The service here is amazing. The staff is amazing. The food is always great. I never can complain about it It's always amazing the fact that this place does not have a five star rating is unacceptable. Sadly, I live in Long Island so I can't come here that often but when I do come here, I enjoy it every single time and every time I do go there it's always slam packed. read more

We've eaten there for over 30 years. it's consistently gone downhill. The only item that remains spectacular are the garlic knots. Last night was one of the worst restaurant meals ever. I asked specifically if the Alfredo was homemade and our server said it was. it was not. it was from a jar, mostly cream (there's no cream in real homemade Alfredo) and the Parmesan cheese was fake. I couldn't finish it and left it on the table when we left. My husband's manicotti was tasteless, no flavor in the filling and the red sauce is pathetic. Even the garlic knots won't get us back there again. Sad read more

Delicious Italian comfort food with generous portions! Mamma Maria's delivers exactly what you'd hope for in a local Italian spot--huge portions, bold flavors, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. The pizza is absolutely top notch--crispy crust, rich sauce, and fresh toppings. Definitely a standout. The waitstaff was fantastic--friendly, attentive, and really made the experience feel personal. You can tell they take pride in great service. Only reason for 4 stars instead of 5 is the drink menu. I wish they offered a broader selection of bourbons and spirits to match the quality of the food. A little more variety behind the bar would take this place to the next level. Still, Mamma Maria's is a solid go-to for a satisfying Italian meal. I'll definitely be back! read more

Their seafood pasta with red sauce was soooo good! It has scallops (deliciously, perfectly browned), clams, shrimps, mussels. Also came with garlic knots and a salad. The waitress was very nice. I went during off-season, between lunch and dinner. Very few people. No wait. read more

Mamma Maria's - Seafood pasta with red sauce - Chicken Wings Near Me - Stamford, New York

See all

I hate writing bad reviews but this experience was overall awful. We waited an hour before we were seated (we had a party of 7) and then it took over an hour for our food to come out after being readily able to order right when we sat down. The food was nothing spectacular, noting I wouldn't be able to differentiate the pasta between my mother's cooking, and this supposedly authentic Italian restaurant. The nail in the coffin was when the cashier (I'm assuming the owner) asked how our meal was, I said it was okay but that we had been here since about 7:15pm (it was now past 10pm) and she rebutted was that we got there closer to 7:30 and that they are supposed to close at 8:30pm (as if it was our issue that they were slow as molasses in seating and serving us). There was no apology, no sincerity, and thus, this place does not deserve business. read more

Well, I can't comment on the food, because they lost my order. I arrived to pick up my order to find a pick up line out the door. So, after waiting 20 minutes at least, while the person behind the counter answered the phone and took live orders while those of us in line had to wait. The experience was compounded by the fact that the server kept forgetting the numbers and had to come back and ask again. Some suggestions: When it's busy like this, dedicate someone to answering the phones. Dedicate another to take out orders. The money spent on salaries will be more than made up by the return customers and the positive reviews. Also, take the space behind the kitchen and make that the take out counter. That way, people who are coming in to sit can actually get in without fighting thru the take out line. Last, find a different "system" for orders. It was obvious that it was all too easy for the kitchen to lose the order or lose track of it in the pile of tickets. I can't say I'll go back any time soon. read more

We stopped for super early dinner. Ordered cheese ravioli and spaghetti & meatballs. Food is delish. Service was quick and very friendly. It is a large place so lots of space for larger groups, if needed. Prices we good too. Menu was a decent size too. Nice variety of pizza and Italian dishes. read more

See all

Very good food. We have eaten at the restaurant and ordered take out. Both are excellent.

Been a customer since buying our second home in Davenport 2018. The dinners-take out or dining in- along w the garlic knots are phenomenal. We ordered white pizza tonight (been hearing it's awesome) w spinach. I can actually say at almost 63 this HAS to be THE BEST white pizza EVER. WOW read more

The food was excellent, and the service was great; however, when I went to pay, I noticed that I was charged for four unsweetened iced teas at $2.50 each, even though two of them were just top-offs and not new glasses. Additionally, after calculating the bill, I realized they had overcharged me by $40, and I also left a generous $30 tip for the nice waitress. Other reviewers have had the same thing happen, so for future diners, check your bill. read more

Make sure you aren't in a hurry because this isn't a rush in and rush out place. We waited in the foyer with a few other groups and we all schemed to share the large table altogether ...the table garlic knots was amazing and we ordered a dozen to go at the end. I got the spinach fig salad but my appetite was mostly satisfied by the garlic knots and the boneless*mild* chicken wings. To a kid it was still too spicy but really, it's just a burst of flavor. The LOs got a kid's portion of spaghetti and meatball and the other LO got the chicken fingers with fries for his main course. The beaux got the stuffed manicotti. We all took our food LOs home. read more

See all

No change. Just bumping to remind everyone that this place is frikkin' outstanding. Ordered our pizza "well done" this time and it was even better than last time. The waitstaff is so over the top kind, attentive, and nice to our kids. And yes - 6 months later it still looks the same as it did 1000 years ago because great pizza places like this must be protected at all costs. Ps. I dipped my crusts into the garlic knot butter and it really turned everything up to 11. read more

We stopped in on Father's Day and had a wonderful time. The food was wonderful and the garlic knots and salad were superb! I had shrimp parm and my partner had Seafood Fra Diavolo in garlic and oil. Both dishes were over the top with portions taken home for another day. We will come back! read more

Delicious reliable Pizza. Meatballs too. Fast and easy to go service as well. As a NYC Ray's Pizza grown girl I find it very hard to find a great slice but Mamma's does it for me. read more

Food that my mom would love ! The waitress was super friendly, took excellent care of us, and showed an interest in my granddaughter. We drove an hour and a half to meet our daughter's family from the Albany area-well worth the drive. The Osobuco was incredible and we all took doggy bags home with us. The place was clean (especially the bathroom) and smelled so Italian I didn't want to leave :) read more

Me and my boyfriend are visiting the area and saw that this place was open, naturally since we live in New Jersey we were a bit skeptical of the quality of Italian food we'd get. Let me tell you... We were a 100% WRONG, we ordered our food to go and once we got to our Airbnb we shoveled into that food so fast. I've never seen us discuss food like we discussed our experience with this place, the dough tastes sooo fresh, the portions are HUGE, and it was a lovely experience in all. HIGHLY HIGHLY recommend, we'll definitely be eating here one last time before we head out! read more

Mamma Maria's - Mozzarella sticks, chicken spinach fig salad, pepperoni pizza twists and calamari - Chicken Wings Near Me - Stamford, New York

Best pizza around. Good crust and plenty of toppings. Cold beer. Great, personable service. Clean!!!

Food was excellent however we weren't prepared to wait sooooooo long (more than an hour after ordering) to get served. Four Garlic knots finally arrived after nearly half hour. Had we known it would be a three hour lunch we would have opted to get slices or something already prepared to go. The waitress was a bit aloof also and never apologized for the delays as I suppose it's normal to them. Not sure I would visit again read more

Mamma Maria's in Stamford NY is family owned Italian restaurant 1800' high in the hills of Delaware County. A sizeable restaurant with outside seating in fairer weather then our cold and snowy night visit in January, the staff is very welcoming. There is a mix of tables and booths. One of the specials was Scungilli over pasta so my wife did not even look at the menu and I went with a pepperoni Calazone. After placing our order we received 4 complementary garlic knots and as other reviewers note, they are really really good! When our meals came I was treated with a Calazone that is thin in stature but hanging over both ends of the dish by close to 5"! A very unique presentation of a Calazone that I have experienced. It was nicely hot with a tasty sauce for dipping. The crust has a great flavor and it was very good. My loves scungilli over pasta was very good, having a decent amount of scungilli she felt. We passed on dessert this visit as it was getting late and roads were bad but we will be back to Mama Marias for sure! read more

See all

Absolutely delicious, reasonably priced and great service! Always have some to bring home too

We eat here at LEAST once a week, and never get tired of it. It's like our second home! The food, the people and our seat by the fire.. they all make for a perfect dinner! read more

Me and my partner are visiting from the city and we were looking for somewhere to eat. Luckily we found this pizzeria because the food was SOOO good!! There was a wait and it seemed like they were busy for dining in, so we ordered takeout and got our food within 20 minutes. The cashier was very kind and answered any questions we had about the food. I definitely recommend read more

See all

Delicious - the pizza was fantastic and the garlic knots. I'd highly recommend Mamma Maria's.

The best Italian around. I've been going here since I was a kid--they are consistently good, so kind, and have the best garlic knots in the world. Can't recommend enough. Great for takeout and dine in! read more

If you want a great slice of pizza and an authentic experience with genuine, fantastic people, this is the place to go read more

Mamma Maria's - Beautiful Sicilian inspired stained glass window - Chicken Wings Near Me - Stamford, New York

See all

I gave you five stars because the food is very good. However, your system of seating people needs work. Your website says Reservations accepted but in reality you only take reservations for parties of 15 or more. When you get there you give the server your name which is put on a list and you are told to go outside and wait. The day we visited we arrived a little before 5pm on a Saturday, we were told about 20 mins. or so to be seated. We waited patiently outside on the porch and around the 45 minute mark my son decided to inquire about the wait as we noticed people leaving and we should have been next. Well no one had come out to tell us they had a table ready & people that arrived after us were already seated. Luckily another table opened up. We were famished at that point. We ordered our drinks, when they came we ordered an appetizer for the table & gave our dinner orders at the same time. After waiting another 15 minutes the waitress brought our basket of garlic knots & said your salads & soup will be right out. We inquired as to where the appetizer was that was ordered & she said it will be right out. A few minutes later she brought our salads but still no appetizer. She said it would be out in a minute, the table next to us, that was seated after us had theirs already & then ours came out. We ate the salads & the apps and watched as that table next to us got their food which was almost the exact same order as we had put in. Another few minutes later our food finally arrived. I had the eggplant rollitini which I highly recommend. The portion was large enough & the price wasn't too bad either. But the wait for a seat, the wait for our food etc.makes me only want to get takeout from now on. They really need to have a better system in place. read more

Food was awesome! Service was good considering there were only two young ladies waiting in the restaurant. Place was clean and well kept. Will try to get back there again soon but it's not close to home!!! Good road trip restaurant!!!! read more

Visiting family here and had a very delicious dinner. The portion sizes are huge and enough for a couple more meals. We realky enjoyed the food Garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, shrimp scampi, and other meals everyone was satisfied with their food. Service was gracious and we all enjoyed our meals and family time together. read more

Really good food. I ordered lasagna and it was about 5 servings for me. The sauce was quite nice as well. S.O. ordered stuffed shells and was pleased with them as well. But, here's the bad/strange. It was a Sunday afternoon and we were passing through coming home from a weekend getaway. Not necessarily looking for a quick bite but not 2.5 hours! We asked for boxes and the check and waited so long I stood up, found a box, packed my own food and then we just walked up to the front to try to pay. It took so long to be acknowledged we could have walked out the door and been miles down the road before anyone ever noticed we were gone. I'm an honest person so I'd never do that. But then they acted surprised that we wanted to pay and go! It was a great meal, just a really weird experience. read more

Awesome food, best place I've found outside of NYC! The food is yummy! You won't be disappointed!

I love this place because it is open late compared to most places in the neighborhood. AND... best garlic knots I have every had, floating in a sea of garlic herb infused oil. The pizza is good, spaghetti and meatballs will feed two people. Nice chicken parm. I was not so much a fan of their lasagna, I like mine with more meat sauce, theirs has a lot of cheese, but if you love this dish with a tonne of creamy ricotta and mozzarella order it! read more

2 Words. Chicken Parm. BEST IN THE WORLD!! This is the place to eat if you love great food, great service, great people! read more

Great local spot with friendly servers, yummy food and big portions. We just spent two hours very happily cared for there and are bringing home more than we even ate! Take-out also very organized and good. Big thanks to Mamma M read more

Me an my family was there yesterday for my mother in laws birthday its one of her favorite restaurants, but we was so disappointed service was so slow an it was not busy.we order appetizers that was burnt an came when the meal was coming,we tried to eat butcouldnt enjoy cause we was to busy chasing flies away.then our meal came an we was a party of 7 noone enjoy there meal it was so blend no taste at all.we told the waitress we wanna sing happy birthday we order desert they took so long that my my mother in law was walking out n we had to call her back she was disappointed on her 75 th birthday this was one of her favorite places an wanted to her to have a good time an that did not work out we will never go back super un happy read more

Best Italian food in the area, I've been coming here for many years, It's consistently excellent' I love the Pizza , veal Parm, all the pasta's the garlic knots are phenomenal!! I will never go anywhere else for Italian food ! The staff is friendly and efficient . I love this place I always feel like I'm eating at Gramma's house !! read more

Great Italian food in Stamford NY. Try the pasta with calamari, it's tender and fresh. The eggplant rotini is the best. My favorite pizza is the white cheese. Wonderful Sicilian cooks. I recommend you go off peak because of limited seating. They do have outside dinning also. I would give it 5 stars but reserve that for spectacular places. This place is a keeper!!! read more

I have been a hardcore Mama Maria's fan for over 25 years. I don't get to come nearly as often as I'd like but whenever I am up at my family's cabin, it is a MUST. I've never had a single thing I didn't like. The food has remained consistent the entire time. The garlic knots?!?!?! They're a staple no matter what I order...they're to die for. The staff knows my family personally from the years of being avid customers. The owners and entire family is extremely down to earth, warm, and generous. The word generous also applies to the food portions. Unless you're sasquatch, you will leave with leftovers. I am so grateful to their business for aiding in so many incredible memories from my childhood. This place is all around a knockout. read more

One of my favorite restaurants, period. I only have the pleasure of being in that area during the summer, and less so in recent years, but when up there, going to this restaurant is always something that I look forward to, consistently over the years a treat every time. The ownership, the wait staff (Brittany is quite possibly the best waitress ever), the food in both quality and portions plus gently priced, all just absolutely wonderful. Listen, you go to a restaurant to enjoy some good food and maybe share some good company, but this place goes beyond that. It's just all-around a very nice, enjoyable experience, so I highly recommend going here. read more

Service was impeccable! Kristin was extremely professional and friendly. Best service by far! Sicilian pizza was huge!!! I talking like enough to feed "an army" but it was delicious! Added bonus as breakfast is already made! Shrimp scampi was also a large portion and a little on the spicy side! Delicious! Highly recommend for visitors or passer-bys! read more

See all

We have been coming to Mamas for 30 years or more. Hands down the best place to eat in the area. Family owned and operated. Huge portions of great food. My favorites; mussels in white wine sauce, shrimp oreganato, seafood fra diavolo and the garlic knots. None better anywhere on this planet! You could make a meal just out of knots and some soup! But order a main dish. Too good to pass up. Best pizza in the area and the strombolis are superb. You dont go away hungry and there is so much food you usually have left overs. You will not be dissapointed. Covid era update! We've been getting takeout at Mama Maria's every weekend since things got shut down with Covid and they open back up for takeout. I think we've missed two weekends in the last six months. We'd like to support local businesses. And Mama Marias is our favorite restaurant. I miss some of the specials. But that's to be expected given the circumstances. But everything we get is consistently excellent. Large portions. Great food. And when the weathers good We can sit outside and eat at their location. My suggestion is to call your order in and head there as soon as you call it in and then get in line. Looking forward to them to open back up the inside dining. read more