Ordered the Penne pasta with Marinara. Received cold, precooked pasta with a brown gunk that tasted like dog food and cigarette butts. Used to love this place, but my opinion began to change when they switched to a pizza tomato sauce that tastes like Ketchup. The "manager" said she was sympathetic, but only the owner is authorized to handle unsatisfied customers and she was not around on a Saturday night. The "just when you thought you've seen everything" moment was when the bus boy picked up the catastrophe, then asked for the cheese shaker, and went off to the kitchen area in order to eat the slop? - I Kid You Not!!!! read more

Been going here for years. Great food and great service. Nice little "Chicago Joint."

The food is awesome but the lady on the register was the worst service I have ever received and I have worked in the restaurant business over 30 years she needs to go back to customer service school read more

Ahhhhhmazzingggg! My son had been in the hospital and we were so sick of fast food Nello's was close so me and my daughter ran and got a couple pizzas and a Caesar salad. They didn't put the salad on the order but he just had them make one for me right away so it was no problem . The pizza was amazing so much flavor and the thin crust squares were so good!!! I love that the sauce was more spicy then sweet I love a Spicy sauce! Salad was good and very fresh! I felt like the pricing was great especially for the quality of food! Defiantly will be back I'm sad that it's so far from us or this would be our new frequent pizza place, but because it's so good the distance will not stop us from making the drive every now and again! read more

We went to Nellos for my daughters BD dinner. You could tell by the noise we had a great time together. Lane was our waiter (by himself) for 14 people. He was great! Thanks Lane for working so hard to make sure we had a nice time! Tell your boss you need a raise. read more

Excellent thick crust pizza. I got a 6" pizza but it was more like 4". That was my only complaint. Definitely will return.

Went searching for a chicago pizzeria on the net found Nellos got great reviews so tried it out. Simply fantastic thin crust pizza! Service excellent. Sauce well seasoned and topped with fresh mozzarella cheese. Sausage tasty and full of flavor. Our server brought us go cups to take our huge soft drinks home with us. Don't see that alot. Looking for good pizza, go here you won't be disappointed. read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - Thin crust sausage pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Been a fan of Nello's Mesa since 1994 when I was 11years old. It's crazy good. Incredibly consistent. Always friendly staff. Try the sausage - it's homemade and so tasty. Pizza, sandwiches, salads - all phenomenal. In the 90s they used to have a hot bacon dressing for their salads - it's a Midwest thing, and since we moved from Wisconsin and they had that, it was a taste of home...they should bring it back. Aside from that - "in crust we trust" it's so dang good. read more

Pizza is fantastic! Customer service is typically fantastic...except for today. Ordered pizza to go...older gal was just grumpy. Hopefully she was just having a bad day. read more

Thai pizza spot was absolutely incredible. It's literally one of the best pizza spots our family has ever experienced. This place definitely lives up to it's reputation. The BBQ pizza was perfect. The next time we are in the area, we are definitely stopping by again. read more

The pizza and people are great. So disappointed they stopped making their wings. They were so good. But I understand why they did it.

For years and years, Nello's has always satisfied with a tasty pie. Be it thick or thin, large or small, the portions and ratios of toppings to crust has always been consistent and on spot on, which puts Nello's among some of the tastiest pizza restaurants in the East Valley. My go to pizza choices typically lean towards the original crust, which is to say that it is deep dish pan style. Not quite Chicago style deep, but pretty darn close. The crust tends to be cooked to a lightly browned, nearly done consistency for most every pie made. I would say however, they tend to lean towards slightly under, rather than over, on the cook of their original crust. However, both styles of crust yield a pleasantly satisfying texture, thickness and flavor, and at least have some tooth to them that stands up well to the ingredients heaped on top. Another favorite is the house salad dressing. It certainly goes well with most any style of salad ordered, however it often times doubles as an extra bit of saucy flavor that somehow finds its way onto my slice of pizza. More often than not, I'll just put that slice of pizza nestled right up to the salad, all on the same plate, creating my own version of what west coasters do when they put their salad atop top their pizza. I can also say that the marinara sauce is very tasty and is good on the side for heaping on extra goodness. The service is certainly congenial, and prompt. I've really never had a bad experience in all of the times I've gone -whether it be a large party or small. Lunch and dinner you can't go wrong: sandwiches, salads, calzones and pizza's are all very tasty. There is a good selection of beer and wine, even local flavors on tap and in bottles too; there is something to complement your meal, if you're not sure, just ask - I find the staff very helpful. Both locations are often busy, and it's no surprise, because the food and service are quite good . . . and they've been doing it since the 80's, so there you go! Overall: 4 stars Food: 4.2 stars Service: 4.3 stars Cleanliness: 3.8 stars Value: 3.8 stars Atmosphere: 4 stars read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - 12" Original Crust Alaskan King Pizza: Crab, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Fresh Tomato, White Sauce. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

4 star worthy. Unfortunately our waiter messed up our order, not hearing and not repeating back our order in full. So, initially only half of our two person order was brought to our table. The other order came later. We managed to share both dishes, but the foul up could have been easily avoided. Still a tasty meal, rather two coarse meal. read more

Employees not wearing masks. I left. So I honestly can't say anything about the food or service.

Good pizza great service would tell anyone to go here talked to a manager about a problem and he took care of it

We went last night at 6:30. No hostess. We stood around for five minutes and finally seated ourselves. We were not acknowledged AT ALL! We sat at the table for 25 minutes and the waitress walked by us at least 8 times. No acknowledgment, no eye contact. We literally got up and walked out. Still the waitress and bartender completely ignored us. May I mention we've been going to this restaurant for over 35 years. Really a shame but I'm not going back. read more

This place was so delicious. First off the glasses they serve their drinks are in are huge, which is nice because you don't have to be waiting for a refill constantly. Their small salads were also huge and could easily be 2 meals or split with 2 people. I got the pesto Bianca pizza and it was so flavorful. The crust was great and not too much bread. The beef dip was delicious and the meat was so good. I loved that you could dip the sandwich. read more

Hmmm... I was super excited to try this place because it has wonderful reviews. I am so confused why it has good reviews because my pizza was so mediocre. The cheese and the crust were the same texture. I was expecting a tiny crunch with the crust but it was bouncy like a pillow, reminded me of school cafeteria. It was so not impressive. Maybe I came on a bad night??? Probably won't be back. I hope there's someone out there that understands what I mean because it was SO average! Side note: My house salad was yummy I loved the sliced carrots and the basaltic house dressing. read more

Extremely rude, stuff, unwelcoming staff behind the bar. Bartenders bickering. Not even busy. How pathetic. I will not be back. Fire the bald aggressive jerk and I might think about it. Place is 100% unwelcoming read more

I have eaten at the Phoenix branch years ago and attended frequently. I always thought it was a ten, with excellent food and service. We did takeout. Our pizza was terrible. Little to no flavor, thin-crust was overcooked. Now I know why I ate at their Phoenix location. I will not return. read more

Nello's Pizza is iconic place and has been around for decades. I normally take my little brother when he comes to town. The pizza, subs, and salads are yummy. Definitely recommend the pizza. The house salad dressing is so good. We've never had a bad experience. read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

I have been going to this Nello's since I moved to the valley. I have tried pretty much very pie they make and they are all delicious ! But I absolutely love their deluxe combo on thin or original deep dish. They even have gluten free crust! Great pasta dishes that are large enough to share. I love their homemade Italian sausage. The salads are enough to feed a small army and their homemade house dressing is a must. Great friendly service, at a great price! read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - Mmm...ice cold beer - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

My second time here......this place is legit! I love the neighborhood bar vibe inside mixed with the old school italian eatery. This is NOT a 2 slices and a coke place folks.....be warned. It's a chicago style deep dish pizza. My 10 inch pizza was delicious and their sauce has a great garlic taste. I also drooled over a supreme stuffed pizza to the left and penne pasta with sausage on the right. Drool worthy ! DosXX draft and 10 inch pizza =13.85 Here's how you know this place is legit.......it was packed at 5pm on a thursday. Just go! read more

A friend came from out of the country so we popped in to have some pizza. My friend said it reminded him of the pizza we grew up with outside of Chicago. Ive since gone back several times and have had good service and food. read more

Prepare to be blown away with a lot of great food! Nello's Pizza is a friendly, family-run neighborhood pizza shop. With their extensive menu, there was so much to choose from, and definitely something for everyone! Their food is perfect for sharing, as one pizza could feed the entire family. When we were here, we ordered the Tortellini Toss, which had adorable pieces of cheese tortellini, artichoke hearts (the love of my life), and the makings of a great Mediterranean salad. They also have a tomato-based house vinaigrette, would definitely recommend getting a salad, just for the dressing. As for pizzas, you can't go wrong with any of their specialty deep dish pizzas. When we were there, we go the Deluxe Combo, which comes with your classic combo toppings: the pepperoni, sausage, bell peppers, and more! There was so much food, we ended up saving half of the pizza as leftovers. The pizza was so huge! And even though we were so full, we kept going back to the pizza, just wanting one...more...bite! read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - Menu - so many options! - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

How can this place have nearly five stars? The atmosphere is fine if you're looking for a casual, family friendly kind of restaurant. The service was fast and cordial, but the pizza left so much to be desired. We ordered two pizzas. One was a thin crust "Deluxe Combo" (pictured) which was passable, but nothing to write home about. The other was a "Pesto Bianca" with chicken added (pictured) which I almost sent back --- and I never send food back. The crust was burnt to a non-edible char; my teeth literally could not bite into it. The chicken (which I paid extra to have!!!) was dry beyond belief. It had a texture that made me think it was day-old chicken tossed onto a grill to merely reheat was had previously been overdone. I was surprised that someone in the back-of-house allowed this pizza to leave the kitchen. read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - Thin Crust Deluxe Combo - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

Earlier this evening, I had an opportunity to sit down with some family at a well known "Chicago" pizza chain. And then someone asked if we had ever tried Nello's. I had never heard of this pizzeria but I am always willing to try a new restaurant. Even when they've been around for 33 years! I've reviewed a few pizza joints recently and they were decent. None of them earned more than four stars because I knew there were places like Nello's out there. And it was only a matter of time until I found one worthy of five stars. And it didn't hurt that there was a Cubs game on. Nello's is clearly more than a pizzeria, though. Just a glance at the menu will tell you that there are enough options to keep you happy if you want more than pizza. We started with the Mozzarella Platter which featured basil, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and banana peppers, with toasted Italian bread and a side of olive oil with Parmesan cheese.... Amazing! This could be an appetizer at a fine dining Italian restaurant. Our group couldn't decide on one or two large pizzas, so four, smaller customized pizzas were ordered. We all chose the pan style crust. This is a crust worthy of five stars without any toppings or sauce! For the record, I really like the pizza sauce here. It has a great tomato flavor with a heavy hint of garlic. And the Deluxe Combo is a solid choice because the Italian sausage used here is high quality stuff. As I noted about the plethora of pizza joints popping up everywhere, this fad will come and go. But it's clear from one visit, that Nello's ain't going anywhere! Oh yeah... Cubs win! Cubs win! read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - The Mozzarella Platter appetizer - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

Nellos has the best pizza in the east valley, and is one of my favorite restaurants period. Great pizza, great beer selection, and great value. An average experience in here is a 5 star, and the great ones are out of the park. The sign says they've been doing it for 38 years and I see why. read more

Best veggie deep dish pizza ever!!! Loaded with fresh veggies and crust was cooked perfect. read more

Nothing beat's a Nello's Numero Uno on original crust (delicious sausage!) and Antipasto Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette or their tasty House dressing. The Deluxe Combo is another one of our favorites and we love the large drinks, especially the Cranberry Juice Cooler. Our first date was at Nello's 30 years ago and we continue to return even though we now live a half hour away. Lot's of good times/memories at this neighborhood family restaurant and whenever we have family/friends visiting from out of state Nello's is on the menu whether we dine in or take out. Service at times can be slow/forgetful but is always friendly and with a smile. If you come on Friday's or Saturday's arrive before 5:15, parking can be difficult. read more

I tried Nello's out for the first time for lunch. I ordered a sausage, peppers and mushroom thin crust. Great Pizza great service and great prices. I will be back to try other items on the menu. read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Great as usual. We shared the spinach salad and a medium deluxe combo original crust. Mango ice tea. Did not drink beer for a change, lol!! read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - I'm getting lasagna and salad today!! - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

The thin crust pizza here is the best I've had in the valley. The thick or deep dish is just okay it doesn't really do it for me to say the least. But boy are the flavors there when you order the thin crust. We always used to come here on Tuesdays to get the Tuesday take out special which apparently stopped. When we called today to go get the usual Tuesday deal to us the dead give away was when the man over the phone had asked us what kind of large soda we would like and when my boyfriend had asked if he meant to say 2 liter he said no. So now that they have taken away my Tuesday special I can tell you at this moment that the chances of us going to nellos after this are slim to none. I'm severely disappointed that they have no specials anymore but nothing lasts forever I guess. I will miss you nellos very much I will but I guess we will be sticking closer to home and trying out pizza on 87....sigh.... :( read more

First time...maybe the last time. Ordered Deluxe combo pizza and a dozen wings. The pizza is alright, but I do expect more as it is their specialty pizza, the taste is about the same as many other pizza place. The one dozen wings, I got all 12 drumsticks!!...where are the "wings"!! Come on...without sayimg a word...you should give the customer 6 wings and 6 drumsticks, ok!! The drumsticks is larger than many other places and is not dry....but it didn't have the favor on it (garlic and parmesan). I support local small business, hope it can improve a bit more. read more

Pizza and red wine! We got a large pizza and half carafe of house wine all for $25. The restaurant is cozy, full of friends and families that you can tell meet there regularly. Our seating was comfortable and the service was attentive. We got the margarita pizza, which was great, but we agreed to get a heavier topping next time to match the hearty crust. We'll be back to try the salads! read more

I normally would love to give this place a 4/5 stars but they've finally disappointed me with the lack of amenities for brining a baby/young infant. Bathroom does not have a changing table and they don't have car seat caddies if you bring your baby in a car seat. Service is always friendly and food is always great. Would still come here because their salad dressing is so good! Everything on the menu is great can't go wrong. :) read more

Overall this place wasn't bad.. We ordered garlic bread, hot wings and pizza. Their garlic bread was just ordinary nothing special about it and pizza was okay.. My boyfriend who has been here before said their pizza was a little off than usual.. Their wings was good though not your Long Wong wings but I probably enjoyed the wings more than the pizza.. I don't know if they just had an off day or what.. But it seemed like they had a lot of regulars, the waitress seemed to know few customers by their name.. read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - Hot Wings - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

The best place around and I'm from the Chicago area switched from Rosattis after they changed owners. Friendly atmosphere.

I finally made it to Nello's and am so happy I did. Laura A. called and said she was craving pizza and since I'm the pizza addict anytime this rare occasion happens I am down in a heartbeat to go. So since she lives in Mesa we decided to check out Nello's as the reviews were all top notch. Upon arrival we were greated and we said we were ordering a to go order so we were shown the to go window. Brian greeted us there after giving us a brief minute to scope out the wonderful menu. We decided to get two 10" pies to get a good trial run at this place. He was very nice and gave us some ideas and we went with The Murphy which has strips of bacon and onions on it and I got a custom pie with sun dried tomato's, gouda cheese, and green peppers. When we got home we devoured both pies the sauce was great and we had one deep dish and one thin crust. I preferred the deep dish but they both were great. I will for sure be back for more pizza and to try their sandwich's as they sounded very good as well. The service was great everyone was very nice it felt like a great neighborhood restaurant. I think that feeling at a lot of restaurants has been lost today so it was very nice. 4.5/5 read more

I ordered a vegetarian pizza and got sausage all over my pizza. I work in the food industry & I get it "blame the cook" but it did not need to take 1 hour to get the pizza when the server knew there was a vegetarian at the table anyway. We ordered a salad to start COME ON. read more

Nello's Pizza Mesa - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona