This was exactly what we were looking for. A friendly place with good food at reasonable prices. Next time I would skip the soft pretzels -- pretty sure they were microwaved. But the rest of the meal was solid. Veggies in the salads were fresh. The Hugo burger with green olives was exactly what I hoped for. My husband's steak was delivered as ordered. Wish we'd tried the blackberry cobbler. Maybe next time. And yes, there will be a next time. read more

Will not go back. It sucked! The steaks were tough, undercooked or overcooked. Sent on steak back and replaced it with spaghetti and meatballs. It was really bad! The meatballs were tasteless and the big pile of pasta.was.cold and dry.Yuk! One star is too much! read more

This place has a lot of potential for renovations - part of me is happy that it's kept it's Irish looking roots and seems homey like an Irish pub would but the other half of me thinks they could certainly use an upgrade to the building. They do so well on St. Patrick's Day and I wish it was like that all the time but it's a standalone establishment in the middle of neighborhoods so most people miss it or prefer to go somewhere where there are plenty of dining options around the area. I've always had a great time here! The Guinness flows and I'm always full. My Irish in laws LOVE coming here and we can eat as a giant family and have the nicest servers every time we come here. Everyone is able to order something different off the menu and the hot bacon oil salad is AMAZING. I'm still a bit confused on the naming as there use to be a Murphy's Steakhouse on Keystone/Fall Creek which I believe they once owned, but now it's a Jamaican restaurant. Then this establishment is named Murphy's at Flynn's but I've heard some call it Pat Flynn's. I'm sure there's an explanation but that could use some clarification. read more

Murphy's Steakhouse - 8oz ribeye with chefs butter and baked potato - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great food at a down home place that feels like an extension of your own kitchen. Great pizza, steaks, and seafood. Bring a sweater old timers because it's a bit chilly from time to time. Wait staff is second to none! Check it out! You'll like this place. read more

Murphy's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This is an awesome place. I've been coming here on a regular basis for many years The staff are efficient and friendly. The food is top notch. The patrons are normally middle aged. There is entertainment on a regular schedule. Murphy's provides a great experience at modest prices. I heartily recommend them. read more

We haven't been here since the moved to this spot. We should have come sooner! The food is still great and the service is still wonderful. I guess we just missed the old location so much. But we will definitely be coming back! Service even on St. Patrick's Day was efficient and friendly. There was a nice bar room as well as a spacious dining room. Still a place you can come to hang out, stay a while, have a beer or a bite and feel welcome. Even if you're nostalgic and missing the old 70's decor :) read more

Went here for a friends birthday dinner. I went immediately after work and was dressed in scrubs. When I walked in I definitely felt pretty underdressed, turns out this is a bit of a nicer restaurant, which no one told me that. The food was really good and everyone seemed pretty happy with what they ordered. We had a large group of about 20 so we were split into two groups of 10 which made the service a bit faster and better because each group of 10 was assigned to their own server. for being a bit of a nicer restaurant the price of the food was really reasonable which surprised me. One downfall was I asked my server for extra lemon for my water , which took her a bit, but I was understanding due to it being a large party, so to take some of the stress off I went to the bar to get my own. When doing so I ran into the server and asked her if I could still have lemons and she got them for me, but grabbed them with her bare hands and put them into a saucer dish. I feel that it's a little nasty because I wasn't sure if her hands were clean or not. I'm sure things like this happen all the time in the food industry but it's one thing to assume it does and another to see it with your own eyes. read more

Fairly unimpressed by this iconic place. Went with some friends to grab a steak dinner and some drinks. Service was ok but the food wasn't that good at all. I ordered the Beef Oscar and it wasn't really as described. It was described as having a crab cake on top. I'm not sure if what I had was considered a crab cake. It was definitely chopped up fake Krab and not "crab". The description doesn't define that you won't be receiving real crab, which would have changed my order. I ordered my beef tenderloin as Medium and it was 100% well-done. The French onion soup was pretty good which was kind of the saving grace. I also had a really delicious martini. I had also ordered a twice baked potato and it was awful. No flavor or anything and really looked more like an order of potato skins. I didn't hate the place, but expected a lot more. I wouldn't go out of my way to go back. read more

Great value, great food, and great service. Kind of a hidden gem that we found while in a business trip. Would go back anytime.

Murphy's at Flynns RUINED my family's plans for the evening of Saturday, November 5 2022. I'll begin this review by stating I am 100% aware of the fact that it was a busy Saturday night, on the day of Indy's Monumental Marathon. Decent weather too. That's why I made a reservation back in October, roughly 10 days prior to November 5th. Large party. Thirteen people. Seven adults and six well-behaved children. My children. Son & wife from Louisville Ky with three kids. Son & wife from Indianapolis with their girl. Daughter and husband from Wheaton IL and their two kids. Thirteen hungry people planning on a nice family dinner at Murphy's. Lots of logistical planning to get all these people to 52nd & Allusonville Road. Daughter's hubby ran the Monumental Marathon on 11/5. This is why we gathered Murphy's utterly stiffed us. We showed up at exactly 6:30pm and no table. After waiting 45 minutes, outside with the kids getting antsy, we left. Why make a reservation if the restaurant doesn't honor it? Stiffed, upset and boy, the people from out of town were ridiculing Indianapolis. And Murphy's. As they should. Bottom line. Don't trust this joint to honor a reservation. Worthless. read more

A nice lunch location close to the State Fairgrounds. They have good lunch specials everyday. I had the tenderloin which was seasoned nicely and was thick and meaty. It was the perfect sandwich for lunch. Most places try to out do each other to see which tenderloin is the biggest. The wait staff was very friendly and on top of refills when needed. read more

Murphy's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Went for a team lunch today! The food is pretty good. Today, I got the lunch special- bowl of chili with a grilled cheese sandwich. I've had their patty melt and cheeseburgers which are also good! Their fries are really yummy too! The chili is solid- good flavor. Usually had a nice kick to it but not today. Grilled cheese- classic sandwich but a little salty and buttery! I really liked it though. I've been here a few times (for lunch) and they're pretty slow (hence why I knocked them down a star). I usually take a short lunch but have to extend it to accommodate wait times. In their defense, I'm usually with a group. I'll come back because their prices are reasonable, the servers are nice, and the food is pretty good. Bonus: it's close to work! read more

Murphy's Steakhouse - Lunch special! Grilled cheese and chili! Yum - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

A little bit pricey but it is a steakhouse. The ambience was something of my moms or grand Palms house. We were probably the youngest people there which I kind of knew going into. The food was a little bit bland but again I think they're cooking and catering for the clientele. I honestly thought everything was super delicious I just need a little bit of salt and pepper. We both had ribeye steaks and desserts. I would definitely go back. This place is americana as it gets read more

Stopped in for dinner. Fried catfish was on the specials. Don't really know what it tasted like because all I tasted was the cooking oil. Might I suggest a draining rack with paper towels or something to take off the excess cooking oil? I like the place, great service, great prices but too much cooking oil. read more

Visiting Indianapolis from Upstate New York and decided to stop at Murphy's for dinner. The food was tasty and Cindy's bubbly personality made my dining experience exceptional. Will definitely come back when I visit again. Cindy you are amazing keep shining your light. read more

Did not have high expectations after reading some of the reviews but hard to pass up 13.99 filet with baked potato and salad. Walking in we weren't greeted immediately but it didn't take long. The place is huge and has tons of seating. Appetizer of soft pretzel and cheese. I didn't care for the cheese but the pretzel was great. We both went for the above mentioned filet dinner. I got their hot bacon dressing on my salad and it took me back to childhood. My Mom would heat bacon grease and a little vinegar and pour it over home grown leaf lettuce. So yummy! The steak was very tender and had good flavor. The baked potato was...well a baked potato, add butter and sour cream YUMM. Dessert was blackberry cobbler it was fantastic. It too tasted much like something my mom would have made. Average age of customers was pretty high. Decor was pleasant. Hate that everyone has TVs ever place. In the bar ok but the dining area had at least 6 spaced through out playing sports and Faux News. We will more then likely be back, but it is way off our beaten path. read more

I'd been to Murphy's when it was on Keystone, years ago, and I'd been to Pat Flynn's, also years ago, but this was my first visit since they merged. Once again, this place is MUCH larger than it looks from the outside. I like the color scheme quite a lot, it's warm and inviting, and the staff is cordial and friendly. For dinner, I had the tenderloin sandwich, and, let me tell you, this is a dandy. It's obviously hand breaded, and the pork was tender, moist and tasty. I felt like the breading could have used a little more seasoning, still, I wouldn't hesitate to order it again. The french fries were good but not exceptional. Still, it was a tasty, satisfying meal that I recommend. We were part of a larger, private group, and much of the group felt the service was a tad slow, however, I do realize it's tough to plan for large groups. All in all, a well above average experience. Murphy's will go int our regular rotation for a night out. read more

Murphy's Steakhouse - Murphys Tenderloin. It's a winner. - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I have been frequenting Murphy's for the last year; ever since I moved to the area. I have always been met with the kindest of people as well as the best service around. Parking is plentiful and this place really give you the "hometown" pub feel. The patrons are friendly and the staff is outstanding!! All of this and you get great drinks and even better food all in one place on Allisonville Rd. Which for this area is hard to find when it's centered between two major bloodlines connecting to the downtown area. read more

Murphy's Steakhouse - Bar is filled with history from all decades from the Indy areas - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Murphy's Steakhouse is a local staple. It has been around forever and isn't likely to go anywhere anytime soon. It's a great place to go for steak without breaking the bank. I've only visited their original location once. This is my first time visiting the new location. Arrived around 1 to meet some friends for lunch. The places wasn't every crowded, so it didn't take long to be seated. Unfortunately things did pick up and they appeared to be short staffed. Our waitress was trying her best to keep up with everything. I wasn't in the mood for a filet and was curios about the pretzel sandwiches they offer. I ordered the turkey Gouda pretzel panini w/fries. It was pretty standard and good, but nothing exceptional. The food is consistent. Just nothing spectacular although rumor has it that their cobblers are exceptional. I wouldn't go out of my way to visit, but I definitely would return to this local staple. read more

Murphy's Steakhouse - Turkey Gouda pretzel panini :) - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Be clear, this is neither a 5-star restaurant nor a 5-star steakhouse. You can find better steaks and better, classier restaurants with more frills. But I give Murphy's 5 stars because it does virtually everything you would want a family owned steakhouse to do at reasonable prices. I've been eating at Murphy's since they were at the Keystone location. I didn't know anything about Flynn's Pub and had never been there before they merged. They definitely had a rough period there afterward. But they worked it out. The menu is diverse, with plenty of cuts of steak, numerous burgers, really good sandwiches and platters and a good assortment of appetizers, your standard bar bites type of stuff. They also have a full bar with a variety of liquor, wine and craft beer. The last time I went, I had the NY strip. It was excellent. No, it wouldn't challenge what they serve at St. Elmo's or Morton's, but it also is about 1/3 the price. It comes with baked potato and a salad as well. With my iced tea and tip, I think my total bill was between $25 and $30. I've always had good service there. They have a number of regulars, usually older folks who have been coming there a long while. They have a big dining room as well as seats in the front room near the bar, so there's usually a minimal wait. I just like a locally owned place such as this one that does the best it can. Again, it's not an upscale steakhouse or one of your chic Mass Ave eateries that will cost twice as much for food that isn't really all that great. I will come here as long as it's open. read more

This is Murphy's at Flynn's on Allisonville at 52nd. The main customer here is over 60 and the menu cater's to that crowd. Not sure what the specials are here, but it certainly isn't vegetables. read more

Had dinner here on a Saturday night. I ordered the filet and a twice baked potato. Ordered the steak medium and it came out well and was cold. I am not sure if a person who had not eaten in a week could have eaten this steak. If that was a filet I would hate to see the lower quality steaks. The twice baked bake potato was cold as ice and did not taste good either. I let the waitress know this and she brings out an empty plate for me to put the potato on and takes it and microwaves it and brings the exact potato back to me. Would it be too much to get me a new hot potato? Will not be dining here ever again! read more

We went mid-week. Service was extremely slow but it was busy due to live music. Food was okay. Good vibe with the music. I wanted to love this place but did not. read more

It's been at least 15 years since I stopped in at this place the combination of Murphy's steak House/Pat Flynn's Murphy's@ Flynn's really great service great atmosphere and the food was totally succulent deafly gonna go back and try some more things off the menu I've never had crabcakes this good going to be back very soon check 1-2 thank you again Debbie for being such a fabulous hostess read more

See all

Really nothing to complain about here. Good basic food combined with consistent service. We tend to wander in here on Thursdays for a steak special, but every meal we have had has been good and often I end up with the meatloaf dinner, served with gravy and mashed potatoes, it's just good, comfortable and consistent. Dessert options change around but we've been happy with our cobbler and pie selections. Not always the liveliest of places but you can tell there's a good regular crowd coming in and there has been live music and performers at times. Lots of parking and easy entry off of Allisonville or 52nd. read more

Murphy's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Really friendly staff and I keep coming back for the bar food (wings, tenders etc.) I was really disappointed in the steak though - it was just really bad. I ordered medium rare and it was medium well an just floating in a butter they top with after. A soggy over-cooked steak was disappointing. Everything else is great though! Love the vibe and the staff, just avoid the steak :) read more

We're new to the area and live walking distance, so have checked it out several times in the last few months, it's one of the few sit-down dinner restaurants near here. The food has been reliably delicious. I will agree with everyone else, the decor is outdated, the clientele is large, pale and 50+, and everyone seems to know everyone else. But the staff was welcoming, the food is good and familiar, and while it's not super cheap, the portions are large. Take Mom. read more

I really wanted to love this place, as we moved very near here. The first time, I ordered crab cakes. When I got them and took a bite, it was like someone had dumped an entire salt shaker in them. Completely inedible. But hey, I decided to give them another chance. So we went there tonight. Ordered pan fried cod. It was raw in the center. The server offered another but I said no. So she said that shrimp wouldn't take long, so I said ok. Plus, who can screw up shrimp! This was flawed thinking. The first one I couldn't find the shrimp. Another was raw. So she said the shrimp was more then the cod, but she only charged me for the cod. Now, I don't expect a free dinner. I did expect the manager to show up, but they never did. Clearly they don't care about keeping and acquiring customers. Not good. Not even close. read more

Fun place, not sure the foods that good but dang it's a party place. I've met more people and you can dance all night! My kind of place! read more

Murphy's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I have lived down the street from Pat Flynn's for 10 years, and cant believe Ive never been here before. We stopped in for a late bite, and got the fish and chips and a reuben. Fish and chips are huge chunks of whitefish with a light delicious breading served up with coleslaw and crispy fries. My new favorite fish and chips spot! The Reuben had a generous amount of tastey corned beef and sauerkraut. The interior is nothing fancy, its a little dated, but they certainly make up for it with the food and drinks! We will definitely be back, and cant wait to try the rest of the menu! read more

My wife and I eat here fairly regularly she always has the 6oz filet special, you won't find a better filet in the city for the price, they have wilted lettuce salad which is excellent. read more

Went there every Thursday for the last year for lunch today was my last day.... they do not care about there customers...could care less attitude It's very unfortunate I always try to support local business owners...I will never set foot in there again read more

Our services was bad, the waitress was had a bad attitude from the start. To end the night she followed us out the restaurant, yelling that she only makes $2 an hrs. We should tip better. I tip well with good service. Had a awesome waitresses this morning at the four seasons. She was tired well. read more

Love Murphy's! It is a long time staple in our Community. Even many of their staff has been there for many years. They are consistently good - all around - food, service, prices and friendliness. I always get a steak and never go wrong. Steak is one of their staples. read more

I didn't hate it. Service was 4/10. Food was 3/10. I ordered catfish and sides of salad and twice baked potato. Catfish was fried properly, with adequate breading. Fish was flaky and good. The twice baked potato side was anemic. I mean it was basically a potato skin (sorta). I know this place is a classic and well loved but I don't know, it really missed the mark. The wife ordered a medium steak and it was very well done. The couple we met for dinner also chose med rare and medium and their steaks were also very well done. I wouldn't go out of my way to visit again. read more

I dined here on a Friday night, after a conference, that was my mistake. I was sitting next to a large table of coworkers who did nothing but complain and talk loudly about how much they hated their job and their bosses. They drank heavy and were obnoxious. I thought the food was pretty good but it wasn't great, however the service was awful. I don't know if it was because we were not regulars, but she kept forgetting our drinks but then we go wait on another table. I more than likely will not return to this establishment. read more

The décor was attractive. I liked the atmosphere very much. I had the fillet of beef tenderloin and it was tasty. The baked potato was good. My friend had the flank steak, but it was over cooked and not per her instructions. The waitress was extra attentive and helpful. There is plenty of free parking in the mall lot. Murphy's was not crowded on a Saturday night but I recommend making reservations just to be safe. Murphy's has an attractive bar either for cocktails or for dinner. I like this place except for the over-cooked flank steak. read more

This is a very welcoming local establishment. Never had anything but tasty food, drink and marvelous personable service. Excellent surf and Turf tonight! read more

This is my favorite restaurant ! The staff is friendly. Erin at the bar makes delicious drinks and is a good listener. The atmosphere reminds me of the show Cheers, but even if you are a first timer; you are treated as a friend. This place will be a lot of fun on St Patrick's day, reverting back to when it was Flynn's. Daily specials, excellent steak and price ! Very diverse menu, everything is quite yummy and prepared just for you. Casual attire is fine or fancy, no judgement here read more

Not the worst dinning experience but far from the worst. Looks like a nice quaint place to come grab a drink but the food could use a little love when seasoning. My first time ever eating clam chowder and I actually enjoyed it. The steak just fell short. I ordered a 12oz NY Strip with a side of fries $18. Fries were ehhhh but that's what I get for getting fries (Leah sent hers back) steak was more ehhhh given the price. Apparently the tenderloin was good (kicking myself) service wasn't bad either our server was good best part was the way she pronounced pizza "pezza" lol. The fried lobster was pretty good too. Overall not a bad mean just not what I expected. read more

Murphy's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all