Three of us went here for our Christmas Eve dinner. We haven't been here for a while because of our past experience, but we thought we'd give it another shot. Big mistake. We started off with the stuffed mushrooms with crab meat and mozzarella cheese on top. The mushrooms were barely cooked. Strike 1. For my entrée, I chose the surf and turf ($85) which was a tiny stuffed lobster tail, and a 6 ounce fillet mignon which I ordered medium rare and it came out, medium well. I sent it back and they brought me a rare almost raw piece. I didn't bother sending it back AGAIN. I just didn't eat it. I took it home. At $85 I was not about to throw it away. The Lobster tail was tiny, (maybe 3 bites) but tasty. My husband and mother both got the duck entrée ($58) which they described was overcooked, dry and chewy. Strike 2 & 3 For dessert, I passed, but my husband and mother both got the Tres Leches cake and Cappuccino's which they said was delicious. So after the bill came, which was over $300, the only thing that was truly enjoyed was the dessert. Pretty expensive meal for cake and coffee. We will not be returning. read more

Polarizing place! I've been to Spiros and the food there is consistently excellent, Sea Basin is something else entirely on the one hand the menu is varied with solid food options. For one dinner I had the Surf and Turf which was excellent, large stuffed lobster tail with a large perhaps 8oz filet mignon well seasoned and tasty. A few weeks later we returned for the $46 pp price fixed menu and while some of the apps like the baked clams and wedge salad were solid one entree in particular the rack of lamb left plenty to be desired, the meat while tender was very bland despite the appearance on the plate, the mashed potato's were awful bland and tasted like something you'd get out of the microwave and it's not a good look to charge $7 for substituting asparagus as an alternative. Also the price fixed menu is missing some dessert options that should be in there like the tasty Tres Leches albeit very overpriced at $10. All in all the ambiance and service is pretty good but the food is hit or miss and they don't seem to carry clam chowder at least the New England style very often. read more

See all

Food is alway fresh reasonably priced, great service. My parents love this place and we have followed suit! Highly recommend!

Everything, as usual, was AMAZING. Our annual Easter tradition is to patronize Spyro's restaurants and they NEVER disappoint! The ambiance was excellent. They revamped the entire dinning room and it is beautiful. They had a full bar and they had sports on the TV. For appetizers we ordered the stuffed clams, muscles, and clam chowder. Everything was delicious. This is my family's go to spot whenever we have an event or we just want to enjoy good drinks and a good meal. We absolutely love this place. The service is always phenomenal, you guys are our second family. We love you guys!! read more

Very reliably good. Great Bar Tender. Ask him to do the cork trick. Menue has standards as well as new dishes. My husband loves to get pork chop Milanese which is always great and too big to finish. Recently up graded/ redecorated except booths in back. Some High tops too. Thank you Spiro! read more

Sea Basin Restaurant - This is my favorite. Swordfish w pineapple mango salsa on a crab cake on wilted spinach. Always perfect. - Seafood Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

Haven't been here in over 25 years. Heard friends talking about it so decided to give it a try. Ended sending back 2 dishes, food is mediocre. Being a big fan of Spyros assumed it would be of equal quality. Not even close. Sorry better restaurants in the area, not a fan. read more

See all

Recently came for restaurant week. Had a drink at the bar while waiting for table. We had reservations, 4 of us. Most of dining room is tables, but near the back of restaurant are a few booths. They are rough to sit in. Very straight backed and kind of tight. Not sure why they didn't get new ones when the renovated the bar/dining area. Hostess was nice and accommodated us at another table. We didn't mind waiting extra to sit elsewhere. To us the booth just is not comfortable. Prix fix menu was great. So many choices including steak, chicken. Seafood, pasta. Appetizer, meal and dessert. All the food was outstanding. Service was just ok, but kind of expected either way the popularity of restaurant week. read more

We've been back to this restaurant many times since their renovations, and love what they have done to the decor and atmosphere of this restaurant. The food is still amazing, and so is the service, but the new bar and decor is absolutely beautiful! Their other restaurant Spiro's was the more upscale restaurant, but now the Sea Basin is just as awesome now. They also have a great happy hour here, and the bartenders really know how to make perfect drinks! We were really happy with everything we had on the bar menu, except for the wings, but that could have been an off night for that. In the past, they were great. We will definitely be back here again and really love the fact that they are right down the road from us. 25 A where they are located is a very busy area, but the Sea Basin has plenty of parking so that is never a problem. If you haven't been to this place, or haven't been back since the renovations, you have to go. You won't be disappointed :-) read more

See all

The food here is really tasty, and the presentation is impressive. I especially enjoyed the desserts The only minor downside was that the music was a little too loud for my liking. Otherwise, highly recommended read more

Randomly stumbled upon this place as we were looking for a seafood place to eat at during our trip to LI. Everything we ordered was not only fresh, but extremely flavorful. The portions of the happy hour appetizers were huge. The mussels in the garlic butter sauce and shrimp scampi are two of my most memorable dishes and would go back for just that. Though the other food looked and tasted just as delicious. Our waitress was extra friendly - just wished she warned us at how big the portions were. The only reason I took one star away was because fried calamari we ordered were slightly chewy for my liking but my friend enjoyed it very much. Looking forward to trying the lobster next time . This was a great find. read more

Sea Basin Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

The food was very good. Service was commendable. All culminating in pleasant ambiance.

Went with a dozen ladies yesterday for lunch. The place looks beautiful BUT the food failed. This place is NOT what it used to be. We had a wonderful waitress though read more

Always wonderful food, service is tops. Very friendly and attentive staff. Love love the baked clams and mussels in white Sauce. The manager , Yeshim, is always a pleasure to see. And, just in case you are not too hungry, the bar rocks. read more

We came here for lunch during a visit with my MIL. She was given rave reviews of this place by some friends. Being that we were in Long Island, I figured that the seafood would be amazing and I was looking forward to enjoying a great meal. We were led to our table upon arrival. The host, managers and servers were very nice. The service was OK but there definitely were times we felt we were waiting to get the bill or for our food. We were there around 4-5 and once 5P hit, the patronage significantly increased. When we first sat, we were given house garlic bread for the table. I was excited but the bread was really hard with almost no garlic butter on it so it was super dry. It was kind of disappointing. I would have rathered plain warm bread with soft butter. We didn't come for the bread so I I went on to peruse the menu. I opted for a skinny paloma which was really good and I love that they coat the rim with tajin. Great touch. I had my heart set on some clam chowder and I ordered that but they don't specify what kind it is and I was brought Manhattan clam chowder, which I don't like much. I was able to swap it out for their lobster bisque which was ok but a little bland and way too thick. For our entrées, I got my kiddo the fried shrimp which came with streak fries. She wasn't feeling anything on the kiddie menu so I just took a stab in the dark and ordered that. The shrimp are big and it's a good portion size but I'm not sure if it's worth the price tag. Hubby had chicken parm which came with a side of linguine and sauce. It was good and he was in heaven with one of his favorite dishes. My MIL had the seafood platter and liked it. I had the stuffed lobster tail and did not like it at all. The dish came with huge asparagus spears which were well cooked. There were also two clam shells with baby scallops in them. They were soooo over cooked. It was like chewing on gum drops. The lobster tail was also very overdone. The stuffing tasted overly sweet and was just weird. It was more breading than crab and very disappointing. I think this dish was $38 and IMO, not worth it. My MIL commented that City Island restaurants would have costed more and not tasted as good and I had to disagree. The seafood was over cooked, bland and cost way too much for the subpar preparation. If this seafood was fresh, the kitchen staff ruined good product. If you're used to seafood being prepared like this, you may enjoy it but if you've ever had top tier seafood, you'll know this just isn't it. I'm sure their fish is probably good but the big money items, like lobster, should be 100% perfection for the prices they charge. As I said, everyone else enjoyed their food. The service was ok but definitely could have been better. There seemed to be some disconnect in where dishes were supposed to go but the staff was very nice. After our meal, my daughter got a nice big cup of chocolate ice-cream with plenty of huge maraschino cherries. We ordered some hard seltzers with tequila sidecars, and my tip would be to ask for orange slices with tajin as opposed to limes with salt. Thank me later. read more

See all

Came here for my sister's birthday with the family. We had come in for a party of 6, no reservations. The place was pretty empty for a Saturday afternoon so it was no problem seating us. We were given menus and bread as soon as we sat down. Right away, we ordered drinks: - pinot grigio - sauvignon blanc - 2 peach watermelon sangrias - Save the Robot beer For appetizers we had: - fried calamari for two - steamed mussels with garlic, olive oil, and white wine sauce For entrees we ordered: - linguini with clam sauce - white sauce with all the natural juices - linguini with shrimp and clam sauce - white clam sauce with all their natural juices - sea basin platter - broiled lobster tail, shrimp, scallops, and flounder served with rice - 2 chef's special - stuffed shrimp, stuffed flounder, bard clams and scallops served with rice - crusted halibut with scallops and angel hair pasta Everything was delicious. Great portions for the price. Great serving staff who were all quick and knowledgeable of the menu. This was the first time being here for all of us and we all loved it! I look forward to trying other things on their menu. read more

See all

Great food good service and nice ambiance will definitely come back although Its a little bit pricey nice spot if you're in the mood for seafood and talian cuisine read more

See all

Great food great service loved it. The ambiance was nice and chill and all of the food came super quick. loved it

I love the food @ sea basin, & they always had a lunch special $24.00 included appetizer, & entree. NO MORE! Now, it just 24.00 for entree only!! We were there yesterday & there was only 1 waitress handling 15 tables. We waited 20 minutes to get our order placed. Then waited 1// hour for the food. (We had bread given to us.). I guess Spyro didn't want the senior crowd anymore. I thing he is making a BIG MISTAKE!!! Paid $46.00 with drink,entree, tax,& tip for lunch read more

Definitely not what it used to be. The fish is still well prepared but you get a lot less food for higher prices. Very cheap with the sides. I was never charged extra for substituting for rice, which doesn't agree with my stomach. The last time I dined there, the dinner came with rice and vegetables. I asked to substitute spinach for the rice. They not only gave a very small portion of spinach but they also eliminated the vegetables that came with the entree. The waitress said you can't substitute for only one item. The also charged an extra $8 for the substitution! The bill was $175 for the meal, a beer, 2 glasses of wine and one dessert. Definitely not worth it. Won't be coming back. Its a shame since we used to look forward to dinner here in the past. read more

skip the dining room and sit at the bar great bar specials daily Paul and kyle are both very good at their craft read more

Went to Sea Basin, with reservations, Saturday evening. The 4 of us were sat at a small table by the bathroom door. I asked to sit somewhere else. They had tables, we were told they are reserved. There was a table set up, but was waiting for another reservation, I was told I can't have that table. When I told the Mgr that we were all walking out, she said fine "walk out". Do yourselves a favor and go someplace else. They got too big for themselves. We went to Pompei, in the Kohl's shopping center and had a wonderful dinner. I'm spreading the word, DONT GO TO SEA BASIN. read more

I had an amazing time here at Sea Basin Restaurant. The food is just super fresh and high-quality. The service is very kind and efficient. The ambiance is very calm and chill! 5 stars for sure! read more

Not impressed with food or service. Used to be the go to place for fresh seafood. Wait staff acted as if they were doing us a favor by seating us. Food tasted like Stouffer's frozen dinners. read more

I have going to Sea Basin restaurant since 1986. The service is always great and the staff polite and friendly. After reading some of the reviews, I was compelled to add my own review. The food is great, and the prices are very fair. It's rare but if by chance there is a problem with your order, they quickly take care of it and make it right. I have paid $14 elsewhere for a drink I can get for $8 at Sea Basin. I feel I get value for my money at Sea Basin, so I dine there about three times a week. They also have a bunch of screens with games playing so you don't have to miss a thing! Thanks! read more

Came here after going to spiros and finding out they couldn't serve alcohol for a few weeks. Luckily they brought some of their menu to their sister restaurant. I've been here several times before and always felt it was a notch or two below spiros. We only tried two things so I personally give it a 3.5 based on both past and current experiences, but the scallops and soup were amazing! If we go back and try more I'll update my review. Staff is always personable at both restaurants. They do need to update the interior with falling off wallpaper and old looking/smelling carpet. read more

See all

Nicely updated inside. Old school classic menu that's significantly better than you think it will be, especially delicate touch on seafood. Please don't confuse Sea Basin with fine dining, it's not supposed to be. It's a local treasure that has survived everything imaginable where you will see local folks celebrating and drinking and enjoying themselves with comfortable classics, a decent wine list and a sharp cocktail menu. read more

Food and service was great. Everyone was very friendly. Great experience. Always a pleasant experience

Service was good.Food pedestrian,would not go back. Hostess was very argumentative and combative. I never experience such a rude women in a restaurant establishment. read more

Food and Service, all good. Now the details. Saturday, me and my honey out for nice dinner. Arrived at 5:50 for a 6 pm reservation. Check in with the hostesses and proceeded to wait until 6:20 for our table. OK, its Saturday night and its busy. People were not rushing to leave like they had a Broadway show to catch. Bread basket and water arrived before the waitress. No butter for the plain bread but was made up for with the garlic bread in the same basket. Our waitress, very polite and efficient(Unfortunately forgot her name) took our drink order. Wife had a mojito and I had my diet coke which arrived in quick time. Without checking with each other, we ended up ordering the Fired Calamari appetizer and Stuffed Flounder. Fried Calamari, arrived hot and crispy. Perfect. Delicious...Definately would be on a repeat order. On to the Stuffed Flounder with crab meat. Again, Perfect, Delicious. The accompanying steamed broccoli and rice a definite compliment. Plenty of crab meat to a very succulent fish. So at this point your asking why the 4 stars when I wrote a 5 star review. Well, the mrs, went to order a 2nd mojito and the waitress came back and said they ran out of mint. What! no more mint. In my mind with a supermarket about 1/2 mile away, you run out and get some mint instead of disappointing a customer. Just my thinking....Otherwise, we will go back. An excellent seafood restaurant. read more

This place is great for a get together with friends is a casual dinner with your significant other Awesome food and service The bacon wrapped scallops are to die for, have them every time we go. Try it you'll like it read more

The food wasn't as good as I thought it would be. It was just ok. They took a long time to take the prefer and a long time to give us the food. I was very disappointed, I thought it would be better because it's been there a really long time. read more

Food good, service good, prices fair. The only objection is the surcharge $1.50 per person, for serving a birthday cake. The seats in the booth seem to slant forward, making it uncomfortable. read more

Honestly not worth it at all. The food was alright, it was the same quality as a dennys or a similar lower quality diner. We got bottomless mimosas and they cut us off after 6 mimosas. When we came into the place we wondered why the restaurant was empty but after leaving we fully understood why. The mimosas had barely any champagne in them it felt like a scam read more

While the food is incredible and the waitstaff (servers and busers) are kind and cheerful, the front of the house manager is incredibly rude. I went there on a first date with someone who happened to have a handicap. The manager made it sound like it was their fault, that they should have announced their handicap. She made me and my date extremely uncomfortable and it is for that reason I will not return. If she is fired then I may reconsider. read more

Went there for the first time last night. Service was decent, our server was friendly. The food was average. I wanted to try it because I had gotten pretty good reviews from people. I would say for the price I was not impressed. I'm glad I gave it a try but I probably won't be going back. A couple of pluses, the food was hot, mozzarella sticks and baked clams were good. read more

We went during spring restaurant week and the menu didn't have a very wide range but the food was all delicious! Can't wait to come back for the normal menu. read more

Sea Basin Restaurant - 1/2lb Stuffed Lobster Tail - Seafood Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

See all

Went to the Sea basin for dinner with a group recently, I had the stuffed lobster and some shrimp scampi. Both dishes were prepared and served hot and delicious. I would recommend. read more

Cheap booth seating. Sat in back booth for two. Way too short benches and pitched forward. Was weird! Could not enjoy meal. You shouldn't skimp. Make your patrons comfortable. Food is OK read more

So this one is tough because they have been pretty good in the past but it is just not consistent anymore. A couple visits ago the food was pretty good...not amazing but pretty good. And the ambiance is very nice & comfy...Feels like an upscale 90's-era restaurant. The last few times we ate there though, the food was bland, texture was weird and ultimately it was just hard to swallow. If the food was more consistent we would probably go back every now and again but it just hasn't really been worth it lately. read more

Our favorite! Great food-cherry pepper calamari, seared tuna, and everything is just the best! Love the atmosphere! Alysia the bartender is the BEST! Amazing drinks! read more