We were looking for pizza slices close to our resort when this place popped up on our Yelp search. Parking can be a little slim but we snagged a spot on the side. There are actually two pizza places in this plaza. The guy working the counter was funny and engaging. We ordered 4 slices total. It didn't take too long for slices to come out and we were on our way. It was flavorful and the crust was perfect. The price was reasonable. I would certainly come back. read more

Great pizza , very authentic to what you would get in the northeast region. Fast, easy delivery 7.3 read more

We checked this place out straight off the plane. Super down to earth spot. We got bruschetta, two slices of pizza and mozzarella sticks. The mozzarella sticks were just ok but the bruschetta... the BEST I've ever had. It came with 4 large pieces of French bread topped with an amazing bruschetta mix that was made fresh (the waitress said they run out of it often!). What made this the best was that the bread was SLIGHTLY toasted so not so hard that it hurt your mouth but warm enough to just enhance all the flavors. It's a must try! The pizza was also phenomenal! If your in town, this place is a must. And get the bruschetta sis. read more

NY Style Pizza? Really? Answer is not even close. Expensive pizza NOT worth the money! My neighbor George insisted we go there for pizza. A waste of $25.00 The pizza is not bad - just NOT NY pizza and NOT worth the money! The dough at NY Pizza and Deli on 66th St. is much more like real NY style pizza dough! I cannot recommend Michael's NY Style Pizza! read more

Here from ny on vacation didn't exspect much but pizza my kids could enjoy not super picky being a chef of 25 years in nyc but I never expected a pizza with no sauce after waiting almost two hours witch wasn't a big deal as they told us it would be after called to say we got a pizza with No SAUCE was pretty much told I was telling lies as they would never do that and god knows howlong it will take to get the new one never again and I'll never recommend this place and ny style that's just a joke read more

Michaels Ny Style Pizza - Can you find the sauce cause I can't - Pizza Near Me - Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

Just left this pizza spot, it was the top recommendation from our airbnb owner for pizza spots! He did NOT make a mistake on this one at all. We wanted pizza since its easy and fast after just getting here today, I order a normal pepperoni and sausage and my wife ordered a veggie Max, both of us were extremely happy after the first bite. Thebpizzas were fresh Hot and out quickly. We didn't get to the deserts but if we do before we leave I'll update this. The server (Lisa) is what our check said, greeted us when we walked in with a smile and was equally as friendly and fast with anything we needed. A negative just to make this more realistic would be theblittle bit of parking. ( I seen they had another lot across the street though). read more

Michaels Ny Style Pizza - a half eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

See all

Carried out twice. Service folks are so polite and helpful. Pizza reall good and Antipasto salad outstanding and fresh ingredients. Worth a try just on the pizza alone. Well done Michael's. read more

Great pizza & fast service. Decent priced, especially feeding your family on vacation!

This pizza place was close to Hilton property. The extra charge of $2.50 for meat was ok until you see how much you get!!!! Went to Jaybo's thought it would be lesser of a pizza at closing and shares a building with a ice cream store. It was far superior then Michaels. Just a warning the crust takes like burnt toast in the morning! read more

Michaels Ny Style Pizza - Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

Just left a show and wanted a quick slice. We saw the sign and stopped in. The wait staff immediately told us they we running behind, but would try to accommodate. Well, I'm not sure what the normal wait time for food is here, we had our antipasti in 5 mins and our large pizza in 15. Delicious! Will be back. read more

Michaels Ny Style Pizza - Sausage and meatball pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

Received a coupon in the mail , so we decided to give Michaels a try , we were pleasantly surprised, Pizza was Hot and very good , crust was Fantastic we will be back and look forward to try other items on the menu ( Good Job Michaels !) read more

My family has been ordering from Michael's for years (and we are Italian and very hard to please)!! We love it all, the pasta, meatballs, pizza, and oh my lord the CANNOLIS. Next time you want italian in a pinch, call Michael's! read more

Ate at this Restaurant several times The staff is Kind and respectful my favorite thing I like to get there is a Stromboli well done and a large order of fries. Its pretty much run like a restaurant you go in they sit you down you look at your menu the waiter brings you your drinks. The staff and people who work there are friendly and approachable they will ask how you like the food and everything and the food is really good. read more

Very very good pizza. We got the pepperoni. The crust is very good. Sauce is very good. Cheese is very good. Pepperoni was average

Great pizza and quick delivery. Excellent deserts as well. I highly recommend the next time your in myrtle beach area. Yum

Great casual spot for pizza, sandwiches, entrees. Ordered the pizza and came out quick. Great fresh ingredients along with super friendly service! They do serve wine and beer. read more

I'm from the northen NJ/NYC area so I'm tough to please when it comes to pizza. This place pleased me! Service was prompt, food was great, price reasonable. We'll be back the next time we're in town. read more

Pizza here was pretty good and kept the kids in our group happy. A few ladies in our party ordered salads that came out covered with brown spots. Half of the salad was inedible. Inexcusable read more

This is the nastiest pizza in the entire world. Pizza lunchables taste better. Save your $30 and get a Red Barron pizza at Walmart if you want pizza that tastes like shit. read more

Took a midweek, off season getaway to meet a friend from the region and happened upon Michael's looking for a delivery option that wasn't a national chain. Friendly phone service & a pleasant delivery driver were a great start. And, yeah, the pizza was pretty ace. Greasy down your chin like one would expect from a NY style pie. Would order again. read more

Wow this place knows how to make pizza a must place to stop while in Myrtle Beach.Stopped because it was close had the all meat pizza crust was thin sauce was perfect. read more

Great local pizza place. Food good, service good. Family friend, ie low key digs. I liked the sausage on the pizza read more

Michaels Ny Style Pizza - Cheese!!! - Pizza Near Me - Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

LOCAL'S REVIEW: I've been to Michaels several times, have recommended it more times than I can remember and after this last visit with friends I left in shock! Ordered our normal pie and upon it being delivered to the table we noticed it was well over cooked (not burnt just looked drier, darker) we tasted it and was going to send it back but didn't want to complain....until more ppl at the table started expressing their dislike did we alert the waitress who then got the owner. As my friends husband explained the quality wasn't there as normal the owner dismissed us saying "well next time you need to order it undercooked"! Wait, what?? How bout just normal cooked...like all the other times?! To make this short and to the point he pretty much dismissed us and could care less about our visit! Really? This is how u want to leave your customers, with a bad taste in their mouth's?? (Pun INTENDED). It's going to be really hard to even want to go back there again! I mean all the other times the food was amazing but the way we were treated by the OWNER?!?! That's not ok!! Especially being locals who's word of mouth is the best advertisement.....bad call sir. Maybe you were having a bad day, who knows. But you should have just made it right, or at least acted like you had cared and taken the constructive criticism at the very least. You should make ppl want to return not make them upset to go right down the road to your competition because of your remarks. read more

Excellent lunch stop on our way out of town. Unassuming atmosphere but food was great - we ordered side salads with creamy Italian. Good and simple - why do more places not serve creamy Italian? Pizza hot New York style. Phillycheese was served on fresh bread and fries got thumbs up. My chicken panini was excellent. If your craving good Italian pizza fare for reasonable prices, this is it. read more

Michaels Ny Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

See all

Best pizza in MB. Super greasy...in a good way. It's got good slices, sauce, and the cannoli was passable.

Great pizza. Hot and fresh! Would try it again in a min. They delivered to the hilton as was recommend by the front desk

GINOS next to Krogers is much better . How awkward is this we order a large pie for pick up.. I go in and theres girls waiting to seat you its a pizza joint and nobody there . So the unfriendly girls send me to the bar in the very dark back . Bartender rings me up asks if I want my change Hell Yes I said . Next time my wife goes in to pick up a pie and the same exact thing happens to her . Now Michaels you're done no more . And you don't deliver Ginos does . Good way to piss off locals ! read more

Michael's is not a healthy place to eat. The workers wipe the sandwich rolls on their butt. They do it all the time. Example: Even when there is not a food complaint. read more

Food was not impressive at all. Staff was not very welcoming. Our waitress was very rude when I asked for the change back from my cash payment, she assumed it was all for her, instead of even asking if I needed my change, and got very pissy when I politely asked for change and explained that the tip was on the table. read more

When we first walked in the place had a subtle hint of sewerage. We proceeded to walk to the back and the smell was a little stronger and realized we were next to the bathroom so we moved closer to the front, near the kitchen. A cook came in from the back entrance and went into the kitchen. He never washed his hands, but grabbed some gloves and walked out of the front. He then returned to the kitchen with one glove in and started to cook. Being VERY familiar with Health Department regulations, I then told the waitress that he needed to wash his hands. She then told me that he was not cooking my pizza and I told her he still needed to wash his hands. No action was taken and he continued to cook. The place isn't spotless, I thought, well it's not bad Before all of this we had already ordered so we decided to stay. We chose this place because it had such a high rating. The pizza wasn't bad--not. 5 star, it was OK! Would we return? Probably not!! I think it could've been cleaner. read more

Ordered two large pizzas and pop after a long day at the beach. The ladies on the phone were very helpful and polite, the prices were very reasonable for the amount of food you get, the delivery guy was prompt and very friendly, and the pizza was very close to what I know to be NY-style pizza! We loved it and would recommend it to anyone! read more