My favorite local spot! Sad, that I moved to FL but my family and I love it so much that every time we visit town, we come here. My parents just got back from a trip to NY and brought about $40 worth of pizza back for my brother and I. Can you tell we love this pizza? TOP THREE 1. Grandma - then but crispy, sauce is flavorful and delicious 2. Sicilian - thick and tasty. fluffy dough, crunchy crust! ugh its a staple 3. Buffalo Chicken - spicy and sweet and creamy thanks to the sauce and hint of ricotta ENJOY! read more

Ordered an avocado salad with shrimp. Menu says 14.95 plus 2.95 for shrimp. Got my food and the shrimp was an extra 9$ because it's 2.95$ Per shrimp. Talk about bait and switch , only ordered it because I can't eat meat for lent. Let me say I've been coming here for years and as of today I will not be back. Ever . Enjoy my 9$ for your 4 shrimp because I won't be back. read more

Very disappointed in the quality of the food. I ordered the margarita brick oven pie along with a primavera brick oven personal pie. It tasted horrible and the pizza was very hard and dry. The quality of the pizzas seemed to be equivalent to a frozen or a little Caesar's pizza. Definitely not worth the $35.00 read more

I went to this place with my best friend and it was really nice environment, nice staff, clean and fast seating... The baked zitti is great with real mozzarella cheese and lots of sauce. The garlic bread is really good. read more

I figured it's about time I wrote a review for Marinara. I've been coming here since I was a little kid. With Marinara, what you see is what you get. I'm not going to just come out here and say it is the best food you will find, as that is not the case. However, Marinara is a neighborhood spot that serves good food. The atmosphere inside oozes of local families and friends. This is truly the place to go for a slice around the area. Every time I come here, I see someone I know. I enjoy the familiarity. The food is pretty good for a local Italian place. I usually get either a couple of slices, a pasta dish of some sort, or a sandwich. Is the food out of this world? No. But what it is, is pretty good and it's certainly good enough to keep me and so many others going back for more after all these years. read more

Definitely a local place, but can be a destination spot for their food! I'm a pasta girl, and theirs is always great! My favorite is fusilli pesto rosso, though I love their penne in brodino(?) sauce! Recently relatively renovated, the restaurant makeover adds nice touches, with a cappucino bar read more

I have been going here since before it was Marinara. Originally it was Willies Pizza and it was damn good back then. The owners bought out Willies and put in Marinara like 20 years ago or something and they have done a fabulous job! The pizza here is nothing short of amazing! I usually won't even eat a square slice but Marinara is the exception. I have been to all the top rated pizza places in the 5 boroughs and this is by far the best. I live in Jersey now but whenever i am on the Island visiting friends i make sure to grab a slice. read more

Marinara is a restaurant with a huge five town following. The food is very good and their pizza selection is vast. They also serve lunch salads for the afternoon crowd. Their parmigiano dishes are very good as well as their pasta dishes. They are always crowded with many regulars. read more

I am from lawn guyland and I have to recommend this place for Italian food that really hits home. Long Island is pretty irreplaceable when it comes to pizza and bagels and Marinara encapsulates that seamlessly. Their sicilian slices are like no other. They have a pretty great chicken marsala slice, which I haven't seen at any other pizza joint. Their buffalo chicken slice is excellent. THE BEST: get a chicken roll! So good. Flaky, pastry dough-like crust with perfect chicken and cheese inside. You will not be upset with it. read more

I was referred here by a co worker and I'm so glad I went! Best Penne Alla Vodka in town! Unfortunately, this place is so popular the wait to be seated on a weekend is lengthy but worth the wait! read more

Great pizza and pasta dishes!!! 10/10 would recommend. My personal favorite is the rigatoni montanera.

We come in here regularly for pizza and dinner. The pizza is delicious, they always have a wonderful variety of slices and other items available. The only item I'm not crazy for are their rolls ( chicken roll) they do it a bit different than I'm used to at other places and the dough is very thin - more like a wrap. I've had several dishes in the restaurant portion all quite tasty. I really enjoy their chicken Primavera when I opt for something on the lighter side. read more

Love coming here for take out. Usually get cheese calzone(huge portion) slices of Sicilian and buffalo chicken pizza. Most Guys in front are great, funny and courteous. Would give it 5 stars if prices were slightly lower and they delivered. read more

I will start this review with a yummmmmmmmmmyyyyy the food is so good in here the service was great I highly recommend the Rigatoni Florantino. They will definitely see me again. Love Love Love read more

Marinara - Rigatoni with chicken and mozzarella and spinach - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

They are a bunch of incompetent workers,cannot get a order correct,the only thing they get right is the pizza slices,once you can point to the slices they would get it right,placing an order is a whole different thing,these people cannot get a order right if their life depending on it,today I had to walk out with cold pizza because my order was WRONG and couldn't wait anymore.like the other post they do not change their gloves.very annoying to say the least. read more

The best buffalo chicken slice I have ever had! Great chicken parm, francese, antipasto salad, and marsala slice as well. If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and eat at Marinara. It's a very reasonably priced, casual Italian restaurant/pizza place. Enjoy! read more

The best chicken franchise I've ever had chicken parm was so good. It was a nice looking restaurant and I loved it

Been working in the area for a week solid so I took out from here a few times over the course of my time out there. (I had previously only grabbed a slice of pie on previous visits to the area). Strictly my take on the take out... da' pizza: solid, really good normal thin crust and really good Sicilian slices to go. The place is hopping busy most of the time but they motor to keep things moving. good cheese, slightly on the salty side (fine by me). I did not try any of the specialty pies (salad on top etc.) da entrees: I had a couple of chicken dishes, both had good portions and tasty. They keep the sides and the main dish separate (a plus for me, I hate having say a butter lemon sauce mixed in with marinara sauce etc). You get a decent portion of bread with the entree and it is quite tasty (good Italian bread, soft on the inside and slightly crunchy with a hint of the oven on the outside). The vegetables were not cooked to mush and everything was very good, especially for take out. The clams in the linguine dish I had were tiny but good, nothing great but not bad taste wise. da pasta: all the pasta was cooke al dente, so if you don't like that, then well you would be out of luck my friend. The side of penne was good with a slightly salty pomodoro sauce, pretty good size portion as well. The linguine I had with clams was the same, al dente, and the sauce had a nice bite as I asked for it fra diavolo (you know, spicy). This place stradles the line between walk up pizza joint and restaurant. You can grab a slice and sit in the standing room only type of area near the counter, take out, or sit down for a full blown meal in the dining area toward the back. Overall I was impressed by: -the speed of service considering the hectic nature at certain times -the attentiveness of the staff -the good quality on the full range of the menu -they almost always check the order vs the receipt when you are paying, this may seem trivial but think about the nice little extra effort just to make sure you don't get the wrong thing when you get home (especially if you ordered something a little odd/special) Definitely a safe place to check out if you are in the area. I doubt you will go wrong with anything here. read more

Can't decide if the food tastes good or if it tastes like it came from Olive Garden. Maybe it was just what I ordered (Fettuccine Alfredo). I would give this place another try with a different meal to see if it was just not one of their strong dishes. Otherwise good service but the table was way too small. read more

Its an awesome restaurant, nice ambience, the staff is very courteous. Food very tasty, for my fine dining and satisfy my taste buds, I will be there. whenever I can with family. read more

Oh My Goodness! The best cannolis ever! Pizza is amazing! As is their pastas. Everything is excellent!! With huge portions. read more

Marinara - New York pizza, awesome!! - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

See all

Absolutely delicious! I am a pasta and pizza lover and I never go home disappointed! Service is great, food is unbelievable and the location is great too! read more

Having moved to Long Island from the mid-west I needed to find my go-to NY pizza place. Marinara is it! Their sauce is slightly sweet and their crust is to die for! You will not be disappointed. read more

Came in here for lunch and to start with the front staff doesn't welcome you or say anything when you walk in. They almost expect you to know wtf is going on here. After asking what is on the menu I had no one respond out of the 8 people in the kitchen. I had to guess what everything was. I than tried to sit in a booth. No one is here keep in mind and the back is completely empty. I wanted to sit in a booth and was kicked out of the booth rudely after I had already ordered. Unbelievable to be honest. Most likely because I'm white, not from NY and don't speak the second language the staff speaks. I didn't even eat a bite out of my food and threw it away happily. I would highly recommend going else where as they don't want your business here and nothing is cooked to order. It's all premade from what seems to be the day before. read more

I've been a loyal customer for almost 10 years, but the last few times there has been a sharp drop in service. It frustrates me when a good place like this starts treating their customers as dispensable. All the meals and $ spent over the years and I guess it's time to move on to another place. read more

Food is always good. No complaints. Love their stratacella soup and their lasagna. Good prices and friendly staff

Got penne all a vodka with added shrimp, was the worst ever. Very dry , not creamy and rich . Would not recommend!!

The pizza is excellent no matter which type you choice. The menu is also very good. Good place to eat no matter if your dining in or taking out. read more

This is a review of their catering option. Catered a Christmas Holiday dinner for my family on 12-27-17. Decided on Italian food and ordered 4 half trays from Marinara. The gal who took my order was extremely efficient and had a deep knowledge of their menu offerings. She was also able to rent me the warm up trays and sterno. The food was ready for pick up right on time and included lots of garlic knots and 2 loaves of Italian bread. All 4 dishes (Chicken Marsala, Sausage & Peppers, Eggplant Rollatini & Penne al la Vodka) were delicious & there was more than enough food to feed the 17 people attending including numerous second helpings. Best part was that I was free to enjoy my guests and the food. Just add a few bottles of wine to this feast and you are good to go! read more

Coming here more and more lately. Good traditional pizza restaurant fare. Gets a bit crowded on weekends. Try asking for fresh garlic topping read more

Food is amazing. they make a great buffalo slice and the pasta we ordered was good too. But since this covid 19 thing they raised their prices. I understand that they need to make money but we are all hurting. not looking for a reduced price but at least keep it the same. I guess it is just the new norm read more

The atmosphere was very nice, and the service was perfect. Every time we come here, there is always a line out the door for taking out, so you know it's fresh food. We went to the sit down section, they gave us garlic bread, when we sat down which was so good, but we had to stop eating it because we wanted pizza. Then we had the house special pizza, which was pepperoni, meatball, black olives, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, extra cheese, and anchovies on the side. It was great and fresh. The only thing i would say is the vegetables needed some sait. Then we had the black & white moose which was ok, it could of used more chocolate. All and all it was an amazing place, love coming here XD!!! read more

See all

I think I've had everything on the menu. Never had a bad dish. Old school Italian and love it. My mom always brings me when I'm in town. Smells great and very clean. read more

I went here and got Caesar Salad (approx 10 dollars on the menu) I wasn't trying to spend too much. I decided to add shrimp to my salad. I got my salad and it was basically 4 overdone shrimp on a bed of iceberg lettuce. I got the bill and my salad costs 22 dollars. I could not believe it. 11 dollars to add 4 shrimp that weren't even good. So overpriced. read more

Mmmmmmmmmm. Good Italian food at a good price served by a great waitstaff. Many a time have I been here with friends. Many a time have I been here with family. In all cases, it's been fantastic. Their menu offers a lot of different pasta dishes--all kinds of pastas, sauces, and veggie/meat choices--individual pizzas, and other meat or eggplant entrees. Almost everything comes with a salad and even that's so yummy. The dessert is to die for and the wine is served in large wine glasses for an extra bit of a special kick. The only problem is parking--seriously watch out in that lot because you could lose a bumper. Also, you can call in an order but they don't deliver. So one way or another, someone has to drive there and cross their fingers. read more

Absolutely love this place. I used to live down the block from here and would go a few times a week. Their slices are top notch. Always fresh and they dont have that "it's been sitting around let's reheat it" look. Their Pesto Rosso is probably my favorite fish their however I can't complain about anything. Service is excellent, prices are decent, and atmosphere is nice as well. Wish I still lived closer because where I'm living now nothing really seems to compare. read more

so glad to have an awesome italian place so close to home! everything here is delicious & my go-to spot for pizza! read more

I have been underwhelmed with the sit down service. But the food is awesome. They make the best chicken roll, fresh perfectly cooked chicken and tasty sauce. Additionally the pizza is my favorite in the area. read more

I am a frequent customer of Marinara,only due to convience. The food is ok,nothing great. The counter service most of the time are confused and get my orders wrong. The waiters and waitresses are friendly. My biggest complaint is that this a glorified pizza joint, not a fancy prancy restaurant as there prices reflect. Do not go and expect a cheap fast dinner. Also do not expect to go and get service late,,,,,,9ish they are trying to clean up and close. I was born and raised in Brooklyn NY, pizza shops didnt close till 2am,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,or later. read more

Sometimes theres that one thing that just makes you think, I dont need to take this sh*t. This rude waitress just spoiled my previously great experience. I won't come back. read more