Have ordered carry out many times and has not disappointed us. Please don't change a thing with the recipe. Other pizza places in New Braunfels have changed for the worst from our first visit. Never turn down a pizza night when the kids ask. read more

Great Pizza, Great Sauces, Easy Pickup Mattenga's Pizzeria on 46 in New Braunfels has become one of my favorite spots for an easy, reliable pizza pickup. I love their pizza and all the unique choices they offer. You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu. The location is close, which makes grabbing dinner super convenient. Their dipping sauces are my absolute favorite part. The Mattenga's Ranch and the Texas Ranch are both so good, and they pair perfectly with our usual orders: the Honey Bexar and the Classic. One thing that's a little strange is the pickup experience. When I pick up, they always show me the pizza before I pay, which I appreciate. But when my husband picks up, they don't show him the pizza, and we've ended up with slightly burnt pies because of it. A little consistency there would make the experience even better. Overall, it's a solid place for a good pie with great flavors and even better sauces. read more

This turned out to be an OK pizza. I think it could've been better, like if it had had more toppings. The picture on their website compared to what I actually picked up was not the same. The picture on the website shows a lot more pineapple and pickles and bacon. When I bit into this pizza I wondered if it had any bacon on it at all. I realized eventually that it did, but it's not evenly dispersed around the pizza but rather in clumps. The crust had no real character. It had no flavor, and was not salty or sweet. I would order again, but maybe not this particular item. Oh, also, when I picked up the pizza the guy at the register asked me my name and when I told him, he asked if I meant Desiree. I said no, and then I had to show him the email before he was able to locate the pizza that was sitting on top of the oven. ‍ read more

This is a really solid pizza place, but, like, it's good for people on a low salt diet. Everything was pretty good but bland. I've literally never put table salt on my pizza before but it really livened everything up and made it great. Maybe the chef just forgot the salt in the dough today (I've done it, too) or maybe they really do cater to those eating heart healthy. But some spice would kick it up a notch. The margarita pizza had a nice basil flavor, and both crusts had a great puff, crunch, and chew. If I still lived here, this would be my new pizza place. The staff are LOVELY. And the pizza really is great. Definitely worth going back to! read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels - 10" cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

This was a great find. All items we ordered arrived hot. Nothing was over salted and the pizza was New York style. They even included a free cheese pizza in our order. The family loved it and it's a great decision to make on a Sunday afternoon. We recently moved close to this place and we will be eating there many more times in the future! read more

See all

I ordered the Sante Fe pizza and Favor delivered. It was SO good! Fresh, hot, and a nice kick with the hatch chiles. Yum!! read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels - Pizza Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

There are pizzas and then there are REALLY good pizzas in our neighborhood. Mattenga's is really good pizza. This is a small pizzeria, great for pickup and great for a small 2-4 person group or enjoy the patio for larger groups. Everything is fresh made to order, all the way down to the vegetables and cheese - literally the cheese on that pizza gets shredded that morning, the fresh tomatoes and the vegetables are sliced that morning. We love that we can get a 20" pizza or a small Friend-size pizza. Plenty of topping choices and house made dipping sauces for the salad, wings and pizza. Would love to see a thin crust and maybe a gluten-free option. Their pizza boxes are always fun! read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels - Pizza Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

We have pizza once a week and wanted to try a new place. We ordered to go a large antipasta salad and a small pizza pepperoni and green peppers. I was told 20 minute wait, got there in less than 15 minutes and my order was ready. Staff was friendly. The large antipasta salad is enough for 4 people. Very generous on the mozzarella cheese, lots of lettuce, a bit too many sliced green olives than what I wanted and not as much salami and Canadian bacon or artichoke hearts I was hoping for. Nevertheless, an excellent salad. Several dressings you can choose from. The pizza was delicious. Next time I'll ask for less olives in the salad and try one of their menu pizzas. The shop is small but there are a few tables if you want to eat there. read more

Got the pothole pizza and the specialty pizza. Pothole was a bit too spicy for my taste. Specialty was good as was the thin crust on both. Service was good really no ambiance as I just picked up pizza and left. read more

One of the best pizza I ever had in life. The size and taste is amazing. The staff was very friendly and the pizza was ready as quoted. The place was small but very clean and nice. They had plenty of staff available. I would definitely recommend to family and friends. I will be coming back again very soon. read more

See all

Great food! Had the pizza rolls and a 20inch pizza. Nice amount of toppings, good chewy New York style crust. The staff was friendly and very solicitous. There is a soda machine and there are tables. However, no plates or silverware (not even disposable) so be prepared. I would classify this a a great take out place, but recommend you keep it at that. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria may be a small place, but it offers excellent service and absolutely delicious pizza. A great spot to enjoy a fresh and flavorful meal! read more

See all

Delivery driver Hope was wonderful! Unfortunately, the representative who took my order lacked empathy. I was told my pizza would arrive within 30 minutes, but after waiting 40 minutes, I called to check on the status. I was informed that the driver hadn't left yet and when I asked if my order was forgotten, I was told they were swamped with orders. Instead of an apology, I was simply asked if I still wanted it. My kids were really hungry, and this disrupted our plans for a movie night and sleepover with friends. Additionally, when the pizza and wings finally arrived,(2 hours later ) they were both cold. I was very disappointed with the $60 I spent, especially since I expected better service and quality. I will stick with Papa John's ! cheaper , faster and great customer service ! Thank you for your attention to this matter. read more

Best pizza, best crust. Definitely our favorite. They always open the box so you can confirm it looks good

My new favorite pizza place in New Braunfels. I have been twice already. Both times my family and I have ordered breadsticks and a family style pepperoni pizza. The ingredients are fresh, the breadsticks were amazing. The pizza resembles a New York style pizza. The staff has always been friendly, and the pizza was on time as promised both times. A word of caution though. When using the online app, it tries to default to Schertz. So beware. One time I placed the order and it when to Schertz. Highly recommend Mattenga's. Will 100% definitely be back. I am bummed I have not known about this place sooner! Enjoy! read more

Very good pizza! The New Braunfels branch is more like a quick take out place than a restaurant. I would definitely order next time for take out as it got very busy with people waiting for their take out orders and the space is smallish. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels - This is the pothole pizza - so good! - Pizza Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

One of my favorites in town! The sauce is fantastic, pepperoni was cup and char (which you can choose other styles of pepperoni) the crust is great too! Love love love everything about Mattenga's! read more

See all

Fantastic pizza every time! My favorite is the hamburger, mushroom and bacon. Pizza's are pretty big and crust is just perfect!

The pepperoni pizza and the pepperoni with hatch peppers was delicious! My only issue was I called in the order instead of using their App to place my order and they forgot to start my pizzas until I walked in to pick it up! read more

When I want pizza, it's always going to be Mattengas! Their pizza is AMAZING. Seriously, I've had so many pizzas from there & there hasn't been a time it's has been perfect. Also, don't forget to ask for their Texas Ranch! It's so good! read more

1st time going, called in an order and they lost it. What a shame. Never got to try the pizza and won't be back!

Well it looks as though this is going to be another uncomfortable review, due to the 5 star ratings this business has received. We specifically tried this place because of the ratings and reviews from friends. We decided to try the Calzone and Mattenga's 16" Molto Meat pizza. Both were fair at best. The Calzone had no flavor and was real doughy The pizza didn't have much flavor either. Sad to say, but ! have had better pizza at the local, cheaper "delivery pizza places". Without saying names, one starts with a D, PJ and PH. The service was good and employee was friendly, but it was definitely not worth the $34.00 price. We definitely have no need to try it again. Especially since, upon ordering and picking up the pizza they repeatedly suggest a tip. Tips are for wait staff that wait on me. I ordered the pizza and I picked it up. You did nothing but cook it and put it in a box. This tipping thing is way out of hand. read more

Great thin crust pizza with whatever you want on it and fast service is pleasant Just plain delicious read more

This spot is terrific! Super tasty brisket pizza was just what we needed. Caprese salad was on point as well. This place is worth the visit. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels - We love this spot! The brisket pizza was so freakin good. Had a caprese salad that was well put together as well. Worth a visit for sure. - Pizza Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

Service was amazing, considering I just got a small pizza for take out. And the pizza was actually very good. I'll be back. read more

This place is awesome!! The food is so good and so is the service. They are all so friendly which makes rhetorical ambiance really nice. We will definitely coming back. AND. their brisket pizza is AMAZING!!! read more

This is our go to place for pizza. The chicken pesto pizza is amazing. The small is an ideal size for 1 person.

The last time we had their pizza the Dough was horrible.. it had little to no salt & had a strange texture and taste. The key to great pizza is extremely dependent of a good dough. If you don't have that, you are done. N Y Pizza Pub is the Best in New Braunfels. read more

Food is awesome! Always fresh! I love the pizza and calzones...last time I picked up some wings and was surprised as I am not a wing guy, but they were great! Young kids at the counter, but they were polite and better than most around here. Small dining area if you want to dine in. Food is fresh and hot to take home. read more

Welcomed with a smile. Delicious veggie pizza. Will come back to try others on the menu.

Pizza was great! But due to the uncleanness of the bathroom and dining room we won't go back. Also,the music was a hard rock head banging song,awful. Easy fixes,will definitely go back if we see a change. Also,love the scripture from Exodus on the boxes:) read more

Hands down some of the best pizza in town!! This will be my new go to !!! Run, don't walk and grab a pizza!!

Best pizza of my life! Just like homeslice in Austin except not Austin. Tiny storefront but quaint and everyone was nice. They have no fountain drinks only bottled sodas and tap water but that's nice. The pizza is airy crunchy and wonderful. I never eat crust and my husband was disappointed because today this changed. read more

I picked up a 16" Molto Meat specialty pizza and it was fresh, hot and delicious. The crust was super thin and crispy and the meat toppings included pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, and Canadian bacon. The cheese and sauce were good and the pizza was enough for three people easily and was $19.99 before tax. Great location right off the highway and it took about 20 minutes to get my order. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels - Phone number and location - Pizza Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

Have found hair in my pizza, Twice! Picked up another one and almost half the pizza is missing cheese!! They do not answer thier phone, so trying to call and complain, is just useless! Never asked for anything free, or a replacement, but after these couple of experiences, I think we will just go back up to NY pizza in New Braunfels. read more

My employer asked me to try out a few pizza places and recommend one to cater our company picnic for about 200 people. Mattengas was my third stop. We won't be going with them and I didn't even try the pizza. I was their only customer at 12:30 PM. I ordered the two topping lunch special pizza and requested an additional topping. I was told "you can't do that". What? "We can't ring it up that way" . I say OK, I'll just give you $1.50 more and throw some onions on the pizza. Another employee walks up and tells me "No, we aren't going to do that. What a stupid way to run a business. I left and got an amazing pizza at Bosses down the street just the way I wanted it. read more

A huge shout out and Thank you to Mattenga's for reaching out and fixing their mistake. My family enjoyed the delicious pizza & wings we will be ordering again soon!!!! read more

Ordered 5 pizzas for our family reunion and they were ready for pick-up within 15-20 minutes. Everybody raved about the pizza. The crusts were thin and crisp, all the ingredients were fresh, and it was a real hit. Service was quick and friendly. Just try it. read more

Stopped by the other day with my kids and had a great experience. Derek took care of us and was super respectful and attentive. The food was great and so was the atmosphere. read more

My husband and i stopped at this place because of the excellent reviews. We were not disappointed at all. They have amazing customer service. The food was delicious, I absolutely LOVED the different ranch flavors. Ambiance was very chill. The staff kept checking up on us and were extremely caring. We have found our pizza place in NB!! read more