Okay first time here. My husband has raved about their calzones (or "rollos") over the years. I tried the baked mostaccioli and it was just okay. Plenty of cheese but the flavor was just kind of meh. The meatballs were okay. The calzone is huge. It was also so greasy that it leaked on everything else. However, I was told that it is still just as good as it used to be. We saw a special for a free garlic bread and tried to use a $1 off coupon when calling it in. When picking up, we were told you can't use the coupon with the bread special. Not a big deal but maybe say that when we are placing our order. All in all, will try again but maybe just stick with pizzas or rollos. read more

See all

Great pizza! Sauce is definitely on the sweeter side, but will absolutely order again!

We used to live in the neighborhood and always loved Marco's Pizza on Lisbon Ave. We moved to Oconomowoc several years ago. We still drive to Marco's for the best tasting pizza. No one can match their sauce, cheese and high quality sausage. read more

The pizza was delicious hot and fresh and not a long wait 10/10 I will definitely be back

Great pizza , awesome taste, plenty of cheese, toppings and an authentic crust to satisfy anyone.

The pizza is always hot and fresh! Been coming here for years and haven't had a bad experience or dish yet! The service is great and quick. It's a nice little pizza pick up spot that's been around forever. Can't recommend enough! read more

Excellent food per usual and a great local spot that I've recommended many times. One of the only local pizza places close to my neighborhood that offers chicken as a topping. I'll definitely return soon. read more

We have never eaten here but we figured we would try it on a whim. BEST PIZZA EVER! I am picky when it comes to pizza and this is hands down the best pizza I have ever had! Delivery driver said you will be back over and over lol HE IS SPOT ON!! The pizza was loaded with cheese and toppings. The crust was just right!! I cant rave enough about it. You have gained a loyal customer! I will recommend your place to everyone I know. THANK YOU for making the best pizza!! read more

Worst service ever The manage was rude They got my order wrong and would not correct their mistake I have been a faithful costumer and a customer no more read more

A little pricey but overall pretty good pizza! Much better than most commercial chains.

Awful ordered pizza for delivery but it never came. Then had to fight to get my money back

Delicious pizza every single time we order for pickup. Pizza is prepared in a timely fashion. Highly recommend.

Last few visits in town I have tried new pizza places . Last night went back to Marcos. Haven't had this in a few years. OMG a Perfect Pie Every time. I have to believe I have eaten pizza from 100 or more establishments in Milwaukee and area around. Definitely still in my Top 3 read more

With a bold statement like "world famous" built into the name, you better believe I was hesitant. Having now tried the pizza, I could see why other reviewers have a love/hate relationship with this pie. For starters, this is definitely a sweeter pizza sauce. Personally, I loved it but not everyone does and a sweeter sauce definitely changes the flavor profile. I went ahead and ordered a special with sausage, mushroom and onion. I definitely thought this toppings combo was delicious with a sweeter sauce, especially with the onion! Moving on, I saw they used canned mushrooms--personally, I prefer fresh but, overall, I like mushrooms on my pizza either way. Plus, this is more of an old-school joint than anything. The sausage was really good--really flavorful and not too greasy. Next, it's definitely a hand-tossed pizza which isn't my personal favorite go-to (I prefer a nice thin or cracker crust). Here, I can understand the appeal of a hand-tossed pizza with a recipe that's been used year after year. I think, for me, where the dough doesn't exactly rise (hehe) is that the dough, especially in the middle, was just way too soggy for me. Heck, the middle slices were falling apart when trying to dish it onto a plate. This pizza has even better potential if kept in the oven just a bit longer. Next time, I'll ask for mine to be "well done" and see what happens. Would I try it again? For sure. Do I think it's world famous? I'll leave that part up to you. ;) read more

Been here twice now, both times the time for pickup I have been given have been accurate and the food was ready when I arrived once both times with in 25 minutes, the second time I was a bit late, but food was still hot. The pizza is amazing and so far quality hasn't wavered. It's classic local pizza place style hand tosses, tastes amazing. The wings were also great. Overall it's a bit pricey but most definitely worth the price. read more

Leaving marcos a second review as my first one was a few years ago. Got a rolo last night and it was spectacular, I have been ordering food from here for 20 years and this was the best rolo I ever had! One thing to always remember if they make a mistake or the food is not perfect please voice your complaints with them because if they don't know things are not perfect they can't fix them!!! Don't go complain in the next door app that will get you nowhere!! read more

See all

Was referred to come here by a friend. I was in town from California and was told this is one of the best pizzas my friend has had. Take out or delivery only, so don't expect a sit down pizza joint. I ordered a very basic pepperoni pizza. Absolutely delicious. Pizza sauce has a sweet taste to it. Will return again if I'm ever in Milwaukee. read more

Ordered a medium pizza and garlic bread. Was told 35 minutes . Arrived early to pick up and was ready. Got home and dug right in. Good food indeed. Has a slight taste of butter in the crust. read more

See all

Their food is sooooo good. I love Marco's pizza. There's just something about their sauce that's oddly unique. Very sweet and savory. I'm also a huge fan of their fried chicken. Why do I rate them two stars then? The staff. First of all - the guy who answers the phone can sometimes be very gruff and customer service is definitely not his forte. I'm willing to forgive that. I don't need an ***-kissing everytime I order pizza. But I was shocked to see NO ONE in the entire restaurant was wearing masks. YUCK! You breathing all your COVID all over my pizza, brah? GTFOH. I had to change my five star review to a two star review because I was horrified. I will not be returning at least until COVID is over. read more

Great pizza; very generous with toppings and personally I love the taste of their sauce. The rude demeanor described in the other reviews is as consistent as the quality of their ALWAYS great pie! Unlike the pizza, the rudeness gets old. But in the long run that only proves how good the pizza is because after 20 years, I'm still going back. read more

Really wish I could give these guys 5 stars but they don't know how to cut a pizza! Best in Milwaukee in my opinion but every single time I have to go over their sad attempt at cutting a pizza smh. read more

Our go to pizza pick up place. No frills but it's just good. Sauce is a little sweet, lots of cheese and the right amount of crust. Extra bonus that they have all the details of you last order associated with your phone number so before you start ordering they ask if you just want the same thing again (which we always do). read more

Since yelp likes the reviews lengthy, he ya go. [In case you don't wanna read the WHOLE REVIEW... BOTTOM LINE, IDK if I'M the only one to get such great quality, quantity, bang for my buck, ..AND SOONER THAN EXPECTED, BUT I LOVE ME SOME MARCOS PIZZA N SANDWICHES/ DINNERS ETC.] Ready??? (Mind u, im mowwin down on my itallian beef as I'm reviewing.) So far its taken me 20 min to get THIS FAR. [Its sooo good] Im gonna base this review on todays experience (not over all-even tho over all id give em a 5 too, so whatevz ‍) but anywho i ordered an itallian beef sammich with fries. Hubby got chicken tender dinner. [They had no problem substituting my hubbys french fries for coleslaw] my husband has to watch his potassium intake so he rarely eats potatoes &other high potassium foods. He is on dialysis & in need of a Healthy kidney donor who is O+. [Just throwing that out there in case anyone reading this was interested. plz hmu] Where was i.. Yes from order to drop off they were 100% He said in about an hour. Delivery guy came sooner, & was nice (as always) Food was nice & hot. My container was even stapled shut so nothing spilled out. My sammich was niced size.. i cant even finish it all. But man. So good. my peppers were separate nice n not on my sammich. I had the perfect amnt of au jou. In a plastic container with foil on top (spill protector &warmer) I even got a a bag with napkins, ketchup, salt, & pepper & a fork. Hubby loves their tenders, but Hes not a yelper tho so whatevz to him too. J/k. But i see Yelp Salutes me now, kuz i wrote my pants off. #missionaccomplished read more

Marco's World Famous Pizza - Already ate 1/2 the fries. Lol - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Amazing pizza, the sauce to crust ratio is spectacular. I have a dairy sensitivity and they make my no cheese meat special all the time loaded with meat! I haven't even tried any other local places because this was so good the first time. It's my Lou Malnatti's of the north! read more

Great pizza, best in the area. Sauce is always fresh, tasty and just a bit sweet. Fast service. Not a lot of frills but great pizza and that's the important thing for a pizza joint! read more

One of my favorite pizza spots for pick up, Love the sauce and usually get mines well done.

Ordered from Marcos because everyone raves that this is the best pizza. This is definately taste bud and opinion based. I felt that the dough was too thick to my liking and the sauce was a bit on the sweet side. Im not sure that I will order again only because I prefer thin crust pizza but it wasnt bad if you prefer a pizza that has more of a crust to it. read more

Best pizza ever! EBA (everything but anchovies) with tomatoes is a must every time I go home! Wish we had a Marco's in California! Just had it Saturday and amazing as always! read more

Best pizza in Milwaukee, bar none. You want a calzone? Delicious. Wings? Great. I can't recommend this spot enough. TO THE OWNERS: Please get yourselves on Onebite.App so I can give you a 9.9 score. read more

Omg you have to get the cheeseburger pizza....SO good! The crusts are crispy and chewy just in the right amounts just in the right places. They are generous with toppings. The staff is friendly. They gave coupons for garlic bread but you gave to make sure that you mention the coupon when you call in your order read more

Best pizza in Milwaukee, especially if you like a lot of cheese and an overall sweeter sauce. Get the Mac & cheese bites on the side.

Our favorite pizza! We keep it simple, cheese, sausage, black olives, extra sauce. Magnificent! All aspects of their pizza is spot on for us, crust, sausage- the best I can think off, and great sauce. read more

Marco's pizza is thick, doughy, greasy, cheesy, and HEAVY. When you pick up a slice, it kind of just flops over under its own weight. It reminds me of the gooey pizza the Ninja Turtles enjoyed in the early 90s: pizza you can order in and just sit with all night in your sewer home and then still have a ton left over in the morning because it is so darn FILLING. At first I thought $15-$20 was a little steep for a large pizza, but the price was quickly justified when I went to pick it up and felt a good 10lbs of pizza in my hands. It's carryout and delivery only, so you'll have to call ahead. On the phone you'll be greeted by a gruff voice that wants to know your name, your order and nothing else. These guys are no-nonsense and they make good pizza. read more

Pizza is probably one of my favorites.. This place is amazing, SOMETIMES... I can say In my honest opinion, my wife and I used to order and pick Marcos up all the time... after about 200 times we realized that the pizza is always hit or miss... Sometimes way to much sauce. Sometimes not enough. Sometimes way to much cheese. Sometimes a perfect amount. Sometimes the crust was perfect and sometimes it was to thin.. even burnt here and there.. I tried ordering less easy sauce and there would be none on there.. Along with that I don't think the people answering phones there should ever be allowed to deal with a customer. Of course unless you like speaking to a holes while ordering your food and giving a business your $... Between the rude customer service and hit or miss pizzas. We go to balestreri's pizza now on 68th or bluemound. Very professional and the pizza is exactly the same every single time.. AMAZING!!! Order from here if you want a good pie, MAYBE? OR TO TALK TO SOMEONE RUDE. THAT IS A GAURANTEE!! read more

I like their food. However the guys who answer the phones are just so crabby sounding. They sound like your a bother to them by calling. But the food is always hot tasty and usually comes sooner than they say. So they're DEFINETLY tip worthy. And they are STILL my GO TO pizza DELIVERY place if i dont order thin crust from dominos. Now im not dissin them, i like their food. I just think the guys should lighten up. Its not enough to make me stop calling.. but its NOT NICE. read more

If I wanted to be treated like I don't matter by rude employees when I order pizza, I'd drive my @$$ to Chicago. You can find pizza as good as this or better around the MKE area where they at the very least pretend like they want your business - go there. I'm honestly shocked people still put up with these clowns. read more

I appreciate Marco's pizza as you can tell it's fresh and homemade, it's just not my type of pizza. They put a lot of sauce, which has a little zest to it, and the bottom of the crust has those little beads. Again, it's fresh and homemade just not my type of pie. read more

We had Marco's for the first time on Friday (delivered) and we were delighted with the food. My wife and daughter had the pizza wihich had loads of cheese with the regular hand-tossed crust. The crust was chewy but not underdone. The sauce is the highlight of the pizza,...sweet but very fresh tasting...truly authentic! I had the 1/2 lb. bacon cheeseburger with the fixings. It was juicy, not greasy, and came with an abundance of fries. We look forward to trying their other items, especially their fried chicken and Italian dishes. read more

Marco's Pizza reminds me of my childhood. It was the pizza my parents would indulge us in every now and again. When my brother and I got older, we ditched the pizza (whose crust was occasionally burned) and headed for their cheeseburger baskets. Oh, heaven. Those burgers are massive and completely delicious. Buried under your pile of fries would be a pickle, made hot from it's location. It's literally a hole in the wall. I'd be surprised if you could fit four customers in their waiting area. There's just a pickup window and the kitchen. It looks dirty and the staff was never super-friendly or efficient, but still....memoriiiies. :) read more

The pizza is always amazing as are the mozzarella sticks. Tried a sausage and pepperoni rollo this time and it definitely did not disappoint either. read more