This was our first time to Mattys. And it didn't let us down. The service was outstanding. The place was packed, but it did not feel crowded. Great outdoor area. We were there for three different birthdays, and everyone had a great time. Food Was very good. Fried ice cream was beyond belief, outstanding and huge Highly recommend it. read more

Went here for dinner on a Sunday night, and the place was packed. The parking lot was full, however the lot across the street had ample additional parking. Matty's is massive, with a ton of seating outside. The big screen tv makes this place perfect to see the game with friends and family, and is pet friendly. There are fire pits, oversized games, outdoor bars, a grill that serves select food and easy access to all areas of the restaurant and event space. This place has a great, lively vibe. The bartenders, patrons and staff were all friendly. Although our service on the patio was a bit slow, the food was very good. I had the Turkey Avocado BLT Wrap, and it was perfect. Lots of turkey, with the right amount of veggies and portioned aioli to create a well balanced flavor. I would definitely go back to Matty's to watch a game, and enjoy the energy that everyone brings and shares. read more

Matty's Bar & Grille - Turkey Avocado BLT Wrap - American Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

We attended a banquet at Matty's Event Center. Very spacious space with a nice area for hanging out in the open space. There is a stage and a fire pit as well as a bar. There is a bar inside the event center with plenty of seating. The staff was nice and tables were cleared of plates often. read more

See all

I have tried A LOT of fish fries in the SEWI area and I can honestly say Matty's has the best hands down! I always get the baked cod so I can't speak to the actual fish "fry" but the piece of cod was huge, very well seasoned, flaky and I much appreciated the small dish of butter off to the side, instead of leaving my baked cod to drown in it. But, the best part of my dinner was the potato pancake! So many places serve up a bland and boring potato pancake because they don't cook it long enough. don't make it thick enough (or too thick) or don't season it at all and Matty's was absolute perfection. Crispy, seasoned, thick enough and the cinnamon applesauce was perfection to the level of doneness of the potato pancake. I couldn't stop raving about it during dinner and on our way home! What I didn't love was the pre-mixed drinks, especially the old fashioneds. Because the old fashioned is the natural pairing to a Wisconsin fish fry I would never expect the bartender to pour this from a premixed concoction, knowing darn well the flavors are far inferior & far too sweet for my taste, nevermind using bourbons I would never choose for my old fashioned. The barstaff was kept pretty busy during our visit with the dinner rush so we had to flag them down when we wanted to order or pay but the one bartender did walk back personally to grab an applesauce that the kitchen forgot! Overall it was a great experience. If pre-mixed drinks are your thing, Matty has you covered. If you've never had a really great fish fry and an even better potato pancake, don't sleep on trying one at Matty's. read more

Matty's Bar & Grille - Baked Cod - American Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

Believe it or not,this was my first time at Matty's Bar & Grill in New Berlin.Their outdoor setup for groups and general entertainment is quite impressive.We had the chance to attend a Birthday Party there last Friday and the catering and service were outstanding.They built a separate building that can host multiple party's at the same time and it was excellent.The food was top notch and there was plenty of it, sandwiches,salads, veggies , fruit taco chips,dips and homemade potato chips,all were excellent.The bad service was friendly and prompt.Honestly I don't know how they could have done better.I would highly recommend them for your event.I am looking forward to trying their regular menu in the future. read more

See all

Once again a great time at Matty's! We all enjoyed our meals and Mary Margaret is an absolutely amazing server. Between us we had the Reuben, Brisket skillet, Eggs Benedict, and the Double Down. Everything we cooked well and had good flavor. Would recommend them. Also enjoyed the cold brew iced coffee. We also had the Matty's Mary's, 25oz size. This would also be recommended. read more

Matty's Bar & Grille - Matty's Mary - American Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

Another great fish fry at Mattys. This place have everything from both indoor and outdoor seating, a big backyard for seating and live music, activities, a great menu and monthly specials. Last night we went for the fish fry. Started off the night with a large Shandy and a handcrafted strawberry handcrafted margarita. They do have margaritas on top but she only drinks Patron Silver. She got the baked cod,mashed potatoes, they were the real ones made with red skin potatoes. Both came with coleslaw, tarter, lemon and two nice pieces of marbled rye. I opted for the perch with potato pancake and applesauce. Our server McKenzie was very nice and efficient. We even shared a piece of the carrot cake. read more

See all

I experienced the back yard on a Monday night. Granny bingo was going on, but I did not participate. The bar was open in the back and food could be ordered from a different stand. The menu for the backyard was smaller than the menu inside the restaurant. I ordered chicken tenders from the kids menu and it was a great size meal. The French fries were so good! read more

Matty's Bar & Grille - Granny Bingo - American Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

See all

Mattys is a solid neighborhood choice for drinks, dinner, and everything in between. Most recently, I went for brunch. Mattys is very well ran. The staff is so attentive. There was a short wait for a table on a Sunday around 11am. The place was packed (and even more so as I was leaving). The omelette and breakfast sandwich were terrific. There is tons of seating and a huge parking lot. They have a HUGE yard area with the biggest TV and bleacher seating. Firepit areas with seating. Great place to watch a game. Definitely give it a try! read more

Matty's Bar & Grille - Vege omelette with fruit and toast - American Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

See all

I've been to Mattys a bunch of times but I previously haven't reviewed them. First of all, the positive. Super busy Friday night but I found a seat at the bar and was served right away. I ordered a drink. They do a ton of premixed cocktails so if that isn't your jam, be warned. They have a stellar whiskey selection for these parts though. I ordered the perch fry with fries. This is where the true disappointment began. Expecting fries, I was shocked when the food showed up with wedges on the plate. I asked if they made a mistake but the bartender said they made the change a year ago. Mattys. Update your menu. Wedges are not fries, and to boot they weren't even crispy. Total false advertising here. If i come back, different choices will be made. read more

Such a fun place and it's huge! I got a wrap and I'd rate that 3-4 stars. But the sweet potato fries. Insane. Definitely recommend coming for a game on a nice night out. read more

Matty's Bar & Grille - Wrap w Sweet Potato Fries - American Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

See all

Great atmosphere and an awesome outdoor space! The food overall was solid, though the cheese curds were just okay. However, if you're a bourbon fan, their massive selection completely steals the show. Definitely worth checking out for the drinks and the patio vibes! read more

See all

Matty's is a place I've driven by numerous times but never gone in. We stopped here with friends, and I'm so glad they wanted to meet up here. It was a Friday, and they were very busy. We headed to the back, where the various bars for drinks were open. The lines weren't too long, but people were everywhere, talking it up and having a great time. It was estimated to be around an hour for a table, but we got seated in under 30 minutes. You can grab about any drink you can think of, and if you're a whiskey or bourbon fan, there are plenty of options to choose from. We got seated inside, and behind us were so many options for spirits to purchase--it was fun just to look over everything they had. On top of that, there was a guy going around giving samples of spirits, so you can always get lucky that way and grab a sample of a possible future purchase We got salads, burgers, cheese curds, and other items. The food was excellent, and I was starving. If you left the place hungry, that's your fault--portion sizes were large, and the food was filling. The place was certainly noisy, and that's to be expected. This wasn't a problem, but keep it in mind. That Friday energy had people laughing, telling their stories from the week, and enjoying the food. Our server was extremely attentive and kept track of everything amidst so much going on there. I was really impressed with both the food and service. Can't wait to make it back there! read more

See all

If you haven't tried the brisket Mac n cheese you are missing out!!!! Please don't ever get rid of this! Great service, great food everytime!! read more

Been going to Matty's for the last 20 years. What is so impressive is that this business has grown from the small neighborhood bar into the multi-faceted food/entertainment venue that it has become. In all this time, they continue to provide friendly service, a relaxing/casual environment, and high quality, creative menu items. There are outside areas that include a couple patios, a stage for live music, and a fire pit for mingling. We had reservations on a Wednesday night, and got in right away. We sat in the bar area, which was nearly full. It was loud, but we were able to have a conversation without shouting. Our server did a great job of getting us settled in, and throughout the entire night (thanks Mac!) For starters some of us got the Old Fashioned on Tap, a Beer, and a regular mixed Old Fashioned. The table consensus is that tap Old Fashioned not nearly as good as the mixed version. It's the week before St. Pattys so there was a special menu that had corn beef entrees. We got the Reuben Sandwich, the Corned Beef Dinner, and a couple of the "Luck of the Irish Burger". We didn't have to wait long for food, and everything was hot. Everyone had good things to say about their dinners. The smash burgers were good (although my preference is to have a larger patty cooked to medium-rare), the sauce was tasty without being overpowering, and the potato bun was a unique touch. Had a bite of the Reuben and it was also excellent. We had a birthday in our group, and you get a free dessert for the occasion. We ended up all sharing a piece of the chocolate peanut butter pie. It was such an decadent treat after the meal. Two big bites for each of us. Matty's is a very nice place that checks all the boxes. read more

See all

I've been there twice and the food was not great. for the price I didn't think the quality was very good. lots of people like it. Just not me. read more

Great selection of bourbon. Food is good also. Generally a fun place to have a meal and a drink. Occasionally a victim of its own popularity. read more

Great Hamburgers! Our sever Christine was very attentive . There is a bar section to sit in or a dining area with tables and chairs High and low type . Boy and girls restrooms. I was very full after the bigger with no room for desert but the desert menu looked great! Nice music playing in the background . read more

See all

Went for bloody Mary's and something to eat. The bloody Mary's were OK could've used more vodka in them, but they did have a nice array of skewered stuff. The server was great. She was funny and very friendly. it's very loud inside, but that's a bar. read more

8/2026 We had our wedding reception at Matty's Bar and Grille, the hall, behind the bar/restaurant. It was amazing! I usually do not give 5 stars because I do not think any place is perfect, BUT that said the service was off the charts, food was great, and price was reasonable. I highly recommend Mattys hall for parties and Matty's catering. Numerous guests came up to us and told us how wonderful the venue, service, and food was. They loved it!! As did we. Huge shout out to the management and staff, Melissa, Kalyee, Emily, Tim, Kayden, and Chris. Thank you so much for making our special day fabulous!!! And Emily thank you for keeping me on task. LOL.... read more

This place is solid. My wife and I stopped in for lunch on Monday October 14th. She had the Turkey Cobb Salad. The ingredients were all very fresh. I had the special which was Pork Schnitzel with Mashed Potatoes and Asparagus. The Schnitzel was excellent. The potatoes had good flavor but were lumpier than I prefer. We split a cup of French Onion Soup, and it was outstanding. Not sure if I'll ever return to New Berlin, but if I do I'll stop by Matty's! read more

See all

Courtney and Christian were great for dog in the park night , very helpful and provided quick and successful service throughout the entire night read more

Great food, bar big and the whole outdoor area is SO SO GREAT!!! Love Mattys! waitstaff is A1, again food Outstanding great service. Love the "BIG BAR!" Last but not least a Great Place to Hang out!!! read more

I just have to give a shout out to Matty's. For two months in a row I made reservations with them for a group of about 30 women, and they always accommodate. Today I appreciated their wonderful flexibility. Initially I had made the reservation for outside, but due to the cool weather I phoned at 9:30 for our 11:30 reservation and asked if they could instead seat us indoors. And they did!!! We had a wonderful server. Shout out to Mary Margaret. She obviously loved her work and was so very friendly and efficient with our large group. Everyone enjoyed their food. Not one complaint. If you are looking for a place to host a large group, look no further than Matty's. read more

tl;dr MaryLee made the whole gosh darn visit! I have never been here before, as it's a little bit out of the way from my normal Bayview/Saint Francis type location close to home. However, my best friend in the entire world lives in Waukesha so this general area is a great middle spot. I was searching (of course on Yelp) to find a great spot and saw the large volume of reviews for Matty's, so decided to give it a shot! Matty's was already hoppin' when we got there on a Wednesday night. It's freezing right now (January) but I hear that they do some amazing live music and have a great outdoor patio when the weather is nice. I had reserved a table, so got immediately seated and was met by the sweet-talking, smart-selling, amazing waitress that is MaryLee. She was funny, bubbly, kind and made sure we had EVERYTHING we needed. She enticed us for the on tap bourbon old fashioned (we were a little skeptical, but she steered us right as the on tap was surprisingly good!) We almost got the mozzarella logs, but instead started off with their homemade chips and grandma's onion dip. Holy cow was it good. Dangerously good. The chips were fresh and super crispy/crunchy and anyone who likes any kind of chip dip is going to have a home run with "grannys". MaryLee explained how they're famously known for their burgers and pizzas, so we decided on the Meatlovers thin crust. I am VERY particular about my thin crust pizza. To be honest, there is really only one thin crust pizza I tout and recommend to everyone (Vinchi's) however, I can confidently say after my time at Matty's - I have another name and contender to throw in the mix for "BEST THIN CRUST PIZZA AROUND." it had the perfect ratio of sauce, the crust was just as crispy as you'd want it to be without toying on the edge of burnt and the toppings WERE BANGING. MaryLee checked in on constantly to make sure everything was tasting great and got us our takeout container for our delicious (and held up surprisingly well next day) leftovers. She is a stellar employee and clearly reps this place well. She alone would make me return, but luckily Matty's food and drinks are pretty damn good, too. Even though it's a bit of a drive for me, we will be back! read more

Matty's Bar & Grille - Meat lovers pizza - American Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

See all

1.) The cheese curds had a nice crispy batter, but that was about it. They were flavorless and the ranch had the consistency of water. 2.) The French onion burger had way too much French onion dip, overpowering the burger. The Swiss cheese was also not melted because of the cold dip. 3.) I ordered a side of Mac and cheese which ended up being comically tiny and luke warm. We also got charged for the Mac and cheese, even though we sent it back. I cannot recommend this place. The food was nothing special and every element was disappointing in one way or another. Way overhyped. read more

I saw that Matty's Bar & Grille was close to a place I was visiting on a Sunday morning, so I looked at their online menu to see if they had a breakfast burrito. What caught my eye, though, was the Little Caesar, which was the burger special of the week in mid-February 2024. I called around 10:40am to make sure I could order it in case it was too early in the day or not the current week's burger special and they said I could get it. I addition to the Little Caesar (I went with fries for the side) I got cheese curds. The cheese curds were great. Perfectly crunchy and I feel like I got a good amount for the price. Absolutely something I would get again. The fries were battered, which I like for the extra crunch the batter adds. The Little Caesar, which I got without the sun dried tomatoes, was very good. The flavors of the burger and Caesar salad on top blended together well and yet at the same time I could taste them individually. It's not the best burger overall that I've ever had, but in terms of specialty burgers, it may be among the best. read more

See all

We had a table of 8 and our soups were Luke warm and most of our meals weren't warm. Our server Abby S was awesome but food could be hot when delivered to the table. I was so excited about the French onion soup and was disappointed because it was barley Luke warm read more

I can't believe I never reviewed this place. I've been coming here a couple of times a year for over 20 years! It's been great watching the business grow and expand the facilities and offerings. They make amazing "bar food," and it's only bar food because it's a bar, when in reality, I think the food here is better than a LOT of restaurants around town, and therefore, has some of the best, if not the best bar food around SE WI. While they have grown, COVID has also caused a shift in focus, away from food trucks and off-site catering, to serving their customers on-site with the best experience they can. That includes live music on the patio and a "big back yard" with a MASSIVE screen for watching games. Burgers and thin crust pizzas are great, but on my most recent visit, I had my mind blown by a Short Rib Pot Roast dish I had two nights ago. Instead of a typical bowl of "stew," this was a plate of incredibly tender and perfectly seasoned beef short rib, with potatoes and onions and just enough roux to wet the ingredients while still allowing the short rib to rightfully be the star! It came with my choice of side, and I opted for the mashed potatoes, which had a few pieces of potato skin to announce that they were made in house and not from a box. My friend loved the French Onion Burger she ordered, and now I have to go back soon to get one, and we shared a Creme Brulee Cheesecake slice that was great without needing whipped cream or sauce to make it great. I've attended events here, such as bourbon tastings and bottle releases, and I've watched their selection of bourbons grow exponentially in just a year. Clearly, they want to be known as a "Bourbon Bar," in addition to having great food. I think they succeeded. I live close to downtown MKE, so it's rare for me to venture to the burbs, but Matty's is on the very short list of places I'm willing to break my routine for. read more

See all

Mackenzie was amazing!!! Service was fast and super friendly! Food was superb, love the onion dip.

Cozy, warm and inviting on a below zero night. Started with mozzarella logs with an amazing cheese pull. Marinara sauce was sweet and balanced but would prefer a bowl vs plate to dip. French onion burger was the perfect medium and saucy. Kids demolished the mac and sliders (extra pickles!). And not a crumb or drizzle left of the chocolate cake. My 10 year old said the ganache gods were pleased. Service was prompt, requests were met, it was a great dinner experience. read more

Matty's Bar & Grille - Mozzarella Logs - American Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

See all

Awesome restaurant with a huge outdoor area with bonfires and a large stage where they play sporting events in the TV. Several bars to choose from. Great service and our food and drinks were wonderful! read more

See all

Our food is always great and I met Mallory and she was great. I understand you are getting a new app and upgrading. She explained everything to me and I appreciate that. She really has gone well above in the service area. Pleasant accommodating and was so thoughtful! Good employees are hard to find but she is a keeper! read more

The staff could not be friendlier, even when it's busy with the Packers game, somebody is always available to stop by and see if you need a refill or if food's OK, it's a great combination of a local bar with great food and a sports bar, but the owner and the staff take pride and what they do and I would recommend it to anyone looking for a great local place. read more

loved it! haven't been in many yrs, and all the changes are great! our server Mac was awesome! easy vibe, smart, funny af and efficient! we will def be back.. read more

Good food friendly service. Great outdoor venue. Outdoor TV's and separate party room for large gatherings. Also have a neat setup for viewing Packer games with a group of friends. read more

Shout out to Mackenzie at Matty's Bar & Grille. She made our dinner experience amazing. Our drinks were always full, and she made excellent suggestions. Thanks Mackenzie for going above and beyond for us. The food was excellent which mad our overall dinning experience awesome. read more

I've been going into the Brookfield Marty's for at least 60 years and instead of going with my older brother was a regular, he's the one that would say give me the largest pizza and stretch it and it's still on the menu! So until he moved away after about 35 years. This was his favorite restaurant and is my Prized and valued for the memories and for the way they treated my brother and myself now too the pizza is incredible and incredibly good read more

Fun atmosphere. Went on a Friday night. There was live music and the weather was nice so it was very busy. Put our name in for 8 ppl at 6pm and we were sat within 45 min outside which I was impressed about... (maybe we were just lucky). The fish fry was very good, potato pancakes were ok, fries were better in my opinion. I'd def order again. We also ordered the spinach artichoke dip and while it was good, I wasn't overly impressed. Came in a bread bowl and I feel like the portion was small because of it. I was more than happy with my overall experience and would definitely come back again but would maybe try a different night of the week in hopes it's less busy :) read more

Matty's Bar & Grille - Fries - American Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

See all

Abby M was such a delight! She didn't just make sure I had the best food and drinks; she made me feel at home. I would come back here for not only the ambiance but also the service and personal connection. read more