Decided to try this place out for lunch one afternoon. Upon walking in, I was invited to the lunch special menu. Decided to roll with 5 wings, fries for around $ 10.99. I asked for 5 more wings, and the total came up to over 22$. The honey hot wings I ordered were the furthest thing from honey hot. Coworkers asked if I ordered a dry rub, that should tell you enough. I wouldn't recommend Mr Y's solely based off of almost 10$ price hike for 5 wings. The fries were alright. read more

Worst ever. First time ordering. Wings were extremely small and undercooked . Buffalo salad had some kind of slimy wet stuff on it and the chicken had no taste. Did not look like buffalo chicken at all. Extremely disappointed!!! read more

Always loved Mr Y's pizza and fries! Growing up that place was a couple different other businesses, but Mr. Y's coming in change the game for us locally in town that don't have many options for places to go. Our family loves pizza :) and great chicken tenders also. Great atmosphere & the staff has always been friendly and professional. Quick to solve any issues that may arise. read more

One time out of five it was decent. Not.good, but decent. Like kost places in this area, the food is blamd and the pizza is doughy with cheap cheese and jar sauce. read more

This place is the definition of inconsistent. I would say 70% of my experiences here, which are probably at least 20 or 30 orders, have been straight up garbage. I seriously think the only reason why they are still open is because of their location. I left a review on Google and It wasn't even really that bad, all I said was, they didn't put enough sauce on their wings because they don't, and now they won't let me leave a google review anymore lol. Proceed with caution...Do better Mr. Y. read more

Mr. Y's Pizza and fries, what can I say. I want it in me, on me and with me. In a biblical way read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - Foot - Pizza Near Me - Darlington, Maryland

Did the pizza change? Cuz this was no Mr Y pizza we just had. Burnt cheese. Thin ass crust. Tasted horrible. Like 80 dollars down the drain for 3 pizzas and 2 cheese fries. read more

I live in the area and still hadn't tried this place yet. People said it was good. I am a huge fan of Conowingo pizza up the road (still the best). 1. I ordered delivery on Sunday at 210pm, I live exactly 10 min away. It took 1 hour and 20 minutes to arrive?! I know Sunday's can be busy but I was quoted 45min and that's just too long. 2. Got boneless wings. Of course they forgot the blue cheese with it so I had no dipping sauce. The boneless wings were ok but not amazing. 3. Got the Buffalo chicken wrap and it was disgusting!. By the time it got here it was so soggy. Had literally no spice or Buffalo blue taste to it what so ever. All you could taste was the seasoning from the grilled chicken in it. Forced down half and threw away the other. Maybe they have some other god foods and maybe getting pick up would be better. But I'm not going to chance it, won't be back. Go get Conowingo pizza or Dublin market up the road and you'll be much happier. read more

Decent side of the road pizza and sub shop. We had a salad and wrap. Hearty portions. Looking through the reviews, many of the complaints relate to delivery time. read more

Great place Great service and for a I don't wanna cook kinda nigh there just a phone call away and the deliver

Power salad tonight was inedible. Broccoli old and garlic overwhelming. Couldn't eat.good thought but needs a much better execution yuck

Can't get an order right, and taste/quality less then mediocre. Regretting my choice for my weekly cheat meal.

The customer service is down right terrible, waited an hour for pick up got there and my pizza wasn't even made, waited an extra 15 minutes for the pizza and while I was waiting no of the employees in the front had their masks all the way covering there faces. My family usually orders food here at least three time in a month period and to be treated like this is crazy! read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - the kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Darlington, Maryland

Best cheeseburgers around. Seriously great. Their pizza is ok too but I'm not a fan of the crust...everything else, outstanding. Online ordering plus they will deliver to our area. You get $10 off coupon every few orders too. read more

We used to order Mr. Ys a lot but all of a sudden one of us would get sick everytime we ordered for like the last 3 times. Its unfortunate because their food is really good! read more

Took WAY too long for a sandwich!! My husband called in an order approximately 30 mins before I picked up the food. I paid for it, then spent 25 more minutes waiting for the food. Meanwhile, our pizza sat on the shelf. Someone FINALLY asked what I was waiting for. They said they were still making the chicken Chesapeake sandwich. The pizza looked good, wings, not so good, and the Chicken Chesapeake was not very good at all, soggy bread, soggy lettuce and chicken strips? Will not order that sandwich again. read more

The Maryland Hamburger with Hamburger, Crab cake, Cheese depending on your choice is very good. We enjoy their delicious subs and pizzas that they deliver to your door still hot and ready to eat. They have excellent cheesesteak subs that you can add bacon and other toppings for a treat. They offer a delicious fried shrimp sub and crab cake subs or dinners. They have mild to hot toppings that they will offer the hot toppings on the side for the first time. They offer fries, onion rings, & other sides to many to list. The fries with gravy or loaded fries are very good. read more

Wow! Best pizza we had in Harford County so far. Comparable to Pizza Johns. I'm not a pepperoni fan but these were perfectly crisped on pizza. read more

Mr. Y's used to be great. Over the last year, the food just isn't very good. I order from elsewhere now. Their delivery people were great though. Very friendly and obviously worked hard. read more

Honestly, If anyone asked me for a great Pizza place I would recommend Mr. Y'all their New Yorker is To die for and their burgers are to, I'm not a Beef eater but when I hear we're getting Mr. Y's I'm all for it. The staff there is really nice and I will say There Wings are spot on like most of their food! They put plenty of Sauce on it for you sauce lovers out there!! read more

Food is okay, unfortunately in this area it's the only delivery option. While some of the food is really good, like the grab cake sandwich ( my favorite ) and the wraps are good, the rest is run of the mill pizza shop food. Nothing special that sticks out. But in a pinch or when you're too tired to cook it's a good place to have delivered and their app is a convenient way to order ahead of time. read more

Nearly every weekend we order a Cheeseburger Sub and the Power Bowl Salad. My husband hardly ever strays from the delicious cheeseburger sub. Don't forget to ask for fries. It's not an automatic add. Once in a while we'll include a medium cheese pizza with extra cheese and we love it. It's kind of inconsistent as far as the crust goes. Sometimes it's the best we've ever had and sometimes it's a little too bland but it never completely disappoints. More often than not it's the best pizza around. I highly recommend trying the cheese w/extra cheese or the one with several kinds of meat. They don't skimp on toppings. Another pizza combination I've tried is Uncle Vito's Pizza on cauliflower crust. Now that was one I've ordered several times. I'll be honest, I didn't care for the Cream of Crab soup. It was a bit too thick and lacking enough crab meat. I do recommend the chocolate cake or the carrot cake for dessert. Both were delicious but the chocolate cake was one of the best I've ever tasted. It's also a huge portion so enough for 2 people however once you have a bite you may wish you had ordered your very own. The waffle fries with crab dip (I can't remember what they call it) had a generous serving of the cream cheese dip. It was flavorful and found that to be a treat I would order again. It's a portion about as big as a large plate. I've also tried the wings. I ordered the hottest you can order and it still wasn't hot enough. Although, my palette is used to eating a jalapeno sprinkled with salt to accompany a sandwich. You won't get but a couple pieces of celery if that matters to you. The Power Bowl Salad has been a favorite ever since I discovered it. It's fresh spinach, broccoli and chicken with olive oil and garlic. It has plenty of garlic but I love it that way. I'm sure you can request to go easy on the garlic but I recommend trying it their way first. It's not overcooked nor is it too oily. You'll get plenty. I usually eat half and save the other half for lunch the next day. Before the Power Bowl became my all time favorite my go to was the Greek salad. It's well made and they don't hold back on the feta. Every weekend we've been pleased with what we order. I think only one time I had an issue with my pizza crust and they quickly resolved it by replacing it with a new one. That had to have been a couple years ago. My other personal favorite is the Cheeseburger. It has two pattys with cheese and they'll add the toppings just the way you order it. If you ask for onions be sure to indicate cooked or raw. It's a lot to eat. Plan ahead to order early. Weekends are extremely busy. We always pick up our order and it's ready when we get there. They will let you know if it will be a 30-45 minute wait if your calling it in. If it's early enough it's usually only 20 minutes. There's also a convenient option to order online and pay online if your looking to save a little time. If you're ordering from here it probably means you live to far for delivery from places in town. Don't worry, you won't be disappointed. I only wish they had a loyalty program for discounts. read more

This place has the best lasagna in area I've ever try bar none! Their pizza is good too but way over priced!

The buffalo chicken pizza here is absolutely amazing. I drive 45 minutes to get this pizza ! Definitely worth the money. Hope it never goes off the menu ! read more

2 hour delivery..then come to find out they made the order wrong.. was suppose to have no cheese (said "no cheese" on the receipt) and the whole thing had cheese.. fries were no surprise cold and soggy..two hours will do that to fries. i called back and told them what happened..they said they'd remake it..they delivered it, i opened the box in front of the driver and sure enough there was cheese..again..then the driver had the nerve to say "so no cheese at all" WHAT PART OF NO CHEESE IS HARD TO UNDERSTAND! so yea they literally dont know how to follow directions that a two year old understands.. spend your money elsewhere. ZERO STAR for real read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - receipt that says no cheese - Pizza Near Me - Darlington, Maryland

See all

The manager clearly needs to be replaced because he's not doing a good job he doesn't know what's going on in the shop that he manages it's 6:13 I ordered a bacon cheeseburger sub and a medium Pizza it was delivered about 10 after 8 then I noticed that my sub did not have bacon on it so I called she said it would be sent out right away I waited and waited and waited until 9:49 for them to deliver it the manager tells me he doesn't know anything about it he told me that the shop closes at 9 p.m. so why did they have me wait till 9:49 for something that was never going to arrive I'm so angry and disgusted there too skimpy on the food they put on everything anymore and they don't taste good anymore either especially the Pizza we have been ordering from this sub shop through three different owners and never had a problem with him until now this is uncalled for and ridiculous they don't deserve one star they don't deserve any stores since we used to love the pizzas read more

Ordered take out. The girl who took the order was great. Articulate, knew the menu, accurate and quick. The reason for two stars? All three subs ordered had stale bread. Come on Mr. Y's!! Would you be happy if you spent your hard earned money and received sub-par quality food? read more

If I were stranded on a deserted island and could bring just three things with me, one of those things would be a Mr. Y's pizza. It is just that ridiculously good. The wings ran a very close second. read more

Every time i place an order here I'm waiting at least 15-20 minutes longer than they tell me on the phone, and when i have tried delivery the order was over an hour late. Not to mention they get the order wrong fairly often. With my most recent visit just now ending with an hour an a half wait with them getting my order wrong again. Done with this establishment. read more

Great pizza place, been coming here since I moved to Dublin. Been through several changes but the present owner is knocking out of the park. Love the cheese steak subs and Hawaiian pizza. They have great delivery service. read more

If you're visiting Conowingo Dam and need a quick lunch break from photographing eagles, this seems like a decent spot. I only had the cheese steak there but it's good. No indoor seating but a few picnic tables outside. Good if you want something cheap, close and fast. read more

I love the Surf n Turf pizza Definitely the best pizza around. The subs are also fantastic.

The square buffalo chicken pizza is to die for !!!! They deliver to Pylesville too. Awesome !!!!

Horrible delivery service. Ordered pizza and a crabby pattie. I live 10 mins down the road. It took them an hour and 20 min to deliver it, the pizza was cold and nasty had no flavor, the crabby patty was drenched in grease where the bun was soaked so all in all spent 33$ in food that we didn't even eat. read more

We recently moved to the Street area and could not find a decent pizza place. Wow, are we lucky we were told about Mr. Ys! The pizza is GREAT! What a great find! read more