Three of us came in and the handsome and charming man proceeded to explain every single pie they had with a smile. I ordered a 1/2 meatball hero and Cesar salad. Two for special with a drink and free refills. Portions were enormous. Got a Pene al a Vodka slice to go. The vibe was great with regulars coming and going like it was home. We all left stuffed and happy. As we were leaving a young man said he appreciated us when we complimented the food. So much nicer than Levitown. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - 1/2 meatball hero and Cesar salad with a soda. - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

Still the best pizza around. And the slices are so big and so consistently delicious that the price really makes no difference. Plus after you order, find a comfortable seat and the staff will be nice enough to bring your food to you. And it's so good. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Brand new restaurant - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

See all

Keep in mind, this was for take-out only. I was in the area recently and we decided to get pizza and some garlic knots for take out. This place came recommended. Inside was clean and modernized. It didn't look like a traditional pizzeria in a lot of ways, but the taste is where it counts. The pizza was generally good. The garlic knots were excellent. I made it a point to take the menu if things were good to keep as an option the next time I'm in the area and I'm glad I did. The one behind the counter was friendly. There is plenty of parking and this place shares the space with other businesses. A good option for locals for sure. If in the area again and wanting pizza or the like, this will be my go to. read more

See all

Always enjoyed the food since I can remember. Good local pizza. Counter staff and owners are nice and always very welcoming Service is good for a local pizzeria with restaurant food too. Ambience is nice too just not a restaurant but perfect local pizza place. read more

Mike is the best! Usually every Friday when my family wants pizza, that's our go to place. They have an express area/entrance so if you call ahead, there's never a wait. Must go if you live in the area! read more

Great pizza!!!!!! What a great surprise for the employees at The Ups Store in Wantagh. Thanks for the pies. I will send our friends your way. read more

Great service, amazing food, family friendly and gives back to the community. Love Mario's! read more

Have a variety of rolls and slices to choose from. Looks like the interior was renovated recently. Quick operation with plenty of staff to turn people out. Penne al la vodka slice and sicilian were so good, nice crispy crust. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

See all

I enjoyed the antipasto salad, but I needed to bring leftovers home. Brian skillfully packaged them, with cheerful service. Thank you! I have been enjoying Mario's of Seaford for at least 15 years. read more

Best pizza place in Seaford! I love getting a pie that's half one topping and half another topping. They always can accommodate requests. The eggplant is delicious and they put so much on their pizza! There was once time that they made extra garlic knots and gave me some free of charge. They were so good that I continue to order them! read more

Mario's Pizzeria - a pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

I can only imagine that they changed owners over the last few weeks. We use to get this great Grandma pie and mozzarella sticks. This time it was totally different, sauce not so great, cheese and Basil limited and mozzarella sticks from Walmart. Now I need to find a new spot. read more

I stopped for a slice because sometimes you just need a plain slice. The place was clean and the staff was friendly. The pizza was very good. The thin crust was was just right. There is nothing worse than picking up a slice and the end folds down and your cheese slides off. The sauce had good flavor as did the mozzarella, not too salty or too greasy. I grabbed a take out menu and will definitely try them again. read more

Ordered a chicken roll and was pleasantly surprised. First, it was hot...not disgustingly lukewarm like a lot of places do. Second, the chicken was actually **NOT** dry. It was very tasty. Third, there was just enough cheese...not too much and not too little. The store seemed clean and everyone was wearing a mask. If I'm in the area again, will definitely stop back in read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Chicken Roll - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

Decent pizza place with some decent food. Been here a bunch of times and always have a nice experence. First the staff is great here. The manager is a very nice guy and remembers everyone who walks in the door and makes you feel welcome. Food wise my favorite has to be the caesar salad bowls with grilled chicken. Dressing is great and the pizza bread bowl is awesome. Highly recommend. Pizza wise buffalo chicken and bbq slices are my favorite. Overall a nice spot to try. read more

There are so many pizzerias in the Seaford Massapequa area. Anytime we order from Mario's in Seaford we are impressed with their customer service and quality of the food. The owner is so pleasant and welcoming. The other staff members are courteous and friendly. The pizza, pasta, garlic knots are very good and they make a great marinara slice for the non cheese eaters like me. Will be a go-to for our family when ordering Italian. read more

This is my go-to pizza place ever since my pizza place in Massapequa closed. We usually go in and order and take our pizza home. Tonight we got a spinach roll, bacon ranch pizza, and a white pizza. The white pizza was verryyyy cheesy and loaded with garlic. Overall, this place is good for specialty slices! read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

Not only is the food terrible but it's overpriced. My wife ordered a white pizza and wings and it was $63. No problem paying that if the food was actually edible. Tv e pizza was full of grease and cheap ingredients. The wings were fried in some type of weird breading and tasted disgusting. The food wound up going in the garbage because it was so gross. My wife was sick in the bathroom for the next 2 days after eating 1 slice of pizza. It's very sad considering their other locations are excellent. read more

Used to be good, but not anymore unfortunately. Crust too thin, top either overdone or underdone, and just doesn't taste good anymore. And they raised their prices when their quality went down. Sad, used to be my favorite pizza place. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Last Mario's pizza delivery I got. Dried out with burnt spots. - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

Ordered on doordash tonight for delivery! Ordered two white slices, a plain, and fried Oreos. After I placed my order I got a phone call they didn't currently have any white slices. I switched to a small white pie. Everything delivered great! read more

Couldn't tell you how it tasted because we had a horrible experience. The pie is kind of small and there are hardly any toppings . The staff was rude. When my husband voiced his concern they took the pizza and put the money on the counter. We thought he was going to take the pizza and fix the toppings. He took the pizza. Gave us back our money and told us to go. read more

This place has always been run by assholes. They are always so snotty when i order like they are in a rush and i am an inconvenience to them that i am ordering food from them. I keep giving them second chances to change how they treat me as a customer and they fail every time. Won't be giving them another chance. Will be getting ginos from now on. read more

Amazing Friendly atmosphere. Food is so good I just keeps coming back. They somehow found a great balance between feeling like a traditional and modern pizzeria at the same time. And their pieces are decent and have deal I have yet to get. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - BBQ Chicken Pizza - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

Marios is my typically go to Pizza place. I have been to many of the locations and all have been consistently good. My favorite is the restaurant in Plainview on 635 Old Country Rd. They are a great place to go to grab a quick lunch. Very nicely decorated and the service is always fast and you can get in and out easily in an hour. The buffalo chicken pizza is excellent as is their greek salad with balsamic chicken. They also offer complementary garlic rolls with the bread which are also delicious. read more

This place is severely underrated. The food is above average, you can't beat the price on the specials and they are so friendly. They will get our business again and again. I loved the vodka sauce with mushrooms and onions in it and the garlic knots are phenomenal. My only wish is that they would cook the bottom of their crust a little more, it comes out kind of soggy and definitely needs a crisp. Other than that it is great! read more

I've given Mario's a try now for two Wednesday in a row. Last week I ordered a Caesar Salad Chicken wrap. It was the most saltiest thing I've eaten in a long time and it was filled with croutons. Today, January 26, I tried fresh mozzarella and tomato pizza. Also inedible. It took 10 minutes to heat up and was barely warm and the the crust tasted as if something prior had burned in the oven and all that foul stench was now in the crust, not to mention it was almost $6 for that one slice. Save your money people, go elsewhere. read more

A staple for our family for over a decade (pizza Friday). Great food, nice management. Unfortunately, they cant seem to hire good people. After two issues with rude service to me and then another to my sister-in-law, we haven't gone back in about 2 years. read more

My husband,my husband's grandparents, and I had a blind taste test and we all felt that Mario's has better pizza than Gino's Pizza. I was the only one that felt Grimaldi's pizza was better than both Mario's and Gino's pizza. Mario's has an awesome pizza sauce. I also love all the varieties of pizza that they have ranging from Chicken Vodka pizza to Veggie pizzas. They also sell pizza per slice. Delicious garlic knots. Super nice staff to top things off! read more

I consider myself a pizza expert because I love pizza and I eat it all the time. I've tried many places on Long Island and Mario's of Seaford is the best. First of all - the ratios and amounts of everything (cheese/tomato sauce/crust) are perfectly balanced: The crust isn't too thick or too thin, it's perfect. The ratio of cheese to sauce is perfect. The cheese and sauce are spread to the perfect width to reach the edge so there's just the right amount of edge. Then the quality and taste of everything: great great sauce- not too much garlic not too much salt not too much sugar not overly seasoned - perfect balance of all flavors. And the cheese is delicious and they always use a lot while maintaining the perfect balance with the sauce. I've done pickup and delivery and always great. Nice staff. Good rewards (points) and discounts for repeat customers. I've had some other dishes there as well and everything is always delicious. read more

The pizza here is awful the man is so nasty on top of being over priced I do not suggest this place the Zeppoli's are awful as well like Little Rock's if your like your teeth don't get them out and his pizza slice is the smallest slice I ever gotten plain and simple his food sucks and he puts on so much Cologne he made the whole dining room stink I thought I was gonna throw up I actually had to get out of there and take my anti-nausea medicine after if you have asthma enter at your own risk read more

Order was messed up the first time but manager Nick did right by me and made sure to fix the issue.

Searching for good pizza in the area. So many options! This one had a good plain cheese but the BEST eggplant pie I've ever had. The thickest slices and most eggplant I've ever had on a pizza. It was heavenly. I dream of it. Get it now. read more

We ordered the family meal for dinner. We got the Sicilian, baked ziti, Greek salad and garlic knots. The price was super reasonable and there was sooooo much good. I have to say, the baked ziti was phenomenal! I will definitely order from Mario's again! read more

Just moved to the area and decided to try Marios. Restaurant looks clean, counter service was very quick and courteous. I ordered a vegetable slice, a margarita slice and a rice ball. Both slices were luke warm and the bottom crust was soft, the center was doughy and mushy, (very disappointing), I ate half of both and threw it out. The rice ball was very crisp on the outside, and after beginning in the oven a few minutes the inside wasn't that hot either. The rice seemed like it wasn't done, grainy and hard. Didn't finish it. There are alot of pizzaria's, I think I'll skip this one next time. Sorry Again service was good! read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Warm, crispy, grainy rice ball - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

Terrible!!! Stopped in for 2 slices the other day and they were horrible. It was obvious that the pie he cut my slices out of was a mistake our being that it was smaller and he cut it into 6 slices instead of 8. The middle of the pizza was looked like they dropped something on it. I go to locations all over the place and because of this visit and the fact that they would serve an inferior slice when they know it is wrong I will no longer patronize Marios anywhere. It can not always be about profit, sometimes you have to think about the customer experience and apparently tossing a mistake our was not obtain, they would rather sell it out by the slice and screw the customer. read more

Mario's is the best pizza place. Always my go-to dinner if I'm in the area and can't cook. The pizza slices, all of them, are always fresh. There are so many different slices to choose from. Their penne alla vodka is the best I've ever had. It doesn't taste like jar sauce like vodka sauce from other restaurants. Service is pretty quick and always friendly. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Penne alla vodka close up. - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

We stumbled onto Mario's on way driving from Manhattan thru Brooklyn to Hamptons. 10pm at night on a Friday. The food is the BEST Italian fast casual we ever had. I got the meatball Sub and my wife got the Caesar salad. And the manager Nick listened to my traffic horror story driving thru Flatbush Ave in Brooklyn. You gotta eat Mario's Pizzeria if you're on Sunrise or anywhere nearby. The foods the best, order delivery from this place too. read more

I am very fortunate to work for a local business owner who has generously purchased our lunches over the past few months. When word gets out that the lunch delivered for the day is Marios eyes light up and EVERYONE heads to the lunch room with tails wagging. The trays of penne ala vodka, sausage and peppers and meatballs are delicious. Yesterday we were pleasantly surprised to receive a tray of fried Oreos which were yummy! read more

I ordered this evening through Grub-hub so I can't speak to the niceness of the staff. I ordered a gluten free pizza with sausage, meatball, spinach and black olives. What I didn't order was garlic! I am allergic to garlic. I suppose they cook the spinach with garlic is all that I can figure out. Anyway the dough was not cooked all the way thru and the middle of the pie was mushy. But the flavor was great. Probably bc of the garlic but in an hour I will be wracked by abdominal bloating and severe cramps. So it's definitely not worth it. This small pie ( the circumference of a dinner plate! ) cost me $28!! $5 of that was tip for the delivery driver bc he was very nice. And on time. But $23? $2 for every additional topping except the first one. That's toooooo much to charge for the size of this pie. read more

Was there today for the first time. I have to say the customer service was great! A young boy at the counter (christian) very personable, everyone seemed to know him. He also had great knowledge of the food the pizzaria had on hand. Great place! Thanks read more

Good place to stop on sunrise. Good parking and good location. Clean place. The service is nice. The pizza is alright.