The beer was good. The atmosphere and decor were top notch. The food, however, was just average. I had the fries with beef, which wasn't bad, and would have been really good had the pasta sauce on it been seasoned a bit. The pickled shrimp was a fancy description for baby cocktail shrimp. The wings were a bit over seasoned and not great. I'll be back for the beer and atmosphere, but I will not go there if I am hungry. read more

This place used to be an easy 4 or 4.5 star brew pub but frankly the food has gone a bit down hill over the last year. They used to have a really delicious beef and cheddar stew in a bread bowl. They used to have a really good poutine appetizer. They used to make a really good juicy delicious bacon cheese burger. Now they have canceled the stew and the poutine but they have replaced them with slightly overcooked tater tot's that harken back to middle school cafeteria lunch. And they have changed that delicious juicy bacon cheese burger to a style they refer to as a "smash burger" which basically means they smash it thin and flat so that it is over cooked and dry and a bit burnt but they slather it with a sort of beer cheese sauce to make up for the lack of juicy deliciousness. Their beer has always been pretty good but it seems to me that lately their beers have been getting more and more heavily hopped and bitter. I guess it is a popular style but not to my taste. Their outdoor beer garden is a very nice space and they are expanding it. So that is good. On the whole I think this place is still reasonably good. It is worth coming to for an evening out with friends but no longer a destination for great food and drink. read more

Stopped in for a mid day beer or 3. Enjoyed each one we tried. Only snacked on their potato tots as we were going out to eat later. Very good. Everyone was friendly and attentive. We live about 100 miles away but made a point if stopping in. Glad we did. read more

See all

The food has delicious. Friendly staff. Great service. Keeping all covid standards. Will definitely go again.

I liked the atmosphere! The shareables were Very Tiny! I got the vegan Poutine, which is French fries with gravy. It was ok! The Thrift Store Pale Ale was good! It is brewed to benefit Operation Veterans Hope! Overall I would come back for a beer and to try their Imposter Vegan sausage! I realized they had it after I ordered!! I think this is a college hangout in the evenings. read more

See all

Incredibly rude staff! They operate with an attitude that they are doing you a favor by waiting on you. I thought that it might have just been because we had a large group - but nope. Between my visit by myself and another friend visiting with his friend - service was consistently rude. Send a clear message to them and go spend your money somewhere else. read more

Go here for the beer - have some food if you're hungry. The variety and freshness of their beers is worth the visit. The food was enjoyable and what I'd expect from a brewery restaurant. Try the jalapeño coleslaw - it was delicious with my feta & tomato burger. Casual atmosphere but somewhat difficult to have a conversation with the tables so close. read more

Nice, hip joint in downtown Carlisle. Very good beer selection with reasonable prices. We didn't eat (much) while here, but a friend ordered tater tots and they were great! They were definitely homemade and seasoned well, with a good spicy ketchup. read more

Food and service was Excellent i Got the chicken Sandwich, Girlfriend got a flight * BBQ Jack Fruit Sandwich. what set them apart was the service. Our server Sean was very attentive and great at his job. Atmosphere was excellent so was the music playing in the background. Will be making this a regular stop wile in the area. read more

Molly Pitcher Brewing - Molly Pitcher Flight! - Burgers Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

I stopped by for a mid-afternoon lunch when the place was more than half empty. The overcooked goat cheese burger came with the advertised sauce but no onion straws and was served on a cold hamburger bun straight out of the fridge. Condiments were neither provided nor offered. The "nitro" porter was served with no head at all-- it was just plain watery. Service was okay, but no more. I was a fan of MP at its original location on East South and I have tried to like the new place, but I get the sense that they just don't care anymore. It doesn't bode well for the future. read more

We arrived in town on a Sunday afternoon. Not many places we googled were open. Decided to try Molly's as it appeared busy. Turns out it was trivia night. We waited for seats to open and ended up at the bar. No big deal. We ordered burgers. Buns were cold, burgers had no flavor and there was very little of the special mayo. Our bartender was nice. The overall experience was okay. Not a place we will go back to. read more

BLT was amazing! So many beer choices and quick and friendly service. Definitely recommend.

It was a packed Friday Night, we got the last table available. We were greeted by our server immediately and our appetizer and beer order were taken immediately. The fried cheese curds were a creamy melty delight with a kick delivered by the chili caper sauce. I had the Bacon Burger perfectly cooked medium with two slices of quarter inch think IPA braised bacon, smoky sweet intense bacon flavor. The Jalapeno Slaw was fresh with a kick. My Patriot Ale was a perfect compliment, fresh and crisp. The placed was packed and we had our beer, appetizer and Burgers were on the table in less than 12 minutes. Fantastic service, Fun atmosphere! You must. try Molly Pitchers!!! read more

See all

I had the poutine fries. It was delicious. I don't really drink beer so I can't comment on that. My lunch companion loved the The Thrift Store beer. Nice atmosphere. I will definitely come back. read more

See all

Please note that the brewery location a 10 E South St is no longer open to the public. They have instead opened a very nice location at 139 West High St. We had a late lunch there on a summer Friday afternoon. The place has an upscale, light industrial look to it, very well done. It was crowded and busy, but we were waited on instantly. We both had the Black Powder Porter and the Bleu-'shroom burgers, both excellent. Highly recommended! If we lived anywhere nearby, we'd be regulars! read more

I live in Philly now, but a visit to Molly Pitcher is a must visit every time I'm home in Carlisle. I love almost every beer that they have - you seriously cannot go wrong. The food is delicious, and I love the outdoor space when the weather is nice. There is live music upstairs every week, and they even have a special date night menu sometimes! The space itself is also open, welcoming, and friendly. Love this place! Must visit if you're in Carlisle! read more

Very cool place, super friendly staff, and great beer. Food is on the right track but could use a little more attention. Love the house made sauces, which I'm glad they have considering the burger alone was pretty dry. I'll be back. read more

When I went it was in the evening to see a friend's band play. That was upstairs. It was a cool vibe. It was packed and bustling. I had gotten the shrimp appetizer. It had an aïoli sauce and finished with potato straws. It was very tasty:) My husband got the fried chicken sandwich. That was also delightful. I would go back there & get those things again. I had also gotten a seasonal white wine that was sweet. I liked it a lot. read more

Excellent tasting beers and really good appetizers. It was a very nice experience of the tastes of foods and the beers with the food are great choices. My husband and I will be back with our son and daughter in law to critique the French appetizers since they are somewhat native to Paris France. read more

I had the most disgusting meal of my life at this restaurant. I may go back to try the drinks I hear they are good. They do not have suitable vegan options. The only vegan option they had was garbage I wasted my money and I regret it deeply. read more

Molly pitcher is a great place. They have very good food, excellent service, and good beer. The fried chicken sandwich is the best chicken sandwich I have ever had. The atmosphere is also a 10/10 and the service is excellent. If you are looking to host a party, I highly recommend molly pitcher. Overall 10/10. Must visit if you are in the area. read more

If I could give zero stars, I would. Apparently you can't order a beer at the bar unless you wait in line for a table. We just wanted to grab a beer on our way to the football game, not eat, and a bartender with histrionic personality disorder berated us in front of the whole bar. Why advertise "to go pints" if you need to wait in line for a table? It's the first bar I've ever been to where you can't order drinks at the bar. Ridiculous... read more

Service is completely illogical and all over the place and the staff has little manners and are disorganized. The food is really good but me and my family wanted to eat as a group of six and a group of four were sat at an 8 person table and we were left to wait for three two person tables for up to 35 mins. read more

Loved the Peanut Butter beer! Growlers are super expensive to buy here so make sure you bring your own. Food was okay. I got the bacon burger with a side salad and my husband got the same but with a side of fries. It was expensive for what you actually get. The burgers are tiny. I really liked the salad but wish I was warned that the creamy herb salad dressing was spicy. My mouth was burning by the end of the salad. We also ordered the buttermilk pie for dessert which was my favorite part of the meal. We would come back again for the beer but not for the food. read more

Service was terrible. Was waiting for a seat and they completely forgot about us and sat many other people before us.

I tried the crab rolls yesterday. The crab was extremely strong tasting with butter dripping off the side of the New England rolls. There was very little crab in each roll. My recommendation is to not buy the crab rolls. read more

Not the type of place for larger parties. Took forever to get a table arranged to fit everyone. Took years to get our checks. The service was not friendly by any means. Idk if I'm alone in this sentiment but I felt obligated to share my experience. read more

Stopped in (without a reservation) and were so glad we did. Super friendly and attentive wait staff, great environment and tasty food and drink. Could not have asked for more! Great place to go and enjoy. read more

I would love to give this brewery/restaurant a higher rating but unfortunately we've been here multiple times and this was not the first time we've encountered the same rude server. We like their beer a lot, love the vibe and really want to support a local business, but she really makes it tough. I hate to say it, but we will need to consider whether we go back. read more

Best brewing company in PA. Don't miss the opportunity to visit if you are in the Carlisle area. Awesome atmosphere and the staff is friendly. Will be back soon! read more

Great food! Great beer! A bit pricey for a full meal (roughly $60 for two people), but very good!!

We went here on a Saturday ( yesterday) early about 3. When we had walked in the women at the door was like can I help you we said 5 and a baby and she was like well you can't sit together so we decided that was fine will stay well she was just plain rude. Almost like she didn't want us there. She goes ok you can't sit together, no getting up and no high chairs. First off the baby was clearly sleeping. Then goes masks must be worn except for eating ok fine. It felt like she just wanted us to leave. Well we sit down food was delicious and the waiter was wonderful only reason I'm giving 3 Stars. I found it funny how the women came outside to her "regulars" and they didn't wear masks the whole time and they were allowed to get up and down. It's poor business and down right rude. For someone whose worked as a server and bartender their whole life I've never seen anything like it nor would I treat anyone like that. We felt unwelcome. We felt judged because we had a child with us. You don't know how much we are coming to spend so why judge!!! When leaving we didn't even receive a thank you for coming and bye. I'm sorry but if it wasn't for the fact that we were hungry and were a hour and half from home we would've left!! Don't bother if you have kids with you! read more

Great vibe and theme for a brewery. My father and I really enjoyed our time here. Food was delicious!

Cool atmosphere, great beer and interesting food choices. Good service. Will be back, moving to Carlisle this summer.

Very nice restaurant and Old Graveyard Stout is excellent. However, Had the fried cheese curds for appetizer.....VERY VERY SMALL portions. They should be embarrassed to serve something that small. read more

We really enjoyed our dinner here, and of course the beers. The tater tots were delicious...way better than your typical frozen tots. We tried three of the IPAs, and all were good. I particularly enjoyed the Going South. Good variety of food options for both meat eaters and vegetarians, and kid friendly enough for my fairly picky 9 year old. read more

Manager is consistently mean. Maybe there is enough demand that they don't need to worry about common decency, but we keep trying to give this place another chance and then the same manager just keeps pushing us away. When you walk in, one of the polite and enthusiastic staff greets you. Then the manager shows up and she treats you like trash. We keep walking out. Most recently, we walked across the street, walked into a great restaurant, were seated and treated with respect, had a great dinner and drinks. read more

This is a craft beer lovers heaven. Personally I hate the over hopped beer trend but the people in my party enjoy it so to each their own. The Poutine was not your standard Poutine. It had a smoky flavor with shredded beef hidden on it. The Feta and Smoked Tomato Burger was cooked to a perfect medium well. I indicated that I had a food allergy and I swear half the wait staff and kitchen staff wanted to walk me through everything on the menu. Service was great during a busy period and food was spot on. read more

First time visiting the pub. I had the soup of the day, mushroom soup made in a potato broth which was delicious. As far as the beer, today I tried the Billy Haze IPA and it is very good. My new fav hangout in Carlisle read more

This is my go to spot. Awesome atmosphere, great beer and food! This place is in walking distance if you want to bar/brewery crawl.