I came for breakfast on a Monday and it was so nice and quiet. I was able to enjoy a nice book with my meal. The service is so welcoming and inviting. They make you feel like you're a regular and have been coming for years. The food is great. Typical diner food and just a real treat. read more

Montville Diner - Silver dollar pancakes - Diners Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

See all

What can I not say ! IT WAS THE BEST !! Im not exaggerating because everything i ordered cooked to perfection! The breakfast potatoes are the best. I didn't leave anything on my plate and im a picky eater!! The greeting from the door to the table and waiter (Tony) lovely man made sure we ate well and happy with our food!!!! I felt so welcomed and relaxed to eat not rushed! Thank you again Tony to making our first visit a memorable one and for the staff thank you for showing kindness no rushing people just tranquility and enjoyment!!! read more

The Montville diner seems like it may be a sinking ship. The overall look is a bit dated. The upholstery in our booth was tattered and torn. My wife ordered a grilled cheese sandwich for $7.00 which is a pretty good value by today's standards. Problem is that she also ordered a side salad for $9.00 which was a bit of a rip off. The salad consisted of some iceberg lettuce, three cherry tomatoes and a couple chunks of cucumber. It really should have been priced between $3.50 to $5.00. I ordered a tuna wrap priced at $14.95 which is about the going rate. However, it was literally half the size and weight of tuna wraps from other diners in the area making it a poor value. It was served with a side of Cole slaw which was terrible. I think it was spoiled. The service was fair at best. It is doubtful that we will return. read more

Enter my Montville diner quite a few times very good never really had a problem there been for breakfast lunch and dinner. I'd recommend it.

It has large cushioned booths. Important for people with back problems. It has a quiet subdued vibe. Very relaxing. Good for conversation. Our server Maria was the absolute best. About her business. We were well taken care of . read more

Average diner with okay food but a great staff and service. Welcomed very kindly as I entered. The wait staff were very nice and kind and kept checking in. Food was decent for a diner. Home fries needs some real seasoning. It was very bland. Coffee was actually good for a diner. Ambience was a bit lackluster. Not sure of the dining area but the breakfast bar area was a bit bland. read more

Montville Diner - Diners Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

Classic Diner decor and they serve alcohol. Seated promptly and order taken in good timing. I had a Chicken and spinach panini with mozzarella and red roasted peppers which was hugh! It came with a good sized portion of crispy fries. Delicious! read more

Montville Diner - Chicken and spinach panini with mozzarella and red roasted peppers - Diners Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

Ham & cheese omelet was ok, home fries were a chopped up mess not that good. Service was good, fast. Hot tea, they don't give you a 2nd tea bag, but you can many coffee refills free, this always bugs me wanting to charge you for a 2nd tea bag! $18 Will not be back. read more

On our way home from some business in Wayne NJ and I decided to take Rt 46 instead of the interstate to find a place for lunch. I saw the Montville Diner and pulled into their parking lot. We were immediately seated in their clean, orderly dining room. Our server, Tony, took our order and tended to my wife's dietary needs. With in minutes refreshing cold drinks are in front of us and a few minutes later our food arrives. Televisions are showing sports as I am enjoying Montville Diner's version of a cheesesteak sub. My wife enjoyed her chicken salad. The service we received was first rate. Tony could work at any Michelin five star restaurant so I hope he is appreciated. I wouldn't need to think twice before recommending the Montville Diner. It's a great place to eat and I will be back. read more

This place surprised me. We went here on a whim when our usual place was busy and was pleasantly surprised by the breakfast. This is a classic Jersey diner. We all ordered pancakes and they were delicious. Service was super fast and they got the order perfectly. It was pretty quiet here for a Saturday morning, but maybe it just a well kept secret. read more

Great Food! Nice People! Great Prices! They have lottery Ask for the Hiking Girl:) Got a Charbroiled burger..and a Mandarin Chicken salad read more

Montville Diner - Diners Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

The sweetest diner with the best food and people! They were so kind and helpful at every single turn. A MUST if you are in the area.

I only had a few minutes to grab something to shove in My face and was in this area so I decided to stop by and order a breakfast sandwich to-go and I'm glad I did because it was amazingly delicious and filling. Can't ever go wrong with a Taylor Ham, Egg and Cheese on a Roll with extra Meat added, "they" say that breakfast is the most important meal of the day and I'm not really sure who "they" are but "they" definitely know what "they're" talking about. Now years ago I also remember stopping in here a few times long before this app even existed or at least long before I knew Yelp existed I should say, but whatever I'm here now and that's all that really matters.   Anyway getting back to the Montville Diner I've always liked this spot and I seriously have to make it a regular stop whenever I'm over this way. Who knows maybe next time I'll have some extra time on my hands and grab a sit down style meal. Come And Get Your Munch On!! read more

Montville Diner - Shake Hands With Breakfast: Taylor Ham, Egg and Cheese on a Roll Extra Ham, Let's ROCK!! - Diners Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

Why does this only 2.9 stars? I thought this diner was great the burger my wife had was cooked as asked ( med rare ) and the pastrami Benedict was great , French Fries here are damn good too , great waiter and great food on a Saturday on Memorial Day weekend with no blemishes at all you can't ask for anything else read more

Absolutley delightful! Our waiter Sergio made my niece feel so special on her birthday! His service was so wonderful and i will definetly go again, we ordered our drinks in less than 2 minutes of sitting down at our table. The food was just delicious and i was practically drooling for more food by the time i was almost done with my food! The Ambiance around me was so special and warm, the people that sat around us were families, the mood was delightful and it sounded like everyone was jubilant. Will definetly come here again. "I wanna give it a 10, but thats impossible so i give it a 5" read more

This diner is a great place for a late night snack. I came here with a large party of 8 after the Montville Fireworks and the staff were very accommodating. The diner is very big with many seats. I ordered disco fries because I wasn't too hungry. The portions they give a very big-- I was not able to finish my disco fries and needed help from my friends. The disco fries was covered in Mozzarella cheese and gravy at the bottom. It was very delicious, but can get a bit too salty to eat after a while. I would definitely recommend ordering disco fries as a side to share. read more

Montville Diner - Disco Fries - Diners Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

Solid diner, friendly service from Jessie. Egg dishes are always a good choice- the home fries are pretty good. I have enjoyed the broiled scrod on a few occasions. Perfectly seasoned, the right level of buttery. Asparagus on the side was fresh but not particularly interesting. Our group also was happy with the waffles and burgers. Cheesecake was decent enough to order. Fudge cake frosting was tasty but cake itself was dry. Definitely a good choice in this area , with a big menu and full bar. And a classic 50s soundtrack for more diner nostalgia. Extra atmospheric on this visit with the Parsippany police doing a takedown out the window on 46. But normally a quiet neighborhood and easy parking. read more

Montville Diner - Broiled Scrod, yummy here. Sides came on a separate plate - Diners Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

This was my first visit to Montville Diner. It was a Sunday at 10:30am. I was seated where I ordered a House Club sandwich with Corned Beef and Pastrami along with fries. I instantly regretted my decision only because of my diet. I enjoyed my meal while listening to Lionel Ritchie and watching Quick Draw lottery numbers. Not all the ingredients are listed on the menu but this hot concoction was awesome. Fries were fluffy which I prefer. Every single staff member was smiling and sometimes laughing which is great for the dining experience. read more

Everyone was so friendly at this diner. The coffee was good and there was plenty of parking in a convenient location.

Went there today against my better judgement but it was 4 o'clock I hadn't eaten anything all day and there was a traffic backup so thought I'd grab something small since dinner wasn't to far off. Pulled into the Montville diner ordered a matzo ball soup. The waiter asked me if I wanted a cup or bowl. I said Bowl, I figure the bowl might have 2 matzo or more vegetables. He brought the soup out I was kind of shocked. Only 1 matzo , absolutely no vegetables with clear broth. Gotta say it was like it was a cup put in a bowl with more broth. I felt cheated. To make matters worse the matzo tasted somewhat spoiled,it was a matzo that was probably starting to spoil. When I went to pay, I asked the man what's the difference between a cup and a bowl? I told him I thought maybe the bowl would have two matzo, some vegetables and this was basically just a cup dumped into a bigger bowl and then cost more money. He said we used to put two matzo but now we just put one. I told him I was more disappointed because the matzo tested like it was going bad.., He didn't even apologize. Don't know how there still in business read more

Stopped in for a quick breakfast and ended up relaxing and having a few cocktails. We had some mimosas with our eggs. Speaking of eggs they have a wide range of Eggs Benedict. The classic was great along with the Avocado Benny. The western omelette was filled with nicely cooked peppers, onions and ham. Our server was lots of fun and the owners are great. Good place to eat and relax. read more

The food wasnt very good and the place smelled just gross! My tea had a fly in it... anymore to say? the tables gross 2 stars generous

Your Basic NJ diner with so many to choose from can you please do better or you won't make it. Very modern and clean not many here on Sunday morning a bad sign for diners that are usually packed. Felt bad for our senior Citizen server who had bad knees and SHOULD NOT have to be walking and serving at her age. Simple orders yet screwed up. Bagel dry with toast on with butter on side... Bagel came soaked in butter. SMH. Eggs with Taylor ham... with fries with Gravy.. Not sure what type of fries these were but some sort of gimmick type fry which were not hot and the gravy bland and tasteless. Toast was barely if not toasted at all. Coffee was lukewarm. In short NJ Diners are plentiful and normally outstanding This one does not meet the mark. read more

Underwhelming. First off, no menu online. It's just odd because nowadays you really need an online presence to compete. Second, the food wasnt that great. I dont know if I just came in at a bad time? We came in on a late Sunday evening for pick up. It said 24 hours, but a paper sign saying we close at 1 am says otherwise. The food was eh. Boyfriend got nachos and I had a spinach salad and matzo ball soup. Mind you, I had to guess what menu items they did have since no menu online. My spinach salad had hard boiled eggs, tomatoes, bacon and raw mushrooms. The raw mushrooms really threw me off, ended up cooking them with an omelette a couple of days later. Not really sure if you can eat raw mushrooms. My matzo ball soup was very salty, ended up just eating the matzo ball which also didnt have much going on. My boyfriend said the nachos were eh. Nothing to write home about; very standard. Overall, it's just very...blah. Combined with the fact that there isnt a menu online and quality of the food, I dont think I'm going back any time soon. It's a shame, diners are always welcome in a town and can be a meeting spot and a wonderful place to hang out and get affordable, amazing food. Hope my next visit will be better. read more

See all

This is a lovely diner I'm fortunate enough to call "local"! The people are so friendly, the food is delicious, and they are following COVID protocol. We were seated right away, attended to by two amazingly friendly people, and received our lunch in warp speed! I'm so glad my family and I can support family businesses like this during the pandemic. The paper menus are great and provide an extra measure of good hygiene! There is hand sanitizer at the front counter and all employees and management are masked up! They have a great menu which includes all of the classic diner hits, as well as a fun cocktail/bar menu featuring adult beverages like Orange Crush, Margaritas, and Cricket Hill beer (brewed right in nearby Fairfield)! We will be back! read more

Montville Diner - Cheeseburger Deluxe Burger with cheese - Diners Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

What a wonderful little diner! I admire diners for being the refuge of the late night patron. Whether it's weary travelers, graveyard shift workers, or the nocturnally inclined, it's nice to know that a hot meal is available when you need it. It's open 24 hours a day! What surprised me about the Montville Diner is the quality and variety of the food. The menu is not limited to burgers and sandwiches. There is a diverse array of entrees including breakfast, Mexican, Italian, seafood, and more. It would be a great restaurant for groups where everyone wants to eat something different. Would definitely eat here again. read more

See all

A tale of three little BEARS. This egg bacon cheese sandwich was too cold. These crispy fried potatoes were too burned. This Taylor Ham sandwich was nice and warm, cooked just right and stacked with Taylor Ham. I love the huge portions and extensive menus which the Montville Diner does well. They have take-out, a full bar but no WiFi or delivery. You like lottery tickets and scratch-offs, you have come to the right place. Their Corn Beef Hash is about $8. Coffee is $1.75 and freshly made. The interior is bright and inviting with counter, bench and table seating just like a New Jersey diner should have. Now here is a real tricky question. Which owner shows more hospitality? read more

Montville Diner - Montville Diner - Diners Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

Diners can be tricky to review because, even if everything goes right, it's still diner-quality at the end of the day. Still, I had a reasonably good experience at Montville Diner. I ordered the chicken wrap ($10.65) and shared an appetizer of disco fries ($6.55). I have never understood the appeal of disco fries. I get that they're an NJ diner staple, and they're... okay, I guess, but I prefer regular fries to disco fries. Regular fries don't have gravy and mozzarella cheese, but those things on fries are rather tasteless, anyway. The wrap, on the other hand, was very solid. Nothing special, but you can't really mess up grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, and cheese. The Italian dressing on the side complemented it the wrap well and the fries that came with the dish were perfect. (Way better than the disco fries!) My fiancée ordered the California burger ($5.75) cooked medium rare and it definitely looked worse than my wrap, but that's not my problem. I'd probably give three stars for the burger, but since that wasn't my order, I'm giving four! Service was fine, and even at 1 A.M. the wait staff was friendly and approachable. read more

Great food and great service! I like going here with my family on the weekends for breakfast.

The service is great and the staff welcoming and friendly. So lucky to have this is our neighborhood. The best turkey!

Exactly what a diner should be. Serving the breakfast staples (eggs, pancakes, etc) and hot and fresh coffee by experienced and efficient servers. Other reviews have bashed the dated decor, but I beg to differ. It's a classic NJ diner. Other diners that have upgraded their decor (I'm talking to you Chit Chat in West Orange!) turn diners into some odd thing that can't decide if it's a diner or a fine dining establishment. read more

Been here a few times. Service is very fast and our server Richie was extremely friendly and professional. Food is good and prices are reasonable. A basic dinner nothing fancy. read more

What an incredible find, stayed at nearby hotel and found this on our way back to 80. Greeted warmly by host, and then had the pleasure of meeting Tony blue eyes, as we came to call him. Fabulous gentleman, very polite, friendly and attentive. Wish we lived closer, would have become a regular stop with a regular waiter request. Had omelettes, huge and tasty. Definitely recommend read more

Came here late night after enjoying some hookah lounge nearby. My friends and I came around 11pm for some munchies. Place was almost completely empty as the bar/clubbers were still out and about, drinking and dancing to their hearts delight. Our waitress was in her 40's and was really cool, she took the time to clown around with us and had a very colorful personality. She was a trip, humoring our idiotic behavior and entertaining us. I was feeling extremely hungry that night so I ordered an italian sausage omelette with mozzarella. It was a little too salty, but after you've been drinking a little you really don't mind these details. My buddy got scrambled eggs and french toast with powdered sugar, which was a way better choice. Ended the meal with a coffee to clear out the alcohol induced cobwebs. Total damage price wise was only $15 with tip. The biggest impression I have of this diner is that the employees were interesting people, talking about their favorite cartoons giving their impressions of them, just being some original personalities. read more

I've been to this place a couple of times. They bring your food really quickly and our waiter, Richie, was super nice and knew what he was doing. The food tastes good and it doesn't cost too much. It's just a simple, no-frills spot for a meal. read more

I always go to Montville Diner because they have the best taylor ham in the area. The owners, Amy and Dimitri, never fail to make me feel welcome and always make sure that we are enjoying our meal. If you are looking for a good diner, you need to come here. It won't disappoint! read more

I just wanted to update that I absolutely love it here. After a few great meals, I come here quite a lot, and everyone is always the best and so kind!! read more

Montville Diner - Cozy interior! - Diners Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

See all

Gross. Never will I come here again. Decor is so dated too. They need a facelift and a change in chef.

I was in the area with my fiance and future mother in law when we decided to stop for lunch. My future mother in law had heard that this diner had been previously rated one of the best in NJ so we figured we couldn't go wrong. Overall, I would say it's exactly what you would expect from a diner. Extensive menu, decent food, an average service. I can't say I would suggest going back, as there are so many other great options in the area, but it's good for a late night go-to or if you're really craving diner food. Also, they have a lottery machine! read more

This place never disappoints! Everyone is always pleasant and food is always great! Pancakes were amazing and really enjoyed burgers! The fries were fantastic! Had the Greek salad and brought half home for later. Loved everything! They even have drinks! read more