Mickey Mantle's did not disappoint. The fresh bread and whipped butter presentation were a great start and felt a little more upscale than your typical steakhouse. I ordered my steak rare, and they absolutely nailed it -- warm on the outside, cool in the center, and it cut like perfection. Hands down one of the best steaks I've had. The thing I'll rave the most about is the crab cake! It was perfect. You have to try it! The fried pickles and fried mushrooms were delicious, and the sauce served with the pickles was especially good. I also tried the soup of the day, a creamy chowder, which was excellent. Sat on the bar side, enjoyed a Michelob Ultra during happy hour, and had a great experience all around. Definitely worth a visit! read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Chowder Soup of the Day - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

The steak wasn't cooked to order My potatoes would not melt the butter and the salad was like eating lettuce without the Caesar dressing . Service was overwhelming in the way they serve it. They put four people at a table made for two at 6:00 pm and tow people party were in settings areas with large tables .over all not a good experience . The drinks were Awful they had plenty of alcohol just no flavor when you order a flavored drink you expect to taste it read more

Came here for dinner in Oklahoma City it was awesome. The atmosphere is relaxed. You can watch the game if you want or you can sit in the main dining area and enjoy a cozy dinner. The waiters and staff were great Lumin very well and the food was amazing. read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Tequila Shrimp - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

Bar service was excellent, but valet service was shady. Great happy hour wine, app and atmosphere. Just wouldn't recommend valet.

If you're looking for an old timey steakhouse feel, this is a great place to have a meal. The service is phenomenal and the food was fantastic. The entire experience from phone call to finished eating was high touch. Would definitely go back here if I was in OKC again. read more

See all

5 Stars! I wasn't sure what to expect because I'm from Dallas and used to really top notch steak houses. Everything was truly top-notch! The food was outstanding--especially the crab cake on the steak and cake, which had a wonderful lemony sauce. The steak was cooked perfectly and had great flavor. The only drawback was that the lobster on the lobster tower was a bit tough, but the shrimp, crab legs, and oysters were all excellent. I'd order everything again exactly the same. My husband and son split the Japanese Wagyu Carving Board and absolutely loved both the Wagyu and the Angus. They also raved about the lobster mac and cheese. The banana pudding cake was absolutely amazing! The atmosphere was quiet and relaxed on a Wednesday night at 5:30 PM, and the bar--attached but still separate--was lively without affecting the dining room. Service was attentive without being overbearing. I would definitely recommend this place and will absolutely return! read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

I enjoyed the bar and the atmosphere. All the bartenders name David so ....easy to remember .there is smoking allowed in the bar area . Most men were smoking cigars not cigarettes. I went for happy hour and not for a meal .Fried pickles a bit overdone but I want to go back and try the food . read more

See all

The food was excellent but the service was phenomenal! Jason Pitman was wonderful and we can't wait to go again just for him!!! read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

I hate to do, but it's back down to 4 stars based on this visit. The food just did not delight like it should at this price point. I will say the exception was the dessert-we had the cookie skillet (best dish of the night in my opinion) and the pecan pie skillet with cinnamon ice cream, also delicious. I had the glazed salmon special for my entree, and I was so disappointed at the lack of flavor. I should probably stick to the steak next time. read more

See all

Great food (can't recommend the A5 Wagyu enough!) but even better service! We were there to celebrate my son's graduation from the FAA Academy and Jason P was a fantastic server and a joy to be around. Entire service team worked well together and made the evening memorable. keep up the great work! read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - The Carving Board sampler! - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Ordered the most expensive dish on the menu, the wagyu sampler. One of the 4 cuts was ALL fat. Manager did take it off our tab, but unbelievable that they would try to serve this! I also have serious doubt the rest was real wagyu from Japan. Not bad meat, but not Wagyu. read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

This is one of those places where you have to pick and choose when you go. My experience with these premier restaurants is that they always have a superior staff. This place did not disappoint. However, we went on an off night. My local friends can confirm that when big events happen downtown the experience is different. I happen to be in town visiting my buds for a golf event. We went here and the staff took care of us and the food was as to be expected from an exceptional chef. Lamb chops great. Steak great. Sides great. Salads crispy and superb. Keep it up guys and you will make lots of mullah and your customers will be repeating. read more

We went for my dad's birthday and it did not disappoint! We got a complimentary dessert and photo taken. So much food and our server was top notch read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Lamb - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

When in the Dirty South! Came to the good city (OKC) to visit one of the better money grabs, and I found my self to this steak house. Right across the street there's a minor league baseball stadium which reminds me of my days in the FED (FPHL)! The FPHL and AAA baseball are both the peak of minor league in their respective sports (Although baseball is soft). The food here was damn good, And the service was even better. I ordered the french onion soup, the NY Strip RARE (Anything above it is for pansy's). Aswell as ordering all the sides on the menu and multiple loaves of bread safe to say i ain't a lug. From the bar I ordered 3 manhattans to start followed by a Long Island Iced tea to bring out my roots of the non greasy town of Massapequa! For dessert I had the cheese cake which was too cakey with not enough cheese. Very nice decor on the walls with some Yankees/ Mickey Mantle memorabilia, those Yankees were real men unlike today's suckers. Overall Damn good, if i find my self in the Dirty South again I will be back safe to say. Also the bathroom was nice read more

See all

Wait staff was excellent. Food very average. Calamari was tasty but chewy. Same with the prime ribeye. It was chewy with lots is sinew. Onion rings lacked flavor and separate very easily. Jalapeño Mac was over cooked and mushy. Brussels lacked flavor and under cook - hard crunch. The chop salad was heavy on dressing and very sweet. read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Ok so we had Andrea as are waiter! Food was off the chart! The steak was incredible! The staff was so friendly and professional! Lots of celebrities and professional athletes eat here! I know why food was5 stars! Excellent job Chef! Will be back ! We had Andre' read more

See all

Steak and seafood in the brick town area near the ballpark. Lots of baseball and mantle memorabilia. Service and food are good but pricey. Nice place for special events or on stipend. read more

The secret to a happy marriage is date night (okay, one of the secrets!), and we spent our date night at Mickey Mantle's. This is one of our regular steak spots in OKC, and it has been 80% hit and 20% miss over the years--after a slow start this night turned out to be another hit. We arrived 20 min early for our reservation and the host offered to see us to our table--maybe a bad idea because the servers were not ready for us, we should have waited at the bar with a drink instead of at our table without. We were seated in a side room we hadn't been in before, with a view of ... the bathroom. Could have been better. Our waitress Karina brought our drinks (a fantastic and reasonably priced Cabernet and an 18-year Glenlivet--the scotch selection is excellent) and our crab cake appetizer, a tower of delicate crabmeat on a lemony sauce. Next we had French onion soup and Mickeys chopped salad. The soup was stuffed with bread and onions, topped with cheese and the salad was fresh and crisp, served on a cold plate. For entrees we chose the steak--a perfectly cooked, melt in your mouth tender filet and a perfectly cooked ribeye. Our sides of fried okra and August gratin potatoes were also hot and delicious. Karina ensured our food was good and our drinks were filled and was great. We have been to countless fine dining steakhouses and I am disappointed that this one doesn't keep track of regular or recurring customers. read more

See all

Was in town for work and heard positive feedback on here! Definitely was correct! Service was excellent on a Tuesday night and food was excellent. Got the 10oz filet and cooked to perfection as medium rare and nice crust. Also we ordered the lamb chops medium and they were outstanding. The bacon covered Brussels sprouts are a must if you like sprouts. The beefsteak caprese salad was solid but was missing some flavor. Would definitely recommend. read more

See all

We love Mickey Mantles--But $8 for a little cracked pepper on your salad is a bit chinsey to nickel-and-dime you on an already solid bill. Won't happen again! read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

First review for me at Mickey Mantle's. First of all it's a great location across from the baseball stadium and Oklahoma sports hall of fame. Inside, there's a lot a sports memorabilia, dark woods and relatively low lighting. By the time we left it was almost full and pretty loud, but still a great atmosphere. I had the 7 oz. Roquefort filet medium rare with a house salad and tomato basil soup. The ranch dressing tasted great, the tomato basil milder than I'm used to but with a lot of flavor, and the steak was cooked perfectly and on a bed of garlic mashed potatoes. The service was excellent and our group had a great time. Recommend! read more

See all

As much as I wanted to like this place it was disappointing Sorry to say the ny strip was very average read more

Decided to dine here based on a recommendation from a friend. We had a lovely evening, the service was friendly and warm and it was a great start to our visit in Oklahoma City. We skipped the appetizers since we weren't too hungry and started with the blue cheese wedge and the soup of the day, which was a beef stew. The salad was delicious and not overdressed and the soup was excellent as well as a touch spicy which was unexpected but it worked. The steaks (a NY strip and a filet) were good and well prepared, but not outstanding. Comparing to other steakhouse I've been to, it was average which is why the 3 star rating. For sides we had the lobster risotto and bacon brussel sprouts were also good, but also not outstanding. It was a fine meal, but not something I would rave about. read more

We were really looking forward to this evening, but it started off on the wrong foot as the non smiling hostess sat us in what we thought was the worst table possible; facing the kitchen and the bathrooms, when the rest of the restaurant was pretty empty. If we had been walk-ins or the restaurant full, I get it. But we had reservations, and I don't understand why we got such a crappy table to start and to their credit, they were quickly willing to change when we asked. After that hiccup, things were fantastic. Our serving team of Isaac and Ally were excellent. They were perfectly attentive, and let us set the pace. We really enjoyed their personalities. They were definitely 5 star service. Cocktails and wine were very good and I thought for the most part reasonably priced. The Hendricks Martini at $22 seems excessive but everything else was more reasonable than expected. We really enjoyed the Malbec by the glass and the Quilt Chardonnay. We started with the shrimp cocktail. Good cocktail sauce, but the shrimp were a little tough and overcooked. Next were the dinner salads. Their homemade garlic dressing is beyond fantastic. No one should skip or upgrade the salad! We both had the Roquefort fillets (7 and 10 oz). They were exceptional and perfectly cooked medium rare. We had that with macaroni and cheese, sautéed spinach, and mashed potatoes. The sautéed spinach was perfection and so delicious. My wife loved the mashed potatoes. The macaroni and cheese has fried onions on top, which actually are an important component because of how sharp the cheese is in the mac & cheese. When combined it makes the mac & cheese very good. The mac & cheese by itself without the fried onions was way too sharp for me though. For dessert we had the German chocolate cake. Ally did us a favor by finding two pieces that were left because it was no longer on the menu. So glad she did. The cake was very good but for German chocolate cake, was a bit too chocolatey for me. The chocolate overpowered the taste of the caramel coconut icing, which should be the reverse flavor. A typical fine steakhouse ambience with lots of pictures of Mickey Mantle and baseball images on the walls. We really found it to be a nice setting once we got a decent table. Definitely recommend trying the restaurant. read more

See all

Great steak and sides!! Can't go wrong the risotto or the mashed potatoes! The broccoli was the most underwhelmed sides. Just steamed. The waygu a3 was very fatty. It wasn't my favorite but the filet was delicious. Great service! I love the extra attention to details they had for our anniversary. It made our special day even more special! read more

See all

Our oldest daughter got my wife a gift card and the reservation for her birthday. The staff were very friendly and helpful. Our waitress Kristie was outstanding and her recommendations were spot on!! The beef and shitake mushroom soup was incredible. The jalepeno, bacon mac and cheese was very good. Wife got the salmon and I got the redfish and both were very good portions and tasted very good. Kristie recommended the special desert of the day, bananas foster. It was so light and not too sweet. Perfect!!! We still have some left on the gift card....damn!! We will have to go again!! read more

I got the rib eye special not disappointed it was medium rare to perfection the sides also well done loaded bake potato , mushrooms, lobster Mac and cheese, and grilled asparagus dessert cherry jubilee cheese cake a must have Servive top notch very attentive read more

Great food, you might want to transfer some additional funds into your checking before you step foot into this joint. Nice spot for a special occasion, stick to the steaks. read more

I recently went as part of a work dinner and was very disappointed. The steak was not seasoned at all and there was only pepper on the table so I couldn't even add salt. Everyone at the table agreed that the steak was bad and that Texas Roadhouse would've been better for half the price. We asked for more bread and were given a rude reaction from the waiter explaining that he already put bread on the table. Another member of our party asked for a drink while the waiter was taking our order and said "so you want me to stop what I'm doing and go get your drink?" In a very rude tone. For the price we paid for the event, we should've gotten a lot better food and service. Will not be going back. Redprime and mahogany are both much better for the same price. read more

We went for our anniversary and it was a homerun! Excellent service and food. Jordan was an awesome waiter! We even got our dessert on the house. Will be coming back read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Chocolate tres leches - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Still one of my favorite places for dinner. Only complaint is I miss the days when the dress code was enforced.

All of the staff were very welcoming, everyone that passed me greeted me and asked if they could get anything for me. The happy hour specials were very good and the atmosphere was warm and welcoming. A top notch restaurant. read more

Service was good. The ribeye with the blue cheese sauce was okay. It wasn't worth the price. The shrimp was tough. They were overcooked. The filet was not cooked to what we asked. They also didn't season it at all. We have gone here for many years used to love it. The crab cakes used to be delicious. They are now not very good. The past two times we have gone, it has not been good. Too expensive and over-rated. I can make steaks better at home. Would not recommend. read more

Really mediocre flavors for the price point. The steak was decent but the family style sides were boring and bland. Service was excellent. Old school ambiance (cigar smoke smell and all). Overall, it's a unique dining room but if you're looking for fantastic food, this isn't the place. read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Nice setup inside. Had a ton of people working. So waiter does what they do but they had other people checking on you, picking up your plates. Good system. Very good drink selection. Started with an appetizer, pickle chips. Good flavor, crispy For dinner had one of the steak specials, with some lobster sauce on top. Started with a salad with balsamic dressing. That was solid. Sourdough bread was warm and good as well The main course was great. Prime ribeye was good perfect. The lobster sauce was delicious. Asparagus was flavorful and cooked good. It came with mashed potatoes. That wasn't bad. Very garlicky. We also ordered some mac and cheese at the table which was good and flavorful. Creamy. Food was delicious. Pricy, but service and food was definitely good. read more

We visited OKC for a little anniversary getaway and made reservations here for dinner one night. The service, ambiance, and food were all outstanding. They made us feel special for our anniversary and we had a lovely evening! read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Chocolate Tres Leches Cake - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Decided to stop in and try out Mickey Mantle's after an early matinee movie down the street. It was an early evening, and as usual we sat at the bar. As others have mentioned, this is a fairly dimly lit establishment with a lot of dark wood. Very classy looking place - and the type of restaurant I like personally. There were 2 bartenders on duty and 1 came over quickly, gave us menus and took our drink order. The cocktails were made perfectly. The bartenders were also super friendly and talkative. Very courteous. We ordered another round of drinks and an appetizer. The app was super delicious. For dinner, my wife asked about the seafood tower (cold), and our server told us that she could order for it for 1 person. GREAT! That was her meal. I ordered a smoked Ribeye as shown in the pics. It came out perfectly prepared. Along with a huge portion of potatoes (plus dinner salad), it was more than I could finish. The place is definitely more on the $$$$ side, but you get what you pay for. Service, cleanliness, food quality and atmosphere were all top notch. We will be going back for my wife's birthday later this month. Great job! read more

See all

Outstanding menu, amazing cuts of steak. Oysters, which was not on the menu but was a special that night. Plates are definitely big enough to share. That way you can enjoy more plates and cuts of meat. Amazing service extremely clean. Highly recommend recommended that definitely take your platinum card. read more

Well, Mickey Mantel's dining room is a bit out of our price range, unless we want sautéed mushrooms for dinner, haha, but their bar experience is affordable and a great Bricktown dinner option. We were dining out before a Thunder basketball game, no reservation, but lucky enough to nab a couple of spots at the bar. Their food is legit bar food. I learned each patron must be able to secure a seat at the bar, no standing allowed, before they are served. We each ordered a happy hour house margarita, along with happy hour offerings of lamb medallions and fried mushrooms. Everything was delicious. We made friends at the bar after we ordered. We learned our new bar friends had traveled from a little town outside of OKC to come and have their lobster cargot fix (not a happy hour offering). They shared they come once every couple of months to order this dish, apparently it's super craveable. It's a lobster in a cream sauce served with bread for dipping--YUM. Next time I return, I'll be sure to order the lobster cargot. If you come on Thunder game nights you can ride their free van to and from the game (tips appreciated). Valet service is $10-cash only, prepay. The biggest downside, for which one star was removed, is that the bar area allows smoking. I hate eating in smoking areas. Unfortunately there were multiple smokers there when we were dining and no other options to move elsewhere. All and all, it was a memorable night in no small part to the service and great food at Mickey Mantle's bar. November 2021 read more

Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse - Fried mushrooms and lamb medallions. November 2021. - Steakhouses Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

We spent some time in the bar over their happy hour time. Several specials for happy hour and we tried several the lamb chops were amazing. $7 dirty Martinis were great. The bartenders were spot on and very enjoyable to hang out with. This is my kinda place. read more