For a Sunday evening this place was hopping! That did not stop them from delivering superb service in a timely manner. We ordered a large pie and it was SO good. The only constructive criticism is it was a smidge greasy/drippy but still honestly just so so good! HEADS UP There are three doors. The door on the left is a quick counter with one table inside and a few tables outside, middle is a residential door, the right goes into a dining room! read more

See all

Garlic crust good. Garlic tomato sauce good. Pizza good. vibes good. Shoutout to the owner Mr. Chris Hubbard. He's a great guy. A proper pizza man. I WILL COME BACK!...probably tomorrow. read more

Hubie's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Cheese pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Middleburgh, New York

The food is always good and the restaurant always clean. While the service isn't always timely it is friendly. It just gives you more time to chat with friends. It is definitely the perfect small town gathering place. "Where everybody knows your name." If you're in Middleburgh I highly recommend Hubie's for a good meal! read more

Hubie is a hit or miss , some days the food is really good and there are days that the food is under cooked and no Flavor, service could be better, read more

I love this place but... if you're going to have hours posted. Then be open. It's frustrating to show up wanting to dine in and enjoy the great food and the site says it's open and you get there and it's closed. read more

Took over an hour to get our food. Not worth the wait. Waitress was nice but did not refill waters or return to check on table.

Really good food and alcohol selection. Knowledgable staff and very friendly. Great scenic drive to get there from all directions. I do recommend on Friday's and weekends making reservations or arriving close to open, to avoid a wait. read more

On our way to Cooperstown, the family got hungry and we stumbled onto this great town of Middleburgh. Hubie's happened to be the first place that could seat us and how lucky we were that we wandered in. I had a great seafood marinara dish with perfectly cooked linguine. The seafood helping was generous. Scallops were tender, but not chewy. Mussels were on the smaller side, but all clean and cooked open. The family had stromboli, eggplant parmigiana, ravioli, and a grilled chicken sandwich with fries. Everyone was happy with their dish. For dessert, the chocolate lava cake with vanilla ice cream and a super helping of whipped cream was a hit. Nicolle provided excellent service, even though it was close to closing time. Remember to tip well. read more

Since moving to upstate New York from New Jersey, I've been on the lookout for good pizza and I'm thankful to have found Hubie's. They've been on the mark every time and the pizza is worth the 20 minute drive! The pizza is thin, how I like it, and I have only been able to find thicker crust pizza in Cobleskill. It's not dry or too doughy- it's just right. I'm not too picky when it comes to my pizza but I rave about Hubie's to my friends. I'm definitely looking forward to my next trip and can't wait to try other menu items. read more

Hubie's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Middleburgh, New York

The pizza was everything you would want a pizza to be! It was cheesy hot and delicious! The peanut butter pie was out of this world and our server was super. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for some amazing pizza in Middleburg. read more

Great food!! Gotta try the Mussles Marinara.Awesome! Specials are usually good. Service is excellent especially if you get Courtney. Nicest waitress around! read more

Came here twice on our stay in town. Once was for pizza during their Friday night street fair. Had to wait over an hour for an average pie. The second night we came back for dinner (only option in town with outdoor dining) and got a sit down meal. We ordered two pasta dishes that were good. It's a bit pricy for what it is but lovely people and a nice local vibe. read more

Hubie's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Middleburgh, New York

See all

I had a large pizza and 2 orders of wings. The pizza was okay. Nothing great nothing bad. The wings were way over cooked. Dry. We threw half of them out. The service was fine. It's a pizzeria I didn't go into the restaurant side. read more

Everything we've ever tried from Hubie's Restaurant has been Amazing! Delicious food & waitstaff are always welcoming & friendly:) read more

Stopped in Saturday night for dinner and so glad we did! We were seated immediately by a very friendly server. We ordered mozzarella sticks, garlic knots chicken parm and mussels with linguine alfredo (which they custom made for my boyfriend). The food was absolutely amazing. The portions were huge and everything was fresh and hot. We would definitely recommended Hubie's and we'll be back for sure! read more

Ok, so most anyone I ever met who grew up in NYC (or Naples for that matter) and loves pizza, can't help being particular about how this food group should crunch, look, smell and eat. I'm not a style maven for pizza, but I know how I prefer it. Mine should start with good dough stretched into a thin crust, baked crispy, dressed with a fine lacquer of freshly made, well seasoned tomato sauce, restrained use of good quality mozzarella - so that when baked it doesn't separate and leave an oil slick on the pie, with some dried oregano and pecorino baked in. No extra doodads on the pie please. And I don't need a brick or coal or wood burning oven to make me feel artisanal or authentic -- a standard 600 degree pizza oven does the trick just fine so long as the baker knows the oven and their craft. Hubies does not do pizza my way, which is fine because our kids love it -- which is the principal reason for stopping to eat here while in town. It is more of what you would expect from a typical neighborhood pizza parlor in New Jersey. Thicker crust, a bit heavy on the sauce, cheese and oil -- makes the pie soggy -- but the flavors are honest. I like their calzones better -- chock full of cheese and whatever flavorings you like, and their burgers are righteous . But what I really enjoy at Hubies is their buffalo wings - something that was invented in central NYS. They are Killer! It is an added plus that we get in and out of here with a stick-to-your-ribs meal for four for $50 bucks -- so it is a bargain all day long too. The Middleburgh scene is pleasant; the ambience is hickster-ish and the owners/servers always wear that genuine, upstate warmness on their sleeve. Sitting on the sidewalk on a nice day with our doggie while getting all into the hot sauce and the wings and the blue cheese and a cold one . . . mmmm good. read more

Inconsistent. The prices are not cheap for non pizza items. Actually, i do not know if pizza is cheap or not. I had a great dinner, followed by a disappointment dinner. Consistency at this price would be good. read more

A very nice young couple own this building and from what I heard they have other buildings in town, their prices are very good and they're always crowded which tells you the food must be great too. They keep the outside of their store in the spring and summer beautifully done with flowers very artistic. I personally don't like to eat in places that I know have been flooded out numerous times, you can clean and clean but it never goes away. They have lots of friends who support them and they do have a thriving business going. Not many tables inside, but designed nice. If you're in the area give them a try at least get a pizza a lot cheaper than across the street and better. read more

Food's always great and fresh. There pizza and wings are delicious! Staff are friendly answer questions correctly.

I love Hubie's, both as a pizza joint (make sure to get the garlic knots) and as a place for a casual, quiet dinner. Small town feel, really great wait staff. Highly recommend you stop in for a meal! Especially in the summer, where you can sit outside, grab a pie and sip on a beer. read more

The pizza here has gone through transformation but has gotten much better than anywhere in the county. Looking forward to ordering again.

This place is very good. But it's not open everyday. All homemade! Before you come call please! read more

See all

All around good Italian food. Well kept establishment. Hubby and I always split the hot wings. Which are HOT but so good. They make their own blue cheese. Pizzas are good. All and all a really solid place. read more

Myself and my friends were heading back to Albany after playing golf at Hanah Mountain resort. We were hungry and decided we would stop in Middleburgh. We decided on Hubie's and we were all glad we did. We did not have reservations on a Friday but we were seated promptly. Dining room is nice and pleasant. We got meatball subs, burger and salad and chicken sandwich. We did not get pizza even though pizza is one of their specialties. They have lots of good beer choices which for 4 golfers is a must lol. Our waitress, Nicolle (with 2 L's) was great. She was attentive and friendly with a great personality. So if you are the area and looking for a nice place to eat, stop at Hubie's. You'll get good food, cold beer and a fun time. read more

This Pizzeria is a stellar. Hands down. If you are looking for a good pizza freshly made with N number of toppings this place is a must try as well they are pretty are quick. read more

I love Hubies; WE love Hubies! It's a Friday night staple for our family! Have only one suggestion, change menu a bit sometimes. Would love a chicken franchese!!!! read more

One of my favorite pizza places around. Consistent which isn't always the case elsewhere. Love the garlicky crust!

Best place in town. Huge portions of great Italian food. Good pizza. Service always great. We go anytime we are on the area from downstate. Kid friendly. Seafood pasta great and salads great too. read more

We love ,love Hubie's .We have been coming here since 2009 ,when we moved to Upstate New York. My husband served in the US Navy and we have lived in several states. The atmosphere is amazing, the staff wonderful .When Hurricane Irene had hit MIddleburgh I thought for sure Hubie's would be gone for sure like many of the small business there but no they reopened quickly and made sure everybody had food. My husband and I just went there last night to celebrate our Wedding Annisverary .We have bought our whole family and will always go there. read more

I've been coming here since I was a child and they don't disappoint. Although I typically stick to my favorite dishes, when I do venture out of my comfort zone I love everything I order. read more

My favorite pizza. I love garlic and they put garlic in their crust. Yum. My favorite is cheese pie with bacon. You need to try it if you like bacon. read more

Getting a chance to eat at Hubie's is the bomb diggity. Anytime I get a chance to visit my grandmother I make a special visit every day I am there to put the smack down on Hubie's pizza. Nothing is better to me than NY pizza and this is the creme de la creme of what NY is all about. You have my business for life! read more

I'll tell you a little story about Hubie's. The first time I came in here with my folks the fellow working the counter was on the phone taking an order for a pizza delivery. He had to ask his manager if they delivered to Ballston Spa...BALLSTON SPA? we wondered, that's like an hour away from here! Well, after trying the pizza at Hubie's it's no wonder people just can't do with their local joint. The pizza at Hubie's is absolutely exceptional. We recently ordered four different pies for a get together and each one was quite nice in its own way. The BBQ Chicken pizza was absolutely magnificent, the pepperoni and Buffalo chicken were also delightful, while the veggie white pizza was just OK. Hubie's is the go to place for pizza in the area, and by "area" I mean most of upstate New York! I've also eaten in once and they have a pretty full Italian style menu and the waitstaff was friendly and efficient. The only problem is their rather European style hours of operation, or shall I say "non-operation," which can include long hiatuses especially around holiday periods. read more

I don't want to give you a 5 star review, but I have to. I grew up in Middleburgh and have eaten lots and lots of your pizza. I rarely go back to Middleburgh these days, but each time I do I am blown away by how great your pie is. Maybe it's the water - that fresh Schoharie Creek water must be the secret ingredient that makes your pizza so delicious. read more

Most of the reviews about the pizza being great are from people who have never had real NYC pizza (seriously, what does California know about pizza?!), and those that have had real NYC pizza don't like Hubie's pizza. It's not stellar. It's pizza in Middleburg, NY. There's too much garlic and the sauce is a little too sweet and thick. That said, it's the best pizza you'll find in Schoharie County, and probably Greene too. Comparing it to NYC pizza just isn't fair. My daughter is 5 and gets the pizza there every time. I try to get other things. Love, love, love the homemade salad dressings, particularly the blue cheese. Best paired with the wings, which are the best wings I've had in my 40 years of existence. I get them probably twice a week and have not once been disappointed. Sometimes the pasta dishes are a little dry, but the burgers and sandwiches are always spot on. Husband said the prime rib special was gross. We don't eat seafood either so no comment on that. All in all, a great place to go, family friendly, clean, and totally worth the $50-ish dollar meal. read more

Fabulous food, good service and a nice atmosphere! Service is always great! Always a busy little place but it doesn't not impact the service or quality of food.. read more

I walked in and was immediately blown away by the decor and atmosphere of this place. Walking through the dining room, I noticed how small the booths are. The men's restroom was the smallest restroom I had ever encountered. It was about 4 feet by 2.5 feet. The pizzas are decently priced, but the white pizza I ordered; meh. The broccoli was hardly cooked, it was crunchy as hell, and the crust had a strange flavor to it. But I have to say, the wait staff was very friendly. Play decent music too. read more

Good food but extremely long wait. Would not recommend if you have children. We waited 40 min to get the food. Then we waited another 15 to get the bill after we asked for it (twice). read more

Hubies has awesome pizza for a small town, they put garlic on the crust and it makes it crave able, just ordered some more! They got great wings too read more

The food in the restaurant is acceptable, but the pizza is undoubtedly thee worst i've ever eaten because of the sauce, it is not pizza sauce, it tastes like cheap canned spaghetti sauce, we tossed the pie out. read more