Great Prices, Great Food, Great People! My family absolutely adores this homey Pizzeria. We get pizza from them every week. The interior is very homey, with beautiful photos/paintings of Italy, a nice dim-lit eating room, (or if you're not into that) they also have a brighter area, perfect for the daytime or nighttime. I personally have not had their pasta, but I've heard great things about it. Their prices are fantastic for their portions. Personally, my favorite is the grandma pizza with mozzarella and basil so fresh, I wouldn't be surprised if they had a farm in their storage room. Super flavorful and 11/10 would eat again. read more

Had my kids birthday today and the KIDS PIZZA wasnt delivered. Had to wait an extra 35 mins

I chose this pizza place cause I was in the neighborhood and saw that their Google reviews were pretty good. I don't know if I got them on an off night but the pizza that I had was literally the worst pizza I ever had in my life. It tasted like it was a slice of pizza that sat in my fridge and I reheated two days later , Was so disappointed. I mean it was late at night, but still no excuse everything should be fresh. read more

Mama Lino's is the best around. Their grandma and Buffalo slices are incredibly delicious! Make sure you check them out you won't be disappointed read more

Mama Lino's Pizzeria - Grandma Slice - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Great tasting pies!! Quick delivery. Last night we tried a regular pizza with ricotta and meatball. Delicious!

I haven't eaten here for decades. Used to come here when I was a teacher in the neighborhood. Was nice to reconnect with a food memory from the past. Unfortunately, the pizzas are a little short of delicious. I make mine well well done because I want the crust to be crunchy throughout. Well, it seems like no amount of time in the high heat could crisp the middle of their thin Neapolitan slices. The siciliano was similar, though they crisp on the edges as they should. Of course the pool of cheese in the middle says you can't be all happy with this 'Za any way you slice it. Flavor is not popping either; sauce is neither sweet nor zesty. A little oregano and touch of sugar goes a long way boys! read more

Mama Lino's Pizzeria - Neapolitan is awkwardly thin, doesn't crisp in the middle, regardless of how well done you make it. - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Ordered meatball parm hero EXTRA SAUCE and they give me this dried out crap with the smallest meatballs ever. Smfh read more

Mama Lino's Pizzeria - a hand holding a piece of pizza - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

We ordered Chicken Parmigiana Pizza and Garlic Bread with Cheese for delivery. They delivered ahead of the expected time which was great. The pizza and the garlic bread was just alright. Don't think we'll be ordering again. read more

See all

I visited Mama Lino's with my Grandson during a visit to NY to see ZZ Top. Staff were great, friendly and chatty. Ordered our huge pizza and it was simply superb, probably the best I've ever tasted - made fresh there and then. Ended up with some freshly made zeppole - again superb. Great value for money and friendly atmosphere. read more

I was about to hit the place order button on Uber eats but the 17.99 veal parmigiana hero price at another restaurant was antithetical to this chronically bristled, early groused, parsimonious diner. Hence, I electronically made my way to Yelp and was smitten by a competitor 10.49 pricing. The veal parm hero/hoagie/grinder on garlic bread was delicious. Nice and crunchy bread, plentiful cheese and a perfect amount of sauce and garlic was really good. Garlic knots were very nicely done, could have been crisped a little more, but were just fine as is. The fries were not soggy. I got it delivered to a residence so the lighting, noise and seating at the restaurant can't be commented on. read more

Love the food. Love the pizza. The service is fast and friendly. When I don't feel like getting pizza I love ordering custom calzones and chicken rolls. read more

MOLDY CHEESE!!! Order delivery and got moldy cheese all over my salad! If the cheese is moldy what does that say for older other ingredients? What does that say for the cheese used in their Pizza? Absolutely horrified and disgusted read more

Mama Lino's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Ordered pizza well done came mushy and cold, veal parmigiana chopped in small chunks and cold! Never again , was a regular customer.....no longer! read more

We had this delivered at work and I was happy with the food and prompt delivery. I can't speak for the pizza or meals. I had the BBQ chicken salad and it was full of chicken. Seemed freshly made. The large was huge and I couldn't finish. The garlic knot was ok. read more

Mama Lino's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Came here twice for pizza - a basic cheese Sicilian pie and another time a cheese pie with sausage. I wasn't blown away at all and with so many other options around, I think I'll pass. I'll have to give their pastas and other food a try, but I won't be coming back for their pizza... read more

The food at this restaurant was out of this world, the prices were better than any other place I've seen and the quality of the food doesn't lack. But the best part was the service at Mama Lino's the assistant manager Jack was a really helpful and respectful young man, we will definitely be going back! read more

Mama Lino's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

New York pizza, Long Island pizza, two different tasting pizzas, this should not be. As a frequent Long Island passer through, time and time again the comparison is unavoidable, so the pizza scales slides away from the extreme ends. Long Island pizza has been snubbed poor and dubbed in second class citizenship standing, and there it shall remain. Part and parcel due to a level of pizza mediocrity and acceptance there of. But why the disparity, heck, Queens is part of Long Island, ain't it? I hold no false hope the bar will ever rise, so here I must review pizza, but not with the same lenses as the pizza all of the five boros has on every fourth block or fifth commercial block and just a few short LIRR stops to the west for me. The spicy Pepperoni caused a raised brow of interest, the meatball slices caused a furrowed brow of disappointment. Match all square at one. The most painstaking short coming of my lunch was the 14 grease infused napkins it took to mop up my slices, Long Island pizza down one. Additional grading penalties could be incurred due to poorly orchestrated pseudo, Italian gumba talk. Long Island pizza, down two. Cheese is cheese, dough is dough, sauce is not just sauce. Mama Lino's tomato sauce must receive a note worthy credit of being high quality, well prepared old style Italian sauce. Plus two for Long Island pizza, match finishes all square at three stars, two in NYC style. read more

Walked in with my hubby for a peaceful lunch. Very attentive and friendly staff with professional service. We both enjoyed the buffalo chicken pizza. The place is nice and clean with comfortable ambiance. Will definitely come with the whole family next time. Keep up the great job!! read more

Mama Lino's Pizzeria - Buffalo Chicken slice - delicious!!!!! - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Best margarita pizza I have ever had. I am from California so obviously pizza here is on another level. That being said the crust, the sauce, the flavor, it was all phenomenal! read more

Mama Lino's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

This place is awesome reminds me of pizza and pasta I used to get when I was a kid living in queens

When you call up, their english is not very strong. This is the perfect place to call if you want your order to be wrong. They pick up the the phone and it sounds like they are fresh off the boat. Placing an order is as much fun as hanging yourself with a rope. If they made you what you ordered then god bless. It's impossible to place an order in 25 minutes or less. Who knows, you may love their pizza and keep coming back. But just remember the guy taking your order will sound like he just smoked a pipe made of crack. read more

I am 27 weeks pregnant and was verbally abused by the delivery man who was late by 50 minutes! He threw the box of food at me and the maintenance man in my building who was fixing the lights had to intervene. He never called or left a voicemail. He is a sicko and needs help. This restaurant is off my list and I would tell anyone who cares about their safety to avoid this restaurant! Grubhub refunded and I'm filing a police report with the security footage from work. read more

Horrible Customer: We ordered from here almost once a week for over a year. On our last delivery order of buffalo wings we noticed multiple feathers stuck to the wings. We called the restaurant to let them know what happened and they could not care less about resolving the issue for us. Joe, the manager or owner, stated they could not pick up and replace the order. They also could not refund me for my order, instead they offered a 50% discount in the chicken wings. So we are now stuck paying for half of an order of chicken wings that is sitting in our trash. On top of the $5.00 delivery fee and $5.00 tip. Unimaginably bad customer service for a frequent customer. read more

I ordered a Medium pizza to be delivered to my home. It took 50 minutes to get here . The delivery guy was very nice BUT the pizza was ice cold and the cheese was old looking. We sent it back and while on the phone was told they would make a new pie. The delivery guy came back with THE EXACT PIZZA !! THEY JUST REHEATED IT AND PUT IT IN THE SAME BOX!!!! IT WAS HOT ON THE BOTTOM OF THE BOX BUT THATS IT!!! The pizza crust was so hard you couldn't even bite it without ripping into it like a lion tearing into its prey!! We were given gift certificates for this place therefore needed to use them up or I would NEVER BE USING THEM!! We spoke to Jack who's supposed to be the manager and refuses to take this cardboard pizza back and make a FRESH NEW PIE!! The owner was supposed to call us back but had to go home so he leaves his business in the hands of this incompetent person!!! DON'T BUY FROM THEM EVER IF YOU HAVE TO DEAL WITH A PERSON LIKE THIS JACK!!!! read more

I appreciate the politeness and greeting each time I've been to this pizzeria. They have indoor seating and lots of food and drinks to choose from. read more

Love this place and their pasta!! This is one of the places my co workers and I order dinner from constantly. Not only are they fast but they also get our orders correct every time (given that we usually place very large dinner orders). Portion sizes are very big for the pasta. I'm not a fan of their chicken parm. I find the chicken to be dry with too much breading. But I do love their penne alla vodka. Garlic knots come with entree orders. read more

I like their pizza but they need to fix their phone. I called to order a mama lino the work pizza but they gave me a reg cheese pizza. At least answer it in a quieter place or repeat the order back to me so i can see if you have the right order. read more

I've only been there once. 2 slices and a soda for under $5. I'm pretty sure this place has the cheapest lunch special in the area. 4 stars. The slices are a-ok. kinda greasy, but decent. minus 1 star The place is pretty run down and quite dated. Looks like it hasn't gotten a good cleaning in a while either. minus 2 stars. The guys behind the counter are nice, and they aim to provide a great service. My friend ordered a few garlic knots, and it came with so much garlic on top I literally LOL'ed when I saw it. Had to stay away from him for the rest of the afternoon. Plus 1 star read more

Awesome food here The Sicilian slices are just soft and tasty the Chicken parm is my fav read more

Quietly tucked in alongside johns farm. Switched owners a number of times, but finally got it right. Pizza's are great. Sauce has dynamite flavor with a good quality mozzarella. They need to investigate the local buffalo slice and knock it out of the park and things will get real good for them. read more

Gave me the wrong pizza when I even double checked and asked twice before I left. It was wrong on the receipt too so I asked what happened and the guy said it's ok because it's the same price. But it wasn't the right one. read more

The best priced pizza in the area and even better with a coupon! Not to mention that the pizza is excellent and fresh. This is my go to place for if I want to get a pie or two of pizza. read more

My family has been ordering pizza here for over 4yrs and we loved it at first but.... the owners changed recently, its not as rowdy anymore and the pizza changed for the worst. Ordered two large cheese pizza; one was very oily and the other the bottom was completely black. Literally upsetting, i used to love eating here and now i dont think i'll go back... read more

The food that I usually order from here is always fresh and good tasting. Never had a problem with any order and delivery is always timely.

Greatest zeppoles around! Huge pieces of dough fully covered in powdered sugar. Not dripping with oil. If you want a quality reminds you of going to the church carnival as a kid zeppole, this is the place to go. The pizza is great. And the owner is friendly. Garlic knots are top notch as well. Had them cater a super bowl party one year and everyone loved the food. read more

My Business "All County Driving School" orders pizza every week for our students that attend our classes. We are happy to have found Mama Lino's as the pizza is delicious. read more

I think they just recently got new owners. I saw some new faces in there. And they don't look Italian. The pizza sauce is bland and too sweet. They gotta work on that to make that spicy tangy pizza sauce. read more

Tried this spot for the first time because I was starving. I was shopping next door. Fantastic breaded chicken and tomato slice. Extremely fresh. I would give 5 stars if the staff and men behind the counter were friendlier. But other than that. Great first impression with that slice. Very clean. And nice big booths to sit at. Nice atmosphere read more

I've been coming here for quite some time now and their pizza is the best around without question. Their dinners are fantastic as well. Every time I come here everyone is so nice and the foods always fresh. My new favorite thing is the wings, their very underrated. The lunch special comes with wings, fries and a drink for under $10, you just can't beat it! read more

What a restaurant! I have traveled to many pizzerias throughout the island , but this pizzeria has to be one of the best. From it's great food to it's exemplary customer service (not to mention speedy delivery), this pizzeria is a great place for a night of family/ friendly fun! read more