First time ordering from Mr Greek and oh man was it sooo delicious! Ordered a gyro wrap with harissa feta and a peri peri chicken wrap with tzaziki. The gyro pita with harissa feta was SO good. It was flavorful, there was a lot of feta provided, and the pita was nice and soft. Also appreciated the lettuce and onions for a nice crunch. We also got a peri peri pita sandwich with tzatziki which was also good, but not as outstanding as the gyro with harissa feta. It was definitely good though and felt like chicken you might enjoy in a salad. Will definitely be coming back for more gyro sandwiches !! read more

Mr Greek - Gyro Sandwich with harissa feta - Mediterranean Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Looking for something different than the ubiquitous hamburgers and chicken, this unpretentious spot in Belmar features informal Greek cuisine. We had gyro sandwiches which were tasty, filling, and good value. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Friendly staff in a relaxed setting.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

I'm Pleasantly full and Satisfied and Thrilled!! That Salad was Monstrous, Awesome, Flavorful, REFRESHING AND DELICIOUS!! I cannot wait to return and enjoy More delicious menu items with My Husband!! Everything was amazing and delicious if you haven't ate at this place, you're surely missing out and [[HIGHLIGHT]]it's right in a sleepy beach town and it's a perfect area to stroll and relax and enjoy[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

Used Uber Eats. So quick. Food very good. Hummus fresh. Pita nice and soft . Falafel little salty but good. The service was awesome.

Mr. Greek did not disappoint!! I came here looking for something filling and fresh, and they nailed on both fronts! The service was fast and friendly, [[HIGHLIGHT]]the restraunt is clean with both indoor and outdoor seating.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I would recommend this to anyone and am excited to bring the rest of my family back! read more

Mr Greek - Mediterranean Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Stopped in for a casual bite. Ordered the gyro and it exceeded my expectations. They do not skimp on the meat. The pita was warmed up, soft and the perfect vessel for the abundant meat, lettuce, tomato, onion and delicious tzatziki sauce. I'm still thinking about it today. Will definitely be back. read more

Excellent menu and selections. Reasonable prices. Good size servings and the food was very good.

First time here. Was wanting a falafel. Wrong move. Very dry, too much tazaziki sauce on it, small overcooked pieces of falafel. Not much in the way of salad in the pita sandwich. Very disappointed. Maybe gyro or schwarma is way to go. Service was quick I'll give them that. Clean bright place with plenty of tables for eating. read more

See all

The food. does not have the quality it had 6 months ago. I'm so disappointed. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Service and cleanliness is still good![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

We ate her tonight and met the owner a very nice guy with a great restaurant. If you like Greek food you'll like this place.

Stopped in for a late lunch after a day on the beach. Service was wonderful and the food was so good and super fresh! I enjoyed a Greek salad, we split a falafel appetizer and my boyfriend had the gyro platter. I ate most of my salad before even realizing I didn't put the dressing on/it was that good! Then I tried the dressing and it was so flavorful-I wish I could get that recipe! read more

Mr Greek - Greek salad and a Falafel Appetizer - Mediterranean Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

What an amazing assortment of food. We go for the Gyros frequently, and tend to split a salad. You get a sizable portion of homemade quality food for an awesome price. [[HIGHLIGHT]]We typically take out, but have eaten in as well and the place is always clean with wonderful hosts.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Next time you are here ask about their homemade deserts that will blow you away. read more

Food is so fresh and so delicious. Mr Greek is our office order go to! You won't regret the Santorini wrap!

The worst experience of my life in that place with the cashier with long black hair, medium build, wears glasses, she didn't want to give us her name because of the bad treatment she gave us, the food is good but they should have trained staff to serve and not that type of girls who serve in a bad way. My favorite dish without a doubt was the gyro, 100% delicious, the Greek salad and hummus are recommended, only the service from the cashier was very bad read more

Food is great and so is the staff. We had an issue with our Uber Eats order, so we went to pick up the food ourselves and cancelled with Uber. They remade the whole order fresh for us. Everything was delicious. We got the gyro sandwiches, veggie wrap, pica chicken wrap, souvlaki platter, friend chicken and rice. Everything was awesome and just what I was craving. Very thankful for the staff remaking our order on a Sunday night right before closing. Highly recommend this place! read more

Went here for lunch today, fresh and delicious food here it's very good. Lots of options to choose from the chicken and pitas were awesome read more

See all

What an original take on spanakopita!!!!! And the falafel, hummus and pita are AMAZING!!!!! This is my go-to for Greek and it should be yours, too. I've never eaten-in so I can't comment on service or ambiance but, wow, THE FOOD IS DELISH!!! read more

Way overpriced. I got a gyro platter. It was lamb, tzatziki sauce, a small amount of lettuce, small amount of pickled peppers and no tomato. Lamb was good but not enough vegetables. Served with plain rice which I guess makes up the platter. That was $20. Then I got a can of soda for $3. I can go anywhere and get a plain gyro for $10 bucks. Between my girlfriend and I with 18% tip it was $58. Will not go back. read more

I'm not a Greek food fan but my wife really liked it. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I don't like eating from take out containers with plastic utensils when I go out to eat.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The 3% credit card fee is infuriating. This cost 2 stars on the rating. read more

Food was very good and service excellent. Would go back again and recommend to a friend

Great price for what you get. We love the gigantes, greek salad, hummus, and hot pita!

We took out and brought to my folks on 5th ave! Delicious gyros, assorted desserts. This was our second time there. The menu on the chalkboard has many choices and we will be back! Do not leave without the Greek orange cake! Omg! read more

Just discovered this place last week. Awesome Greek food. Loved the gyros, grapes leaves and baklava. Can't wait to have again when I'm at the shore. read more

We've come to the conclusion that if people don't adhere to the health department precautions while they're making your food, they probably don't take pride in making your food either. My husband ordered a chicken pita sandwich without tomatoes. When I went in to pick up his order there were 4 employees there. 1 of them was wearing a "mask" appropriately (it was a bandanna, but at least it was something). There was another employee that thought that as long as he was sitting at a table he couldn't possibly spread Covid. At one point he got up to speak to the guy who was wearing his bandana, and at least he was respectful enough to pull up his own bandana while he spoke to the other guy. The older couple who were preparing food in the kitchen were both wearing masks under their noses. When I got the food home to my husband he quickly noticed the sandwich seemed to have extra tomatoes instead of no tomatoes as he asked, which it turns out was fine since the chicken was tough anyway. There's a LOT better places to eat on the shore in my opinion, starting with anywhere that wears masks appropriately. read more

Every time I go here, I get excellent food- just got another gyro...start with a nice homemade soft pita, extremely generous serving of lamb, delicious fresh tzatziki...I would eat here a lot more often if my waistline could handle it! And folks are extremely nice. Glad to have this place around the corner!, read more

Wow! This brand new place in Belmar is great! You know when you've got a hankering for a good gyro with tzatziki? This is your place! I got a gyro and a side of truffle fries with feta, and it was all delicious! (AND it all came in eco-friendly disposable containers!) Staff was very pleasant. Restaurant isn't 'fancy', but it's clean, neat and functional. I'll be back -! read more

Folks/ this is it! Authentic, fresh delicious and easy Greek food at the Jersey shore. Wish that Theo could clone this place and move it all over NJ. Was craving a gyro and salad and had to head to Oakhurst. Quickly ordered pickup via the phone Instagram link- they also support all the delivery apps. The food? PLENTY - the Greek salad was easily customized with yellow pepper slices, no onions and chickpeas and perfect with a pita and dressing on the side. My lamb gyro was Delicious - cut it in half and shared with my sister and adult son ate almost all his chicken gyro. He said it was even better at midnight. The tahini dressing for the falafel was fresh and great for pita dipping. Got some soup for a family member- she loved the lemon chicken taste for summer dining. Super clean outdoor dining, and indoor space is bright. Lots of dessert options to try as well. But frankly too full- maybe next time? read more

See all

We ordered gyro platters with fries and a spinach pie with feta. We did not like the quality of the gyro, but the fries were good. The spinach pie was delicious. We did not like the tzatziki sauce either which was surprising. Overall we go to a LOT of Greek places and this one just wasn't our favorite. Not sure we'd go back. read more

Went for lunch and had the Lamb Gyro. Tried the Harrisa goat cheese sauce. It was hot and spicey. A nice change from the common tsazicki sauce. Friendly staff read more

A gem. We've had takeout twice from there in a month! If you're a falafel connoisseur, get here. I heard they are better then Cava (Bridgewater) and Jerusalem Pizza (Highland Park). I tried a wrap and it was delicious. Didn't care for the spanakopita (it always gets measured against Poseidon Bakery in Manhattan). read more

This is one of my regular spots since moving to the area. As someone who usually only goes to places with a ton of reviews I realized one of my favorites was missing the support. A must try. Get the trio of dips and extra pita, you won't be disappointed. read more

I was excited when I saw a Greek restaurant open in Belmar. I ordered chicken platter, hummus and grape leaves . The chicken was disgusting, not sure how they cook it, it was a plate full of shavings of meat but was somewhat indecipherable. I threw it out after paying $14.50 for the platter. The hummus was tasteless and the grape leaves were only okay. Will not spend another $30 for a meal here. read more

This place is awesome ! Fresh Greek food, the dips are all to die for and the portions are very generous. Great friendly service and really cute decor inside. They are constantly cleaning down the tables and the place is spotless. There are even tables outside if you are lucky enough to visit on a nice day. I recommend the trio of dips (your choice of which 3 - all 4 rock!) and any of the platters ! read more

Came here 10 minutes before close and ate outside, the guy working the counter was SO kind to us and took care of our table even when we were outside and past closing. Food was incredible too, highly recommend! read more

We ordered through Uber eats. The food was ready very quickly. The prices are very reasonable. The food was very good and fresh. A great find. read more

My boyfriend and I were so hungry after a day at the beach, and I'm Greek and love trying new Greeks spots. I got the falafel platter and he got the chicken platter and it comes with so much food and we ate every bite. The staff was super friendly and left very satified, my boyfriend kept talking about it even into the next day! read more

Was starving so stopped in here to eat and so glad that we did! We had our dogs with us so we were looking for somewhere that would let us sit outside with them. It wasn't very busy, but there were a bunch of people picking up take out orders so we decided to give it a try. The food was delicious! My best friend is Greek so sometimes I can be pretty judgmental on Greek food because she makes the best and this was definitely on par. We ordered the pork platter which was surprisingly super juicy and flavorful. (Sometimes skewers are really dried out.) The tzatziki was very good and super flavorful. The Greek Salad was huge! Lemon potatoes were by far my favorite. The Avgolemono soup was good, a little more like a traditional chicken soup, but still good! The Tessaloniki shrimp were the best I think I have ever had. Even coming out in a Togo container they tasted perfectly seared. This place was great service was great, yeah it is expensive, but Greek food is always going to be more expensive and you can tell they are using the best ingredients. Also get the Frappe, it's a Greek coffee which is super strong and frothy iced and you can choose dairy alternatives if you prefer! read more

Got the chicken platter and baklava. Both were delicious and big portions! I will be back to try more from their menu! read more

Mr Greek - Baklava - Mediterranean Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Everything we ordered was delicious. Gyro platter, trio of dips, French fries and falafel. All the ingredients were fresh. We will definitely order again. read more

Ordered a lamb Gyro for a nice quick lunch. Gyro was really tasty, filled nicely. The staff was pleasant and the restaurant looked very clean. I would recommend to anyone who wants some good quick Greek eats. read more