For once, I don't have a lot to say because there are only so many words you need to say "some of the best pies you'll ever eat". Hmm...just eight words, it seems. Everything I've ever had from Mixed Fillings has been great -- not just good, great. Everyone I've encountered with the business has been incredibly kind, too. What makes the pies stick out most for me are the crusts. I'm a bit picky about pie crusts -- they need to not be bland but not overpower the filling, and they have to be firm enough to hold up but not so firm as to be unpleasant to slice through or eat. Mixed Fillings nails this. I'm writing this as I take my last few bites of a delicious buttermilk blueberry pie, and I'm already thinking about what I want to purchase next. read more

Getting some pie slices for my hubby for his birthday weekend while at RAM. I happily also picked up one of the chocolate chip cookies I have seen on their socials but never had. Is there anything they do that is not next level? I was never a pie person and Mixed Fillings changed that. It's not just a slice of pie, it's layered flavors that so perfectly complement each other. My husband shared a bite of his 99 Problems but Nutella Ain't One, the chocolate and mascarpone with that delicious Oreo crust (and I don't normally like Oreos), wow! My cookie choice was amazing, the buckwheat and corn meal chocolate chip cookie was so different and easily the best chocolate chip cookie I have had in a long time. Short line and quick service, just let them know what you want and they pack it all up for you. Just bring a cooler or take it home quick in this heat! read more

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop - 99 Problems, but Nutella Ain't One - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Natasha and Curtis always have a smile and THE BEST pies HANDSSSS DOWN!! They may now be in their third location and while I do miss the charming quaint shop location with blooming passion flowers their pies are still 10000% on point and now they have room for classes! I love swinging by their booth at Riverside Arts Market on Saturdays and can confirm I countdown every year for my birthday month pie aka time for Black Bottom pie, a delicious key lime with oreo crust. read more

1. Key lime hands-down, one of the best Keylime pies that I have ever had. The crust was buttery, but it also had like a granola with pecans in it. Oh my God it was absolutely delicious. The key lime was the perfect balance of citrusy but very creamy as well. Absolutely loved it five out of five stars. I've never had anything like it. 2. Pecan. At first I was afraid because I felt like I just paid seven dollars for a slice of store-bought pecan pie from appearance. However, after biting into it, it certainly was not your store-bought pecan pie. Perfect balance of not too sweet, but still a little salty the molasses the toasted pecans. It was all perfect. The crust was your standard crest. Nothing spectacular about that one like the Keylime, but it was very very good. The service was excellent. You cannot go inside the building. You have to to order it at the door. All in all awesome experience, I would go back to try others. read more

See all

Mixed Pie Fillings has turned dessert into a community experience. I found Natasha on Instagram and fell in love with her passion for life, love, and my ultimate love language (FOOD)! We look for the "pie lady" every Saturday at RAM! Thank you to the Mixed Pie Fillings fam for cultivating such a beautiful community through everybody's favorite language: dessert! Jax is better because off because of y'all! You'll love it all, but shoutout to OK Boomer and Blurred Limes for being good starting points! read more

Mixed Fillings had a booth at the Riverside Arts Market, and I was thrilled to try a pie from one of the most iconic pie shops in the country via Food & Wine. The hardest part was narrowing it down to one slice, but I managed, selecting the Black Bottom Pie. A nod to Black History Month, this key lime pie had an Oreo crust and torched meringue, making it extra special. 10/10 read more

We recently placed an advanced order for a pie done only for special occasions. The Head Honcho. We picked it up at the charming new location in downtown Jax. I'm truly glad they've found a great storefront again. They are always polite, eager to serve and epitomize the type of local business you want to support. Oh, forgot to mention, the best pie you'll ever have...anywhere. We weee fortunate enough to order the Head Honcho. Think butterscotch meringue. Sweet, thick, creamy on top, with a genius pretzel crust to balance everything out. If you live close and haven't tried Mixed Fillings, don't wait. If you're far away...make the drive. You'll thank me later. Highly recommend this gem. read more

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop - Head Honcho - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I love Mixed Fillings! I've been a fan since the very beginning and have followed them from their original location until now. I've also had the pleasure of taking two in-person classes in their current spot, and I've learned so much. Everyone is always so nice and eager to help. And the pies are delicious! read more

*Quick Note*: just because this location is closed doesn't mean that Mixing Fillings is closed! You can preorder pies and pick them up currently on Saturdays at Riverside Arts Market! There is a reason why Mixing Fillings is at the top of multiple lists saying that they have the BEST pies in the Southeast. It's because they are the best. My favorite pie that they make is called the Love and Light. It's a lemon meringue strawberry jam pie with a pretzel brown sugar crust. Beyond heavenly. Sometimes self-care comes in the form of deliciousness. My only complaint is that I usually can't get to a Mixed Fillings location or pop-up prior to them selling out for the day, but that's a yay for them and a sad for me. I'm so glad to see businesses doing the thang. That said, make sure to preorder your pie so that you can guarantee that you get one. Can't decide on just one pie? Then order a PIE FLIGHT and get slices of multiple different pies. read more

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop - Love & Light Pie! - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Her pies are my favorite--every single one is so well done. The crust is perfect and the fillings are always balanced, not overly sweet. You can really taste the care in what she makes. read more

Best Pie, Best Vibe, Best Humans, Creative, Loving, Fun, Sassy, Giving, Amazing Community Connectivity, Accepting, Passionate, Generous, Professional, Witty, Charming, Experienced, Outstanding Customer Service and Their Pie is UNMATCHED PURE MAGIC YUMMY FLAKY DELICIOUSNESS. One of the very best woman/ family owned businesses in Jacksonville and is a MUST STOP for 904, beyond and travelers. Eat the Pie, Enjoy Life and Taste Love in EVERY FREAKING BITE! read more

See all

The pies are delicious . I stood in line to get several slices. Nothing compares to the variety or taste.

I really don't know where to begin this review because this place is so overwhelmingly phenomenal that if I start with the pies, I'm missing out on the customer service if I start with customer service I'm missing out on the quaint shop that is very warm and inviting and if I start on that, then I forget about the artwork that's for sale. So as you can tell, there's a lot going on in very small place. I will start with the owners a wife and husband team, who truly put their heart and soul into these pies. They have created very cute names (Sienfeld must have been a favorite show) for each of their pies have a creative title (one of them should be named "no pie for you"). They're very artistically displayed and slices prepared to the side . You can tell from the first bite they use real butter and only the freshest ingredients. Of the four pieces that we purchased for sampling the crème brûlée was by far my favorite! Rich with flavor, sweetness to the last bite this one is one to last for all season! The apple pie was very good, maybe a little more sweetness to it, but it was great. The maple pie was exceptionally sweet. If you do not have a sweet tooth this one is not for you. However the crust was phenomenal. Finally the peach pie. I'm not a big peach fan but my aunt loved it. My uncle really enjoyed it and I would say it wasn't bad, if only I liked peaches. But again their crust is out of this world. When you walk in your greeted by the wife, who has the most genuine smile, and is most gracious and welcoming you to what is like her home. While she is busy in the front providing outstanding customer service, her husband is to the side working in the bakery, making pies that are just out of this world. They make a great team and you can tell they truly enjoy what they're doing! To bring a sense of community, they have various pieces of artwork for sale by local artists. I believe this is a phenomenal touch to embrace the community add artwork while they share their own artwork, the artwork of pie making. Overall, this is definitely a place. I will come back between the customer service and the pies I'm hooked for life!! read more

See all

Update 6/14/25: THEY have a NEW location! It's downtown across from the courthouse. If you have any questions check out their IG for all info including on parking. The pie always slaps here. I don't even like pie that much but I love their Wake me up before you cocoa! It hits the spot. Today I added a scoop of ice cream and omg the best!! I got to meet the owner Natasha and she's a sweet in person as she is online. This small business does SO MUCH for our community besides feeding us amazing pies. You will not be disappointed! Sorry no pics. I couldn't wait to eat my pie. read more

This was my first visit to their location on Park St. Their previous location was fun, but I loved being able to see Chef Natasha in action. I was warmly greeted by her cousin upon entering & picked up my order from her hubby at the end of the counter. I recognized them from their social media posts and it really added to the cozy vibe inside the beautiful shop. I'm a planner, so I pre-ordered my pie flight a few days in advance to be sure I could get the slices I wanted. Of the four I selected, I'd only had one before- Blurred Limes because I can never resist key lime pie. I thought about ranking the slices but that's really a pointless endeavor because each one is delicious, decadent, & divine. read more

See all

https://www.instagram.com/reel/dwtwvlsx648/?igsh=adjhmwtrbdd6anro today 4.4.26 i found "mixed feelings pie shop" by happenstance @ ram it was my 1st time ever.... hearing of this bakery, i love key lime pie until today i thought j.alexander had the best.... there was, with publix coming in a strong 2nd, but after buying a piece of this pie, i must say hands down the award goes to mixed fillings pie shop it was delicious it was by far theeee.... best.... key lime pie ive ever.... had support small businesses, easter & mother's day are coming up, order your pie today. your family, friends, loved ones & pallet will thank you as a resident of jax, we all.... must.... do our part to help our local shops grow, especially.... downtown. i wish them the best & much success ig @lartisanmarketllc #jmgwmtfl read more

Wow wow wow!! I actually am not that big into pie but Mixed Fillings makes such delicious pies it's dangerous! I would for sure be ordering pies from them often if I lived in the area. I tried both the beach don't kill my vibe which is a coconut cream pie topped with a coating of chocolate and their crème brûlée pie. The crème brûlée pie was so cool because the crackling sugar top added great texture to the pie. They were both so perfect I can't decide on a favorite. The pie shop was cutely decorated and the staff that we interacted with were friendly. The slices are $7 each. They have an option for pie flights as well. A whole pie varies around $40. Honestly I don't think you can go wrong with any pie so just try to try them all! read more

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop - Crème brûlée pie - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

I drove over two hours to experience Mixed Fillings Pie Shop and will do it again and again! It is a must-visit for dessert lovers. We actually got a slice of each pie on the menu that day to try. Blurred Limes is my all time favorite! All of the pies are fresh, flavorful, and perfectly balanced with flaky and creative crusts and delicious fillings. The staff is friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. Whether for a slice or a whole pie, you won't be disappointed! HIGHLY recommend!!! read more

Im so glad i got a chance to check them out before they closed! They have some phenomenal pies and should have gotten more when I went, but unfortunately I did not know they would be closing! The service was also great here and they have the cutest pie shop. Can't wait to go back when they reopen at their new place, whenever they have a location. read more

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

The pies are melt in your mouth blessings from the food gods! I highly recommend ordering one for pickup, or stopping by for a slice.

Outstanding pie! Truly special!! The key lime pie with pretzel crust was memorable and perfect for birthday!

My husband stopped by this shop today and picked up a variety of slices for Valentine's Day. The coconut pie was rich and creamy and the layer of chocolate just made it better. The peanut butter pie is light and fluffy and the chocolate crust was delicious. The brownie pie is a thick and goofy and the crust is crunchy. we'll be sharing that tomorrow night with vanilla ice cream. This a hidden gem! Absolutely love it!! read more

The walk-up format makes it easy to quickly get some pie and go! Excellent customer service(we had lots of questions) and a wide variety of options. The pie is made from scratch and Delicious. Must try! I'll be a repeat customer. read more

I had Mixed Fillings on my radar for a while and finally got a chance to stop in on a recent trip to Jacksonville. It is so worth a visit! The shop is very cute with greenery and cozy vibes. But the best part is the case filled with sweet and savory pie selections. I opted for a 6-slice pie flight because I couldn't pick just one flavor! It was such a fun way to sample the various options. I took home slices of creme brulee, blueberry, cookies and cream, peanut butter chocolate, banana cream and key lime. Each one was lighter than I expected - not too sweet, just the perfect amount. I highly recommend this spot to satisfy your sweet tooth with a slice or to pick up a full pie for a special occasion. If I lived closer, I would certainly be getting my holiday dessert from here! read more

See all

Went to the shop on Tuesday afternoon. Shop was quaint. Counter style eat in. Owner is very personable. The bakery case was filled with pies. The counter clerk was very helpful. Ordered: Cookies and Dreams Key Lime Sugar Creme Brûlée Apple of my Pie Taste: Oreo takes like the actual cookie and was silky and smooth. Surprisingly did not have a chalky texture or aftertaste. Very impressive and delicious. Apple of My Pie was bomb.com. I was expecting it to be overly sweet and it was not which was a welcomed surprise. The crumb topping was fire and the crust is flaky. We have not yet tried the others and will update when we do. Overall beautiful store front with excellent pie. read more

One of my favorite stops for dessert in Jax! Their shop is so cute, their owner is so sweet and their flavors are delicious - not to mention the punny names! Stop in, you won't be disappointment! read more

See all

Such a cute, cozy, welcoming pie gem in Jax!! It's so hard to find good pie places in Jax with variety. First time here-- tbh I've had this place saved in my Yelp collections for a while and wish I visited sooner. Finally came after several recs from friends & family. I came here with my bf who is visiting from NYC who really wanted to try some great southern pies and we were more than pleased. We ordered the flight of 6 pies for $38- which was absolutely perfect for indecisive foodies who want to try nearly everything they see! The pies & their names that we bought are pictured as attached. HIGHLY recommend their Creamsicle pie (seasonal I think?) which was perfect for someone like me who dislikes fruit/jammy pies-- I loved this fruit pie since it was a more vanilla-y creamy pie with notes of fruity fragrant citrusy flavor. And as a chocolate lover, I highly recommend anything "French Silk" from here; this first time I bought the only one available which was the OK, Boomer pie. My bf loved the Creamsicle and the Blurred Limes (Key Lime) pie so much that he ended up going off on his own after our lil sampling to buy 2 FULL sized $40 pies of those 2 flavors (which we almost had no fridge space for, but I tried to make space anyways). The full pies we bought will be shared with some of my friends & family to try to spread the love :) I'm a chocolate pie, cream pie, & custard pie girlie, so you bet I will be on the lookout!! read more

See all

We were greeted by a lovely lady who described all the pies to us as we couldn't make a choice. She told us that the Key Lime has been voted #1 in Florida! WOW! You can buy by the slice or by the pie. So my friend & I purchased several slices to go as we were going to be kind & share with our spouses. We got the Key Lime, the Apple and a coconut cream all to go. Slices were large considering the price is a little more than your average. All were taste tested by several of us and were rated very good to excellent. My favorite part was the delicious whipped cream. This is not just a to go place. You can sit down & have your pie with coffee & other drinks. There was plenty of parking the day we were in Riverside. read more

See all

Omgggg to die for! This pie is simply incredible! The shop is so cute and trendy! The staff is just too sweet! Order and head and pick up at the end of the counter! Highly recommend! Made Easter weekend snacking that much more delis read more

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop - Peanut Butter & Jealous Pie - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

best pie ever and I'm not even a huge fan of pie!! recommend Key Lime and the Lemon/Lavender! The pretzel crust changes the game. The pie is super fresh too!! Support small jax businesses :) read more

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I love these pies here!! It's some of the best pies I've ever had. I've tried two of the pies so far (the key lime with cranberry topping and the apple pie with walnut topping) and loved them both. I ended up getting the key lime one (Chill, Don't Cross the Lime) for the holidays. The people here are also super sweet. I love supporting small businesses in Jacksonville :) read more

See all

I've never been a huge pie person but Mixed Fillings Pie changed my mind. I've been here countless times and every time I have guest in town, I make sure I bring them here. It's super cute here. You walk through a little alley and ring a bell to get service. I want to say I've tried a good number of the pies here. The mousse ones are my favorite. Peanut butter & jealous, a whole latte pie, I've got 99 problems but Nutella ain't one and cookies & dreams are some of my favorites. All sweet pies that are always good the next day. The key lime pie is also super delicious! The other pies I've tried are yummy but not my preference when it comes to pie. My friend got me the ultimate flight for my birthday. She had called in to ask if they could write happy birthday on the box for me and they came through and was super sweet when I picked up. I believe you can't pick and choose your pies with the ultimate flight. If you're planning a trip, I would go early on the weekends because they get busy and they sell out quick. The savory pies always sell within the hour that they open in my experience so I haven't gotten the chance to try chicken pot pie yet. Also be sure you have a lot of time on holidays because the line get long! Totally worth it but I think I waited an hour on pi day. Still always one of my most recommended place to try in JAX and I love supporting a small business. :) read more

See all

Yum yum yum. Great to see a small local business thrive. I visited them way back when they were on Oak Street and now they are front and center on Park Street. Lovely spacious space with bar seating and a few comfy chairs to sit and indulge on the delectable pies made by these artisans. Rather than getting a cake we decided to come here and celebrate a birthday. You can't go wrong with their rich Key Lime Pie. A packed in surprise in their crust is a pretzel and brown sugar crunchy goodness. The mix of crunchy and creamy and tart and sweet and salty are a party in your mouth. The staff is very friendly and obviously proud of their works of art. They serve it with love. The fun pie names makes it even more enjoyable. Blurred Limes for example. Don't miss this experience. Worth the drive from wherever. read more

See all

We experienced Mixed Fillings Pie Shop for our first time and we were excited just looking at the pies in their cases. This is a female owned family business that makes some tasty pies with creative recipes. Today we ordered three slices and they were: Beach Don't Kill My Vibe (coconut cream with a chocolate ganache topping, whipped cream and flaky crust) and Chill Don't Cross the Lime ( Spiced Cranberry sauce, lime custard, whipped cream, pretzel brown sugar crust) and lastly, OK Boomer (Old Fashioned toasted pecan crust is filled with decadent French silk and topped with an espresso whipped cream). Slices are around $7 and whole pies are $40. They even offer a pie flight which is several slices of pie that make up a whole pie for $40. The pies we tried are magnificent and well worth not only the price but worth a three hour drive from Orlando to experience this exceptional emporium of super tasty pie heaven. The staff member that assisted us is a cousin of the owner and she was awesome, friendly and very helpful. We have many more pies to try so a future visit is planned. We might even order pies for Christmas. If you plan to order pies fir the holidays you really should think about that weeks before the holidays. read more

See all

"You down with OPP (Yeah you know me!!!)" "You down with OPP (Yeah you know me!!!)" "Whos down with OPP (Every last slice Homie!!)" Anyone familiar with that 90's song famously sung by the wrap band "Naughty by Sweet Nature"? The song talks about "OPP" which in general means "Other People's Pies" Well this time around, I don't want yalls Pies or any other pies. And stay away from me if I happen to bring some goodies from The Mixed Fillings Pie Shop because I...am...NOT...sharing. Mixed Fillings Pie Shop is a small shop that delivers uniquely named pies. The pies doesn't disappoint. And the pies are not overly sweet, which is what I like about them the most. They go perfectly with ice cream or coffee. The menu is straight to the point and seasonally, they will introduce new pies. Come stop by and visit the friendly staff. So again, I leave you with BYOP (bring your own pies). I'll gladly say BYOB; I'll bring the beers.... ...but don't you dare touch my Pies. Capish!?! read more

See all

OMG! I fell in love with this place after one bite. Hubby picked up a couple slices for us to share. He arrived around 2 pm and there was already a limited selection. We still got 2 great flavors. Blurred Limes - best key lime pie slice I've ever had! Slight tartness, perfect consistency, fresh whipped cream and epic pretzel crust. Worth trying if you think key lime pie is usually too tart. The Moon Pie - smooth, chocolatey, marshmallowy, epic pretzel crust. S'mores and chocolate pie fans, get this one! I recommend both of these and honestly couldn't pick a favorite. I loved the pretzel crust, very unique and had a wonderful texture. I'm looking forward to trying a few new pie flavors very soon. read more

See all

I'm not a big pie person but every pie i tried was delicious. Each had a rich filling full in flavor but not overly sweet. My favorite was the creme brûlée pie. If it's your first time visiting, I would suggest a flight: 4 slices for 25 dollars. You can tell each pie was made with love and tender care. I can't wait to go back for the chicken pot pie. read more

See all

Sometimes a place Just captures the joy of dessert! And not just the sugar high or the novelty of something you can't have at home. But rather the combination of master recipes, perfect technique, excellent team training, & flawless execution all together with the lighthearted comfort of pies! The quality of the pies at Mixed Fillings would easily justify fine dining if dessert wasn't often relegated to an afterthought or something enjoyed "after" something else. Here, the pies are the main attraction. And the variety matches the quality! Whether you prefer fruit pies, mousse pies, cream pies, key lime, or even savory quiches - this place offers a staple of excellent choices, plus seasonal features. I learned about Mixed Fillings from a feature in Yelp, appropriately. And whenever we visit Jacksonville from So. Florida, we make a point to visit. After a few years, we've enjoyed continued quality & witnessed steady growth of the business. When we 1st found Mixed Feelings, they were located in a charming, but almost secret alley location that had an immense "cool" factor - like a speakeasy, take-out for sweets. Back then, pies seemed to sell out before midday & picking up pies meant you also had to deal with the weather & tight parking (there was no indoors). We visited their new location today and - wow! Quaint & spacious - welcoming & promising. Hopefully a sign of continued success for many years. Based on their excellent product & their communication on social media, it's obvious the proprietors work hard to offer their best. And I'm willing to plainly claim that this is easily the best in Jacksonville & possibly the best in the entire state. read more

See all

I've come here on two occasions now and have finally tried enough of their pies to give a review (pie is serious business). The shop is nestled in five points, which makes it a little cumbersome when it comes to parking. Staff members are super friendly and the place has local art for sale on the wall. Key lime - Their award winning key lime pie was just okay to be honest. The pretzel crust was a pleasant surprise though! Lavender Lemon - okay Oreo - If you love Oreos get this! Loved it. Would come back just for this. Crème brûlée - good, but the sugar was too burnt causing too much bitterness. Mushroom Quiche - 8/10 even though them warming it up means nuking it in a microwave.... It's probably phenomenal fresh out of the even. I have no mixed feelings about this place. All the pies served are above average, if not great. If you want good pie in Jacksonville come here! read more

I got the Wake Me Up Before You Cocoa pie slice from here!! This place was voted the #1 pie shop in Florida for 2022 and I'm not even the slightest bit of surprised to hear this great news! Their pies are exquisite, heavenly, and one of a kind! My pie had chocolate chunks, espresso, and cocoa combined with a savory pretzel brown sugar crust which was the perfect combination! It created the right level of sweetness overall! This is a woman owned and black owned speakeasy pie shop that offers a number of specialty pies! They're currently in the process of opening up a sit down pie shop which I'm super excited to visit!! ⁣ read more

See all