Tried the tomato pizza . Since I'm from northeast Philly I figured I own the rights to judge . Nothing is a 5.to me ,But the pizza was really good and when I said well done I got it well done. So they obviously take pride in the craft . I use to work for chickie& Pete's a so I know a thing or two . I definitely recommend this spot for the pizza . So props and Wentz needs to be traded he Stinks! read more

Came to key west on vacation from Philadelphia. Mr Z's was right near our rental home. We ate here late night probably every single night of the week and had 0 regrets. The cheesesteaks are just as good as some of the places we go to in Philly. And the pizzas are awesome too. Highly recommend! read more

Delicious pizza option! Great location. Veteran owned business with nice staff. Great hours too. Cash only.

I'm an avid cheesesteak eater and have to say this Mr. Z's is good, but NOT great. The food is good, but the service is less than average. I called and tried to place an order and asked them to hold for a second, literally seconds, to check my order and said what I would like and no one answered. Called back and got the order, but you have to stay on the line with your customer until they finish their order. I shouldn't have to call back. Do not come here if you are looking for good service and quality food. read more

Cheese Steak Strombolie is my favorite thing to order from Mr Zs. Staff is always friendly and the delivery is always fast. Keep up the good work guys. read more

We stopped in last night bout 9...Went in for stromboli was informed By the tall white dude very rudely thy dont do strombolis then turned his back to us like he was no longer interested in taking our order....Even though it does say on the internet menu...I was referred by a local bartender that Mr. Z's is great place to eat...(ended up with philly)that was good...if it wasnt for black dude who was also cooking being helpful and also polite would have walked out!!! read more

This place has the best white pizza with generous sizes! The gentleman working were attentive and walked my food to the car. I would without a doubt order again due to great customer service and delicious food! read more

Me. Z's is the best place for late night eats near Duval Street. Workers are the bomb and their food is even better. GET THE CHEESESTEAK IF YOU KNOW WHATS BEST FOR YOU but all of the food is good. You won't be disappointed!!!!! read more

The best chicken Philly I have ever eaten. I loved it! It's was filled with chicken, mushrooms and white cheese I can't explain the season but the flavor was absolutely delicious. Very tasty and soft bread and customer service was awesome too. Tried the cheese fries and they were really good too. read more

This local delivery spot was recommended to us by the bartender at bottle caps. AND they delivered directly to the restaurant. Prices are super reasonable, $7.00 subs that are enough for two to share. My husband and I had the chicken parm and cheese fries which definitely hit the late night hunger spot. The only reason why Mr Z's isn't getting a 5th star is because the only accept cash...which is fine, but a heads up when we placed the order would have been great. Luckily, bottle caps had an ATM inside. read more

I've had cheese steak hoagies, their amazing Stromboli, and pizza slices. Never been disappointed! They have fast and friendly service. All that I have tried there had been excellent. I do recommend the Stromboli, it takes about 25 minutes, but you can call ahead if needed to. read more

The worst pizza. The cheese tasted old, like it was 2-day old pizza reheated several times over. Bad service, no military discount. read more

Mr Z's - The worst pizza ever! three day old cheese and don't honor military... Expecially since it's 9/11 - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Key West, Florida

Not a fan. We tried calling around 8pm on a Monday night (3 times) and no one picked up. Ended up ordering online. We chose pick up because we thought it would be quicker... but it took an hour. We got the meatball pizza.. no flavor, very little sauce... a huge disappointment. We also got cheese fries, okay fries (shoestring style,) but the cheese sauce that came with it was super thick and had these weird chunks in it. Next time, we'll just get Papa Johns! read more

Ordered 2 steak sandwiches to be delivered at midnight and they were delicious and fresh! Perfect end for a night. Plan to try more items next tine, highly recommended! read more

Excellent late night snack food!! Much needed after a day of drinking in Key West!! Cheesesteak was great ( and we are from Philly!). Pizza crust was really good! read more

Grabbed some slices of pepperoni pizza after a night out. Totally hit the spot- absolutely delicious!!

Coolest pizza place downtown, and their cheese fries are bomb!!! prices are amazing too:)

Excellent customer service! Small spot off the beaten path. Large pizza, 2 sandwiches (great cheesesteaks) 2 beers and cheese fries, about $40. Worth every penny! Went in to order, told them we were on bikes, they offered to deliver and asked when we'd be ready. Locals get half off. That's pretty awesome! Businesses are always asking you to support local businesses, this business supports local residents. Highly recommend. read more

I have been down to Key West several times and always make Mr Z's a required stop to get my fix of either a Philly Cheese Steak or a Stromboli. Not only is the staff make you feel like your a welcomed local but the decor is so cool, it makes it feel like your in philly. It's a great stop if your craving for a pizza at 2 am, after you got your drink on. The best by far in old-town, I tell everyone I know to check the place out when they are in the keys, if they want fantastic food at an affordable price. read more

I'm a Philly native who works on cruise ships. As glamorous as it may sound to sing on a ship transversing the Caribbean, the one thing that is consistently terrible is the food. I always miss the food at home in Philadelphia. But every time, let me be clear, EVERY TIME I dock in Key West, I make a pilgrimage to Mr Zs. I will admit it, I'm a cheesesteak snob, but they do it right. They staff even has those south Philly accents that are a given at any cheesesteak joint in Philadelphia. If you're looking for a truly authentic experience, not to mention a damn good cheesesteak (and don't forget the roast pork italiano! A Philly favorite that in my opinion is even better than Phillys best known sandwich), make sure to drop by Southard street. read more

I really don't understand why this place has such good reviews! I has pizza almost daily on the way through the keys, this was the worst! Look past the pot smokers and homeless congregating outside, tupac blaring inside and rude employees why don't greet you and it's still a hot mess. The pizza was undercooked and the cheese was crap. Never again, go to Only Wood for an authentic pizza pie or Paradise pizza instead. read more

Pizza was really good. I do not remember it being this good a few years ago. They found out I was vegetarian and made me a really solid veggie sub with egg plant chunks (that even with the skin on, was digestible, not bitter and good), onions and much more. Good dressing on it. They custom made the sub for me and the hit a home run with it. I was mad I got full so quickly as I wanted more but couldn't do it lol. One bad mark: the guys behind the counter blatantly were eating in a very "sloppy man" kind of way which kind of sucked. As a former employee of Mike Z (and this actual location) as well as having a father that had a pizza shop and pub for over 25 years, I understand how pizza shops really are. You eat on the job, your shirt is soaked with sweat and there is a sort of smart ass pack mentality. I get it. However, I would at least try to hide the fact that I was munching on an italian hoagie in between orders by turning my back or going in the back to take a bit. When I saw finger entering food into the mouth and those fingers touching the lips/inner mouth with no immediate hand wash, it wasn't a surprise to me (or gross) because I've been there...but come one guys...try to hide it at least. Not everyone is a former pizza shop rat like me. There was a general air to the place too that was very "smart ass" like. I'm not totally sure these guys wouldn't pull an immature prank on your food if you gave them too much of a hard time. Perhaps they were just hot as hell slaving over ovens for me and the rest of key west too, as I'm sure most people don't tip them. Go get the food, it's good! read more

Words cannot fully describe the quality and flavor of the cheese steaks here. To me they taste fresher and cleaner than anything up north. A must visit late night in key west read more

not sure what happened to this place - I used to bring people here to eat because the philly's were so good - been coming to key west for 15 years and 4 years ago this was the best philly cheese steak i have ever had and the service was good - went last year and the cheesesteak was not good and tonight it was worse and the service was horrible. young boy with tatooed neck should not have a job period let alone service industry. I will not be back here and will be surprised to see mr Z's in business in a year unless its because there are just not enough places to eat read more

I ordered to the Hyatt Windward this weekend. I was really excited, but the product did not meet my expectations unfortunately.

We've spent years trying to find good pizza delivery in KW. Mr. Z's fits the bill. The pizza is fantastic (love the red sauce) and the sandwiches are super fresh. I love the Italian Sub. I was surprised how ripe the tomatoes were on the sammies. Really good - don't pass it up! read more

My rating on their cheese steaks can fluctuate between a 4 star and 5 star depending on how late in the night it is and how much I've had to drink. The steak cheese steaks are decent but I am a little more partial to the chicken cheese steaks myself. Their pizza isn't really remarkable imo so I usually stick with the cheese steaks. This place is one of my favorite late night grab and go places in key west to get food to help soak up all the alcohol from the nights festivities. The whole operation is very small so don't go here expecting to find much in the way of seating. I think they have about 5 stools against one wall with a little half ledge to eat off of. The deliver also but I've never used the delivery service myself. If you are in key west though you should definitely try this place out at least once to say you've been there. read more

The CheeseSteak & CheeseFries hit the SPOT! It was a little difficult to get in touch because they are crazy-busy but truly worth the wait. Once we placed our order they got it to us fast and hot. If you feel like an in-home dinner or in our case in-hotel, it was FANTASTIC! Go Mr Z's and Hokies - you made our Sunday night! *Side note, Hope all of y'all are doing okay after Irma. Truly appreciated our time in your fine town and sending thoughts and prayers to all. read more

I stop by Mr.Z's for a slice of pepperoni pizza and a beer every time I go to Key West. It's the perfect quick, cheap pit stop when you're out drinking in Old Town. read more

A must-stop for us any time we're in Key West. My brothers and dad swear by the cheesesteaks, and I am extremely partial to the pizza. The crust is NY style with a nice crisp bottom and it's all so fresh. I've also shared cheese fries and they are to die for. Can't miss it. read more

Mr. Z's tomato pie is quite possibly the best pizza I've ever had in my life. There's really nothing more to say.

Got the steak and cheese and it was fantastic! The wait wasn't long, even though there was a good crowd in there when I arrived. The crew was friendly and the food was great. Definitely recommend! read more

As a kid growing up in the philly area, cheesesteaks are close to my heart. These guys do a fairly decent job making an authentic one. The meat is moist, bread is chewy and the cheese is gooey. There is not much to not love about it. Throw some mushrooms and onions on there and you've got a meal. The pizza which I've tried once was pretty good. I always get mine extra hot to get the crunch factor. I like the ambiance, no frills, old school pizza shop feel with the guys behind the counter throwing pizza and attitude all at once. A lil piece of Philly in Key West to make all of us east coast transplants a bit more comfortable. Bring cash though, no cards at this location, $10 minimum in new town, but they don't have beer. read more

I live in NYC and would put their pizza on the high end of the spectrum of any pizza that I've had there. Definitely worth a stop

Ummm chicken parm.....BREADED chicken mozzarella and tomato sauce. Somehow they think chicken parm is GRILLED chicken with cheese and sauce. Very disappointed. How do u mess that up? read more

Dude.... What can I say, this place is killer. The guys in the shop really have it going on. Don't mess with anything but the philly with the house american cheese. That stuff is worth It's weight in gold read more

Had slices multiple times on my way home from drinks with friends and they're the best slice in town. Ordered a few meatballs at a buck a piece and they were great as well. Open till 4am and a Philly establishment. Fast. Clean and damn good read more

The tomato pie is really delicious, but the staff kind of sucks. I ate there during "dinner hours" one evening and had the same bad attitude that I got from them at midnight on my way home from visiting a friend. I was sober, but they are obviously comfortable treating everyone as they would an obnoxious drunk. It was offensive and turned me off from returning. I would rather go hungry than be treated like I am lucky to be giving them business. read more

A great late night spot! Picked up a cheese steak and a couple of slices of pizza on the walk back to our hotel at 1 am. delicious! Staff was very friendly and busy. Convenient location. read more

We ordered two pizzas to be delivered to the condo. A tomato pie (our friends wanted this one) and a pepperoni and mushroom for us. I wasn't a huge fan of the pepperoni mushroom (it wasn't bad), but I LOVED the tomato pie!! Even if you are like, "Tomato pie? Not my thing," try it!! So good!!! They use San Marzano tomatoes in the sauce. Yummy!!!! read more