The bread was awful. Maybe it's my fault because I didn't want it toasted but the first sandwich I…read moreordered was not just dry, it tasted like it was a few hours from turning moldy. Just wrong. They remade it with a good attitude, and the bread was so dry it just crumbled apart and was dry enough to choke on. I ate half with no bread. Two stars for ok service and a decent amount of meat. I forgot to add mozzarella and when I asked to add it, I was told my sandwich "was already on the other side" er, it's 6 steps and the cheese is right there. The guy on the other side did it but wow. The ambience was fine. Clean space. Since the place has pickle in the name I expected at least a small side spear like most other delis or a variety of pickles for sale. Neither of those things is true. Just odd. 1 sandwich 1 single serving of chips and a 12 oz drink was almost 18 dollars. I will never go back.

Driven by here a few times since moving to NWA. Decided to try it today for lunch. Underwhelmed is…read morean understatement. Not a big eater but the meat to bread ratio is wild and not in a good way. Also a small smear of avocado for $1.49 outrageous. Maybe I ordered the wrong thing but a turkey sandwich should be the standard. Maybe I would come back to try pizza.

The #11 Italian is my go to. You can't pass up on their cookies either. Always amazing staff. The…read moreoverall atmosphere is fantastic too. It is clean and professional.

Had great sandwiches and salads today. Staff were friendly and helpful. Italian is really good…read moreand I had a turkey/ham that hit the spot. Wife had the spinach salad with balsamic which she enjoyed. Sandos are light toasted and full of flavor. Definitely recommend.

Top notch Italian Beef (on par with Portillo's). The Tomato Bisque is excellent with just a little…read morezip. It's nice that half sandwiches are an option. I had a half grilled cheese to go with my soup.

I thought they were a little expensive compared to others at first, but I'm now seeing that's…read morepretty average around here! I still think they're worth it!

It may not be a bastion of gourmet ingenuity, but Pickleman's deserves a lot better than a 2.5 star…read moreaverage just because they bungled a few delivery orders. What evidence do I have to support my contention? I'm glad you asked. Exhibit A, and without question the restaurant's Pièce De Résistance, is the lentil chili. Now, I know what you're thinking - chili is supposed to contain meat and only a communist would proffer such a vaunted title on a vegan dish. Right? I used to think the same way, but the delicious balance of chili seasoning and fearless heat of Pickleman's take on this classic makes it one of my go-to late night dishes when I'm hanging out downtown. Exhibit B is composed of the salad selection, which features options to suit many tastes, all of which contain genuinely fresh vegetables in addition to their specific peculiarities. That may seem like a simple thing, but seasoned salad eaters know it can be rare, indeed. It may seem weird to lead off a review of a sandwich and pizza place with two options that are neither, but I've honestly never had any reason to venture beyond that side of the menu because they're both so delicious. And that they do those things so well is more than enough reason for me to juice their rating, whatever failings other reviewers have experienced notwithstanding.

Someone kept saying I should go here...since my family is from Chicago and Italian Beefs are our…read morejam. Well, this one isn't a full on traditional beef. The bread is a certain toasted taste. Wrong. The beef had a certain twang taste. Wrong. The au jus was the start of a good taste. But, needed more seasoning and especially more salt. **italian beef shown, is double beef. Cost an extra $5 or so to do it...

"Your restaurant is so good. The lady waitress was nice. My…read moregrilled cheese was 10/10." Declan 8yrs old. Dad- Italian stallion- 7/10 Only because I tasted the olive and I'm not a fan of olive. But other than that it was good. Mom- caparese melt- 9/10 Only because it had too much pesto for my liking. The vibes were chill the waitress was very nice. Our kid is on the spectrum and is hard to please sometimes but he loved it he even tried his dad Italian stallion and gave it a thumbs up. We will be back next time we are in AR. Thank you!

Driving through Fayetteville, I had to stop at Hammontree's Grilled Cheese. I've seen this place…read moreall over the internet for years, so it finally made the list. First impressions were a bit mixed. The restaurant was quiet, but the floors were noticeably dirty, and the restrooms were just okay. Nothing outrageously bad, but definitely not as clean as I would expect for such a slow night. The service was probably the biggest disappointment. Our server wasn't rude, but she wasn't particularly welcoming either. She took our order, dropped off the food, and brought the check without ever really checking back in. There were only three occupied tables in the restaurant with three servers working, so it wasn't like they were overwhelmed. One thing that really stood out was that every employee in the dining room except the bartender had headphones either in their ears or hanging around their necks. It gave the impression that customer service wasn't much of a priority. I started by ordering a sweet tea, only to be told they don't have it because they brew their tea in-house and "can't add sugar." That explanation seemed a little odd. I switched to a Coke instead, which turned out to be one of the flattest fountain drinks I've had in a long time. After a few sips, I gave up and just drank water. Now for the part that really matters: the food. We ordered the Kids Rookie grilled cheese and the Big Dog from the kids' menu, along with the Cheebacca and the Brie's Company. We also couldn't leave without trying the Blueberry Grilled Cheese for dessert. The only real miss on the food side was the chips. They were stale, cold, and almost rubbery. Honestly, they were some of the worst house chips you could possibly have. The sandwiches deserve a much better side, or they'd honestly be better off taking the chips off the menu altogether. The kids' meals were an incredible value at only $5 each. My 5-year-old couldn't decide between a grilled cheese and a hot dog, so he got both. The Big Dog was excellent--hot, juicy, and grilled just long enough to get those perfect char marks. The Rookie was exactly what you'd want for a picky eater: simple, cheesy, and well made. The Cheebacca ($12) was packed with sharp white cheddar, house cheese, bacon, pulled pork, grilled onions, and a garlic cilantro sauce on sourdough. Every ingredient complemented the next, and nothing overpowered the sandwich. Easily one I'd order again. The Brie's Company ($12) was the surprise of the meal. Grilled apples, Brie, Gouda, caramelized onions, and fig jam on sourdough sounded adventurous, but it absolutely worked. Sweet, savory, rich, and balanced all at once. If you're willing to step outside the traditional grilled cheese, this one is worth trying. Then came dessert. The Blueberry Grilled Cheese ($7.25) combines mascarpone, cream cheese, fresh blueberries, and honey between slices of grilled pound cake. It sounds unusual, but somehow it's fantastic. It's one of those desserts that makes you question why you've never had it before. Awkwardly delicious in the best possible way, and absolutely worth ordering. Overall, Hammontree's is a place where the kitchen is doing almost everything right while the front of house leaves quite a bit to be desired. Cleaner dining areas, better service, and replacing those terrible chips would easily push this into 4 star territory. As it stands, the food absolutely lives up to the hype, but the overall experience holds it back. If you're passing through Fayetteville, it's still worth stopping in. Just skip the chips, order one of the specialty grilled cheeses, and don't leave without trying the dessert.

This Jimmy John's has CONSISTENTLY been over an hour late for all deliveries I have ordered,…read moreregardless of the fact that it was pre-scheduled for a specific arrival time. (Example: placing an order at 9am for a 11:30am arrival time, and food arrives at 12:55pm)

We ordered from here tonight on door dash. While the order was made quickly, it didn't take much…read moretime since the sandwiches were made so terribly. There's minimal dressings, almost no avocado on them, copious amounts of cheese and almost no meat. The bread was rock hard and tasted like it was so cold it was frozen. Seriously, don't bother with this place. Terrible excuse for a sandwich, and the management should be embarrassed they have employees serving food like this to customers paying their outrageous prices.

Great food service and love the Mennonite dresses and atmosphere - the menu has great choices and…read morethe little store at the entrance has great products

Keeping it simple, there is not a better desert option in NWA. Most people go for the bread…read morepudding, which is phenomenal, but I've always loved their French Silk. I don't see it in the menu anymore, but it is a light chocolate that melts...

I don't know what makes their sandwiches so darn good but they are DELICIOUS! Maybe it is the…read morehomemade bread. Worth stopping in for lunch!

Wow! What a jewel!!…read moreThis place is run by Amish and Mennonite's. It's fabulously clean and inviting! Fresh baked goods are the highlight! Bread selections can include sour dough, jalapeño cheddar, white and ... Then sweets and treats cookies, muffins... selections change often. Deli selection is great! Sweet Lebanon bologna plus the standard chicken, turkey, ham and more!! Frozen entrees supply is growing! Ready for you to take home and reheat! Haven't tried any but I've had their cook's food and I'm sure it's amazing!! Fresh - salads, butter, an assortment and it varies. So be sure and check the fridge every time!! Specialty sodas too! Gourmet chips. A few tables do sit at but it's mostly a to-go kind of place! Oh and a drive through window too.

I'm a bit of a self-confessed "burger snob"... I was a happy camper here! Lean beef, hand pattied,…read morecooked with just a slight crisp on the outside and tender inside. Toasted bun and, really outstanding fries! Simple but, rare to get a really good one. On-prem brewed beer was solid too (yes, they sell cans of mass beer too) and friendly owners in a cozy establishment right on Main Street Gentry. So, if you are left of Btv/Rogers, any where near Siloam Springs or Gentry, give this place a try - you won't be disappointed!

Yum!! The chicken…read moretacos ar the best I've ever eaten. Chunks of chicken (not dry shreds) lots of seasonings and served with onions and cilantro. The agua frescos are SO fresh!! They may be out of something but that happens when it's fresh made food!

The place was empty, and the service was great. The taco salad was good but it had rice In it and…read moreI'm not big on rice but it was good. Couple little pieces of tomatoes, guessing they ran out. All in all it was pretty good, if I'm in the area I might stop in again and try something else but can't see myself driving out of my way to get there