This is a REAL and authentic pizzeria. They have a variety of pizzas and most importantly, they have squares and grandma pizza! They make everything in house and the sauce is incredible. The staff is very friendly. I HIGHLY recommend them. read more

Middle Island Pizza - Sign - Pizza Near Me - Middle Island, New York

Just moved to the area and was craving pizza.. tried this place out and it was delicious! Definitely recommend and will be coming back!

Fabulous pizza! My coworker and I loved it and next time we're working in the area we will be back!! Fresh & delicious!!!

Best pizza and chicken Parmesan around been going for years and will continue to do so

I love their pizza! No complaints whatsoever. I've been going here since I was a child! Pizza is always super tasty and flavorful

I live in Coram and honestly, this is one of the better ones around.Freshly made. delivery time is good.

The service here was phenomenal!!! They took the time to name every single slice of pizza on display and even made sure to list what was in them! They even brought napkins to our table! The pizza was delicious and their marinara sauce is so good I could drink it! I'll definitely be coming back here. read more

My sister, my husband and I went there for the first time. We all thought the pizza was pretty terrific! The service was fast as well!

Chicken piccata and chicken francese dinners were horrible. Tasted as though the cook literally pored a bottle of lemon juice over both with abandonment. Requested angel hair pasta, was given thick spaghetti. Only positive was that the people behind the counter were extremely friendly. read more

Food was great, the service was amazing, the workers are very nice and the feel of the place is very comfortable.

Ordered a pizza and dinners from them through their website using Slice. Food didn't show up as scheduled. I called the restaurant and got no help at all. Turned out the food was delivered to the wrong address. read more

I called Thursday night for an eggplant hero. I told them NO parm and not to toast the bread. I arrived to pick it up and checked it. It was smothered in mozzarella cheese. They took it back and made me a new one, it looked ok. I get home there was no cheese which was good but the bread was toasted and the eggplant was cool at best. I forced half down and threw out the rest. The kitchen staff either don't understand English or just don't give a shit. Their food used to be good. I'm done here. read more

I ordered the chicken cutlet cheesesteak hero. It was $20 which in my opinion is overpriced for it not being steak. I normally get the meatball parm hero which is a 10/10 and wanted to try something different . The glaze the cutlet had on it was extremely salty ! Tasted like a pound of salt. I had to toss it because I couldn't even stomach the amount of salt in the hero. Worst hero I've ever had . read more

We love the food especially the meatball and chicken parm phenomenal food is always ready when I'm arriving never have to wait great job I recommend this Pizzeria read more

TERRIBLE!! Don't know what has happened here....the pizza is TERRIBLE! I just ordered a chicken park hero and calzone....the hero was the worst I ever had...chicken was sliced or cubed up into strips with very little breading. The calzones have shrunk in size and aren't good at all. This place is terrible...I won't be going back! read more

2 stars because they were open. The pizza was not the best I've ever had and the mozzarella tasted as if it wasn't real at all. Sadly ,I'm not a fan.To make it worse the knots were very dry. I've had frozen pizza that tastes better than theirs and I'm talking reheated and cold Digiornia. read more

Sooo good. Everything there is just amazing. Either you want a regular slice or go crazy with a pasta slice. It doesn't matter they never disappoint. Best pizza place in the area hands down. read more

Favorite pizza spot on LI. Fast service and friendly staff. Calzones are out of this world and the spaghetti and meatball slice is phenomenal!! read more

Middle Island Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middle Island, New York

I am so very angry if you want a nice meal and courteous service DON'T go here. I suggest that you go anywhere else I would suggest going to McDonald's, burger king Wendy's anywhere is better than that place. They are not very polite people. They don't greet you in a polite manner.. I spent like $30 I am a disabled veteran and that's a lot of money for me. Not only that I ordered 2 garlic knots and neither had a kid on them. The sausage and peppers order was all over the place. They should have used two containers instead of the one because the lid came off and spilled all over the bag. Not only that but my father ordered a chicken parmesan dish for me that was supposed to come with fettuccine but they forget it. Had to go back for it, when I got back I said that I thought the chicken parm was out upside down. He was like no I didn't you must have dropped it. He never apologized for forgetting the pasta. Worst service ever. I am a veteran and I shouldn't be treated the way that they did. I would have given them negative stars if possible. read more

See all

Ordered a week in advance for catering order for Christmas Eve.Arrived at time promised and they couldn't find order.I was told 5 minutes.45 minutes later my food was ready.Got it home and the food was inedible.DISGUSTING.$250.00 worth of food in garbage.Women behind counter needs a lesson in customer service also.RUDE.Never again.Whats with the chicken parm where the chicken is paper thin and hard as a rock. read more

Mike the gentleman that works the counter is one of the main reasons I keep coming back here. The food is good but not always consistent but when it's good it's really good. Mike always makes sure it's heated properly because it's been cold a few times. And anytime I bring a concern to him he just genuinely concerned and rectified my issue constantly. As a business operator myself and employer of 40 plus you have a winner on your hands read more

Nice spot. Good pizza, nice staff, and clean. The place could use updating and actual parking spots. I was surprised to see random non staff people milling around in back where the pizzas were being made. That didn't bug me much. What lowered my rating was the delivery guy rushing to the car that was parked much too close to the door. Because he was rushing I went to walk around the back of the car and to my surprise he backed up nearly hitting me before bolting off. I know deliveries are important but so is safety. read more

Had Middle Island Pizza on probably 3 or 4 different occasions. They do make a great pizza, the plain cheese and pepperoni are the best. If your in the mood for Linguini with Clam Sauce and you don't feel like making it from scratch, this is the place to order it from. It's quite good - perfect balance of fresh mince garlic, olive oil & baby clams. read more

They are so accommodating and nice to their customers. Plenty of choices and food and prices are good.

Rude staff. I called to see if I could get a combination pizza and was asking questions. This was the second time I called as I was trying to make a decision with my mother on her way home. The person literally rudely told me "I can't do this. I have customers. You need to call me back when You make up your minds". He hung up the phone on me.That is terrible customer service. You lost me as a customer. read more

Over priced mediocre pizza. 18 dollar cheese pie. Go else where for a better bang on ur buck, especially for pizza that's not worth the price read more

This was the first pizza I had after moving to Long Island from another state, it was the day after I'd moved in. The owner was there and was very friendly, happy to tell me what was on all of the pizzas. Best welcome home I've ever gotten, great flavors, perfect crust, they've got a loyal customer for life. Looking forward to eating there again and trying some of the other specialty pizzas. read more

Working next door to this establishment for more than 18 years it's almost disturbing tonight how I heard this owner talk about their employees. Usually I'm not one to write negative reviews, I'd rather just leave it alone, but after constant mess ups, always late and the way the staff speak about/to customer is horrible. Where I grew up the customer is always right and tonight was unacceptable. When there is two different things on the menu with different names there's no reason for the owner to explain to me they're the same thing. They're not. Very disappointing and will be finding another place to order Italian from. read more

I ordered through Uber, the Uber order was correct but the receipt on my order was wrong. We paid $87 and received one dish! When I called, instead of checking to see if they could have made the error, they hung up on me, said the Uber driver must have stolen our food. This was not the first time they were nasty and rude when they made a mistake with an order. I feel bad for the Uber driver if they are responsible for the refund because it seems like Middle Island Pizza found a way to make a buck at Ubers expense read more

Ate here on the way home from the Lab. Should have gotten a frozen pie at the supermarket. Why? Bland, yet overly salty sauce. Tough rubbery crust. "Gloppy" cheese. Later found out their other place is in Ridge, and that one is hit or miss. This might have been an "off"day here, but I work too hard to pay full price for stuff that may or may not be good. Consistency is not hard, people. Won't be back. read more

The saddest of sad. Grumpy barely knows where to start. The glass pizza case was a case study in sad. I wont say that the pizza was old, but what looked like a buffalo chicken slice had an AARP sticker on it. It gave a new meaning to Grandma slice. I wish i knew the Italian word for microwave, because they used one on our stuffed mushrooms. Grumpy can tell the difference between fresh and delicious and microwaved and gross. Stay away from them if you like things that taste good. We could go on if we wanted, but we all know that there are better pizza places around that could use your business. If you suffer from the horror of living nearby i would recommend the large pizza stone from Pampered Chef. Just make your own and avoid the indignity of it all. read more

Ordered and picked up pizza here a few times and have been pretty happy so far. Not out of the ballpark memorable but decent and I would continue to order if I have the hankering. The pies always arrive fast and hot but not too thrilled that there's a delivery charge. Oh well, c'est la vie. Pros that keep me coming back: -They're close so the food is fast and hot -They take Discover, not all places do (boooooo) -You can add tip on your credit card. I always try to leave a cash tip but sometimes I just don't have it on me so it's good that you can do that because not all places allow you -- or they make you leave the tip ahead of time ::eyeroll:: read more

I'm a humble graduate student that works near by. On Fridays for lunch a bunch of us go out for pizza. Our go to spot has been closed as of late (perhaps permanently), so we were in need of a new locale to meet our needs for Friday pizza. Middle Island Pizza has potential. It's not particularly ground breaking, or awe-inspiring, but it's pretty good. The prices are about right ($4 for a specialty slice) and they offer a wide array of slices, sandwiches, salads and pasta dishes. I haven't heard my co-workers complaining about the salads or sandwiches as of yet, so I would imagine that they too are well received. The specialty slices are big. I've gone twice now, and both times, every slice that we got seemed like it was that one mythical "bigger than all the others in the pie" slice. We've yet to find it's corresponding "this still counts even though it's only 3 bites" slice, so it is possible they have managed to create a normal sized pizza whose slices are more than the total pie. One "warning", occasionally they'll have a stuffed meat pizza (which is pretty delicious), right between the other slice pies, but perhaps unbeknownst to you, that is not a $4 slice, that's more like a $5.50 slice. And you do not need two, no matter who you are. The method of counter service at Middle Island pizza may make you feel a bit rushed/hurried, so be ready to know what you want when you step up to the counter. While I have no real complaints about the pizza here, I have no real "this is better than elsewhere" type comments either. It's good. If you look forward to eating pizza on Friday for lunch, this place will more than adequately meet those criteria. read more

Middle Island Pizza - Buffalo Chicken and Chicken Marsala Slices - Pizza Near Me - Middle Island, New York

Middle Island Pizza. They charge for delivery and the pizza lacks sauce as well as any kind of decent flavors. Other than being sub-par, I guess it's alright... never need to go back. read more

The workers here are really nice. The food is always hit or miss. Sometimes the eggplant is great sometimes it tastes old. The regular pizza is good but again sometimes I get a great pie other times it's just ok. The rolls could be so good but 75% of the time it's still raw inside. I've had dough completely uncooked after I've already taken a bite. Wish the consistency was better because I'd order at least once a week. read more

This place I have been coming to for years and honestly has some of the best food iv had.. Their pizza is the best around and they have so many specialty pizzas to choose from. Their dinners are also amazing and you get nice portions. Chicken Milanese one of my favorites. This place is a must and if you come here , then you know it's worth it. read more

Absolutely terrible service. I ordered a chicken club for delivery while at work. I work less then a half a mile from middle island pizza. The chicken club arrived an hour after I ordered and the chicken was and it had no cheese on it like I requested. I called to explain the situation and the guy said "okay i dont understand how its cold" and then he just hung up. I called back to try to speak to a manager and the guy told me "GUY STOP CALLING ME" and then hung up again. Very rude. The delivery driver Anthony is great though. I wish the people picking up the phone actually had some manners and customer service. read more

Ordered a pizza at 11am, was told 45 min for delivery, 1 hour later still no pizza, I work in a nursing home and only get half hour lunch, ordered in more than enough time, now I have wait another hour to eat because I have work. Never again. read more

Really bland sicilian pizza and insane price for "specialty slice", $6.00 per slice of white pizza. Not returning here for sure.

Best kept secret around. Delicious food, nice folks, clean environment. Loved the chicken parm roll and cannoli..great sauce....so very yummy. Going 2 live off the memories 4 the rest of the week. read more

Middle Island Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middle Island, New York