WTH happened to this place? The meat was sitting out, precooked. They put it on the grill to warm…read moreit up. It wasn't seasoned Fries were cold. They been sitting out for awhile also. This place used to be really good. This was the one downtown Harrisburg. They fell off big time

Good Cheesesteak with fresh Philly style roll and chopped steak. Very friendly staff, decent…read moreprices and the Inside was clean and had plenty of space to eat.

My first home is New York City, my second home is Philadelphia, and now my third home--due to just…read morehaters--is Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. This is probably the reason most entertainers and people of fame who come from Harrisburg move away and don't say they are from there But anyway... Me, having Philly family and being a Philly fan of everything, especially those Eagles (don't stop reading because of that!), I had a chance to get a cheesesteak from South Philly Hoagie, and let me tell you, I was impressed. The bread makes everything, and then of course the meat. I ordered mine with mayonnaise, cheese whiz, and of course, mushrooms. Now, I did order it through the Uber Eats app, and I wish I could've added provolone, but I never had to add pizza sauce to my cheesesteak until today. I'm glad I did! It made it pop, even though it was missing that provolone. One thing I do wish is that they would actually take the bread and get some of that steak juice right on the bun. Other than that, I'm not mad at it. Of course, it's not Philly. It didn't bounce me right back to the hometown of Will Smith, and it didn't have me saying "I'M A WORK OF ART." However, I was pleased and satisfied. Maybe the flavoring can hold me over until my next pay next week so I can take a train down to Philly. The French fries were amazing, if I must say. The sub was plenty full and had plenty of meat on it. If you asked me, "Would I buy this again?" Yes, I definitely would! And I would do it over-the-counter so I can have it my way, like Burger King! Branden-Lee AKA B L E E

Stopped by on the way home on a roadtrip and I'm so glad we did. I ordered a 12" but the 6"…read moresandwich was plenty enough for a filling lunch. They piled the meat high and it eas super tender. The sandwich I ordered had red sauce that I asked to be removed and it was perfect. They made the order super quickly and we were back on our road trip in less than 10 minutes. The place is a super small place with no seating inside so beware.

We finally got to try The Cheesesteak Guy the other day & it was pretty good…read more The employee was very friendly & explained everything for us & we both did build your own cheesesteaks. They really STUFF these guys full which is nice. My boyfriend really enjoyed his. Mine was super greasy so I had to dab that off as best I could. It was good but it didn't really hit the spot for me. My quest for the cheesesteaks continues.

We stopped by The Cheesesteak Guy on a Friday night about an hour before closing. There were a few…read morepeople there when we arrived, and more filtered in as the evening went on--always a good sign. I ordered the Cacio e Pepe Cheesesteak for $16, while my dining companion went with a traditional Cooper cheesesteak with onions and peppers on a non-seeded roll ($15), plus an order of tater tots ($5). We both grabbed sodas for $3 each, and our grand total--including tip--was just over $50. The traditional Cooper cheesesteak, tots, and sodas were pretty run-of-the-mill--solid, satisfying, and exactly what you'd expect. But the Cacio e Pepe Cheesesteak? That deserves special attention. The Cheesesteak Guy raves about this sandwich on Facebook, describing it as a fusion of the classic Philly cheesesteak and the Roman pasta dish Cacio e Pepe--and for once, the hype is fully justified. Thinly sliced ribeye topped with melted Pecorino Romano and a generous amount of freshly cracked black pepper, all on a perfectly seeded roll. It was rich, indulgent, and gloriously peppery in the best way. Plenty of Pecorino (which is currently my favorite cheese), bold flavor, and a roll that held everything together beautifully. Truly perfection in a bun--tender, savory, and downright unforgettable. My only suggestion? A little more consistency in the meat prep. Some chunks of ribeye inside my sandwich were quite large and seemed to miss the slice-and-dice phase. Still delicious, but smaller, evenly chopped pieces would make it easier to eat and even better overall. That said, I'll absolutely be back--Patty Melt and Greek Burger are already on my list. Bonus points for plentiful free parking since it's located in a strip mall. One tip if you're going at night: pay close attention, because the sign isn't lit and can be easy to miss in the dark. If you're craving a cheesesteak with a creative twist, don't sleep on the Cacio e Pepe. It's something special.

The service was good. It's a small place, yes it's located on the side of an another business, but…read morethese small restaurants are where you find the good stuff! The cheesesteak was very good! The bread and steak were delicious, even the wiz went well with it, although putting it on before the meat is a little different. The brisket sandwich, I was not a fan of. It's just my opinion but it's served pretty basic. It comes with au jus, but that doesn't really add much. It's kind of bland, and it doesn't taste like it was smoked, idk how they prepared the meat, or if they get it delivered, but it was very bland. I've read other reviews of people saying they waited over an hour and this and that, but I got my sandwich's pretty quickly! Hot and ready to go! I would definitely recommend this place if you're in the area! I ordered Mac salad but I got potato salad instead, but I don't hold that against them, accidents happen, and the potato salad was good!

I saw a glowing review of this place on Facebook, so I was eager to try it. It said it is less than…read more30 minutes from Harrisburg, so I drove up after work in Harrisburg. When I arrived, I was told it would be one hour for a hot sandwich, or 40 minutes for a cold sandwich. They have 3 or 4 tables placed end to end to make one long table. Someone was seated at the table, so I could hardly get by to go to the restroom. I left without getting anything. There are some picnic tables outside. This place is basically a takeout place for the locals. Recommend getting a sandwich at one of the Harrisburg places. Do not plan to return.

Tried the honey butter chicken cheesesteak and it was phenomenal!! My son got the chicken bacon…read moreranch cheesesteak, which he said is the best chicken bacon ranch cheesesteak he has ever had! The staff and owners are truly a gem, going above and beyond "normal" customer service!! We highly recommend Stuff'D Steaks & Hoagies

I ordered an OG steak sandwich and while the meat was a bit dry it was absolutely delicious. The…read moreroll made it! It was busy due to a concert at the Giant center but they made sure the food was served quickly.

By far the best cheese steak we have ever eaten. We are from the Baltimore area and have had…read morehundreds of cheese steaks before. Some were great, some good and others should have never been called cheese steak subs. We moved to PA a few years back and have explored our community for the best places to eat. It was one day about 3 months ago, my wife and me had a hankering for a really good cheese steak sub. We punched in the request in our GPS and several places displayed upon the screen. After a quick check on reviews of the various locations, we settled on South Philly Hogies. Although the trip was 18 minutes away at 23 miles, off we went to try this establishment. We both ordered the California Cheese Steak and fries. We drove home and I can tell you by far this was the best Cheese Steak we had ever eaten. The bread it is served on is so soft and fresh and they have no issues with making it your way. I would be remiss if I didn't make mention that the staff are always nice and friendly. The quality and quantity that you get with your order almost seems impossible these days. We were so pleased that every time a family visits us here in PA, South Philly Hogies will always get a stop from us. We enjoyed every bite and discovered that we like it so much that as soon as we receive our food, we travel to the shopping mall and eat on the lot. We never make it home now with our food. All you hear in the car is lips smacking and people saying "um, um , um" I must also report that they are truly wonderful with regard to prices. I have paid upwards of almost $30.00 for the food we ordered from other establishments and the food was not that great at all. Not wishing to see price increased at this location but I would gladly pay a little more because they are that good. Thank you guys for doing such a great job with your service and your food. We will see you again as you are now on our once every 2 week visit list. For ever! Mr. & Mrs. Green

While our first impressions left us a little concerned, when the food arrived, we weren't…read moredisappointed! There was only one young man there when we arrived who took our orders and then said "this may take a few minutes, I'm the only one here and I don't know how to make the sandwiches". We then sat in the dark dining room wondering if we made the right choice and what to expect. About 25 minutes later (as promised) he came out with our food. They looked and tasted fantastic! A second older man brought out the last one and apologized for his absence as he had been delayed while buying supplies. He turned on the lights and we had an excellent lunch (along with a good story). If you like a great cheese steak sandwich, on tasty bread, this is the place in Red Lion. It is staying on our list for our next visit!

They have my very favorite cheese steak! They are filled to over-flowing with meat! Should…read moreprobably be eaten in two meals, but it is sooo good that I always eat the whole thing!!!! As others have said, you sometimes have to wait a bit for your order as there is usually only one person there, but they are worth the wait!

Cannot recommend this spot enough. Excellent food and friendly, genuine service…read more My girlfriend and I split a Large Steak Surf N Turf, a Small Chicken Philly and an order of Garlic Butter Seafood Fries for pickup. Now, neither of us is shy about effin' up some good food, but we could not finish everything. The servings are large, the meat and seafood portions more than generous, and the flavors pop! We were not even halfway through our meal before we were discussing our next visit. Real Philly, welcome to York!

Absolutely stellar customer service. Got the 12" and didn't realize i needed to scroll down to…read moreorder the fixings. The worker was very helpful and took my additional toppings order perfectly and made sure they were on the sandwich as requested. It is the best cheesesteak I've ever had in my life and to be fair I trusted the recommendation for marinara which Ive never tried before. It was absolutely mouthwatering and top notch quality . Would definitely return again if I was local.