Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mill City Public House

    4.5 (125 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Updated 2 months ago

    Mill City Public House Photos

    Business Info

    MILL CITY PUBLIC HOUSE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Good for groups
    Happy hour specials
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mill City Public House

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Brussels sprouts
    Kay K.

    Phoned in a carry out order for the brussels sprouts and brisket french dip. Food was packaged well and held up after a 20 minute transit. The sprouts are heavily sauced (almost too saucey) but the combo of goat cheese and candied pecans is a winner. Just doesn't need so much balsamic glaze. The brisket french dip is dynamite. It's comfort food in all the right ways. The sandwich is a hefty portion and made for 2 delicious meals.

    Potosi root beer!! Best root beer around
    Quill G.

    This is our second time eating at Mill City: the first time was a mixed bag, but we've heard people rave about it so much that we decided to try again. It was an hour and a half wait, so obviously they are popular! The interior is a great mix of rustic and art-deco, with a fun-yet-classy feel. The staff are professional and efficient; they did a great job keeping things moving despite being obviously short-staffed. We ordered the Tropical Agua Fresca mocktail and did not enjoy it, it was missing flavor or sweetness to balance out the slightly bitter, watered-down taste. The burgers were tasty and the fries were good, but everything was VERY salty. I'm not convinced their items are worth their high prices, especially since you can get better food for cheaper elsewhere in the area. We also had the creme brulee for dessert; it wasn't bad, but it was too heavy on the vanilla. Overall, everything we have had there has lots of potential but ends up missing the mark due to imbalanced flavoring and over/under seasoning.

    Menu
    Clay G.

    Had a great lunch today at Mill City Public House in Kaukauna. The food was delicious and the Jackalope decor was fantastic. They kept Bob Ross on one television and Bon Appetite on the other. The service was amazing and we had the opportunity to meet one of the chefs. I had the "an okay burger" by name but it was everything great. We also had the brisket sandwich which was a home run. It was super tender and melted in my mouth. I'll highly recommend this jewel.

    Menu
    Kade B.

    Came here for lunch with my parents before a baseball game. I got the classic smash burger. Burger was great - the bun was toasted perfectly. Fries were a little over seasoned, but they were still good! Definitely on the pricier side, but I'd say it was worth it food wise. Service wasn't the best I've had. Our server took a while after greeting us to get our drink order, but service doesn't usually make or break a place for me (maybe because I usually dine alone and it doesn't bug me as much). I'd still recommend checking this place out to anyone visiting!

    Megan K.

    Drinks and food before a show, got a spot at the bar during our wait. Good experience- good drinks

    Aviation and pisco sour
    Gabby L.

    Everything about this place is amazing. First I want to compliment the Jack-elope decor & bob ross playing on the tv, the ambiance of this place is so nice! We started off with two cocktails (amazing btw) and Brussels sprouts. They looked so good I forgot to take a picture before we dug in and they were even better than they looked. I had a hard time deciding what to eat for my entree because there were so many options that looked so good!!! I settled for the salmon BLT because it was different and all the ingredients listed sounded amazing. I was very satisfied with my selection, it had so much flavor!! Boyfriend got the jalepeno bacon burger which also was amazing, he had them add bacon jam to it. We ordered a side of the truffle tots simply because we can't pass up truffle... we are addicted and they satisfied that addiction. We ordered another round of cocktails and dessert. The beignets were so good and not greasy at all which we have had an issue with at other restaurants in the past. Unfortunately we are not from Wisconsin so we can't come back to try all the other delicious sounding dishes, but fortunately we visit Appleton every year when we come into town for the EAA show and this will definitely be on our list to come back every year!

    Ok burger
    Helen S.

    I am currently in search of the best burger near me. I have had a couple of not so good ones, but today...yum. I checked my handy dandy Yelp app to see what my fellow friends suggested. Mill City Public House popped up. Sounded promising, so we went. I have really never understood the charm of a smashed burger before. This one was really good. Our server, Alex, was great! What an energetic and comedic guy. Really enjoyed him. I ordered the Cosmo Adjacent as my cocktail. It was something I had never tried before. Slightly fruity, a touch tart, but enjoyable. The menu is quite varied, and there were some other tempting items, but I remained focused and ordered the burger with fries. Wonderful decision. The double smash burger had just the right amount of char, aka the crunchy parts. The bun was also toasted. It may be the wagyu beef, or the excellent seasoning, but this burger was tasty. Fries were also good. The dining area we were in was small, but I think there might be another dining area. We were in the bar portion, while small, my husband and I did not feel cramped. We could have a conversation without any problems. Try it out and say Hi to Alex if you see him!

    Beet salad with salmon added
    Bri B.

    Atmosphere: Really small parking lot, tight fit during dinner hours. Host stand right when you walk in, please don't ignore and wait to be seated, they will move you if you seat yourself (I witnessed this a few visits back because a couple sat themselves at a large table when it was really busy and they were reseated to a 2 top). Trust the host! They know what they are doing. Large bar area. The inside is decorated really lovely. Comfortable seating throughout. Clean bathrooms. I love what they have on the tv's in the bar area, always fun to watch Bob Ross work his magic! Service: Host seats you right away and waters come shortly after. Staff does a good job describing the specials and are friendly. The waitstaff always has great communication with the kitchen, the apps are always spread out nicely from the entrée. Food: This is where I am so torn. I've ordered some of the same dishes several times, and one time it is the best thing you've ever eaten, and the next time it is just so-so. I think a lot of it has to do with the prep of the food and the garnish station. The meat portions are drastically different every time. I recommended to a friend to order the fried chicken sandwich, because it's something I've enjoyed. So we both order it, their piece of chicken was so small you couldn't even see it and was covered by the bun, and mine was so huge the bun looked like a cracker next to it. One time I ordered the ribs, super packed with garnishes (blue cheese, onion jam, scallions) and the ribs were really meaty, smokey and crispy on the outside. The next time I ordered them there was almost no garnish at all and the ribs were very wet with no crisp and little meat. They have great concepts, but I wish they would be more consistent. I will keep coming back hoping they find their groove.

    Creamy tomato soup
    Rachel R.

    Milly City is easily one of the best restaurants in Appleton! My husband and I eat there a few times a month. They have great menu staples but they all have a creative spin. The soups are particularly delicious and it's rare that I don't order their daily soup special! The staff at Mill City is extraordinarily kind and attentive. Service is always as good as the food! I would selfishly LOVE more vegetarian options! Most of the main entrees are meat-based (to be expected), so it would be nice if there were just a couple veg or veg-friendly additions, particularly to the larger plates. Although I like the falafel wrap and order it frequently, it is EXTREMELY salty, which I don't always have the palette for. When I don't order that, it can be hard to come up with a full vegetarian meal that's not made up of appetizers or a salad! All in all, totally love Mill City, and would recommend it to anyone!

    Absolutely incredible burger

    See all

    Photo of K M.
    0
    19
    0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Great neighborhood vibe. Really nice staff, great food, and enjoyed our meal very much.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Amazing food. Run by amazing people. Every burger is worth a try and the tots are fantastic. I also highly recommend the beignets as well.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Mill City Public House

    You might also consider

    Stone Arch Brewpub - The giant pretzel is a must order

    Stone Arch Brewpub

    4.0(447 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    $$

    I Came Back to Appleton... Wisconsin Immediately Fed Me…read more There are many ways to kick off an HS Reunion weekend. Apparently, the correct Wisconsin way is cheese curds, a soft pretzel, beer cheese, mustard, and craft beer. One of my host~family sisters and longtime friends brought me to Stone Arch Brewpub shortly after I touched down in Appleton, and this was exactly the kind of welcome~back I needed. Let's talk about those cheese curds. Pillowy. Soft. Tender. Ridiculously good. I don't say this lightly, but these may be some of the best cheese curds I've ever eaten. Then came the pretzel~super buttery and incredibly soft~with Wisconsin beer cheese and mustard for dipping. At that point, the reunion could have ended and I would've considered the trip successful. But we weren't done. We worked our way through an assortment of craft beers spanning Hazy IPAs, West Coast IPAs, Sours and Gose~style beers. The atmosphere was cool, the service was great, and the combination of food, beer and catching up with an old friend made this feel like the perfect beginning to my return to Appleton. Sometimes the best travel experiences aren't about finding the newest or trendiest place. Sometimes it's about sitting down with someone who knows you, sharing some great food and beer, and realizing some things really do feel like coming home. Stone Arch was a damn good way to start the reunion. Would absolutely return.

    The food was delicious. The waitress was kind and accommodating, and the service was excellent. I…read moreloved the warm glow of the restaurant and the feel of It's beautiful, rustic and historical decor. I didn't wanna leave! I will surely be back.

    Photos
    Stone Arch Brewpub - Adler Brau

    Adler Brau

    Stone Arch Brewpub - Scotch egg is delicious!!!

    Scotch egg is delicious!!!

    Stone Arch Brewpub - Dining room

    See all

    Dining room

    Marvol - Oysters

    Marvol

    4.4(5 reviews)
    1.0 mi

    This was the best meal I've had in YEARS. Also the best dirty martini I've ever had, hands down…read more The service was excellent and the staff was so friendly. The food was soooo good. It's very cozy in there so be prepared to sit literally right next to someone you don't know, but it was fine. Also not as expensive as I would have thought...for two of us, we got 5 items, plus a dessert, 2 beers, a glass of rosé and the martini, and it was only $165.

    Marvol has an ambitious name and ambitious goal...and like its sister restaurant (the eponymous…read moreEllinor), a paradoxically unassuming location. And like Ellinor, many may double check their Google maps as they get nearer to the restaurant, wondering if they're in the wrong place. Unlike Ellinor, Marvol lives in a small, obscure corner of Appleton - it's not in an established neighborhood full of progressive diners with progressive views and progressive palates. And I love them for it. Sure, it may have just been a business decision to minimize overhead, but it says something bigger. It's an Appleton restaurant - everyone is welcome. True to the owners' approach to dining, Marvol's seating is more than cosy. It's intimate. You have to be okay with getting close to a stranger for the journey. Marvol's food doesn't disappoint. More important than the storybook plating and the flare, the food screams of excellent sourcing. Marvol's trout belly and roe, Kendall's greens, Wisconsin sweet corn and crab. Every ingredient can stand on its own - but they're so much better together. Whereas Ellinor caters to the many with mainstays and midwestern must-haves (red meat, burger, pizza with pork in it), Marvol feels like a small test kitchen full of new ideas. Some will land, others won't, but it's all part of the experience. It kind of feels like Chef Adam is inviting us into his brainstorm, where he jots down his ideas for the week on a notebook - and that's the menu. Though I had my favorites, I don't think going through them would help you. Because Marvol has probably moved on. All I can say is, you can trust Adam. Note: A huge selling point of Marvol is their drinks. I did not try any, as I don't drink alcohol. There is no official NA cocktail menu.

    Photos
    Marvol - Dirty martini

    Dirty martini

    Marvol - Affogato

    See all

    Affogato

    Jim's Place - Lots of brews on tap.

    Jim's Place

    3.6(14 reviews)
    1.0 mi
    $

    Jim's Place is a classic local Appleton bar. The bar itself is wooden and has ample space for…read morepeople to sit. The crowd is pretty mixed: college students, 20-30-something townies, and throw in a couple old guys. The staff here is so friendly! I love the bartenders. They're always happy to replenish my water and never make me feel guilty for not ordering a drink (yeah, I know, I'm lame). When my friend moved away from Appleton, we threw her a goodbye party here because this was always her favorite bar. The group of us took up all of the tables and the staff was very attentive to all of us. The bartenders even played jukebox music just for us. The locals were as friendly as usual and chatted with some of us. What I love about Jim's Place is that it's laid-back (though not as much as, say, The Nickel) and you can still easily have a conversation with someone instead of yelling over the music. Also, the way the bar is set up makes it pretty easy to chat with people you don't know, which I like. Fun fact: I hung out with my professor here once!

    Bartender was super nice. She was awesome, attentive, and very friendly. Atmosphere is cool…read moredive bar. Love it. Mostly chill but there are a few (seem like regulars) that are really off putting. Don't try to just strike up a conversation with the person beside you. So rude. It's not a reflection of the whole bar... but that regular flamer was a dickhead. Totally made me uncomfortable and want to leave. Couldn't wait to finish my beer.

    Photos
    Jim's Place
    Jim's Place - Good friends and great times make this easy going historic bar a rare gem in downtown Appleton! Good drinks fabulous pizza.

    Good friends and great times make this easy going historic bar a rare gem in downtown Appleton! Good drinks fabulous pizza.

    Jim's Place - Monis presents Jims Place

    See all

    Monis presents Jims Place

    Mill City Public House - beerbar - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...