This is truly Long Island's most efficient McDonald's. It was 7 years ago when I'd be near this one more - and it is still now. They have to be because people love the location right off the SS Parkway on 5th Avenue in Bayshore. Easy to pull in and easy to get back on the Parkway and lose verrrry little time. Their speediness was noticed and appreciated- the woman at the window was super pleasant and helpful. read more

Don't touch this place with a 10-foot pole. The bright girl who took our order rung our MEALS up as ALL INDIVIDUAL items and something we DIDN'T ORDER so our bill was way more than it should've been. So we ask for a refund and to be charged for it as MEALS and instead of refunding and recharging as meals they ONLY refunded us for the ITEM WE DID NOT ORDER and DIDN'T CHARGE THE FOOD AS MEALS STILL, BURNING OUR MONEY. This location needs to fire these incompetent late night employees and get some people that can maybe count at least a tiny bit. Do not waste your time and money at this location, there's better nearby. Cannot believe these kids' incompetency. read more

They're saying the N word in the drive thru..... smh. Sad. Very disappointed. Everyone young and goofing off handling food.

Love the little Big Mac! It's about time they made a smaller version! I wish they had gluten free bread options though! Maybe one day... McDonald's should also bring back the CHICKEN FAJITA!!!!!!! read more

workers were a little passive aggresive but ok. they mess up my order 50% of the time. food is as expected.

I am giving it 3 stars because they used to be so much better. Lately, they are constantly forgetting something from the order. It happened a few times so I called and was told they put me on a list and next time I come they will make it up. The next time I was there, I gave my name and they called up a manager who acted like I was nuts. She said she would do it as a "courtesy" but to next time have a receipt. That pissed me off and I handed her the receipt. I informed her that I didn't even call the first times it happened and she said "oh well there's nothing i can do about that. I'm not making up for that". No one said she had to, I was just informing her it wasn't like i was out for a free cheeseburger making up stories. They messed up my order again tonight so I made sure to get a name of the person who assured me I could get a replacement. read more

typical McDonald's all food is basically the same quality all around. drive through line is however always slow and long. biggest disappointment was ordering a diet coke and getting home and realizing they gave me a regular coke read more

Ok two stars is fair to this McD's the food like you know is ok. but the drive through needs work they always seem to miss a item like 5 out 10 times something is always missing. so always check your back if you're going through the drive through. read more

I think this is the stingiest McDonald's I've ever ordered from. The constantly forget sauce and it doesn't matter how manny daises you add to your cart the will deliberately not give it to you. read more

This McDonald's opened about 2-3 years and since it has opened, they've had the same manager. A couple of nights ago it was about 3AM and he took my order with much description and energy. He is absolutely fantastic and is amazing at his job! Get him a raise! read more

This is a good place to go sometimes, the food may be very salted or under salted I order specific food and I don't get what I paid for. read more

McDonald's - a person holding a sandwich in their hand - Fast Food Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Multiple employees not wearing gloves, caught one through the drive-thru window putting his hands in my bag with no gloves on. Told them I no longer trust them and asked for my money back. read more

I went in the drive through thos morning and asked for a special I had a coupon for with tea I was missing a sandwich a syrup a hash brown coffee instead of tea and I was very over charges read more

For families who need a quick McDonald's stop on the way to or back from the Fire Island Ferry (going to Kismet, Saltaire, Fair Harbor, or Dunewood), I would recommend the location of this clean, bright facility. Conveniently located just north of the intersection of Fifth Avenue and Southern State Parkway, it has a drive-thru and ample parking for dining in. We stopped here after taking the early morning ferry (7:30am) from Fire Island to pickup Egg McMuffins before a long drive back through NYC and over into New Jersey. The exit from this McDonald's drive-thru leads you right to the westbound entrance of the Southern State Parkway, which places you just before the Sagitkos Parkway exit. read more

To put it simply, today ruined this McDonald's. I found a black bug-sized thing floating in my Sprite after I already drank it, and when I went back in it took several minutes to get a hold of someone because nobody was working the register. They forgot all of the sauces I requested and didn't even give me a drink cup for my order when I paid. I think this place really needs extra attention to the customer if they're able to hire more people. It's only okay on their best days. read more

Love coming here, messed up my iced coffee like twice but food order is usually always right.

Slow service. Long wait time on drive thru. Poor management. Missing food items and wrong price orders. read more

This is a full-service location with a complete menu. The dining room is clean and bright. As this is a relatively new location, the counter service could be better. However, it is quick and the food, for fast food, is good. This location opened as Hurricane Sandy and Winter Storm Athena came through the area and they were one of the few locations in the area that had electricity. The staff performed fantastically in a difficult situation. So, a hearty "Thanks" for that! read more

i spent $60 on a dordash order and they forgot my burger. i tried calling back and they never answered. im very upsey that i paid money and i did not receive my money's worth. read more

Choose another Mcdonald's, they do not accept mobile deals. If this changes I will update review. See my screenshot when I tried ordering this BOGO deal in Jan 2018. read more

McDonald's - They don't accept mobile coupon deals (see top of photo) - Fast Food Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

The crew trainer Steven was wonderful... awesome McDonald's they all act like a big family I really wish I Worked there

the food was perfect! well cooked. but the shocking part is when I was digging into these hot McNuggets, there was some part of the chicken that looked like a bone or something else inside my chicken nuggets! there was something else that came in the box that looked like a fried cashew. read more

Grietar Mc Donald's they will bring the food to the table for you and they don't overcharge you if you want extras on your hamburgers such as Big Mac sauce clean courteous read more

one of y'all's worker forgot my damn chicken nugget. playing with my emotions. ya don't gotta do me like this bro. i ordered 10 & received 9. i counted them shits cause i know sum wasn't right. was tight af. i'll give 3 stars cause the fries was good and all. them sprite be dangerous do not get that shit. but anyways don't forget my chicken nugget ever again. read more

So disappointing when you pay extra for something get all the way home and it's not what you wanted. The place is overall clean. Just not the first time this has happened with my orders. read more

I wish they had the option for "No Stars". They ALWAYS mess up my order. I go there every morning and everyday they mess something up. Whether its basic things, like remembering to put sugar in my coffee, I always ask for egg whites, they always put regular eggs, and the managers are cold and have an attitude. I wish there was a different location closer to me so I didn't have to rely on this place for my breakfast. read more

There are three mcdonalds around my area and this one by far is the best.. The food is fresh and the price for my usual iced coffee is cheaper than what i pay at the other locations they also have the sauce i like where as the others do not even carry it .. Never had a problem yet.. Def recommend this location read more

Havent been here in the day time but they have the best fries at night ! Always fresh right out the fryer

I've always had a good experience at this McDonald's, the staff is friendly and efficient. My order is always correct and I see the manager trying to aid his staff and move things along. read more

Worst ever. The majority of the time they can't get my order right. Something as simple as black coffee with sugar was too hard for them to get, I just ended up leaving. I tried ordering a Big Mac with extra pickles and onions. I told him 5 times and they still couldn't get it right. I just don't go to there any longer. I am giving them 1 star only because this app will not let me give it 0 stars. read more

This is the WORST mcdonalds on long island and i've lived here for 18 years. They recently got it rebuilt, but you would've thought the service would improve as well. WRONG. I went through the drive thru with a simple order, two bacon mcdoubles only ketchup and bacon, no cheese. I paid and got my food. I open the bag to find two sandwiches with cheese. I check my receipt and it says no cheese ... so why did my order have cheese ?? I go inside to get it corrected, i wait at the register for 10 minutes until someone bothered to ask what the problem was. He grabs my food and tells the grill. I move over to the side and wait another 10 minutes for my CORRECT order. There were plenty of workers just standing around doing nothing. I wouldn't come back here even if you paid me. Being a former mcdonalds employee i understand the stress and environment, but it shouldn't take that long. Take my advice and just settle for wendys. read more

Wish I didnt have to pick a star!!!!!! So lets just start by saying I work late nights usually get out late and end up stopping here on my way home and no matter if you are the only car in the drive thru or a line of cars behind you you can wait anywhere from 10-45 mins for food. This place is obviously poorly managed during the night time hours if there is only 3 people scheduled to work and a 45 min wait tonight.I WANT TO KNOW WHAT IN MCDONALDS KITCHEN COULD TAKE THAT LONG? No one knew of course but it took them that long! i was far from the only person pissed off tn! when i said i could have went to islip ate and been home by now he said okay go there from now on! SO I WILL! After waiting all this time you would think they could get my simple order correct?!? haha nope i order a number 3 plain with a dr pepper a med coke and 3- 4 piece nuggets and i get about 5 useless bugers with bacon and add mc sauce..gross! but silly me didnt check till i got home cuz i didnt think they could screw so many things up in one night! i was banging on the window because the genius who took my order didnt give me my other drink. When an employee (he said his name was kelly i think) spotted me and asked to help me? and i explained and he said i honestly cant even tell you whats going on i just know management wont be happy tomorrow..and sadly that is the best answer i got all night. Not that it was a bad answer but i could have got a little further with a manager which i think he showed initiative tonight and took charge when a manager couldnt! that says a whole lot and that is a great employee right there and what you should want to see in your management. Anyways after i get home and check the order call the useless moron manager they have working tonight (anna?) she says "u can drive back and come pick up ur order i have it right here?" oh yeah i know i could do that ya genius! but why would i want to waste more time energy and gas? Why did it take so long and why wasnt it atleast right?she says "well like i said i have it right here" well im not driving back at 3 in the morning when i got there at 2am t come back for my food. in case you were wondering you could have offered me coupons for free food next time (and a bunch of them at that because of how RIDICULOUS tonight was) or could have told me ill have someone above me that is important contact you back tomorrow, or appologized to start! read more