Monday night meant we HAD to check deep-dish pizza off the Chicago list. Chef was not convinced we needed to do it , but the rest of us insisted - and Nancy's in the West Loop did not disappoint. The deep dish was GREAT and absolutely worth making room for. The surprise for me, though, was the Caesar salad. It was different from a traditional Caesar in all the right ways and absolutely perfect. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I haven't gone to Nancy's thru the years, but I've been there on my last two visits to Chicago. Conclusion for you quick reader types: . Nancy's is your FIRST AND ONLY PLACE you need to go for pizza in Chicago. . Oh...don't think I'm right....well, think again....I'm absolutely right and here's why: I've been going to Chicago style pizza joints for over 40 years. So many of ell known pizza places have been "corporatized" I say....and watered down...or, in the case of Gino's East, ruined their end product. . Pequod's: this is the place people think is all the rage these days, right? A neat funky place. The pizza has some very good qualities. BUT, the sauce at Pequod's doesn't have a balanced flavor and smoothness to the sauce. And the sauce level was crazy and oozing everywhere on the day I had it. It was overpowering the other great elements to the pizza. . Nancy's Pizza: They have the quintessential sauce flavor down. They have the quintessential pepperoni taste to their pizza. Nancy's has a great crust to their pizza - both in flavor and crust texture. The pizza at Nancy's is THE MODEL REPRESENTATION OF DEEP DISH CHICAGO PIZZA. And you know what else Nancy's does at this location: They repeat the ideal customer experience from one visit to the next. They repeatedly duplicate a great tasting pizza every visit. . Folks reading this review (may not) know me. But, I have gone to so many places for pizza for Chicago. I've brought back pizzas on a trip continually thru the years. I've shipped pizzas in constantly. Me and Chicago style pizza have met! lol. No lol. lol. . Did I leave anything to the imagination folks? Yes, I am a true believer in Nancy's Pizza! You will be too, once you try the pizza. read more

See all

I'm genuinely disappointed with my recent experience at this restaurant. When I arrived to pick up my order, I was given the wrong pizza, mistakes happen, but what followed was unacceptable. It took over 1.5 hours for them to deliver the corrected pizza, and throughout the entire process the manager (or whomever they have answering the phone) showed a noticeable lack of urgency or concern about fixing their own error. What happened to quality control? A mix-up at the counter is one thing, but the slow response and indifferent attitude made it clear that customer satisfaction wasn't a priority. By the time the correct pizza arrived, the frustration had overshadowed the meal entirely. I hope they take this feedback seriously, because the food may be good, but the service especially when resolving mistakes needs major improvement. read more

We were a party of 7 for dinner on a Tuesday night. We made reservations and had a table right on time. Pizza selections were tremendous and we had the stuffed pizza. Our server was pleasant and boxed up our leftovers. We enjoyed the experience. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Nancy's Pizza came highly recommended, and it did not disappoint. There seem to be some street parking around the location. When you walk in you will find bar seating, high top tables, and traditional table dinning. Our server was the best. She walked us through the history of the restaurant, and answered all our questions, and helped guide our order. Which lead us to try both the wings and pizza. We were skeptical about the pizza with it being our first time trying this style, but we ended up really enjoying it. Fair warning you will get full fast - one slice was all I could manage to eat. The wings were delicious - we got hot buffalo lemon pepper and they will be a repeat for me in Chicago. If you are looking to try out a pizza spot in Chicago that also has great wings Nancy's is your spot. read more

See all

We arrived to Chicago late and had to get some deep dish for our first meal. Luckily Nancy's Pizza was close by and open late. We ordered the Caesar salad and a small deep dish pizza and the two of us could only eat one slice each. It was such a thick slice and was just overflowing with cheese. The crust was a crispy golden texture and stood tall. There was more cheese than any other deep dish we'd ever had. The Caesar salad was also surprisingly delicious. I liked their unique way that they served it with a bit of arugula and bacon bits mixed in. The ambiance and service were great as well. Even though we came close to closing time, our server was very friendly and we didn't feel rushed. The vibe was a bit retro and modern mixed together which was neat. I'm glad we started off our Chicago weekend at Nancy's. Side note: as a graphic designer, I loved the menu design! So cute and easy to read. read more

See all

Where do I start? This place is amazing. This was my first time trying it. The staff that took the orders for the pizzas were really really nice. One young lady. I believe her name was Yasmin. She was extremely helpful. Helping me navigate the app. The pizza was delicious. The crust was delicious. The salad was good. The service was good. Everything was a 10 to me. I got it for lunch and that was my first time having it. It was so good that for dinner we stopped and got another one so two in one day that speaks volume it was amazing. I will definitely be back. The service was phenomenal and the food. I didn't speak much on the bar because the bartenders were not as friendly. The drink was only OK but the food and the pizza order taker was really nice. read more

See all

Have been on a thin crust kick and have been putting trying Nancy's bc it's a chain but we were proven wrong! The uncle Tony's thin was amazing, the border slices were nice and crispy and even the interior slices were crispy which is where we're usually let down. Also had a small custom stuffed pizza with sausage, banana peppers and onions was so good and even better as leftovers. Will definitely be back as we were pleasantly surprised. Service was slow as it was the weird time between late lunch and early dinner but saw a ton of carry out orders. read more

This place is usually so good regardless take out or dine in. they must have changed staff or something. got the family size pizza mind you $65 for a pizza amd the whole thing was soggy the crust was mushy and literally eating the box with the crust cause its stuck this is not the regular crust they normally make. called and the manager made so many excuses so sad to be a regular customer and get this type of food. not to mention the order took 45 mins to get read more

See all

We had the best time here. DELICIOUS deep dish pizza, friendly staff, amazing ambiance and music. Would recommend to anyone - 10/10. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Best pizza in Chicago hands down! If you like it cheesy like giordanos, you're gonna love Nancy's. It's pretty much the same style of deep dish Chicago pizza pie, but believe it or not even cheesier, and I felt like the flavors were even better. The cheese pull we got was insane and even though we ate it in the car, to go, it was the highlight of our visit to Chicago. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Came for dinner and we enjoyed our time overall here. Unfortunately, we made a reservation and came early but had to wait until 10 minutes after our scheduled reservation time for the table to be ready. Despite this, our service was good and our food was great and we enjoyed it. The salad was good and both pizzas were enjoyed by our group. We also enjoyed the garlic bread but didn't get a picture before we finished it. read more

See all

Decent pizza, could be way cheesier (cmon!) It's part of the large dining group in Chicago so the rewards accumulate. Service can be slow as it gets realllllllly busy Ambiance fast casual read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I now understand why people say this Nancy's Pizza is some of the best in Chicago. Not only is their pizza good but so were the wings, the drinks, the service, and the vibe. I only had enough time to visit here once but had such a wonderful time that I had to make sure they got their 5 star review. P.S. Thank you to Adam who made sure I didn't leave Chicago without trying Nancy's iconic deep dish pizza. As a New Yorker, I've never wanted or considered trying deep dish Pizza but when in Chicago ... :). read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Ember & Ash (Spritz) - Custom made by Adam - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This review is for the location on Washington Ave. at Carpenter St. We ordered two small pizzas: A thin crust with sausage, and a "rustic" style with black olives. I really enjoyed the thin crust, it had a nice crunch with more flavor than some "cracker crust" pizzas. The sausage had just the right amount of fennel, and the sauce was good. The rustic style was equally good; the crust has more volume but is still not thick, and any toppings plus sprinkled Parmesan are baked on top. As a starter, we split the Caesar salad. It was very good but note to vegetarians -- ask for it without the bacon bits. We haven't been to any of the Nancy's locations. We would come back to this one just because we know how good it was! Service was friendly and fast. We found parking on Carpenter right in front of the entrance, and paid with Park Chicago app. read more

See all

Deep dish was a little overcooked and hard to cut through. Fried mozz had no cheese pull. Service after lunch hour was pretty slow even when it wasn't busy. Tiramisu was delicious but cannoli only had filling on the ends, nothing in the middle. read more

LOVEEEE this place! Visited Chicago from Las Vegas, NV and I loved this place so much. I don't remember loving deep dish pizza this much the first time I visited Chicago. My mom and I ordered the bone-in buffalo wings, fried mozzarella, mixed green salad and the original stuffed pizza with cheese only. The bone-in wings had a touch of lime, which made them so much better. The fried mozzarella came with marinara and a pesto sauce for dipping, and I was obsessed with the pesto sauce! The mixed green salad? Delicious! Perfect amount of dressing, flavorful, we finished the whole thing! The cheese stuffed pizza, DELICIOUS! Extremely filling, but sooooo good. Definitely my favorite restaurant we visited in Chicago during our visit. Service was quick, no complaints. We got there before the rush and got seated right away. Noise level was moderate and the restaurant was clean and welcoming. I can't wait to revisit Chicago and return to this restaurant. read more

See all

Finally tried this restaurant that I've walked past many times. What surprised me is that they have a take out option that is open later than the sit down restaurant! We got a deep dish and a thin crust. The thin crust was similar to most thin crust pizzas I've had. I enjoyed the deep dish more and loved how flaky the crust was. The pizza was ready within 25 minutes of ordering, which pleasantly surprised me since deep dish usually takes longer. We asked for red pepper flakes and they gave us multiple bags of both red pepper flakes and Parmesan cheese in Nancy branded baggies- a really nice touch! read more

See all

Overall, I had a really good experience at Nancy's pizza. I ordered the fettuccine alfredo, which was quite basic and nothing special. However, the Italian breadsticks were delicious, airy, and very affordable. I also ordered the blueberry pecan salad which pleasantly surprised me! The service was quick and they were accommodating to my vegetarian requests. It's a family friendly spot and quite cozy! I look forward to returning and trying the deep dish pizza! read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Blueberry Pecan Salad - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Ordered delivery but absolutely loved their Tavern style pizza. I tend to get cheese and giardinera since my wife is vegetarian and it was excellent. Light and cracker-thin, but still a great crunch and their giard has some heat which I loved. Would visit in person. I've always been intrigued by the outside. read more

On my ladyr night in Chicago I wanted to try my first stuff crust pizza. I sat at the bar. Nice customer service and it was clean. The drink was a bit small but maybe it's because my bartender measured as she should have. Pizza was pretty good, light on the initial cheese pull. Nice place to visit for pizza if you want to try deep dish pizza. read more

See all

I've had Nancy's Pizza a million times and they have literally never disappointed me. So here I am, totally baked, full-on munchies mode, trying to decide if I should wait for delivery like a responsible adult or just pick up my pizza and call it a night. Obviously I chose pick-up because patience is not a virtue when your cravings have taken over. I live like four blocks away so I ordered online and decided to share with my dog Winston a super thin 12" pizza with Italian sausage and mushrooms. When I went to pick it up everyone was insanely friendly and engaging. The restaurant is always clean, the staff is always ready to help, and somehow every single time I pick up an order it is always ready right on time. Never late, never rushed, just perfect every single time. I don't know how they do it but I respect it. And the pizza? Oh man, the pizza. I took it home and every bite hit me like I had never tasted pizza in my life. The crust, the toppings, the flavor balance, everything was perfect. Sitting at home baked and devouring that pizza felt like a spiritual experience. Honestly Nancy's has to be one of the top pizza places in Chicago. Nancy's I don't care what day it is I will be back. You've got a loyal fan here and probably Winston too because he is clearly a pizza connoisseur. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I'm here for 3 days from Southern California for work and wanted to try deep dish pizza while I am here and found this spot. It did not disappoint, and I would recommend it if you have not tried it. We also had lemon pepper wings that were devoured before we took a picture, but they were so flavorful. Service was great! Loved everything about this place. read more

See all

What a great place! Staff are amazing and attentive. Had the thin crust pizza which was legit. Sauce packed with flavor and the crust cooked to perfection. In my mind this is legit what a Chicago pizza should taste like (the do the original too, which looks great if that's your thing). Their garlic bread was also super tasty. The bone in wings cooked perfectly. The sweet bbq sauce was a bit too sweet for my tastes but still very good. read more

See all

We were looking for a great deep dish pizza in Chicago. And we happen to come around Nancy. We want a pizza that looks cheesy and flavorful and the reviews did not scare us wrong! The customer service was great. They made sure that we had everything that we needed and answer any questions. We may have out about the menu. The wings are really flavorful too and a nice addition to our deep dish pizza. I love that the restaurant is on the corner of the building and has large windows so you can see outside and have a great view. And it was nicely decorated and clean. I definitely recommend this pizza area if you are in Chicago. read more

See all

I was extremely excited to try this place after a review on social media & the fact that the takeout section was busier than chick-fil-a on a Saturday night. Pizza was dry. Garlic was muted. To my liking the entire family ate here for just under $60 & we were stuffed. Buttered kids pasta needs some help. Fries with the balsamic were the star of the show. Sort of interested in their wings but I'm in no rush. I'm not certain but there has to be better pizza in west loop read more

See all

Very good pizza. I'm torn about how to rate Nancy's - the thin crust, Chicago square style pizza was great! It was also darn expensive at ~$49. My heart says the quality and taste make this restaurant a clear five. To boot, the restaurant is fun, clean and service is high end. A wonderful dining experience in the West Loop. My brain, though, also tells me "how can you spend $50 on a pizza?" I would recommend and come back. Ideally on a work trip / credit card. read more

Place an order online for a medium stuffed pizza. I ordered a medium Stuffed Pizza with Sausage. Their medium is a measly 10 inch and rather pricey for the size. Their competitors if I'm not mistaken are 12 inches for medium and 14 inches for large at a better price. The pickup process was great and my pizza was ready by the time promised. But this ten inch seemed tiny. The pizza itself was ok. The crust tasted plain, it had a decent amount of cheese but could have used more sausage. The sauce was chunky but felt they could have balanced the sauce and cheese a little bit better. Overall despite the smaller size, it was still a very filling pizza. There's definitely better in Chicago. Not sure if I'll be returning anytime soon though. read more

See all

Came here for a work xmas party! We were assigned tables right by the door and entering the restaurant space. This made it challenging for not only other patrons to get around us, but to ensure service to all. Our server was amazing! She made sure everyone had a drink - which im sure had to be a challenge with all of us switching seats to socialize. Good was great! I'll definitely be coming back for pizza, as there is a designated take out window. read more

We got it delivered and it was still fantastic. To be honest we ate most of it the next day and it's a no doubt 5/5. Highly recommend read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Medium Thin crust pepperoni and feta - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Solid pepperoni, mushroom and mozzarella cheese pizza pie, ordered and received extra crispy. Began with a mixed green and Caesar salad - both as fresh as could be and plentiful. Super clean restaurant, cool décor, great location and decent beers on tap and wine available. Really struggled with this not being a '5', and I can only point to crust texture (Like a cracker / bread crust) being one deviation outside our preferred norm, some likely love it, just unconventional for us. Shout out to Linsey who took great care of us. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Fantastic Salads. - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Called ahead to see if there was a wait was told no came in 5 mins later and there was a 20/30 min wait half the restaurant is completely empty and had to order food Togo host was extremely rude read more

Bar seating was nice, service was pretty good and quick. This was my first time ever having deep dish and it wasn't bad! Might just be a basic thick crust girl at heart though. The wings were awesome--I'd honestly come back just for them next time. read more

See all

We went to Nancy's for post-marathon deep dish and salad. It was a bit of a hobble-waddle from our hotel, but worth it and also nice to get away from the busier part of town. We were seated quickly and had the nicest server. It seemed like the kind of spot that's great for a group (there were several there). I ordered a prickly pear margarita and not only was it balanced and tasty, but so pretty! We had the chopped salad - huge! - and Nana's Special pizza add pepperoni. DELICIOUS! As hungry as I was, we could only eat half the pie so the other half came on the flight with us home. It was my mid-air meal and made me smile all over again. read more

Got here at 1030. Says they are open till 1am. They' were doing carry out only. We are from out of town and took and uber to get here. We need a place to sit and eat. I'm just guess most uber drivers don't like food in their car. read more

Cool space good cocktails cheap wine big salads and great pizza. Wall of floor to ceiling windows for premium people watches. Friendly service. Wheelchair accessible. read more

Fabulous Chicago style pizza! The sauce is plentiful and fresh. The cheese is gooey and delicious, and the crust is great. We got it stuffed with mushrooms. Service was attentive and quick. The ambiance is casual and fun. Prices are reasonable. So good! read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - 9" Small Original Stuffed Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

(G)o - huge space! Got takeout but definitely want to dine in later and see the interior design. Spotted some cute rubber ducks hiding around the bar. (W)ow - Their onion rings are actually phenomenal. Not too much breading, crispy, not greasy, and huge! (A)ge - didn't get to see other customers bc we did takeout, which was fast and easy (M)enu - Pizza, garlic bread, and onion rings are the trifecta of late night eats. The pizza is round and they slice it into easy to eat rectangles for sharing. Solid flavor and generous toppings, although the crust wasn't as crispy as I would have liked. I enjoyed how the pepperoni was hidden underneath the sauce and chicken. Garlic bread was huge and not too buttery to make the container oily. As mentioned, onion rings really outshined all the other dishes. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - 14" Large Classic Thin Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Soooo good....honestly soooo good! The food was amazing and the service was awesome. The restaurant itself is clean and comfortable and a great place to connect with others. We were a party of seven and everyone in the party had a great time! read more

See all

The location is great, right around some busy bars and restaurants. Sat at the bar and there was several TVs that had different sports games on. Great midday place to grab a pizza, the ground beef was not seasoned well. If they would add Italian seasoning to the ground beef this would be a solid hamburger beef pizza for sure. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Rustic Pizza with hamburger beef and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all