If you're looking for a basic, classic diner experience in, or near Cobleskill, you can't get much…read moremore spot-on than the Cobleskill Diner. We were visiting a relative in town and my wife, son and I took him for a late lunch at the diner. (Which we treated as breakfast, served all day. We were seated at a booth near the entrance...the upholstery needed a little help, and overall the place could use a little sprucing up. There's advertising on everything...the placemats, the coffee mugs, the glasses. At first, I thought it was a retro decor style choice until I realized all of these were featuring current local business ads. The coffee was okay. I've had worse but there was some flavor in it so it was a step above the "browned water" you can get at other places. The food was good enough for a classic diner experience. Not elevated in any way, but classic dishes served, well, classically. The breakfast potatoes were good and I was happy they were able to do egg whites without any question or up-charge in my breakfast. Portion sizes were okay. My teenage son needed to ask for an additional piece of French toast with his meal as he was still hungry after finishing the initial serving (with eggs and potatoes) We can chalk that up to a teenage appetite. I think the sweet-spot of the Cobleskill diner is the prices. They're low. You can get the same meal at diners in other places for twice the price. This makes it feel like a place that supports the local community. Our server was nice and took good care of us.

Loved my strawberry shortcake sundae! Yum! $6.99 / small…read more(this is a small!!) Nice place to sit outside with tables and service was friendly and fast. Lots of choices for the whole family! A must stop for ice cream this summer.

What an awesome spot! Friendly staff, delicious food in…read moregenerous portions and great prices, only wish I lived closer, I would most definitely be a regular! I ordered poached eggs over corned beef hash, rye toast and coffee My husband went with eggs over easy, a side of ham, rye toast and coffee All told, with a 30% tip, this came to $26. WHAT!!! In the town I live in that same amount of money would pay for ONE person's breakfast!

Went for breakfast Food was great…read moreService was excellent Prices were fair Will definitely go back

Excellent burger! Service was fast; decor and store are beautiful! Super friendly staff!read more

I'm giving this 3 stars due to service, not for the food. The food was excellent. Let me share why…read moreI'm giving it the 3 on service. We are not local, we are literally traveling through town to head south back to our home in NC after a 3 week road trip to Maine. We don't know the area at all , so we used Yelp to help find a place to eat a very late lunch. Nothing within an hour of here had great reviews and the ones that had okay reviews all seemed sketchy when we pulled into their parking lots. We then found this place. Yelp claimed it was open until 5. Google said 6. We arrived and saw 2 people sitting inside. I asked the cashier in the restaurant because the sign on the door said they close at 4 and it was 3:45. She said we could still eat. I even asked if she needed us to take it to go, she said no, it would be fine. We felt super uncomfortable the whole time. The young blond hair 20(ish) year old gentleman was very friendly with us. He was also helping the older women sitting by us that were wrapping things up. He gets 5 stars from us, he was fantastic. The young ladies that were working, and there were maybe 4 or 5 of them coming in and out of the kitchen and such, gave a bad vibe to a place that is probably usually really cool. They all acted frustrated and irritated with us. One girl mumbled something to the young gentleman about what we ordered like it was a hassle, but he quickly responded that our Caesar salad and panini were easy peasy and he could go make them. I'm not upset, however, a little irritated because I do understand we went in at closing, but I asked if it was okay to still order, and even told the girl it was not a big deal if they were closing and we could not order because we are typically not the people who do this. She said it was okay, so if those employees were to be irritated with anyone, it should be the girl who told us it was okay to order. Final thoughts, food was great, just don't arrive within 15-20 minutes before closing otherwise you might get glares, feel super uncomfortable, and have to eat fast like we did.

Awesome food, service, and sidewalk cafe atmosphere. The special was a hand cut ribeye, and was…read morethe best beef I have had since before Covid

Was a crowded Memorial Day. Our bus tour landed at…read moreCooperstown. Had a very delicious fish and chips and a nice stout to drink. Server was very busy but took great care of us!! Very nice inside.

Ok,granted this is definitely a hole in the wall diner. But,the food is always good. The staff is…read morealways friendly. And the prices are very reasonable. So if you want friendly service,great food and reasonable prices, you should consider this diner. I had the meatloaf with French fries and gravy. And a cup of stuffed pepper soup. Both were Very good. I overheard the server saying that they also serve Mac salad topped with gravy. I had already eaten my lunch so I'm saving that for next time. I've visited this diner more than a few times. Mostly breakfast and lunch. I haven't been disappointed yet. Thanks Ashly and the rest of the crew. This place is worth a try. Nothing fancy but a good meal to be had by all.

As soon as you enter , you are welcomed with a beautiful soul. Ashley, was real authentic raw and…read morekind. She welcomed us and gave us the specials . She cooked our food with love and entertainment. Breakfast and a show is very hard to come by. The breakfast was delicious!!! Eggs perfect . Bacon cooked to perfection. The toast was fresh and good. The pancakes stuffed me up for the whole day and was buttery goodness! Big mama Ashley you are the best! God bless you and keep being you! I hope I send some City folk your way because baybayyyy you are a STAR! And you deserve to be seen! If your ever upstate or hiking go to Miss Johnstown Diner , it's a small intimate diner with vibes beyond your imagination!

Came here for a late lunch on a Friday afternoon and we were worried that there would be a wait but…read morethankfully we got seated right away. The moment I stepped foot in the diner, I was instantly enveloped in a nostalgic and cozy atmosphere. It was full of charm with all the decorations. Definitely what you would picture in those classic movies/shows. Food was 10/10!! I ordered the buttermilk pancakes which is what they are most famous for and for good reason too! Fluffy and light and amazing portions (5 big pancakes with mixed berries)! The pancakes were so good that we bought a bag of pancake mix to take home. My sister ordered the eggs any way and she loved everything that came with it: eggs, choice of bacon or sausage, potatoes, and toast. Everything on the menu looked absolutely delicious and it was hard to decide what to order. They have weekly specials as well. Our waitress Susie was an absolute sweetheart and made our entire experience memorable. That being that we had asked her for some more water and by the time she came back around, someone else had already stopped by and filled up our glasses. She apologized for the delay by giving us a free chocolate chip cookie and it was the best damn cookie I've had in a long time. She went above and beyond for something that wasn't a big deal, but we appreciated the thought. I'd definitely come back here if I'm near the area.

By law you can't drive by this diner more than twice and not stop in for breakfast or lunch. Just…read moreget there early if possible if you are eating in, it's also good for take out if you are hitting the road. Set your expectation to 'diner' level and you will get far more than you expect out of each dish. It's also an over all pleasant environment with a great view and our door seating and service that gets you what you need. If you have vegan eaters in your group, they have an additional vegan menu if you ask for it.

Food is great diner food. Staff is friendly and efficient, they also are really on top of the…read morecoffee refills! Super attentive. Parking is a bit tight and seating scarce BUT during warm weather they have an outdoor seating area so it is easier to get seating then. Price is right

I don't recommend this place, bad food and service the same…read moreOrder waffles with eggs Waffles like rubber, eggs very dark like made with very tired oil Blond waiter never even look after bringing the food, had to call loud to get more coffee, waiter only look when I took money of my wallet Never again

Lovely diner. Looks small from outside but has number of areas with tables…read more Weekend brunch was filled with local families. Lots of pick-up orders also. The staff is fun. The food was good and came out fast. This is just a good diner

This traditional lunch car diner has its original insides with a newer addition on the side. Very…read morecute and retro. Good prices. Good service. Good food.