Came on a freezing cold Friday night! Best decision! Food was delicious! Staff and service was fabulous!! Had the eggplant appetizer and the meatballs and both were delicious!! Our party had the shrimp meal the rigatoni cabarnora the chicken Milanese and the short rib !!! All very good and nice size portions!! The waiter and the manager were so nice and attentive! It took a while to get our dessert and manager treated us!!! No one rushed us ! Can't wait to come back!!! Try the Affagado! It is delic!!! read more

Food is good. Expensive but quality. Great service. Lobster tail is big. They do well with special requests. Asked for small salads and they gave all 4 of us a lovely little salad. Fried calamari was delicious. read more

As soon as you arrive it's obvious why My Cousins is the name, welcomed like family. Wife and I shared the ahi tuna and meatballs. Both are amazing and have the day seeing as the meatballs are hand made they won. I enjoyed the perfectly cooked and seasoned NY strip creamed spinach. The wife had the salmon over asparagus and it was amazing !!! The wife highly recommends a skinny margarita. We look forward to our next meal !! read more

This is a family owned restaurant and as such provides friendly service and a cosy atmosphere. The food is outstanding especially the meatballs, French Onion soup, calamarie, and my favorite muscles and clams. Strip steak, pasta, lobster tails, Clasic Burger, juicy pork chops, rack of lamb and more are all delicious. Deserts are great as is the beautiful bar that serves craft cocktails and Guiness on tap. On Tuesday nights there is light live entertainment that embraces the restaurant's relaxed mood. The Mahopac area has needed an affordable fine dining restaurant and My Cousins fits the bill. read more

We celebrated our 25th wedding anniversary here. Exceptional food and service. Shout out to Jessica, our server. Wonderful!

Definitely get the fried cauliflower!! The owner was there which I feel is always a nice touch.

Nice experience all around. Good cocktail list and great selection of whiskey! 5 Star Onion Soup, Great Specialty Burger and the NY Strip was perfect. Attentive staff, very fair pricing and a place I will definitely return to. read more

Nice place. Long wait but the bar was nice. Great bartender helped us pick nice cocktails and snacks

Hubby and I had a late lunch/early dinner here today and we are hooked. Everything was wonderful, staff, food, atmosphere. The owner, David, was so conscientious, stopping by every table to make sure diners were happy with their order. We started with Aunt Chrissy's meatballs which were seriously the best meatballs I've had. Rack of lamb with spinach and mashed potatoes was excellent and the Smothered Pork Chop was so tender and juicy. Definitely will be going back often! read more

I went to a private party at Cousins. They had appetizers and wine . The food was amazing and so much of it. They kept coming around with more and good size portions . The fried cauliflower was fabulous. It was a fundraiser and advertised as appetizers only and drinks. But they also put out a little buffet table with eggplant ricotta, cheese and salami and cooked vegetables and more. The waitstaff are very nice and so is the owner. read more

Nice ambiance. Only had drinks but will be back to try the food too. Wonderful bar service though!

Great place! The service was great and the food amazing! David knows how to run a great restaurant! If I didn't work so much I'd be there all the time!! If you haven't tried My Cousins you're missing out!! read more

We have been going there regularly since it has opened. The food is very good the mustard chicken and pasta dishes are outstanding. The starters are good and not to much always gets the table conversation started. To prove how I honestly feel when we meet friends for dinner we come here. The food while good more importantly is consistent. The service is great which adds to the ambiance. Feels like your favorite local place with an elevated menu. Thanks guys your GREAT!. read more

If you are looking for a restaurant with a delightful ambiance, excellent service and delicious food you have to go to My Cousin's!! You will not be disappointed!! read more

Delicious!!!!! Great service! Fabulous bread and herbed butter. Cauliflower appetizer was the best! Entrees perfect ! read more

Went here with my daughter this evening.... our server was Dylan. From the drinks, to the appetizer, to the main course....amazing, the food was full of flavor, presentation was really nice. Dylan was as sweet as could be, we will definitely be going back, and if we're lucky..... we'll get Dylan again! read more

Best place in Mahopac hands down. Classy/Hip vibes all around. I've been twice so far and the food was great. Don't sleep on the Cauliflower pancakes. The staff is what pushes this place over the edge, absolutely amazing. Owner is such a great guy and always checking on tables. Must go! read more

I'm so excited about this amazing new restaurant!! Everything I tried so far was amazing!! And I can't wait to go back to try everything else!! Artichoke dip was delicious!! The candied bacon I will have dreams about!! The Shrimp and bow tie pasta was dynamite!! Staff was so sweet and on point!! And the owner David was so attentive to everyone!! Can't wait to go back!! read more

I can't say enough about this new jewel located in Mahopac. Having opened just a few days ago they were on point from the minute we walked in the door. The attentiveness of the staff, the cocktails, happy hour appetizers and dinner where superb. The waiter Vinny made us immediately feel like family. He is extremely warm and entertaining. He didn't miss a step keeping our needs met along with the rest of the wait staff. The cauliflower pancakes are a must. Nothing frozen here. The owner mentioned they were his grandmothers recipe. We also had fries zucchini, which was also freshly made and sliders that were generous in size. Everything was fabulous! The pork chop was cooked to order. Tender and juicy with a fresh made apple, onion and bacon compote. Accompanied by lyonnaise potatoes that were pan seared to perfection. The lobster tail came with a choice of a side which we picked mashed potatoes. Also excellent and generous in portion size. The owner came over during each course to make sure everything was made to order and that we were happy. Something I appreciate. I can't say enough about this place except try it. You won't be disappointed and it will become a "go to" place for you. read more

Where do I begin? The ambiance, food, service all top notch. The owner is on top of everything from table set ups to wine service and kitchen. The food was unbelievable! Everything was delicious and seasoned perfectly. The portions were plentiful. This place is a welcomed change to the area! We will definitely be back. read more

So I tried My Cousin's tonight, their first week in business and I was very impressed. The food was fantastic. Some of the things we tried were the French Onion Soup, Cauliflower Patties, Lobster Tail with Lyonaise Potatoes, and Diablo Di Mare...all excellent. And despite being slammed and at full capacity their first Saturday in business, the service was great. The waitress and staff were attentive and the owner was present and in the dining room making sure everybody was happy and taken care of. This is a great new addition to the area and I'm looking forward to returning. read more

Great food and great service from everyone from the owners to the hostess. Great ambiance for a date night or dinner with the family

All around great establishment. Been there a few times. Owner is super attentive. Decor is classy. NYC vibes. Oh and the food is delicious.

Very good. Wonderful staff. Liked everything we've ordered except salmon was overcooked for our liking.

What a great new restaurant in Mahopac. The owner is super friendly and the wait staff is very nice. We went with a party of nine and they accommodated us even though we had no reservations. What a pleasant experience we had. The food was excellent and the drinks were as well. I highly recommend visiting My Cousins for your next meal. read more

See all

We had a fabulous dinner. The food was perfect. We started with the charcuterie and cheese board and wedge salad. We then had the braised short rib special. It was so tender that no knife was needed. The risotto was perfect as well. We did not have room for dessert... the service was excellent. All severs were obviously well trained and on point. We will certainly be back! read more

I always have a great meal and good service. The martinis are delicious and it's a fun relaxing atmosphere

Tremendous service, pork chop is a must, all pastas were great, highly recommend for family night out or intimate date

Excellent upscale food in a casualish environment. Food and desserts were very good for northern Westchester/Putnam area.

Delicious food, the cheese board with a nice bottle of wine was great for date night!

Meatballs (appetizer) are as good as My nonnas! Service and ambience are perfect - relaxing and welcoming. Owner Dave is a Wonderful friendly host and his staff attentive. Upscale without being snooty. So far cocktails are awesome - creative! Waiting for Main course but so far amazing - will continue after dinner! read more

I went this evening to a new restaurant, My Cousin's, Mahopac, NY. The service was exemplary. The staff were attentive, courteous and friendly. Honestly, they couldn't do enough for us. As for the food, it was absolutely delicious. We had Tuna Shashimi, Sweet Steakhouse Wedge salad, side of broccoli and creamed spinach and lobster tails. We ended our dinner with Apple crumb. Everything was devine! You need to go try it! You won't be disappointed. read more

Great food and service. Their candy bacon appetizer was small but delicious..ok seriously bacon can't be bad..went for first time last night and really enjoyed..Only negative was our table for 2 was very small and between people trying to talk over the music, it was very loud. read more

The best place for an anniversary. Fantastic food, great service. Highly recommend.

DELICIOUS!!!!! The staff is phenomenal. The bartenders Bill and Casey were on point, incredibly knowledgeable and very accommodating. The cauliflower appetizer was delicious!!!! Shrimp farfalle had the perfect spicy sauce, and the filet was cooked to absolute perfection. Highly recommend the vanilla bean creme brûlée. The restaurant was packed from the second I walked in until I was leaving and was so efficiently and well run. I can't wait to come back read more

We've there there a few times already and the food, service and ambiance is awesome. The cauliflower pancakes, and charcuterie is great. Congrats Dave you have a winner read more

I just celebrated my baby shower this past weekend at My Cousin's and it was unbelievable! Alyssa was such a pleasure to work with. She promptly and patiently answered all my questions, let us view the room multiple times to envision setup, helped create a great menu, and was so flexible and accommodating for any last minute changes I had. The day of went off perfectly - everything was set up as needed and the service of the staff was excellent. All of my guests were raving about the food so its safe to say they will definitely be coming back! Throughout the day of both Alyssa and David came over multiple times to make sure the food, drinks and service were to my liking. The care and concern for their guests is top notch! I would have another party there in a heartbeat - everything was excellent! read more

So good!! From start to finish Dave and his team at My Cousins do a fabulous job, great service and excellent food! Highly recommend the cauliflower fritters and delicious broccoli rabe pasta, crème brûlée was perfect ! Definitely go!! read more

Great place. Amazing food. Very crowded and short staffed but the server killed it. Owner came by introduced himself, very nice but the servers make the place, at least ours did. I had the Chicken Milanese delicious. My husband had the Diablo Di Mare. Hes still talking about it. I will definitely be back. read more

We had a wonderful dinner with friends last night at this new restaurant. The service and food was excellent. The blackberry sangria was refreshing, the cauliflower pancakes were crispy , and everyone enjoyed their entrees. We wish the owner and staff much success! read more