Fancy? No. Delicious food, friendly service, fair prices, and a small town vibe? YES. Its a go to…read morefor weekend breakfast but I've been for dinner once as well. I'll definitely continue going back! Tip: They get busy on the weekend, so just be prepared that you may need to wait. There isn't a parking lot dedicated to the diner, but street parking and a community lot down the hill is free. Don't forget to check out the dessert offerings!

Well my wife and I stopped into this cute little dinner in Bolivar, OHIO. Boy was this the best…read moredecision we had made in awhile. Cute little place with such warmth and friendliness. I had the Lemon Pepper Shrimp special and I loved every bite, also had green beans and Mac & cheese, great choice for sure. Beans were not over salty and the Mac & cheese was the best I have had in a while. Not overly cheesy as some are. My wife had the spaghetti with meatballs two large homemade type. She loved it and I was fortunate to finish it off. She also had a salad with freshly made ranch dressing. The she had the sugar free butter pecan ice cream which was to die for. The two waitresses are the bomb so very attentive and helpful always giving great suggestions. If you are near this town drive the extra distance to come here. Well worth the drive. They also take reservations on Thursday and Friday. Can you imagine that a dinner taking reservations. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED COMING HERE

Coffee and bagels are a simple breakfast. It doesn't have to be complicated to be good. Simply…read moreCinnamon sticks to the basics, while having a few fancier things. Get either regular coffee or something more complicated. There's breakfast sandwiches and pastries too. Find this in the small town of Bolivar. Getting here from the highway is, complicated. This is located behind the shopping center on the north side of the street. It has a small parking lot. The menu isn't that huge either, which makes it easier to choose something. A regular coffee is good with anything. It's about $2 for a regular size. Bagels are one of the food options. These are about $1 each, which is also about the cost of a pastry. It was slow like others have said here. It's because there's usually only one person working at a time. There's a few places to sit inside, and though it doesn't have outlets, it has wifi.

My husband and I love simply cinnamon! We found it on a whim, and go at least once or twice a week…read more Their coffee is our favorite but their cookies and other food is delicious too. The staff is friendly and very helpful! My only complaint is sometimes you have to wait in a long line, but that's just because it's so good!

This is a cute family restaurant and has a lot of personal touches in the decor - winter and…read moreValentine's Day themed. Our server was sweet and friendly. The prices are extremely low, but it is cash only. I had the Fiesta Breakfast Plate and for the price it was okay. The eggs were moist and the rye toast was hot and flavorful. The mushrooms on top of the eggs were canned which wasn't what I expected. The salsa helped liven things up. My husband had the ham and bean soup. He said it was definitely homemade, but there weren't very many beans in the bowl though they did have Westminster crackers that he loves! Overall, we would probably go back when we were in the neighborhood, but order something else.

Great food - great prices - even BETTER service! We went for lunch. Hubs had the cheeseburger and…read moreonion rings and I had the Manhattan which was a top round roast beef sandwich with brown gravy on top and mashed potatoes with the brown gravy, both dishes were very good. They serve breakfast during open hours / would love to go back again this trip! Oh wait did I mention homemade pie!??

Used our "Amish Country Summer Package" which included dinner here…read more We got sat instantly right at 5:30, prime time. Karen greeted us right away and explained the deal to us. I got the full buffet & she got the salmon w/ sweet potato fries & salad bar. Drinks were included as well. Plus she brought wheat rolls. The hot buffet was limited but everything was always fresh & very tasty. I can't complain about any item. The salmon was pretty good as it had a nice crust on it. The sweet potato fries were perfect & the cinnamon butter was even better. Salad bar was really fresh & the local cheddar cheese was amazing. The cold prepared salads were a bit too wet but yummy. Only dessert item was jello. The full buffet w/ drink only cost $18! And Karen was the best server!

This is our go to Saturday ride to Amish Country. I can't believe this is my second week in a row…read more You get there and you add your name to the list and step back, or go outside and wait. It's packed but do not get impatient, they have this down to a science and you are usually called within 20-30 minutes or less. It depends on the line. The food is tasty, very delicious. The pies... yum o'lala. Clean, everyone is kind. Oh and the Amish families eat there, so you know it has to be good. Our guest ate from the Buffett, we eat from the menu.

It was a cute restaurant. Only open till 2 PM for lunch. Limited menu. Cheesesteak was very good…read more My wife got the attic with Home cut fries. I had the cheesesteak with the homemade macaroni salad. It was a very good very cute.

Delicious food and friendly staff. We took my in laws there on a Sunday for lunch and both my…read morehusband and father in law really liked the Swiss steak.

A truly warm and welcoming place that makes the customer feel like the honored guest and then…read moreblesses the guest by pointing their heart towards service of others. I visited on a weekday afternoon just before the high school up the street let out for the day. I ordered a hazelnut Irish crème latte cold from their March special menu that rivaled any drink from nationwide coffee shops. I didn't get to check the food menu much, but it looked extensive. And the hard served ice cream that a guest got while I was there looked amazing. I enjoyed my cold latte while doing some work. If you need a place to cool down or warm up with a coffee drink and get some work done then I think this place will serve you well. The ambience was comfortable, warm, friendly, and pleasant. I think there is a side room that could host a group. If you have kids they might enjoy the game table that lines the hallway by the bathrooms. On shelves in one of the corners and at the front of the shop where you order your food and drinks are brochures or other paraphernalia highlighting local businesses and services, community efforts, and monthly campaigns that will help you or someone you know find a resource or at least help promote service to others in your heart. I look forward to stopping in again soon.

We were unaware that today is a holiday in Amish country, so we set out to find a place to eat…read more Eventually, we stumbled upon this establishment where you place your order at the front counter, and they bring your food to you. The salad, wrap, and French toast were enjoyable. However, they don't offer refills, and there's a charge for using your credit card. 5/9/24

The lodge was superior with well appointed rooms and hallways. The reception area was…read morewelcoming.But the highlight was the 2nd floor deck with a splendid view of the countryside....and a place to watch summer storms as they moved through. We walked around the town and surroundings..quiet and peaceful. The only disappointment was the adjacent restaurant...with uninspired and often fattening food. This was in contrast to the excellent breakfast at the lodging.

Went to the Ohio star theater and didn't want to fight the lines at the Amish buffet there in…read moreSugarcreek. Figured we'd give the Amish door a shot since AI generated this as a recommendation. It was $23 a person and another $4 for a coffee. The bill for 4 grownups with the buffet and 2 coffees was $108 on 7/11/26. The dinner buffet at 4pm was one 5 foot double sides buffet. The salad was the same. To put this in perspective, Yoders kitchen is 4 times that. The dessert options, with this paid full buffet dinner was graham cracker pudding or chocolate cookie pudding. The dinner options were breaded fried shrimp, chicken, meatballs, some sort of sausage or kielbasa and a shredded meat of some sort. That's it. That's it. I planned my mother in laws birthday out to the very last minute, to give her the best birthday celebration possible, and I felt so disappointed that this restaurant was so underwhelming.

The food was amazing; service superb and we got to meet and talk with the owners. It's a small…read morelocally owned place with that welcoming feeling

We had a great lunch at the Mill Street Diner on New Year's Eve. Not much was open in Amish Country…read morethat day so we felt lucky that they were open. They were steadily busy, but the staff was friendly and upbeat. It is in an old building that made you feel you had stepped back in time. Comfortable booths and high ceilings. Very homey feel. The food was hot and flavorful and not very expensive. We'll be back when we are in Sugarcreek again!

Great place for a girls' lunch! I am never disappointed! Quaint location with great views! You can…read morespend a bit of time there because of all the shopping. They have rotating specials to keep things interesting. I would especially recommend the mint lemon tea in the summer season!

We stopped by for lunch on our way to Amish country because the pictures of the food seemed to have…read morelots of fresh ingredients and it sounded cute. It's a big restaurant off of a country road with plenty of parking. As of two weeks ago they were doing work on the highway that was kind of unpleasant with grated roads and lane closures but it looks like it will be done soon maybe.... Anyway, it's a large space with a gift shop and shabby chic decor that all appeared to be for sale since everything has a price tag on it even in the restaurant. The service was pleasant enough. The menu has fairly straightforward cafe like offerings of sandwiches and salads. I wanted something light so I opted for the cesar salad in spite of my reservations when it said tomatoes and olives were on it. Weird but whatever chicken, lettuce, croutons and cesar dressing still felt on brand so I went for it. This is not a cesar salad. It was a salad with balsamic dressing of some kind, toasted bread with the crust cut off and a cold chicken breast. And, it comes with bread but I was told they didn't have rye so I ended up with sourdough that was also not sourdough and the waitperson didn't bring it until I was mostly through eating my refrigerator cold chicken. Just, yikes. Additionally, I still don't know how there was rye for my sister's sandwich but I wasn't allowed to order it with my food. As for her lunch, the pastrami was fine but with a lackluster amount of meat. The French onion soup was the only thing that felt reasonable with quality and price. All in all, I think the snack bars or even grocery stores in the area/ Amish country appeared to have better offerings. I wouldn't recommend this place for lunch. The gift shop was cute and reasonably priced so maybe check it out for that but that's it.

The food is absolutely delicious, the service is great, and the restaurant is cozy. As someone with…read morea gluten intolerance, this is the only place I can eat pasta that is actually delicious. Definitely recommend!

Wow what a little gem! We started with the bread service, comes with tapenade and butter for $4…read more The bread was warm and delicious. We ordered the burrata with crostini which was really good. I ordered the special - pasta with a cheese sauce, mushrooms, sausage, sun dried tomatoes and peas. It was so good!! I don't know the name but don't hesitate to order the special. We also got a linguini with clam sauce, which was great!! We ordered tiramisu to go and got a huge portion to go. The service was great. Our server was so knowledgeable and we felt well taken care of! The ambiance is good, both indoor and outdoor seating available.