If you don't feel like reading my whole review, here's the short version... the hype is real and…read moreworth the trip! My wife's sister, who just moved away from Hawaii told us about this place. She told us we had to come here. She made sure to mention to carve out a couple hours of the day, because we'll be waiting in line. As you can see pictures from other people's reviews, that's definitely the case. We took an Uber over there, and as soon as we got in the car and the driver mentioned the address he said, are y'all ready to wait?!?! I think we got there around 10 AM and the line was already long! We knew we would have to be very patient this day. Luckily it wasn't super hot outside so that helped with the waiting process. They did have someone come around and offer coffee and water to purchase while we waited in line. I thought that was pretty smart under the circumstances that everyone has to deal with while waiting here. After probably a 2 hour wait... we finally got in! They have other options of things to eat. Scones, croissants and things like that. We were there for the star player... the cinnamon roll! These things are huge! My wife and I said since we waited so long, we might as well get two and enjoy one of them for later. I never envisioned myself waiting two hours for a cinnamon roll, or any other type of treats, but this was well worth it. We wanted to have one while it was fresh out the oven, so we found a bench to sit at around a bus stop. It was so soft, pretty much melted in your mouth. The icing was tasty. It was so fresh, it's the best cinnamon roll I've ever had in my life. I'm sure spending two hours of your time being in Maui you don't want to sit in line waiting on something like a cinnamon roll, trust me I felt the same way. After doing this, I WILL do it again the next time I'm there! Next time, I would be there first thing in the morning and waiting in line before they open up, that way I'll have time for other activities around the island that I have planned for the day. The wait is worth it, and I highly suggest this place!

I really wanted to like it, but it just wasn't for me…read more Waited 3.5 hours on a Tuesday morning (from 6:30am-10am, their croissants were sold out so we bought 4 of the cinnamon rolls & a box of cookies. The cookies are delicious, I love that they put pistachios in it & it's not overly sweet, they were my favorite. The cinnamon rolls unfortunately fell short for me. There was something about them that just didn't "wow" me enough to be believing the hype. However, I'm still glad that I tried it. & to each their own.

I regret not writing a review sooner. This review is a year late. My family enjoyed Prison Street…read morePizza in September 2022. We enjoyed it so much we couldn't stop thinking about it and came back a second time within the same week of our Maui vacation. Thin crust. Super fresh dough. Yummy cheesy goodness. Good tunes playing for indoor dining. Great, friendly service. The reason I'm finally writing a review is because a year later my family is still talking about Prison Street Pizza. This month we find ourselves in Lake Tahoe for vacation. We ate pizza at Jiffy's Pizza in North Tahoe and it reminded us of Prison Street Pizza in Lahaina. Fresh dough, crispy thin crust, and flavorful sauce and cheese. Pure yummy. I highly recommend Prison Street Pizza in Lahaina. I also highly recommend Jiffy's Pizza in North Lake Tahoe. LOL. ;)

Miss this place wish he would reopen somewhere in Lahaina…read more Since the fires we ha e lost so many awesome places to eat.

Made to order fresh Maui style donuts from Kamala' treat. Every order is custom from plain to a…read morewide variety of fillings and it was just amazing. Beautiful crust on the outside with a side doughy and moist texture inside. Best to call ahead if you have limited time

This pizza is nothing but absolutely DELICIOUS. The crust, sauces, and cheese complement each other…read moreso well to the point where my family and I just had to order another one. The pizza is fresh and perfectly baked. The staff is very friendly and works efficiently. The only complaint I have is the price. The cost of the pizza compares to that found in restaurants. The size is relatively small and there is no table service so that the price becomes steep. I do think, however, that it is worth it. The pizza is honestly very high quality. And I will return my next time in Maui.

One of our favorite spots . We love everything on the menu !…read more They make their own pasta! Portions are perfect ! Their pizzas are incredible as well.

We had a reservation for 5/21 and had the best time…read more The staff is very kind and welcoming. Our server (older gentleman) was the best, he was funny and very knowledgeable when it came to the menu. The pizza is AMAZING, def try the pizza. The pasta (pesto sauce) was sooooo yummmm. You can def taste how fresh the pasta is. Everything was so good we came back the next night LOL. The staff even remembered us which was sweet. This was our favorite dinner spot and so excited to come back on our next trip to Maui. After having burrata here I won't be able to have it anywhere else haha. The hazelnut gelato was also very delicious, very fresh.

We stopped by for Happy Hour in January 2023 and happy we did. They have a full bar and they have…read moremy favorite Maui Brewing Lahaina Town Brown on draft. This will be a stop everytime we're in town. We sat at the bar, ordered cold beer, and a Garlic Mushroom pizza. They do a good wood fire pizza! Friendly service and good food. The only bummer was that the restroom is a shared bathroom outside the restaurant(key code needed). Kapena's is located on the south side of Front Street at 505 Front Street. There is street parking and a paid parking lot across the street.

The bruschetta here is a must-have appetizer. It's such a refreshing treat after a long day out in…read morethe sun. The tomatoes are fresh and juicy with just the right amount of mozzarella and balsamic vinegar. This place has such a great vibe. It's fun and chill and really enjoyable. I had to knock off one star because the bartender, who was super nice and sweet, kept forgetting my drink and had to ask me 2-3 times what I ordered. Overall though it was a great experience!

We scored an amazing parking spot and beautiful view table to start off on the right foot…read more We've been coming here for years when pizza was the focus and the interior was rustic, but not since reopening after the fires and WOW! It's gorgeous inside and some of the best service we've had - hostess, waiter, bussers, everyone was excellent. We also loved the food we had. It's upscale and island prices, but well worth it. Everything was tasty and we enjoyed a nice bottle of wine. They will cork your leftovers for you to take back so don't be shy about getting a bottle. We're so happy this part of Front Street is surviving and thriving and we will definitely be back.

Honu! What an amazing dinner in Maui. My husband, was…read moresearching for a great whiskey bourbon experience during our trip. Someone recommended your establishment and we gave it a try. It turns out it was an awesome dining experience and he truly enjoyed the flight tasting experience! We made reservations for the dinner. You need to make reservations ahead of time for the restaurant if you plan to eat there. This small cozy restaurant has breathtaking views and the waves cresting against the coast was an amazing sounding experience. We started with a half dozen of oysters it was so fresh, the shave wasabi went so terrific with it. We added the beef tallow truffle fries and it was delicious as well. I ordered the chef specialty fresh fish dish and my husband had an osso bucco. Both were delicious and filled us up. He ordered a couple different whiskeys and he said it blended well with all the dishes. They had many options for dessert. We ordered Roselani's vanilla ice cream and a americano. It was the perfect finish to our dining experience!

Food fabulous! Service quick and correct! Nice setting and…read moredoes not disappoint Fabulous musician playing 80/90 music that everyone loved

Good food. But instead of getting regular burger, my mother in law (who has a small appetite)…read morewanted the kids meal burger, but the server said he would not take that order and the kids menu, which was on the regular menu not a kids menu, she couldn't order that item. WTF. The only thing I can think of why he wouldn't take the order was the regular burger was $19 and the kids burger was $11. I asked if he can give her the kids burger at the adult price. He said no. We are already a society of wasteful people, and why waste the regular burger when she can't eat it. That really rubbed me wrong

I have heard about and seen the pies and how amazing they are. Unfortunately, I haven't had a…read morechance to sample them. The reason why is because of the awesome sandwiches Leoda's offers! The bread is so fresh and the sandwiches are definitely shareable( if you are willing to!)! We got here before the shop opened and there were already people waiting in line. You can eat inside or out. Just order and sit down because they will bring it to you when it's ready!

I was driving along the coast and spotted this pie shop. It's conveniently located just off the…read morehighway and easy to access. There was a line when I arrived, but it moved quickly. All of the pies were on display. It was so hard to choose one, but I finally decided on the chocolate mac-nut pie. The shop offers both indoor and outdoor seating, but it was so busy and crowded. I luckily was able to find a spot outside. I finished my pie so fast. The crust was really good and the filling was delicious. I wish I had gone back to pick up more pies to go!