My jeweler for over 40 years. Never disappoints. Great to work with. Can always be trusted to find…read morea solution to your needs.

I highly recommend Aronstam Jewelers! Marc Aronstam is a very creative artist & is great to work…read morewith! Over the past 5 years, I have worked with Marc to reset, redesign and update family heirloom pieces, including an antique ring and loose stones to create pendants and earrings that suit me. He considers my style preferences, budget and the character of the original pieces. His recommendations and final designs have resulted in exquisite statement pieces that have exceeded my expectations. These new pendants and earrings are now my favorite pieces & will be heirlooms for the next generation of my family!

I was suppose to write this a while ago but work etc and getting locked out of my account made it…read moredifficult. Anyways, I have to say I love this place... though to be perfectly honest I have yet to physically visit. For context my experience was initially online then via phone. I was trying to pre-order a seiko Pepsi watch and this was the only location that was doing pre-orders without marking it up 2~5 x the price. I couldn't put a deposit down but I could add myself to a waiting list. Few weeks went by and I had forgotten about it and accepted it probably just wasn't in the stars for me to get a collector's watch at retail. Then Joe Moyer reaches out to me. We talk and he asks me about myself and if I was still interested in the watch. I know it doesn't sound like much but I think it's more about what it didn't sound like. It didn't sound sketch or overly transactional. It genuinely felt like a conversation and I didn't feel duped or have buyers remorse afterwards.

My brother brought my son in to pick out a watch for graduation. They both had a great experience…read moreand felt like they were treated the same as a someone buying a $50,000 watch. Thank you for creating a special memory for my son!

Lois is great! She was willing to work on my weird project - a custom watch band for a vintage…read morewatch that is not a Rolex or something else expensive. She has old school classic jewelry repair know how that is nearly impossible to find these days. I take all my repairs here now.

Highly recommend Barrington Jewels if you are looking to customize a piece for yourself. The staff…read moreis friendly and able to make recommendations on how to best make the item work. I took in a pair of ear cuffs from Hearts on Fire. They were individual cuffs that could be easily taken on/off (they didn't have an ear post). I loved them but I'd almost lost them at least twice when wearing them so I was looking for a way to turn them into a more permanent ear decoration. Barrington helped me get the two cuffs sauntered together and added a post so I'd be able to wear them without fear of losing them! I loved the finished product. The price was reasonable as well! Very happy with my experience! Thank you Barrington!

I had a wonderful time exploring this store. They have a wide selection of unique gif worthy items…read morefor any celebration. I must say some items seemed on the pricier side to me. The service was wonderful! The staff is so helpful and courteous. They answered our questions and took the time to take us around the store as needed.

My daughter loves Silver in the City, so this is where I go when I want to pick her up a special…read moregift. I usually shop at the store on Mass Ave, but I was in Carmel, so decided to check it out. The clerks were busy stocking shelves for Christmas when we entered, but welcomed us with big smiles. The shop seems a bit smaller that their other location, but still carries most of the same merchandise. They are known for their silver jewelry by various artists. Currently, they are featuring charm necklaces. An Indiana theme runs throughout the store with everything from Indiana necklaces to Indiana kitchen towels. It's a great place to pick up a gift with candles, art and even some local foods. I even saw a few toys and puzzles today for the kids. I was looking for a funny card and they have a small selection of cards but they were somewhat inappropriate to give a daughter. But they do have lots of crazy socks. There is street parking or parking behind the building.

My wife and I have been going exclusively to Reis-Nichols since we got married six years ago, and…read morewe wouldn't go anywhere else. From the very first time we walked in and met our jeweler Kathleen (who we still work with today because she's truly the best) we knew we were in great hands. They always take amazing care of us. Whether you come in knowing exactly what you want or, like us, not knowing much at all, the team treats you with the respect and attention you deserve. They're patient, knowledgeable, and genuinely want to help you find the best fit and value. If you're looking for a place you can trust and keep coming back to for years, this is it. Expect to find your forever jewelry home too!

The Reis-Nichols team feels more like old friends and family! Spencer, George, Therese, Cole and…read morethe entire gang make every experience amazing. They take special days and make them unforgettable moments!!

After reading the other reviews, I have to say that you can't rush quality. You want a custom,…read morebeautiful and one-of a kind ring? Well, it may take a few weeks for all kinds of reasons like ordering materials, the artist has a backlog... etc? If you want 'quick' you should go to a commercial, boring, big box jeweler. Ok, mini rant over. Let's talk about Mark and the work he has done for me and my husband. My husband wanted to have a custom engagement ring made for me. He had a design in mind and a recommendation from a family member to see Mark. Mark gave great advice on sizing, diamond quality and integrity of the band design. He even showed my husband the difference between Russian and Israeli cut diamonds (um, huge difference). Without Mark's advice I would have gotten a ring from somewhere else that needs adjusting all the time (I had a lot of single prong stuff in mind for the band, bad idea) . Mark can also order directly from a manufacturer, which is what we did for our wedding bands. It's cheaper than custom and, like another reviewer said, the prices are clearly stated in the manufacturer's ordering book at market prices. In the end the design I wanted had already been made - so why have it done at a custom price? I appreciated Mark's honesty and transparency on that decision. Lastly, Mark and his wife are kind and fair people. No pressuring you into something you don't want or can't afford. We had a great buying experience for all three purchases so far.

I got to work with Mark on designing an engagement ring with a sapphire I had in mind. He was very…read morecollaborative in sketching and conceptualizing the curves and setting scheme, set up some consultations to review the design and waxes as it progressed, and made recommendations as to some of the particulars. Didn't feel pressured or any unpleasant sales-y atmosphere, and Paula was great too. Fiancée is also very pleased with the outcome! As mentioned in some of the other reviews, allow some extra time for variability in ordering things and other suppliers.

I had a few pieces that needed repair before an event and brought them to Indy Facets. They quoted…read moreme a date by which they could have the items fixed, but when they found out this was after my event they adjusted the schedule so I had them on time. The repair work was done well.

I had an idea for a gift for beautiful Susan for her birthday. It was a jewelry gift, so I knew…read morethere was only one place for me to go, Indy Facets Private Jeweler and Shaun Goodyear. Shaun had worked with me on Sue's engagement ring, and it was an amazing experience, an incredible ring, and a great value. I shared my idea for Sue's gift. Susan loves tanzanite, and Shaun looked at what I wanted for Sue and brought me a beautiful option he could have ready in time for Sue's birthday. As always, with Indy Facets, the outcome was perfect. It was a beautiful surprise last night, and I couldn't be happier with how it turned out!! I surprised Sue with her gift last night at dinner with our friends. I wanted her to have them to wear today on her birthday. Thanks again to Shaun and Indy Facets for creating such a beautiful gift for the birthday girl I love the most.