Ok so I don't know where to start. The pizza is just fantastic. It is light and airy while holding its toppings up and every ingredient tastes amazing. The sweetness from the sausage was a perfect counter to the savory flavor of all the other meats. Grace said the salad was as enjoyable as any she's had for a while. Service was fast and very friendly. the atmosphere where we sat and ate reminded us of our youth and we are very excited to go back. read more

Finally able to stop in. The deal here is you order at the window, they give you paper plates, some parm packets and the food is brought out to your table. No inside seating just outside. I don't mind, sometimes. I ordered a 12" Margherita Pizza and a small Cesar Salad my total was $21. Not bad, I asked for a few cups of water but they don't have free water. You can purchase a walmart great value of purified water for $1.61. I only got one because I wasn't paying that times 3. There was loud music (rock/pop) not my typical style. Outside the tv's were playing different things. The pizza was really good but the rock music playing was death to my ears. I think it was a one time stop. When I go out to eat and pay I really enjoy the interaction of people. That isn't a thing here. read more

See all

Best pizza I've had in a long time, garlic knots and calzone were top notch! Clean area considering outdoors and good service. Cherry on top is ice cream next to it and soon they are starting to sell beer, so it will be an amazing spot for baseball season!! read more

See all

Pizza was delicious, we tried Extravaganza, meat lovers and pepperoni. Also got a greek salad - it was really good and fresh, as well. For dessert, kids really enjoyed the ice cream cones and an ice cream float, and some of us got the affogato, which was also really good. The pizzeria has a space in the back for kids to run around, throw frisbee and play ball, so we ended up hanging out for a few hours in the cozy outside seating area while the kids played. Perfect afternoon! read more

Main St Pizza & Ice Cream - extravaganza pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hastings, Florida

Pizza is epic. Ice cream hits. Service is so kind and sweet. Love them!! I highly recommend the bbq chicken

My friend and I stopped in to Main Street Pizza for a few appetizers prior to an event nearby. We ordered at the window and found a seat on the deck. There is no indoor seating. When we walked up to the window, we smelled all the good smells. We ordered cheesy garlic bread, served with marinara and two meatballs smothered in marinara. I'm not a huge bread fan but could not stop eating the cheesy garlic bread! It seemed to melt in my mouth. It was hot, soft and oh so cheesy. And the mariner sauce was perfectly blended with just a little sweetness. We each had a meatball. The meat was tender and flavorful. And it was a big portion. And again with the perfect marinara. The presentation was nice even in to go containers. If you're in Hastings, you must give them a try! read more

See all

One of the best pizzas we have ever had!! My daughter and I ordered, 16 inch half Bianca and half Char pepperoni. Both were very delicious and filling. The Char pepperoni has a little honey taste which was very unique and tasty. The staff were friendly. You should definitely try it when you are in this area. I highly recommend this place! read more

This is a great little place to stop and ran some pizza. All seating is outside so if it's a beautiful day, it's soooo nice! We did not see any high chairs, but we also did not ask as our little one was in a stroller. We ordered a buffalo chicken pizza. It was delicious, however we like a more heat, but that is just a preference. They do not sell by the price or have any type of children's menu. They suggested ordering the meatballs (2 meatballs in marinara sauce) for our 5 year old. We did and she loved them and the sauce. We ended up bringing the rest of the sauce home and put some noodles in it. They have canned drinks and water. No alcohol. I think they were reasonable prices and they were super sweet. Definitely will stop here again! read more

this is an easy 5 stars! Just based on the garlic knots alone told me all I need to know, they were delicious! The dough! The dough was light and fluffy, not at all dry or thick, they were perfectly slathered with garlic butter, parm and mozzarella, so freaking good! Me and Michelle were not planning to eat them all but they were so good we devoured them, with a side of equally delicious meatballs in some marinara sauce, yes to all of it! Hastings is lucky to have this gem! :) read more

Main St Pizza & Ice Cream - Garlic knots add cheese, delicious!! - Pizza Near Me - Hastings, Florida

See all

Great pizza,crust had nice flavor and not soggy. Toppings were tasty and generous. Glad they covered the side porch!! read more

Terrible wings. Breaded, oven baked, dry, slimy disgusting texture. This place should close their doors. Makes me want to puke read more

Great garlic Parm wings! Get them extra crispy! Steak and cheese sub, Gyro and pizza all very good. We come often!

We were in the area and had to try out this new pizza place. Based on prior reviews we got the cheesy garlic knots and they did not disappoint. Soft and cheesy with a large side of marinara. The marinara... it's homemade... it's PERFECT! I wanted the Bianca (white) my husband wanted pepperoni and mushroom. They told us we could split a pizza. It was wonderful! Every bite was heaven. The cheese was stringy and delicious! The staff was helpful and friendly. The breeze on the deck was great on a hot day like today. We will be back! read more

See all

We're coming back! Their food was so good, delicious pizza and garlic knots, that we have decided to dine here again. 5/5

Place is delicious, good food, meatballs are delicious, the Mediterranean pizza is my jam.. wish they delivered

food is fine, this review is strictly for anyone who has thought of applying and working there, DONT :) The owner is very rude n has very little compassion for his employees. the rest of the staff is fine, but still one of the worst work environments I've endeared due to the boss/owner. So again ordering food here isn't an issue but working here is, even still i wouldn't purchase to support someone like him :) this is not a personal biased review he generally is just a rude person and has people in and out of there all the time, I had better management and benefits working for a KFC and that says something :) read more

It's a bit pricey for the quality, wasn't the worst but wasn't the best, and there's no indoor seating

If you're traveling between St Augustine and Gainesville, stop here for pizza and Italian food. Food is fresh and tasty, service is friendly, outdoor seating is comfortable. Really exemplary customer experience. The pizza is first rate, hot and fresh. Meatball sub and Italian subs are outstanding. Seriously, people, enjoy St Aug but get your food on the way home. read more

So many places claim to have superior pizza, but Main Street really does. Fresh top quality ingredients, insanely good crust, made to order and fast and friendly. Outdoor seating on a breezy elevated deck under umbrellas with a view of Main Street. I drive 50 miles for their pizza, and usually get several to take home, refrigerate and reheat. You will not be disappointed! I would give more than 5 stars if possible. read more

Absolutely amazing food and staff. The owner is phenomenal. I was leery to see another pizza place in Hastings, but they are really rocking it. read more

Ordered the Margaretta Pizza which should have had fresh tomatoes & mozzarella. Well, NO tomatoes, no basil, only pizza sauce & very little cheese which made it "tasteless". read more

This is the same owner who used to run slice in Palatka. Good solid pizza and Calzones for the area. I like their Pizza Bianca the best but all of the pizza I have tried are good. Service is quick and Friendly. Limited parking but it's not a sit down pizzeria so it's usually adequate. read more

Review from a true New Yorker who knows New York Pizza. Pizza is absolutely great! The crust, cheese and flavor was on point!!

Take out time was on point...super cute deck with umbrellas and THE best gluten free pizza crust we've ever had! sausage and pepperoni were delish and not greasy and the veggies tased super fresh and still crisp! Great job, y'all and can't wait to try other stuff on your menu!!! read more