give Magoo's a try while we were in town for the race. Good value for your money. Next time, we will request half and half so as to be able to try more variety. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Chappli Kabab Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Ive been told for months by so many locals that this is the pizza place to try out and I'm only mad at myself that I waited four months to try it! I'm half Indian and my Indian side was so thrilled by the Indian flavors of this pizza. I couldn't decide which pizza I wanted to try so I decided to do two different flavors. The chicken tikka had a white sauce base, which was creamy and garlicky. The chappli kebab definitely topped it off for me. I absolutely loved the Indian spices in the meat and the subtle spice to it. I finished the whole pizza, and yet my stomach is still rumbling from wanting more! Can't wait to go back soon for more!! read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Half chappli kebab (left) and half Chicken Tikka Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

First time ordering Magoos and first time using grubhub. I was pleasantly surprised. About an hour delivery wise but the pizza was great! Finely chopped toppings rather than chunks. Tasted just right to me. I'll order again for sure! read more

Stopped in Indy on the way to Chicago & ordered the Supreme Pizza medium size with red sauce over the phone. It's only carry out right now. We loved the pizza! It's delicious and basically a large size. Definitely recommend this place read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Delcious! Chicken tikka pizza with garlic sauce is remarkable! Don't underestimate the chappli, it's wonderfully flavored!

In the past I bought pizzas from Mogoo's in Avon, IN. Since moving to the Westside of Indianapolis I tried ordering from the Mcgoo's on West 38th St., and was extremely disappointed with the service that I received. I arrived at the time that I was quoted on their web page, and received a message that my order was ready. My pizza was not ready upon my arrival. I was told 12 more minutes. Finally 25 minutes later my order (pizza and garlic bread) was finally ready. No apologies for the lateness on their part. This was over 45 minutes after I ordered! Several other customers walk right in and was handed their order while I was waiting. I will not go back!!!!! read more

Love the Chicken tikka pizza with the garlic sauce. This coming from a guy that I usually doesn't like much on my pizza. The location on 38th Steet also has excellent pizza deals for select days if you search their online site. Looking forward to next visit as many of their other pizzas and side dishes look really good. read more