I am totally hooked on their vegetarian pizza! In want to say first of all everyone that works there is so nice! I work up the street from here and I asked around for good pizza, one of the delivery drivers informed me how delicious the pizza was and that the new owners were so nice. I was not let down! Great taste and wonderful service! And I love that you are extending your menu and vegetarian friendly! read more

Placed a order for take out and was given a time to come pick it up. Order was not ready for another twenty minutes. Got home and half the order needed to be reheated since it was cold. We have been going here for years and the staff was unorganized. read more

Got the cheese pizza for the kids and it was amazing. Ordered a plain cheese expecting something simple but it was really good.

Wow. A slice is 1/4 pizza. For $2.50 this is a good deal to me. The cheese is melted hot and gooey and smells just like you want pizza to smell. I'll be coming back here again. read more

New Wayne Pizza - The "slice" is actually 1/4 of a pizza ... ( my home made salad just wasn't going to cut it today) at New Wayne Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, Pennsylvania

Ordered a pizza at 6:45pm, was delivered at 8pm burnt and luke warm. First time ordering from here, was disappointed. Won't order again

I ordered a fish platter and that was my mistake. The breading was horrible and was drinched in oil. I did not know that they served frozen fish and you can tell by the taste of it. The french fries were old and they tasted as if they had been sitting around and then refried for my order. I called and the lady who answered to see i could order something else in its place and was told no. She then started talking to a man in the back about it and be said why would we do that. They said i could order something else but i woild be charged full price. I asked for even a partial credit and was told no. She says it wasn't thier fault, its not a fancy restaurant that sells fresh fish and i should have known it was frozen. Not only were they both rude but then she hung up the phone on me. We have ordered from this restaurant plenty of times but i will NEVER order or recommend again!!!! Not like they would even care. read more

See all

First for reference I would like to state that I am from the NJ/NY area and I know GOOOOOOD pizza. Let me tell you about New Wayne Pizza. They freakin delivered to us in a snow storm, we had no power and no one else would deliver, granted there a half a mile away but they still delivered. Then we opened the box of pizza and inhaled it. So much so that we now order it every Friday. We also get the boneless chicken strips. I have no idea what it is or why but these are perfect. Needless to say, this is the best pizza I've had since living in Philadelphia now Devon in 2 years. They're also the nicest humans ever. We love you guys!! read more

Under new ownership, from Thunderbird in Broomall. Claim to use same recipes as Alex, former New Wayne owner, but doesn't taste that way. The pizza seems to have a lower quality cheese and the overall method of cooking seems different as well. Agree with another review that calls the pizza "sour" - that's how it tasted. Cheesesteaks have a strange seasoning, that may just be from lack of cleaning the grille. With all the other pizza shops in Wayne, it's tough to give a place another shot when it fails to meet the mark. read more

I've been eating at New Wayne for close to a year now and can't believe I never actually wrote a review of this place. To start, they have very good pizza. It's not too bready. It has the right amount of cheese and dough. Some of their other menu items are also pretty good. Their chicken cheesesteaks and regular cheesesteaks are delicious. They don't use cheeze whiz, which is a plus. I'm not a huge fan of their gyros. I've had both the chicken and lamb gyros. Both come with thinly sliced processed meat. Don't get me wrong, they do taste good; however, I expected real chicken breast with my chicken gyro order. I guess I should blame Pandora's in Center City for this. They actually made their gyros with juicy chicken breast. Friends and family have told me this is typical for gyros. Eh, not for me. The chicken provolone and spinach hoagie is very filling. Now with this, you will get juicy chicken breast as opposed to thinly sliced processed meat. Their salads are also good. The lettuce tastes fresh and they don't seem to skimp on what you ask for. For example, if you order a chicken caesar salad, you will be pleased with the quantity of chicken placed on top of your greens. As for sides, their fries are really good. I don't think they do anything special to them, but they have the right amount of crisp on the outside with a fluffy inner. read more

Solid pizza joint in the heart of Wayne. Great service and efficient operations. Call or online order ahead, they're very good about their times. Pizza has a Greek style with crispy crust. Lots of good options too. Parking can be challenging on a busy night, so bring a food runner that you can conveniently drop/pickup. read more

We got pizza here ever since we moved to the area in late 90s...and it's always been amazing with zero issues. Sure placing phone orders was a bit iffy - but the food was great even if the service was a bit slow. I tried to order today only to be rudely told that "I'm out of the delivery area." - I'm in Wayne. I'm 10 minutes away at best....and it hasn't been a problem for over 10 years...except apparently it is now too far for the new owners? This isn't what it used to be and I suppose it's time to find a new pizza place. Edit: It get better. They charged me for the pizzas that they refused to deliver to me. Nice.... read more

Fantastic pizza and service. The people are tremendously friendly, and the pizza crust/dough is something special. Give the grilled chicken as a pizza topping a try, it has a ton of flavor! read more

Got the Reuben Calzone. It was really good...good amount of cheese to. corned beef to kraut combinations for me. The crust was tasty, and there wasn't too much bread...filled almost completely, which I appreciate. I don't want a whole bunch of dough with no filling in it. There was also just the right amount of greasiness, so it was dripping, but not super messy. Not too salty, which is another thing I appreciate. read more

Oh my god. Ruben calzone. I'm keeling over with my tongue hanging out of my mouth just thinking about it. We haven't had anything here that we didn't like. They also have a great fruit salad, if you don't want something starch-y grease-y good. There are a LOT of pizza places in the area... I think 7?! This is my decadent, Indulge in something savory pizza. The other places may be good for basic pizzas, but New Wayne Pizza is an treat. Not a sit down restaurant. read more

New Wayne Pizza totally saved the day for my son. He placed a large order for a graduation party from a national chain (take a guess, you have 30 minutes or less to get it). He placed it 24 hours in advance to make sure everything was fine. He went to pick it up and they claimed someone with his name showed up and took all the pizzas. No refund and no food. He had a group of 10 hungry college kids waiting for dinner. I called NWP and ordered plenty of stuff, it was delivered in 33 minutes and my son said the food was great and the delivery guy was very nice. Thanks for coming in clutch for a bunch of hungry Eastern University kids! Have always loved you guys, now you've got a bunch of new fans. read more

The cooks and cashiers are not wearing gloves and they are making food with their dirty hands! The cooks were even eating while making other peoples food. They touch the money, the cash register and the food bare handed. Disgusting! read more

Great food. Quick service. I got the cheesesteak & it was perfect. Fries are great too. Can't wait to come back & try the Stromboli. This is the kind of hole in the wall place I live to find when I come into town. Real-deal Italian joint. read more

I ordered two pizzas for delivery and the order got screwed up through the online system. My pepperoni/ sausage was registered as a cheese. The delivery was 30+ minutes late but when calling them, they offered to refund me on my credit card or via store credit. I chose credit card. After we enjoyed the pizza, there was a knock on our door. Someone from New Wayne was standing there and they told me their system was down and drove back to refund me in cash to make it right. The pizza was good but the customer service was even better! read more

Service is good. Delivery is great. The fish hoagie and pizza are great. I most try and you will continue to eat there.

Awful, overpriced pizza. It was like $18 for a "large" pepperoni pie which tasted worse than frozen pizza. The "large" here would be a medium or small at any other restaurant. I was excited to try this place because people are always coming in and out of it. read more

This pizza is horrible... tastes like pizza from the frozen food section at the grocery store, doesn't taste like good New York style at all. No wonder it was $11. read more

The food was ordered for my daughter at school for lunch time. She received her food within the time frame. It was hot, fresh and tasty. She had pizza and she loved it. Thanks a bunch!! I would order more often but they can only order food to school on emergency basis. However, when we are around and about I will know where to go. read more

I've had several things on the menu, including: pizzas, cheesesteaks, salads, wings and all have been delicious. Nice family restaurant, just added seating next door... 100 percent worth a try read more

o my god. I was feeling crappy earlier because I had some international travel plans snarled and had consequently taken off work for nothing. I was so upset I was not hungry. I decide to go see scott pilgrim and I kind of want something to eat. there's a kind of big menu with lots of pizza and stuff. I want something pretty simple and chill on my stomach. I get a turkey sandwich on wheat toast w/ lettuce tomato, mayo. and pickles. believe it or not, at some places this type or order just comes okay or not bad. here- it was PHE. NOMENAL. it was really excellent. I have not had their pizza, hot hoagies, strombolis or anything. but if 75% of the same kind of care goes into them, I know they will be good. there are a number of pizza places around wayne and nearby mainline towns. this one knocked me out. I try to rush over the movie theater for pilgrim, they won't let me in w/ the food! I have to rush and eat half the snadwich. it is huge! lots of lettuce. I LOVE lots of extra lettuce. read more

Our favorite pizza place in the area! Now that they have indoor seating we love to bring the kids to eat in the restaurant.

New Wayne Pizza is the bomb! Staying in town on business for the week and ran across this gem! The crust is super crispy, the tomato sauce tastes fresh, and the sausage is delicious! Give it a try...you'll be pleased you did! read more

One of the best places to get pizza in Wayne. I really like their pizza crust because it's thin and crispy. Their pizzas are also reasonably priced and sized. The only downside is that you have to order take out since you cannot eat in. read more

Best pizza and cheesesteaks in town! Don't listen to BJ L's review. Been loyal customer since 1992 with no relation to owners.

Steak Stromboli here is one of the best food items on the mainline. Fresh meat and made fresh.

First of all poor service and bad attitude at the counter. Order a meal that's pretty easy and specific. Chicken steak NO cheese, with grilled peppers onions. Not hard. Well the lady gave an attitude about how to do that? Like really? Than ask for a new one to be delivered or my money back. Well it was a process and hassle. I'm sorry I didn't mess order up. Even gave it a try to redeem and the lady again giving an attitude. Thanks for ruining lunch. Don't have all day to eat. Never again will I even think about this place when working in the area. read more

I'm a big fan of their special stromboli. The pizza is solid, but the stromboli is the best option on the menu. The salads are OK too. The folks behind the counter are very friendly. read more

Been going to New Wayne for 15+ years and they have always had great pizza at reasonable prices. Very nice family owned business that I would definitely recommend. read more

When I was quickly put on hold, I could hear her speaking to people picking up food. Each person who was there was treated like family, and at one point she screamed, "wait wait wait, you gave me a twenty!!!" And the guy, who presumably bought something for much less, said "yeah, I know, have a great holiday, you guys are great." The Reuben calzone was amazing and it sounds like these folks have a following. read more

I signed up for yelp just to review this place. I have been getting pizza here for years. I don't get to come that often because I live half an hour away, but in my opinion it's worth the drive. The people who work here are great. They know my order and they are always so sweet. The pizza is consistently amazing. It's my favorite pizza in the world (and I have tried a lot of different pizza). The fries are also delicious. read more

I LOVE New Wayne Pizza!!! The food is great but the staff is outa this world. I only wish they would stay open later, just a little later!!! Pleeez!!! On Friday and Saturday at least til midnight, but 1am would be great. read more

The pizza here is excellent. Got a large pepperoni pie for pickup and it was ready before I arrived!

This pizza place is soooo good. The pizza is delicious, but so is are the other delicious items on its menu, like the wings and salads. My favorite is the caeser salad, but if you don't like that then they also have plenty of other options to choose from. Overall if you are looking for a good pizza place, New Wayne is one of the better ones around here read more

We ordered a large make your own pizza with ricotta, spinach, tomato, and broccoli for delivery...the ingredients were fresh and delicious...the crust was nice and thin and crispy...delivery was prompt and the phone customer service was friendly...will order from them again!!!! read more

When I moved to Wayne 3 years ago, this place was consistently phenomenal. I ordered here at the very least once a week. I never once had a bad experience. Alex decided to retire, and the idiots from Thunderbird (Broomall) bought it, promising the same food and experience. I've tried and tried and tried to give them another chance and they can't get simple things done right. Food is now terrible, customer service is below average, and their delivery drivers are horrible. I can't wait for a better place to open here. It truly is sad. read more

Love this place. Recently under new ownership and better than ever. Have discovered some new favorites on the menu - grilled Reuben, buffalo chicken quesadilla, and both bbq and buffalo wings are great. Daily homemade soup specials have yet to disappoint either - chicken orzo is fantastic. And can't go wrong with old favorites - cheesesteaks, pizza, and cheese fries - consistently excellent. A friendly neighbor takeout spot that we are lucky to have - I highly recommend. read more