Mario's has always been a neighborhood staple, and their Tuesday pizza specials are still some of the best deals in town--great value and genuinely solid pies when they're on their game. If you're going for a quick mid‑week dinner, that's definitely the time to go. That said, the overall experience has slipped. Service has become noticeably lacking, with long waits, missed items, and a general sense that the front‑of‑house is stretched thin. The quality of the food has taken a hit, too--what used to be consistently good now feels hit‑or‑miss depending on the day. There's still potential here, especially with those unbeatable Tuesday specials, but Mario's isn't quite delivering the way it used to. A decent stop if you're nearby, but not the destination it once was. Cheers read more

Can't beat their Tuesday $5.99 cheese pizza deal. During the football season I'm here almost weekly. It's packed tight on Tuesday nights so be sure to call it in. Their crusty is tasty and crispy. I really love their sauce. My mouth is watering as I type! The crust FEELS like a NYC crust. You can fold it in half and chomp away. Nothing soggy or doughy g Here. We usually get the cheese pizzas with Parmesan instead of mozzarella because of the lactose intolerant ones in the house. Shhhhh I think it's even tastier that way! Even when we do get the regular cheese pizza, the cheese is pretty tasty. It's a super thick coating. And of course ... the suppi pizza is sooooooo good read more

i just had the worst grinder ever in my 66 years. We ordered food to be delivered. I ordered a large Turkey Grinder with Mayo, Cheese, Onions and lettuce, no tomatoes, no Oil, no Salt\Pepper not heated. it came heated, no Mayo, no Cheese and had Tomatoes. The roll was soggy from being heated. The slip that came with order was word for word how it was ordered. They still messed the order up. I will never order from this place again. read more

Food is always outstanding when Mario makes it. Best pizza in all of RI. I highly recommend

Pizza was good, especially with the Tuesday Special discount price, but they were in complete non-compliance with Covid Regulations. Both cooks were not wearing masks or gloves. Woman working counter didn't put mask on until she got to the register. Based on the pizza along it would be worth another visit, but complete ignorance of the executive order(s) under a pandemic is a big negative for me. read more

I moved here 10yrs ago and I asked where the best pizza was in town and 2 people told me Mario's. It was bad greasy pizza then and it still is. I ordered a Eggplant Grinder,mozzarella sticks and a salad. The grinder was soaked in oil, bland sauce Mozzerella sticks cd in the middle with bland sauce and The salad was lots of lettuce very few toppings. I tried the place 2 times 10 years apart and nothing changed except for they don't follow Covid protocols at all, and they aren't even trying to fake they are. read more

This is the second time I've tried to dine in at Mario's North and pizzeria. It's been sometime since I've tried Mario's food. I only have good things to say about food. Not so much that the dining room is not open. As I said previously I tried once before today. Everything around him is open going on. It's time for him to open up the dining room and get some of his regular customers back. read more

SMALL SLICES! Like 1/3 the size of a normal slice. Owner was not co-operative in resolving issue. We spent $29.00 and still had to prepare more food because there was not enough food for a meal. Meatballs filled with salt too BTW. Meh at best. read more

We love Mario's Pizza and look forward to Tuesday Night pizza night every week. The staff is so helpful and friendly. They go above and beyond! read more

My favorite pizza place. The dough is always really fresh and you can tell. Plus the fries and non-pizza options are great as well

All I've had from Mario's is the pizza & boneless chicken wings. They both are greasy but good. Not the best but good. The pizza is doughy with copious amounts of cheese & sauce. And grease. The offer a separate game room which can be rented out for private parties. The 2 times I have gone has been for parties & we even held one there. They have a teenager help out with food & another with the games. The machines are a bit dated but enough for a children's birthday party. Mario's isn't fancy & I haven't had much of their food but it's definitely worth checking our for a quick pie or even for a party if you're interested. read more

Mario's does have a pretty large menu with choices for just about any kind of appetite. Pizza, burgers, salads, soup, wraps, grinders, and honestly most stuff in between. The pizza is OK, usually way to greasy and you have to sop up the extra grease with napkins. The crust is good, crisp yet soft in the middle and has good flavor. My husband loves the Soupy pizza and so do his friends, I was not at all impressed. If their pepperoni is greasy imagine the Soupy...ugh! It's chunks of Soupy that resemble sausage, not the good thin sliced Soupy that we are all used to. As for anything else on the menu, save your time. Every time I've ever ordered takeout from them it's just not good. Grinders are a no go. I ordered an Italian, it was skimpy and seemed to me that the meat was rancid. My sister didn't think it was rancid but either way it was enough to put me off. The chicken cutlet is made with processed chicken patties, yuck. Their salads are over priced for a basic and unimpressive salad, though they are quite large, just nothing special. Just as their salads are over priced so is everything else, it's $9.50 for a 4 potato skins appetizer. Just about every other app on the menu is the same price; Poppers 6 of them for $9 and change. Their plain pizza isn't too bad in price but still not worth what it costs. They do deliver and that's a plus, your choices for delivery pizza in Westerly are limited. read more

First time dining at Mario's. I was expecting great food, since I had heard the steak and cheese grinder was good. We ordered the antipasto to start, here's what we got: chopped room-temperature iceberg lettuce in a bowl with two slices of tomato, four flavorless pepperoncinis, some cooked salami which tasted like bologna and definitely didn't look fresh, and a few slices of provolone cheese (which incidentally wasn't terrible). Did I mention that this was $10.50? For lunch, my friend ordered the chicken parmesan, hoping to try some authentic Italian marinara. What he received was two small, overcooked chicken cutlets that tasted like old french fry grease. It had a good portion of pasta on the side, but the sauce tasted like it was dumped right out of a can and heated up. I ordered the "Steak and cheese grinder," and the vapid but nice waitress asked if I wanted it toasted? I'm not sure what that means--(I come from the Philadelphia area, and am used to cheese-steaks)--but I said toasted. What came out was surprising, to say the least: a dry, burnt roll with what appeared to be ground sausage with a glob of tasteless cheese on top. Awful. What is most surprising to me was that even the garlic bread was bad. How can one possibly screw up garlic bread? It was absolutely tasteless, unless you account for the burnt flavor, and I am still not entirely sure how this was accomplished. This food is awful, and it is clear that the owners of this business do not care. This place is tucked away from the beaten path, and if it wasn't for the friendly waitress, I could confidently say that I will never darken the doorstep of Mario's again. Although, everyone deserves a second chance, no? To sum up: a salad, a burnt, greasy chicken cutlet, sub-par cheese-steak, diet coke and a water = $40.00? Awesome Mario's experience = Priceless. Do owners ever taste what they serve? read more

I stopped at Mario's to get two pizza slices to go. First big problem it cost me over eight dollars. I ordered it with mushrooms and onions, it came out with canned mushrooms and raw onions. It was horrible. Pizza slices seemed as though they were sitting around all day. If you like lousy overpriced pizza this is your place. Will never stop here again read more

Although I live part-time in Westerly, I haven't been to Mario's in several years. In fact, I think they even changed names 4-5 years ago, but who can remember that far back. We went to Mario's on a Saturday evening well after the dinner hour. The dining room hasn't changed much (2 stars - don't expect fine dining). But we were delighted with the food. I had a calzone totally unlike what I usually experience in the Boston area. And my companion had a very interesting dish - locally made sausage with potatoes in a red sauce. The portion size was huge. We split the calzone and took the sausage and potatoes home for another day. Not your typical bread and rolls before dinner, but a rolled out , saucer-sized piece of dough baked and topped with fennel seeds. It took a little time to get our dinner, nothing extraordinary, but they took their time to prepare it. And it showed. Can't wait to go back. Good family restaurant. read more

The worst shrimp scampi ever. The sauce if you want to call it that tastes like pasta water. No flavor what so ever. Very disappointed

Pizza for the kids! Great deals and delivery. Old school crust and lots of cheese. Great taste and value... Real pizza like when you were a kid before these no-sauce veggie or clam pies came out! read more

Best wings in town hands down. Pizza is good too, especially on Tuesdays when it's $5.99 large cheese pizza day.

Weird cheese mix blanketing the toppings. Reminded me of school lunch pizza. Each slice weighed a ton - too much sauce; too much cheese; not enough pepperoni ; green peppers were red and green and pickled; crust was too soft read more

Horrible service - unless you are a regular. We noticed we was there first, but got served last. There is no game room anymore, all the games are behind the bar, by the tables (bout 6 tables). Also about 5 people walked out because it was crowded. Waitress was rude. But made sure was nice at the end for the "tip." I would only recommend to do take out. Food is awesome and you don't have to deal with one waitress there. Oh and when you ask what happened to the game room, you (lol) will get ignored. No lie. I don't know why just thought it was funny. read more

Mario's always a great place to eat! Plenty of food, reasonable prices, the waitress always pleasant, and efficient! Recently it appears the place we loved has turned into a "chucky cheese atmosphere". Huge game units moved from the party room into the main dining area. The restaurant is cramped and over crowded with these oversized game units. Less tables for patrons, the feel is not warm or welcoming. We stopped in with friends Saturday, we entered and immediately walked out. Communication amongst friends has spread quickly; apparently others in all age groups agree this was a mistake. Younger parents feel the games distract from a family meal. At least before the games were in another room. Mario's thanks for the memories hopefully this was the right decision for you! read more

Outstanding pizza. Nachos are unbelievable as well. I have not tried anything else yet but what I have had so far has been just amazing! Fair prices, fast service, local delivery...can't ask for anything more. With so many pizza places in town, this is among the best. Definitely recommend this place. You won't be disappointed. read more

Website said $9.50 for burger fries and drink, total was $13.50 with unsalted frozen fries and no drink.

Was introduced to this place by my dad who grew up in the area in Westerly. By far the best pizza ive ever had and will always go back when visiting New England read more

I've been to all the pizza places in town and by far this one is the best! I love the pizza and they're always so nice when you go in. And the relatively quick for to-go orders. Even on the busier days. If I had to tell anyone the best pizza place to go I'd probably say here. read more

I have been going to Mario's for over 10 years and their food is always awesome! My particular favorite is the fish and chips. The batter is light and crispy, not thick like a lot of places. They also give you a HUGE portion, I usually order the kid's size and still can't finish it. Their calzones, pizza and grinders are also great! read more

So awesome and savory with every bite also I love the greasy goodness so good on you also the pink lemonade is the best and the restaurant smells like greatness five stars! read more

Great food. Best cheese pizza I've had as the cheese is always fresh ground with added herbs and spices. On Tuesdays you can get large cheese pizzas for $5.99ea, makes dinner a no-brainer. And the pizza is just as good cold so order a lot. read more

This place is amazing. I feel like I'm 11 everytime I come here. The pizza is rich - it's buttery and cheesy and so outstanding. It's NOT at all the NYC pizza I'm used to but it's so good it makes me less homesick. The local atmosphere is really great - the staff is very kind and helpful. Go on Tuesday for the best deals! read more

Great fresh pasta plenty to eat will go back to try some other stuff prices are average , but volume is great

People can say it's greasy all they want. They're normal amount of cheese is like extra cheese everywhere else. That's why. I love this place. read more

I had just moved to this area about 6 months ago. The food is okay. I say that for this reason. It isn't consistent at all, sometimes burnt and sometimes undercooked. We always order the spaghetti from the kids menu for our son because he loves spaghetti with Italian bread. It is advertised on there menu that the kids spaghetti come with Italian bread when in fact it doesn't. It comes with a hamburger bun. Not toasted or even buttered. And upon me calling to inquire about this. Apparently all kids menu breads come with a hamburger bun. Not Italian bread. The staff is very unprofessional. And tried to lie there way out of my concern to no it's an Italian roll the to "all kids food come with a hamburger bun". I will not be ordering from again. Dishonest and dissatisfying. read more

Excellent pizza. Perfect amount of fresh cheese. Crispy yet chewy crust slightly burnt to perfection. At most places I order extra cheese but not needed here. Almost as good as the old Roxy's pizza in westerly.... and that's saying something. read more

Order pizza from here all the time and it's always been good I ordered spaghetti and meatballs tonight and it was horrible. Stick to the pizza from now on read more