Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mexitaly

    4.9 (10 reviews)

    Mexitaly Photos

    MEXITALY ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mexitaly

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Spicy crab tacos so good!
    Mahogany D.

    Food is good drinks are better!! Definitely a place that is good to hit while in PR. Quick!

    Orquidea R.

    Really beautifully decorated and vibrant place centrally located. While it's supposed to be a combination of menus, Mexican, Italian, PuertoRican, the Mexican dishes and vibes are the most apparent. The drinks are great and strong which is a plus for your money. We had the carne ahumada skewers and the queso fundido dip, both excellent. Staff were attentive and friendly. We visited while a patron's birthday celebration and the staff made it very fun for them. I'd like to come back to try other things on the menu. As for drinks, this is the place to come!

    Margarita
    Stephanie S.

    Great place to check out in San Juan. The food and drinks were delicious. Our service was great. Recommend if you are looking for a good meal and a great vibe for dinner. I was surprised this place wasn't busier. It is an easy short walk from the main touristy restaurants in the Condado and worth it.

    Dining room area, wall decor. Love the vibes!
    Paulina L.

    We came for dinner after walking around Condado beach after the sunset. It was close by our airBnb so we could walk to and from here. They also had parking nearby. Our friend raved about this place and recommended some of his favorite things. We had Skillet queso fundido and Mozzerella sticks for appetizers. I loved their margaritas! Any flavor, you can't go wrong. Strawberry, Coco Strawberry, Passion Fruit. For the entree my partner and I shared the Tacos Mexitaly with ground beef made Supreme style. These were so delicious too. I would order these again next time. The servers were all so nice to us and pretty! We look forward to coming back in the future

    Burrito with a side of curly fries.

    See all

    15 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    20 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    22 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 hours ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Review Highlights - Mexitaly

    Literally the only restaurant that didn't disappoint.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Mexican 3,514 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    El Vagón - Ceviche tacos

    El Vagón

    4.6(283 reviews)
    0.4 km
    $

    This place is kinda spartan, first-come, outside , but mostly under a covering, tables. It is among…read morefast food restaurant chains in this hood, but this is an interesting original. We waved as we walked in to a waiter, pointed to a seemingly available picnic table, and he waved that we were good to go, so we sat right away, at 7:45p...after that more tables opened up. Drinks: 1. Pina colada - no bueno...like a coconut ice, not pina colada. 2. Passion fruit juice with fresh mint - delicious! 3. Cherry juice drink with alcohol - wife liked it, and I thought it was good. Appetizers: 1. Beef empanadas- I thought the crust overpowered the meat and onion, but daughter and wife loved it. 2. Nachos - terrible. Chips were stale and cheese/beans covering was bare, but then they gave us additional refried beans in a little cup, and straight I thought the refried beans were delicious. 3. Baha fish tacos - phenomenal!!! Entrees: 1 Chicken fajitas: disappointing. The spicing was off, on the chicken, and the guacamole was mostly sour cream. 2. Steak fajitas: very good and way better than the chicken Service was quick and the staff knew their stuff, but it took a long time to get the bill because other tables came in.

    The atmosphere is really great with chill, welcoming vibes. Service staff is friendly and…read moreattentive. The Baja fish tacos are amazing. Fresh and crispy, delightful. Get them.

    Photos
    El Vagón
    El Vagón - Baja fried fish tacos

    Baja fried fish tacos

    El Vagón - Shrimp Diabolo at El Vagòn

    See all

    Shrimp Diabolo at El Vagòn

    La Madre - Steak tacos

    La Madre

    4.2(699 reviews)
    4.4 km
    $$

    La Madre in Viejo San Juan really hit the spot when we were all craving something other than hotel…read morefood--and specifically, good Mexican food. It absolutely delivered. The vibe was great, the food was fresh and well made, and the service was friendly overall. A fun bonus: we actually got to see the famous rock band Maná dining there, which was such a cool surprise! We ordered quite a bit--the chips and queso, chips and guac, hot sauce, tamale, rice and beans, kids cheese quesadilla, and veggie fajitas. The kids' quesadilla was a huge hit with our 5-year-old (who is a picky eater and devoured it). The veggie fajitas were decent and tasty, though for the price I would have liked a bit more on the plate in terms of sides. There was a small hiccup where cilantro was accidentally added to one of my dishes, and it did take quite a while for the corrected dish to come out, but they were very kind about it. That said, everything else was enjoyable and the overall experience was still very good. Overall, a great spot for solid Mexican food in Old San Juan with a fun atmosphere and fresh flavors.

    After exploring Old San Juan, I'd say this restaurant really fits the artistic aesthetic. Both with…read morethe decorations and food. On to the specifics of the food. Duck Quesadillas: When I think of a duck quesadilla, I think of something that has a rich profile, but this was surprisingly humble. The duck, mushroom, and cheese all harmonized well to create a symphonic doughy pillow. Definitely recommend it. Grouper Fillet: I don't get the chance to eat Grouper often, but when I do it always hits. I can confidently say that my experience has continued. Despite the bed of sweet potatoes, you could still make out the distinct semi-sweet flavor of the fish. Also the creamy sauce paired perfectly with both the potatoes and fish. Of all the different restaurants I could've chosen, I think this was one of the best ones to end off my night in Old San Juan. Looking forward to coming back!

    Photos
    La Madre - Restaurant

    Restaurant

    La Madre
    La Madre

    See all

    Tomate Cocina Mexicana & Margarita Bar

    Tomate Cocina Mexicana & Margarita Bar

    4.3(545 reviews)
    4.1 km
    $$

    My Husband and I are in Puerto Rico to celebrate our 40th anniversary…read more Besides Puerto Rican food we decided to try TomatePR because we love Mexican and the reviews were great. We were married in Zihuataneho Mexico, were spoiled with good Mexican food living in Chicago, and find after moving outside Nashville, we have craved better Mexican food, so we came here. Gina came to our table to make sure all was OK with wait staff, and food we were eating. Well, it was MORE than OK! Food was wonderful, made fresh, and all questions and requests were answered. She did make us feel like "old friends", and after a long incredible dinner, she offed us 2 tequila shots, and played our "special married song" for our special anniversary. We both had tears in our eyes as that was so special. She took photos for Facebook (but we do not belong) so we are hoping she texts them to my husband who gave her our number. Thank you Gina, all the people who took care of us. Please go there for an excellent meal, margaritas, and the best service. We are going to try to go back before this vacation ends. G&B

    Had dinner here on my first night in Puerto Rico. I had the Carne Asada tacos with flour tortillas…read more My husband had the chicken fajitas and then we got the shots flight. The tacos were very good not very filling. If you are super hungry, you definitely need a side or an appetizer along with them. The salsa was very flavorful and had a nice kick. My husband enjoyed his fajitas. I tasted a piece of the chicken and it wasn't really bursting with flavor but still good. About halfway through our meal live music started to play. It was a little loud, but not too loud that we couldn't hear each other talking. Cute environment waitress was really friendly. It's somewhere I would revisit and recommend.

    Photos
    Tomate Cocina Mexicana & Margarita Bar - Inside the restaurant.

    Inside the restaurant.

    Tomate Cocina Mexicana & Margarita Bar - Build your own margaritas

    Build your own margaritas

    Tomate Cocina Mexicana & Margarita Bar - Mango Chipotle Margarita

    See all

    Mango Chipotle Margarita

    Burrito Social - Tacos Tatu

    Burrito Social

    3.9(155 reviews)
    0.5 km
    $$

    We were famished after getting in from our flight and in need of some quick food that we could…read morecount on being good. Enter Burrito Social, which was walking distance from our AirBnB. We came in in between lunch and dinner so it was just us and we sat outside on their patio. They give you chips and this lovely salsa, which was absolutely delightful. I decided to have their pineapple margarita bc vacation, and I was pleasantly surprised. I wasn't expected to be blown away but it was indeed a very good margarita. Then for our meals we obviously got burritos. I got the barbacoa burrito and my partner got the chicken burrito. These are hefty burritos that have the usual fixings of a burrito inside plus french fries. What a nice add. We both really enjoyed our burritos and had leftovers to take back and enjoy later. It got crowded quickly once dinnertime hit. This is a great little spot to stop in if you're hungry and need a guaranteed good meal.

    I loved the service I recieved here and I was so happy I stopped before leaving to the airport…read more The staff were welcoming and entertaining I was a solo traveler and I felt comfortable. Good was great. Bartender (guy with the braids that I called "mangu" or "my Platano friend" even though he's puerto Rican hahaha I had the corn dip and chicken wings ! Something quick because I was behind in schedule Everyone was great and I will return!

    Photos
    Burrito Social - Interior

    Interior

    Burrito Social - Marg made with grapefruit juice

    Marg made with grapefruit juice

    Burrito Social - Local IPA

    See all

    Local IPA

    El Axolote - Tinga tacos

    El Axolote

    4.1(65 reviews)
    0.7 km
    $$

    El axolote is located in one of the most beautiful neighborhoods surrounded by color murals and…read moreartwork. We were craving some street style tacos and saw the great reviews from my fellow yelpers! We enjoyed the shredded tinga tacos and the carne asada. I preferred the carne asada over the shredded tinga tacos. The queso was pretty good but probably would have been worth it to add the chorizo for a little extra flavor. The chips were a little thicker than I prefer, but definitely hand made in the restaurant. The service was great, all of the employees were so nice and we got our drinks and food quickly! Seating is indoor and outdoor. This restaurant would be good for larger groups as they have some larger tables. We will be back! There was plenty of street parking, but no dedicated parking lot.

    I had a really excellent lunch here after exploring a bit around San Juan. I was able to be seated…read moreimmediately and ordered a Michelada, chips and salsa, and the tinga tacos. Prices are all very reasonable. Most tacos are around $15 for three and come with a generous portion of rice and beans. The michelada was good and the chips and salsa were a phenomenal app for only $2. They gave three types of salsa, all were excellent but my favorite was the salsa verde. Portion was very generous - it could have been half the size and I would still say it was a good value. Tacos were filling and warm. The rice was a little bland I thought, but was a nice accompaniment nonetheless. The corn tortillas fell apart a bit but the filling was sooo delicious that I ended up just eating it separately. The place itself is really cool on the inside with a lot of interesting art. I wish they had wifi so I could have sat and hung out for a bit! Would definitely go back.

    Photos
    El Axolote - Indoor seating

    Indoor seating

    El Axolote - Gobernador

    Gobernador

    El Axolote - Carne Asada tacos

    See all

    Carne Asada tacos

    Nómada Cocina Mexicana - Tacos

    Nómada Cocina Mexicana

    4.7(3 reviews)
    0.5 km

    O M G Yes that's…read morehow this review starts! Lol amazing food. Our hotel did not have room service so we opted for Uber eats and let me tell you!! This food was soooooo good! They delivered fast each time we had it 2 nights in a row. If you are visiting PR and are wanting authentic tacos and burritos - look no further! The flavor was truly like no other. I don't even look at burritos in America the same. The sauces were hand made everything was made to order. Without needing to repeat myself for a 3rd time - this is where you want to go if you are in the mood for tacos and or burritos! Lol Not too sure of the ambiance as I did not visit the actual store so the environment could not be predicted BUT I'm sure of the appearance and display of the food presentation it too had to be top notch. Very clean and classy. Definitely going back when I can. Hope they can bring this to the states (yes I know they are apart of us) would love to see this restaurant as a chain locally!

    Solid food. Ordered two orders of the three tacos of choice. The tortillas taste handmade. I…read moreordered two chicken poblano and one short rib. They did mess up the order. The second order was supposed to be two short rib but we received two chicken poblano. It worked out in our favor. The chicken poblano tacos were superior to the short rib. The short rib was kind of dry. The chicken was super juicy and the poblano sauce elevated the flavor. The Salsa Verde was the perfect accompaniment. The radishes were also refreshing. I like this place.

    Photos
    Nómada Cocina Mexicana - Two chicken poblano, one beef short rib taco. Yum.

    See all

    Two chicken poblano, one beef short rib taco. Yum.

    Tijuana's Bar and Grill - Chicken

    Tijuana's Bar and Grill

    3.5(323 reviews)
    0.5 km
    $$

    We came here for a late lunch on a Thursday. There were 9 of us (including two small children), and…read moreit was between the lunch and dinner hours so it was not busy. We were brought chips and salsa to munch on while we perused the menu. The chips were stale and definitely not fresh. I liked the salsa, but just a heads up that it's a bit spicy. The food was great other than this. Three of our party had the Tri-Juana which was a taco, burrito, and enchilada. I was told the taco shell was stale, but it was otherwise good. Three of our party had soup (I didn't get any pictures), and they said it was really good. I had the Chicken Enchiladas with Mole Poblano sauce. I thought this was incredible. The flavor was rich, and the shredded chicken was cooked just right. It came with rice and refried beans which were also delicious. Most of us had margaritas as well. Their margarita menu is huge. I had the Caribbean Rita was refreshing and hit the spot perfectly. I would definitely have this one again. The reason for the 4 stars instead of 5 was because even though our server was very friendly, the service was incredibly slow. We'd been there for 30 minutes before we even ordered our drinks and food. Our server was visibly busy managing many other tables. I imagine the other servers had been cut due to the time of day, but it was frustrating. (That and the stale chips). The ambiance was nice, and the location right inside the mall, close to the airport, was ideal. I would definitely go back, but I would want to try another time of day to see if the negative factors from today would be better.

    Both the food and the drinks were delicious. The atmosphere is really enjoyable. Our server,…read moreFrancisco, took great care of us, his recommendations for both food and drinks, along with his friendly approach, made our dinner even more enjoyable. My only criticism is that the restroom was quite dirty. If they pay more attention to that, they definitely deserve 5 stars!

    Photos
    Tijuana's Bar and Grill - Quaint little bar area

    Quaint little bar area

    Tijuana's Bar and Grill - Mole Poblano Enchilada

    Mole Poblano Enchilada

    Tijuana's Bar and Grill - Pina colada & chips

    See all

    Pina colada & chips

    Mexitaly - mexican - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...