Local Historic dimly lit spot with wood slabs used as decor on the walls that miners would sign and…read morepin to the walls once they returned from their mining work. They have live music pianist who is very enjoyable to watch. Staff is helpful and knowledgeable about the restaurant history and menu. We ordered the Elk Special, Caesar salad and tequila sours. Food is good but the experience made it even more special.

We had the trout - delicious and cooked just right. Bread, baked potato, and veggies topped it…read moreoff. We also had a piano player who did a great job. Service was the best!!

We had an absolutely wonderful dinner at New Sheridan Chop House on our last night in Telluride,…read moreand it ended up being the best meal we had during our entire trip. We started with the steamed mussels served in a heavenly coconut broth, along with the shrimp cocktail and squash blossoms. Every appetizer was outstanding, fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. The coconut broth with the mussels was especially memorable. It was so delicious that we wanted to savor every last drop. It was one of those meals where everything we ordered just kept getting better. For our entrées, I had the Skuna Bay Salmon and my boyfriend had the Colorado Rack of Lamb, and both were absolutely delicious. Everything was cooked beautifully and full of flavor. We genuinely enjoyed every bite. I had mentioned in the reservation that we were celebrating my boyfriend's birthday, and the restaurant went above and beyond by complimenting a flourless chocolate cake for his birthday. It was such a thoughtful gesture and the perfect way to end an already fantastic meal. And then there was our server, Marissa. She was absolutely lovely, warm, attentive, and genuinely wonderful throughout the entire evening. Our water glasses were never empty, and she even scraped the crumbs from our table. Those little details may seem insignificant, but they make such a difference when you're enjoying a special dinner. Marissa provided exactly the kind of thoughtful, polished service you hope for when dining at a nice restaurant. Our table was also lovely. We were seated with a view overlooking Colorado Avenue. It was late and quiet by the time we had dinner, but it was still a nice view and added to the charm of the evening. From the food and service to the thoughtful birthday gesture and our pleasant table location, everything about our evening at New Sheridan Chop House was exceptional. Without question, this was the best meal we had in Telluride. If you're visiting Telluride and looking for a restaurant that delivers delicious food and genuinely attentive hospitality, I highly recommend New Sheridan Chop House. We would absolutely return!

YES! The history, the food and the service. Short ribs appetizer for dinner tasty. Bison steak was…read morefantastic. Great wine list, perfect service. The bar... there is history in this bar of over 100 years. Pool tables in the back, great drinks, Guinness on tap.

Italian restaurant has a great location, especially with its outdoor dining area that's half…read morecovered and equipped with heaters. It's also right next to the lawn where outdoor concerts are held, which adds a nice atmosphere. There's also a ton of staff, they're always nearby for everything and anything you need. I did think it was a little odd that drinks were served in red solo cups, which took away from the overall dining vibe. We started with the burrata - it was decent, nothing particularly memorable. Wasn't the best, wasn't the worst. For my entrée, I ordered the mushroom pasta. It was okay, but I personally would have liked more depth of mushroom flavor. For dessert, we tried the tiramisu, which was tasty but extremely pricey for the portion size. While I enjoyed parts of the meal, the value wasn't quite there for me. I may come back in the future, but I'm not rushing back anytime soon.

We gave La Piazza two tries in the same week. The food was…read moreas close to microwave pasta and nothing seemed fresh. Service was friendly but hit or miss. The ambiance inside seemed choppy. The ambiance outside on the plaza is stunning. Prices seemed high for what you get even for Telluride. Many better options in the Village and in Town. It's a "pass" for us in the future.

Best burger I've ever had. Service was great, sat in timely manner. The view from the top deck was…read morebeautiful.

My friend and I were visiting Ouray and we were hungry after a long day of activities and we made…read moreit just before closing. Everyone there was super nice and they let us order takeout and sit at the bar to have a drink while our pizza was being made. The place felt welcoming and chill. Everyone was just so great. The wonderful lady that took our order made a delicious espresso martini. The pizza was good, although I'm sure it's so much better eating right out of the oven. Thank you for taking care of us!

Diverse menu selections, exceptionally good service. Nice atmosphere & very accommodating. (Ask for…read moreAmy Jo!)

The new remodel is lovely. The food was very good. On a Sunday mid afternoon with no one else in…read morethe restaurant, the service couldn't have been any slower.

10/10 the experience is so very worth it. The chef will not lead you wrong. I've been to many…read moreMichelin star restaurants, they're on track if the review heads this way. Until the. This is a rarely exciting experience in town and I highly suggest it

A warning! We were taken in by all the five star reviews and found this restaurant not to live up…read moreto any of them. Either the reviews have been gamed or this restaurant has fallen off a cliff in the past couple of weeks. We had very high expectations and on OpenTable it showed two seatings . We chose the earlier seating because we understand that a tasting meal is spread out over a long period of time. It turns out the early seating must be something new for them and we seated on a patio all by ourselves. In retrospect, I should've spent more time on their website. The website only list the later seating which is why I am sure they are trying something new with the 5:30 PM seating. As I said, we were seated on a patio that was not particularly well kept. I had a view of a ladder and an exhaust fan. The rest of the furniture was pretty haphazardly arranged. Some of the plants were almost dead, and there was a lot of plant debris in the corners. This is something a good sweeping would've taken care of. The first three courses came out extremely quickly and it became obvious that they wanted us out by 7 PM. The 7 PM seating starts with a glass of wine on the patio and then the diners are invited inside for their meal. So as we were completing our meal guests had started to wander out on the patio to have their cocktail. The whole thing was really uncomfortable. The service and the wine pairing were good if not, a little rushed. The wine pairing was extremely well priced and he really knew his wine. It was a high point. At a restaurant at this price point one would expect fine stemware changing with each type of wine, but that was not the case here. The stemware was thick, stemmed and heavy, the type you would expect at a casual dining restaurant like Applebee's. We have dined at Michelin star restaurants and I know many reviews compare this restaurant with other Michelin star restaurants. I find this a bit unbelievable. The food had a couple of moments of brilliance, but the rest was simply average. We feel for the price, there are much better choices Telluride.

First time here, restaurant is located in the Hotel Telluride. Not a large space, we sat down…read morearound 6:00 pm on a Sunday. We were the only people here so that was not a good sign. Ordered the BBQ salmon with a balsamic drizzle and roasted vegetables. Carmella was or exceptional server. The food was delicious! Restaurant started to fill up. All good here.

Sat at the bar. Solid breakfast, easy to get in & out. Was a great sized service, literally all…read moreyou could eat. Got the breakfast burrito. Good solid value for the money.

We had a great experience! Fernando took care of us at the bar last Friday, and everything was…read moreexcellent. The pizza was delicious, the beers were ice cold, and the service was outstanding. He made us feel right at home from the moment we arrived. I highly recommend stopping by for a pizza and a cold beer. If you're lucky enough to have Fernando as your bartender, you're in for an even better experience. We'll definitely be back for another round of beers and to catch a World Cup match! Btw, I miss the breakfasts, they were delicious!

The manager is the worst person on the planet, every time we go there he is yelling and insulting…read moreemployees, in the off season the cool other guy takes over and it is delicious. That guy needs to move on, it is common knowledge he stinks and it leaks into the food. What an embarrassment. The ambiance is mop bucket at best.