I ordered a cheese and sausage stuffed pizza from Nancy's and it was delicious. I placed the order over the phone and she was polite and she said the pizza would arrive between 30 and 45 minutes. The driver arrived 35 minutes later with a piping hot pizza. I will order from Nancy's again, we were very satisfied at our party! read more

Food was outstanding, deep dish cheese pizza and chopped salad. The salad's are amazing because you can design them your way. I am not a gorgonzola fan but do love mozzarella so, I was able to get mozzarella in my salad vs. gorg. Also, I love banana peppers so I added that to my salad. Crisp lettuce and lots of dressing. From now on we are going to order salad along with our pizza!! read more

DON'T make the mistake of even trying Nancy's in Island Lake, IL. I was visiting friends in town and I volunteered to pick up pizza on the way. I used google to find pizza close to their house, but didn't check the reviews first, big mistake!! LG thin with 2 toppings & MED thin with 2 toppings and it was over $50. The price is too high and as it turns out, simply not worth it. I ordered crispy but it was SOGGY, the undercarriage was white! I feel like they were also cheap with the toppings. It's just a small place in a low end strip mall, and with no dining area. How can a place with such a low overhead charge so much for such an inadequate product!! It looks like the best scam going in Island Lake. It's not going to take long for an entrepreneur to see there is a huge opportunity to open up a place and watch Nancy's rightfully close up. Nancy's Pizza is on my list of places that I will never visit again! read more

What a disappointment. I used to buy a Nancy's stuffed pizza every Sunday night all Summer long as well as Spring and Fall. That began back in the 80's, and blended perfectly with my then bachelor life - perfect way to cap a great weekend. Then I got married, moved to the 'burb's, and had a kid. But boy did I miss Nancy's stuffed pizza. So when I found this one, in spite of the 30 minute drive, I ordered one. The person on the phone was a delight -professional and helpful. when I arrived to pick it up, they were precise and it was ready. Excellent! However, the pizza did NOT meet their prior standards of excellence. In fact, it was a bitter disappointment. Why? First of all, is was NOT stuffed pizza, It was a thick crust or pan pizza. How do I know? I ate them for 10 years. I know my pizza (it is a requirement to become a true Chicagoan - on the test). In addition, all the toppings slid to one side of the box, which was truly a bummer. In addition, it was on plain cardboard with no plastic mesh under the pizza, nor was there a spacer to prevent the top from getting smashed by the lid. This cause the pizza to stick to the cardboard and is a PIA to peel off. Toppings were reasonably fresh, and the sauce was 'OK'. A little to acidic for my taste (I like to add a bit of molasses to all tomato dishes to damp down the acidity. The original Nancy's did that) I am sure lots of people like them, and taste is to the individual, but I can buy a lot of frozen pizzas that are as good for the $40 I spent. And I will continue to do so, and get my stuffed from Old World Pizza who still makes them the right way to my taste. read more

Pizza's good, always delivered fast and hot. Very consistent. However, I don't know who's cutting these pizzas, Ray Charles or Stevie Wonder! They're all over the place! read more

Great pizzas and pasta. Their food is delicious, from their thin crust to stuffed. This is a takeout only location so not a restaurant, but they have an extensive menu. read more

Pizza was decent, but prices are insane! 3x 16" thin pizzas with an average 2.5x ingredients each, and only 20% of the toppings were meat, the other 80% were things like olives, garlic, onion, cheap toppings total with tax and no tip, just over $113. Wife ordered the pizza for a family event, I didn't know what the price was until I got there, probably should have just left! Can get pizza for like 40% less at the place by our house, but ordered Nancy's for nostalgic purposes. Screw the nostalgia, never again. Also, why do you cut the squares so small, to try to trick people into thinking they're getting more? read more

What could you improve? how about knowing how to cook a pizza the way it was asked to be cooked it's always a crapshoot with your store in Island Lake and I've had enough of uncooked soggy ass pizzas coming to my house goodbye and good luck read more

Got introduced by same friends of mine here in Volo. Had never tried it or actually heard of Nancy's but I was blown away. Probably the best pizza in the area and I've lived here for 11 yrs now. It's always worth the wait, if I wanted it right away I would just drive to pick it up. So glad I found this place read more

it always takes SO LONG for delivery. Wouldn't be so mad if they didn't say it would be here by 7:15 and it's currently 7:35.. still no pizza better be the best freaking pizza i've ever had. read more

The pizza is perfect......... Got a "family size" with Sweet peppers and sausage. The sausage was so dense it covered the entire surface. No hunting for a piece of sausage on this pizza. Incredible. No complaints. The best Go-To Pizza place in the entire area. Kudos to the owners. Pride, Quality and Value. We'll be back! Again and again and again. read more

Tried their stuffed pizza and fries and the flavors here are just excellent! While the stuffed pizza had a little too much cheese for my preferences (like, 1.5" cheese layer), they definitely have the best flavor around for their sauce and crust. Sauce was savory and very thick and is my new favorite. I am excited to try their thin crust. Fries were crispy and loaded up with toppings. Nancy's is not stingy with toppings, that's for sure! The stuffed pizza is expensive, but is so tall and so dense that I was done after a slice and a half, so it was definitely worth it. read more

Best pizza in the area always,always , top quality never disappointed in maybe 5 years of ordering. Here

We used to go to Nancys often. After last night never again.We ordered a small pizza and a large pizza, that was it. It was $44.25 !!!!!! The pizza was thin crust. I had a 25% off coupon so the final price was $35.30. There is ALOT of competition out there, they are NOT competitive in their prices thats for sure! Gave us a new menu. Prices have gone up at least a dollar on everything! No thanks, theres better pizza out there for a better price! . read more

Recommended...but NOT THE WINGS. I've been a Nancy's pizza lover for 40+ years. Since Edwardo's folded years ago, I think Nancy's stuffed is the best stuffed their is. And their thin crust is great too. Other things on their menu are very good. But last night I git the 7-piece order of wings...for $11. I'm sad about what has happened to wings in general. Across the board, the quality has gone down and the prices have skyrocketed. And unfortunately, Nancy's is in that boat. The wings were borderline bad. Each piece (remember, 7 pieces isn't 7 wings...it's 3.5 wings) cost $1.57. They were smallish (I've seen smaller), they were not meaty, overcooked and fairly dry. The sweet bbq sauce was fine but it did nothing to make the wings anything like plump and juicy, which good wings should be. I still love Nancy's, but the wings were a big disappointment. read more

Four stars or five? That was the question for me today. Nancys original Stuffed pizza has been my favorite pizza for over 40 years! Starting with the Harwood Heights/Niles location. I don't have the chance to get it often anymore, but when I do the closest location is Island Lake. We ordered it tonight as a special treat. If I'm able to I will post a video of my pure giddiness, excitement and joy knowing I was getting Nancys Pizza! The not so great news: it definitely was not the same stuffed Nancys Pizza I've had all these years. It was basically pretty flat. I'm hoping to add pictures. The GREAT news: it still tasted absolutely delicious! I called and spoke to management and they offered to make me a new one, but since I don't live real close I opted not to go that route. BEST news of all, they assured me that's not the new way of making their pizzas! (hey! We are all human beings, and we all have bad moments and we all have times that don't shine, right?!) We learn from our mistakes and we move forward! Hence my dilemma: four stars or five. But I have to go with five. It still tasted great and management was very professional and kind and offered to make it all over again. Most of all, this was just a glitch in the process, it's not their new way of making their stuffed pizza. ( truly I was concerned that this was their new way of making their stuffed pizza) And for that I am celebrating! * disclaimer, totally raw/vulnerable moment with a video. Still in my PJs, but it's all good read more

Nancy's Pizza - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Island Lake, Illinois

See all

8/27/2020 - not happy. We are long time loyal customers and today I called asking about a coupon for the 25.00 deal offering a free cheese pizza and explained that we are having a lot of work done to the house and do not have the coupon handy. The person who answered said they would not honor it if we do not have the physical coupon. While I understand that it is policy, I also believe in honoring loyalty and this did not happen. I told the person that I would be calling rosatties and he said Okay and hung up. Horrible service from that young guy and I'm disappointed in Nancy's for not honoring the coupon for long time regular customers who tip well and have spent a small fortune on pizza. 7/21/2018- this place is so amazing that I have to update my review. We had a party today and again phenomenal. Everyone asked if I ordered extra t Cheese and I told them nope, "Nancy's = quality." I love that I don't have to worry about over or undercooked pizza and that every time I can feel confident knowing my guests will be happy. Thank you once again for knocking it out of the park! Your pizza is the best around for deli Last review: Ordered from Nancy's and wow! Great thin crust pizza! We hadn't ordered from there in quite some time, but this may be our new "go-to" delivery. The pizza looked and tasted amazing. read more

Nancy's is great one of the Chicago original pizza joints they have lasted the test of time in a very competitive pizza market they have a great stuffed pizza pie. Which is unique and delicious. It will fill you up they use top quality ingredients and you'll be very happy you tried Nancy's pizza. Yummy. read more

Crap never again will I order from here'. Ask for a well done pizza, and I get a pizza barely cooked soggy crust & cheese that Never finished cooking. read more

Best pizza in the area, next to gilmer road house. Expensive as f***, but the WORST chicken wings in the area for 22$ I will never buy baked bread less unfried chicken. I spent money to put my own food in a airfryer. Love it here but upset at 50$ for a 12 inch pizza and 14 wings. Reluctant on that again. read more

Live in Wauconda and wanted to try something new so we ordered pizza from nancys and they delivered to us we had the deep dish stuffed and it was great better then any pizza we could find in Wauconda , we will definitely order again, man was very polite on phone and delivery was very prompt .... thanks , read more

Always good customer service and friendly staff. Pizza is always on point if you ask for any specific directions Solid Za

We really enjoy the pizzas from Nancy's. They are a little pricey for thin crust but they are all delicious. Our favorite is the BBQ chicken. read more

INSANELY delicious. Excellent thin crust pizza. Toppings are super fresh, sauce is delicious and not overwhelming, crust and dough are delicious. Officially my new favorite pizza. I ordered thin crust with mushrooms, black olives, tomato, and jalapeno--the only problem ill be having is with sharing. read more

I love Nancy's pizza. The deep dish is probably my favorite. Any time I call for delivery they are very kind and the customer service is amazing. Eric, one of the delivery drivers, is always such a joy to speak with and is so kind. I enjoy catching up whenever he delivers my pizza. Thank you Nancy's :) read more

AMAZING STUFFED DEEPDISH, highly recommend to my friend and family. Godfather beef sandwich is awsome read more

The food is great but they have horrible service! I order all the time from them and they have a fit about coupons! Just a tip, coupons are meant to drive business, create loyalty and increase returning customers! That is why you put them on the box. If i order from you all the time which you clearly see in my account why do you need the physical coupon? I call usually in the car on my way home last minute so i dont always have the chance to find one when i just walked in the door. I can honestly say this deters me from ordering from your restaurant. I know its a couple dollars but it's the principle it! I do not feel valued as a customer! The delivery guy will literally stand at the door while i have to go and dig one up. Not my idea of good service! read more

This place is very disappointing and ridiculous, in the time of a global pandemic when we hear "support local" and "small businesses are suffering" we tried to order from Nancy's. Our address is 5.1 miles away from the restaurant, we called to verify that delivery was possible, the phone staff put us on hold 3 times to verify, finally asking the manager on duty. After 20 minutes on the phone she finally said "yes, we can deliver to you". We place an order. Twenty minutes later we get a call back from the manager absolutely refusing to deliver a pizza. Again 5.1 miles away, in a time every restaurant is clamoring for business. Now it's an hour later and we have to start all over again to try and order a pizza. Epic fail Nancy's, I hope you aren't collecting EIDL and PPP loans while turning down local business read more

Extremely disappointed with them ! Our order was over 30 minutes late called when it was 10 minutes late and was told by a nice girl on the phone . Oh he should be there any minute he left . That was a lie . 30 minutes later I call back the same girl confused said that's strange puts me on hold for over 5 minutes I call back now upset and annoyed the manager picks up puts me on hold immediately didn't even give me a chance to talk ! I call back he says his name is joe and he lies and says oh there was traffic and the delivery driver is late . No sorry so I immediately get pissed I laughed and said your kidding right ? We are all on a shelter in place there is literally no traffic nor cars on the road !! Mind you we are only 12 minutes from this location ! I called him out on his low then he says he should be there any minute so I snap and said what are you crediting on my card ?! He clearly didn't understand what I was saying and then refunded me for the medium deep dish pizza . Delivery driver comes 3 minutes later apologizes and says so sorry our store is really really busy and we are running behind !!! I called back and that Anna girl picked up Again and I told her her manager completely lied and his driver rated them out ! Our fettuccine Alfredo burnt and dry like it was seating under the heat Lamps way to long ! The pizza was burnt on all the crusts and edges and soggy , fries were cold it was a complete mess ! I am nothing but understanding of restaurants during this hard time to be maybe a little late but to lie to our customers and then never even call to say sorry or it will be late etc or even call us !! Awful experience and so rude to blame your driver !!! I'll support other local restaurants instead . read more

This place has great pizza! My only hesitation for giving it 5 stars is because I wish it was crispier! I tried the super thin to see if that'd be crispier and it was a bit, but also when they say super thin, they mean super thin! It's sooo tasty though. The sausage is my favorite, and the veggies always seem fresh! Also, they always deliver right on time! read more

Love their 2 1/2 stuffed pizza .... it's delicious and fulfilling... ty guys for the awesome fast service and delivery... keep up the good work! read more

We've been eating Nancy's pizza for years now and every single time we do my husband and I look at each other in food heaven. It's so good, I can't believe how good it is and I say that every time we order. Every time. Do yourself a favor and order the 2.5 inch stuffed deep dish pizza, it's fantastic (a little pricey but you'll forget all about that!). Coupons come with your order to help with the extremely worth it financial burden the next time you order read more

Great food, horrible customer service!! We purchased dinner 'to go' there several weeks ago. When we got home we noticed the side salad was missing. We called them to tell them and they confirmed it was still at the restaurant. Asked that the salad be added to our account for our next order. No problem. Attempted to order our usual last night. Asked that our comp'd salad be added to the order. Guy said he didn't see it noted on the account. We told him it was the younger girl we spoke to several weeks ago. He said she wasn't allowed to do that because she would have needed to talk to a manager first. He said that we cannot have the salad we already paid for. We canceled the order we were trying to place. What a JOKE! We spend upwards of $45 every time we order...you seriously think we are trying to scam you out of a $3 SIDE SALAD!? You completely lost our business. Have some faith in humanity and trust your customers.... read more

This is my favorite Chicago style pizza in the area! I always add 3-4 meats. It's so thick that you can only eat 1-2 pieces. They never disappoint! read more

Very good Job! Great pizza, we never had any problems before!! I love this pizza place!!

Had Nancy's by where we used to live and it was our main pizza go-to but unfortunately they closed. Glad we found this location when we moved. Good pizza - thin crust, rustic crust, deep dish - tried them all and they're all great! Spinach salad wasn't bad either - a lot of spinach and was fresh. Cannoli are tasty. The only down sides are the delivery times (we just do pick up now-a-days) and the prices are a little steep - but those won't stop us from being customers. read more

Update: the owner has made some changes that are good and delivery times are much better, pizza is still good but a bit pricey. Would recommend as I feel it's the best pizza in town read more

Nancy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Island Lake, Illinois

The food brings a tear to my eyes. So GD good. Do yourself a favor...get it. I drive a half a hour to pick it up. I wish they would deliver or grub hub or something like that would get it. The pasta is also awesome read more

I frequently order from Nancy's. The food and service is always great. We ordered pizza on Friday for pickup and ended up waiting unusually long for it to be prepared. However, Brian called me and apologized and offered to credit my account. He went above and beyond to make the situation right. I would highly recommend this pizza place! The customer service really impressed me! And, of course, the food is amazing! read more

Excellent deep dish pizza. Pricey, but worth the cost. Can't comment on delivery - as we always pick up our order. Occasionally we order a salad, pretty basic, but always fresh. Once and awhile I give in to my husband and order thin crust which is good, too! So glad we have good pizza in Island Lake! read more