It was my first time placing an order at this restaurant, I got a pork roll, egg and cheese on a bagel. I got 2 slices of pork roll so thin I could practically see through the meat and the bagel was not very good, more like a grocery store bagel. With coffee it costs me about $12 dollars. I will never return. read more

Good Experience here for breakfast. Tasty and efficient service. We were visiting a steel plant and this was close by. I had a fruit parfait and an Asiago bagel. Nice and clean too. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Interior 4/23/24 - Bagels Near Me - Sayreville, New Jersey

See all

Second and last time at this location. The second time again leaving with no food. After having my food made and I go to pay, I'm told "our system is down we can't accept gift cards" I said,"what am I supposed to do?" They tell me pay with card or cash. Thieves, sounds suspect both times months apart their "systems are down." Best believe I will be contacting corporate ! read more

I was in the area so I decided to grab some breakfast. Service was quick and friendly. I enjoyed my food. Coffee was decent. I would return if I'm in the area. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Sayreville, New Jersey

See all

I got the most simplest thing in the world, a bagel with cream cheese. There is no way that you can really mess up a bagel with cream cheese right ? Wrong ! I opened it up and there was nothing there. $5 on just bread ? That's ridiculous. The picture is absolutely self explanatory. The bagel is thin , yes I liked it scooped out but there's no excuse for a bagel with cream cheese to look like this. There's maybe a teaspoon of cream cheese. There's no excuse for a bagel and cream cheese to look like this especially for $5. I will not be coming here again. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Sayreville, New Jersey

See all

Here almost every week for my regular bagel and cream cheese and can never complain. Great service great atmosphere and always a friendly staff. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Sayreville, New Jersey

Not sure what happened to this place. It used to be very good at one point but it seems that as the franchise expanded, they got greedier just like every other fast food corporation. I haven't complained publicly before but this is the third time in a row where I've received terrible quality of food. Our bagels literally had no cream cheese in it and they forgot my hashbrown. Who wants to pay $5+ for basically just a bagel? Prices are ridiculously high and I feel like they keep increasing them every few months too. You'll see other reviews talking about the same thing, but it seems that they don't care anyway. Avoid this location and/or franchise and get your bagels from a local shop instead. I won't be going back. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Sayreville, New Jersey

See all

Breakfast here is usually good.... No complaints... Good location as well... Usually just order breakfast read more

Definitely one of the best bagel stores in town. Great people and great service. I go there everyday to pick up breakfast and everyone is very nice and their food is of great quality! read more

Got the farmhouse sandwich $10 for this pathetic sandwich. Save your money and go down the road. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Sayreville, New Jersey

I've been going here for years. The food is amazing - the bagels are simply the best and the quality has never changed. Sometimes they get really busy and it is a chaotic, but this is a true gem in sayreville and always love this place! My favorites are the bagels with cream cheese and the veggie wrap! read more

Ordered the food online ...confirmation says will be ready between 8:49-9:02 I get there at 9:08 and food is not ready. I'm guy tells me 3 more min. I see the owner scrambling to throw my food together , with no care or regards. Ordered the breakfast burrito the hasbrowns are undercooked and it's missing the sauce that goes in it. Never coming back . read more

First and last time here. I ordered a coffee and egg sandwich. I paid and sat down and waited for my sandwich. As I am preparing myself to leave a gentleman with glasses is yelling behind the counter M'am, M'am did you pay me??? Yes sir, I paid that gentleman at the register. You just lost a customer sir! Please ask your employee at the register before yelling across the store. It's rude and insulting. read more

Worst bagel place in the area! Hardly any meat on breakfast sandwiches like 1 piece of bacon cut in half so it looks like 2 pieces and 1 paper thin slice of Taylor ham.Also door dash and Uber eats hide the negative reviews out of 1700 reviews on DoorDash for some reason you can only view 4!!! Huge red flag read more

Hate giving bad reviews but money is tight for people these days so I will post. Ordered a pork roll and cheese sandwich and there was literally 3 of the thinly sliced pork roll that I ever seen. (Like deli ham thin). That is ok if you put enough on but in this case it was only 3 slices so the sandwich was mostly the bagel itself. I will note that I do frequent the Edison location and it's fantastic and doesn't even compare to this one so I was really surprised that this one was as bad as it was. read more

Stopped in for a quick lunch before an appt. Super quick service, polite, clean and easy stop in. The poppy seed bagel was really good.

the food at this place never disappoints, the service is excellent, staff is super nice and the ambiance is comfortable. highly recommend

The service was very quick today, but then again there were no customers besides me. Lol I ordered a breakfast sandwich. Sausage, egg and cheese on a plain roll. I must say, wasn't bad at all. For a sandwich and a box of tropicana OJ, 7 bucks. Not bad I think. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Sausage, egg and cheese on a plain roll - Bagels Near Me - Sayreville, New Jersey

I am appalled at the breakfast that was delivered to my house today. I ordered a Taylor ham egg and cheese sandwich. There was two half slices of Taylor ham that were so thin you could see through. You couldn't even taste the Taylor ham. It was awful. I threw it out. The second sandwich was steak and eggs which tasted more like eggs and cardboard. It you want to throw your money out the window. Please go here. Nasty. I will never be back. read more

If I can give them less than one star I would. I ordered a simple muffin and egg and cheese on a bagel and didn't check it until I got to work which was about 20 minutes away. When I checked they had put bacon on my sandwich and that is against my religion and instead of giving me a poppy bagel like I had asked they gave me a sesame bagel. When I contacted the store I asked if they can just give me a refund for the sandwich and that the muffin was OK they said we cannot give you a refund. I asked what was the reason and they said we have never done it before and it is against Covid. I was very confused because I told the manager that I paid with card so what did Covid have to do with this? They offered me another sandwich but I told them I don't pass through this area often and that I won't be back only for a sandwich. Worst customer service experience ever, sadly I expected more from Manhattan Bagel. read more

Place is okay...just average. The bagels taste alright but they don't warm everything up... so I ordered a bagel with stuff on it (can't remember the name) and the cheese wasn't melted at all and it was barely warm even tho it was just made. Also got a lemonade but it was extremely sweet and looks like it has been sitting for a while, it didn't seem that sanitary to me either the way they store it...wish they were in bottles. Nonetheless, would only visit here again if I'm desperate for breakfast. read more

Was disappointed with the amount of peanut butter applied to my bagel for the price . Not sure I'll be back again .

Egg sandwich was cold. 'Fresh squeezed' OJ was just Tropicana poured into a cup. $5 for a small cup of Tropicana sold as fresh squeezed.

Bagels are always good. Service is quick. But I'm not sure if the staff knows the difference between ham and pork roll ! Third time I brought a sandwich home and it was ham !! C'mon guys you are in Sayreville wake up and know the difference !! read more

Owner with dark hair and glasses with acent not nice to delivery help.expectd them to donit his way and not the delivery company way. He has is so money hungry greed that he has delivery going to other counties read more

If I can only give this Manhattan Bagel no stars then I'd definitely would. My wife stopped by for a pork roll, egg and cheese sandwich and politely asked the order taker to put some freshly cooked egg on it. As you know, from a customer's standpoint in front of the register you'll be able to see what's going on on the grill and the kitchen. There were cold, pre-cooked eggs on top of foils on the counter that's been sitting for God knows how long. Who would want that crap in your sandwich? Mind you, it was the owner who's doing the grill so he was definitely the one who prepped those eggs. The one who took my wifes order insisted that the egg that they put in her sandwich is fresh. So my wife again politely asked if they can just make her a new one. All of a sudden crew members of this establishment ganged up on her and saying nasty stuff about her being a food snob, that she was bullying them and asking her "What do you want to do now with this sandwich, waste it??!!" Who the heck are you to ask your customer some nasty question like that??!! Another older woman employee went out from behind the counter and almost shoved my wife who was waiting for her order on the side of the counter and gave her a nasty look. Now I understand why the rating of this establishment is so low. All the crew members here should get a re-training for proper customer service. They are very RUDE, DISRESPECTFUL and NO MANNERS!!!! My wife was just trying to get a sandwich coz she just got out from the hospital coz she stayed overnight taking care of her seriously ill dad and this is what she'll get?? All you workers in that place should be more sensitive and giving to the needs of your customers and you MR. OWNER, instead of supporting and taking the side of your VERY DISRESPECTFUL workers should have just apologized and took control of the situation rather than letting your staff throw their nasty attitude to my wife. By the way, I myself ordered a sandwich there before and when I took my first bite a very long light brown hair got stuck between my teeth. NJ health department, you should do something about this place. You be the judge. read more

The place is very clean but the girls behind the counter are not nice.dont listen to what you want sandwich is wrong not worth the money .the bacon looks like heat and serve. Just not worth the money. read more

I am only giving 1 star because I can not give 0 stars. I ordered food on doordash for pickup on my way into work. When i went in I told them my name and they didn't believe me. They then asked where I ordered from and they still didn't believe me. They told me I need to go get my phone so they can confirm... I guess they think a black woman wouldn't dare be named Kalynn and that maybe I look like the sandwich stealing type. This is the second time I went there. The firs time I went there I thought the energy was off and food wasn't that great... but this time it was all confirmed. NEVER AGAIN! read more

Ok the regular staff workers are great Recently they have hired teenagers that appear to be family members who aren't writing down the correct orders, can't spell or don't know the difference between a salt and sesame bagel On weekends they are getting the orders wrong 50% of the time. Don't leave there unless you check your order especially when they don't repeat the order back to you when they go to ring you up. That is usually a sign there is something wrong Also there is one middle age lady who works there that wears her protective gloves all the time - this would be great if she didn't keep them on while cleaning the windows, putting her hands on the doorstop to close the door and then use the same gloves to make buttered and cream cheese bagels Health department needs to know about this read more

Stopped in this morning around 630 am for the first time for a quick breakfast. The place is adorable and was very clean and neat. I was in a rush and thankfully there was no one else there. I was taken care of nicely and quickly. The prices are comparable to your local DD but with much better FRESH coffee and bagels. Will be stopping in from time to time to try out other things on the menu. read more

They are real stingy with lox and cream cheese. Leaves lots to be desired. Disappointed.

Terrible service. Messed up my uber eats order. Didn't give me the food I was charged for and when I called to speak to the manager all he could say was " I don't know what to say". Complete joke and a bunch of crooks! read more

I go here all the the time when they're nothing special to begin with. They put one piece of bacon on my bagel and messed up the order. The bacon looks like precooked cheap bacon. The lady on the grill was rude. This place is not worth the time or money. Never going back read more

Usually this place makes decent breakfast sandwiches. Today they screwed up my fiancé's order. When she took it back to get it corrected, the person making the sandwich gave her a huge attitude and made a scene. Seems like in the morning When they get a big rush, the cook gets overwhelmed and can't produce quality food. Not going back. read more

I'm not sure why the reviews here are so negative. The service is quick and friendly, especially the one girl who seems to be there everyday ... she is very nice, efficient, and hardworking. The food isn't incredible but it's not bad, and it's certainly good enough quality for what you pay... you get a nicely sized sandwich for $5 ... go to Starbucks and you get a tiny sandwich for the same price. I'll definitely go back! read more

This is the worst manhattan bagel establishment I have ever been to! Employees seem to be unsupervised. The restaurant is always dirty and the service is slow. read more

Never heard of a bagel shop that charges for toasting the bagels - but this does. Server didn't have good reason why they charge - rude / discriminating. read more

I am a regular at this location, and yes they may get an order wrong once in a while, but they are only human. They always apologize and try to compensate me with bagels. I am glad they came back after the fire they had. The staff is very friendly and the place is always clean. I will continue to give them my business. read more

They have on of the best bagels I have ever eaten, very fresh and every bite is tasty. Would recommend to a friend.